33
qYBk BP VjP%? t $t8BIR $t RYs %RI }jsR8sR W $98st < N , 7 _,, ytR$Z PB 3ZR$Bt 7ZI$R =t$%R$k BP q-sR s VZR$t VZR$t =7V 7 * _$t{YR s-T_jst{, ytR$Z P[ Z _jsR8s}YkR$, eZsB8 VRRB{$s$Bt ps{Y$t p8stk 7 e 7Yss}B% eZsB8\=VeV 3ZR$Bt VRRB{$s$Bt ]ZjYs8 7{$t{ ]t VA$tIBt !-PBIRY$ !d; n* = w*sIU FZt 1E 1((nD _jsR8s {BthZs$BtR b$Y RYs %Rsj s }Bt B Y -{$s$Bt BP ZtZRZsj VjP%? t $t8BIR Ak t${ }s${jR qYR 8BIR -Y$A$ s JZsR$T}$BI${ }sT t BP }IB8$tstjk Z}bsI PJZt{k Rb}$t wVjP%? t ]sR{sIRD sR Y RsPk Ps{B R {YstR $t $8 qY$R bB, }RtR s YBk Ys 8}jBkR bB {B8}j8tT sk 8{Yst$R8R PB RsAj$RY$t VjP%? t ]sR{sIRU wdD s tBtRstIsI sI$sAs${ T R}BtR BP t${ }s${jR b$Y js BA$R stI w1D BB$Isj 8stBYkIBIkts8${ w<*D &{R Ys s R{BtITBI $t $t%R sR}{ s$B qY I%jB}I YT Bk -}js$tR Y stR$$Bt PB8 VjP%? t ]sR{sIR B Y qBB$I${$k ytIZ{I VjP%? t e$t8BIR wqVeRD $t{jZI$t 8BI$h{s$BtR BP Y qVeR Y8Rj%R ts Y RYs %Rsj }B$t

qY‡B—k BP VjP%?‡t ‡$˙‡t8BI‡R $t RY‡s— —‡%‡—R‡I …w3fusion.ph.utexas.edu/ifs/ifsreports/970_Breizman.pdf · qY‡B—k BP VjP%?‡t ‡$˙‡t8BI‡R $t

  • Upload
    vomien

  • View
    221

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

qYBk BP VjP%?t $t8BIR $t RYs %RI jsR8sR

W $98st < N , 7 _,,ytR$Z PB 3ZR$Bt 7ZI$R =t$%R$k BP q-sR s VZR$t VZR$t =7V

7 * _$tYRs-T_jst, ytR$Z P[Z _jsR8sYkR$,

eZsB8 VRRB$s$Bt psY$t p8stk

7 e 7YssB%eZsB8\=VeV 3ZR$Bt VRRB$s$Bt ]ZjYs8 7$t ]t

VA$tIBt !-PBIRY$ !d; n* =w*sIU FZt 1E 1((nD

_jsR8s BthZs$BtR b$Y RYs %Rsj s Bt B Y -$s$Bt BP ZtZRZsjVjP%?t $t8BIR Ak t$ s$jR qYR 8BIR -Y$A$ s JZsR$T$BI$ sTt BP IB8$tstjk ZbsI PJZtk Rb$t wVjP%?t ]sRsIRD sR Y RsPkPsB R YstR $t $8 qY$R bB, RtR s YBk Ys 8jBkR bB B8j8tTsk 8Yst$R8R PB RsAj$RY$t VjP%?t ]sRsIRU wdD s tBtRstIsI sI$sAs$ TRBtR BP t$ s$jR b$Y js BA$R stI w1D BB$Isj 8stBYkIBIkts8$w<*D &R Ys s RBtITBI $t $t%R sR s$B qY I%jBI YTBk -js$tR Y stR$$Bt PB8 VjP%?t ]sRsIR B Y qBB$I$$k ytIZI VjP%?te$t8BIR wqVeRD $tjZI$t 8BI$hs$BtR BP Y qVeR Y8Rj%R ts Y RYs%Rsj B$t

1

y yWqi!*=]qy!W

qY s R%sj sRBtR bYk VjP%?t $t8BIR s BP $tR $t 8st$ PZR$Bt TRsY qY hR $R Y Btt Ys YR 8BIR st IsI t$ $Bt Btht8t >dHs$Zjsjk Y Btht8t BP PZR$BtTBIZI sjYs s$jR $t AZt$t jsR8s -$T8tR >1H qY RBtI $R Y BAR%s$Bt Ys At$t VjP%?t $t8BIR st B%$I Zt$JZI$stBR$ BBZt$$R %$s RBTsjjI <*TRBRBk >nH 3$tsjjk Y $R st $8RTR$% s8BZt BP Y$YTJZsj$k stI R$jj tB Bsjjk -js$tI -$8tsj Iss PB8 %s$BZR8sY$tR wFB$t eZBst qBZR wFeqD qB,s8s, 3ZR$Bt qR isB wq3qiD FqTE(=*yyyT* stI BYRD Ys tRR$sR s Is$jI YB$sj stsjkR$R BP Y VjP%?t 8BIRY8Rj%R stI BP Y$ $ts$BtR b$Y Y t$ $Bt BZjs$BtqY RYs VjP%?t bs% PJZtk st YsR At -tR$%jk -jBI $t Y -$8tR

b$Y s s$Zjsjk RBt $tR $t qBB$I$$k ytIZI VjP%?t e$t8BIR wqVeD >;H qYqVeR s sRRB$sI b$Y Y sR $t Y VjP%?t Bt$tZZ8 bY$Y Ps$j$sR Y$ -$s$BtAk IZ$t I$RR$s$Bt PB8 Bt$tZZ8 Is8$t qY Bj BP Bt$tZZ8 Is8$t bBZjIsjRB A sjk IZI $P 8BIR s$R s sI$sj jBs$BtR bY Y YstR B A 8$t$8sjRs$sj %s$s$Bt BP Y jBsj RYs VjP%?t bs% PJZtk

) ~ wDp

Xz E

RwD~, wdD

bY z stI E s Y BB$Isj stI Y BjB$Isj 8BI tZ8AR ~ $R Y VjP%?t %jB$k p$R Y 8s`B sI$ZR stI R $R Y RsPk PsB V BBI -s8j BP RZY s sR $R Y pjBAsjVjP%?t e$t8BI wpVeD >xEH qY PJZt$R BP $8sk $tR PB 8stk -$8tRs BZYjk BP Y BI BP Y qVe PJZtk # ~ bw1RpD GYt Y 8BI tZ8ARs RZARst$sjjk js Yst Zt$k $ $R sst PB8 eJ wdD Ys RZY 8BIR s 8BRtR$$% B Y RsPk PsB Bhj Yst Yk s B Y jsR8s ItR$k Bhj qYZR stkjBs$Bt bY R $R tsjk 4s RYBZjI A %$bI sR s Bt$sj R$ PB s RYs VjP%?t 8BIqY sPB8t$BtI R$sj Bj BP 4s R w9B RYsD R$R BtZR b$Y tZ8BZR BAR%sT

$BtR BP RBTsjjI VjP%?t ]sRsIR wV]D $t B,s8s, I$RYsR b$Y tBtT8BtBBt$ RTBhjRqY sRsIR b I$RB%I Bt FqTE(= >H stI Yt sjRB PBZtI Bt Feq >MH bY YkYs% At RZI$I -tR$%jk qY ]sRsI 8BIR k$sjjk ss $t XAZtYR" qYk8 BZR$I Y qVe s stI -Y$A$ s JZsR$T$BI$ st BP PJZtk Rb$tsR RYBbt $t 3$ d y YsR At %sjI >d(H Ys Y 8BI PJZt$R sZsjjk s Y8Bsj %BjZ$Bt BP IZ B Y $8 ItIt R w0D BP Y RsPk PsB s Y 9B

n

RYs B$t <Bb% Y -$8tR -Y$A$ Btjk s RZAR BP Y PJZt$R IR$AIAk eJ wdD yt s$Zjs 8BR BP Y BAR%I PJZt$R 8B% ZbsI bYt Y RsPkPsB IsRR $t $8 qY$R PsZ $tI$sR Ys RB8 BP Y stI$Is PJZt$R $%tAk eJ wdD 8sk tB A RZ$sAj PB RsAj$RY$t st $t8BI y $R sjRB tBbBYk YsY sjjBbI 8BIR s tB pVeR bY$Y bBZjI BIZ PJZtk Rb$t $t Y BBR$I$$Btyt BI B RsAj$RY Y XZjR" PB Y 8BI -$Rt Bt YsR B jBB, R$hsjjk s

Y YkR$R 8Yst$R8R Ys 8s$ts$t Y $t8BI RZZ G tB Ys $t s jsR8sYs $R BjI stI Rs$sjjk Zt$PB8 Y $R s Itsk $t Y RYs VjP%?t bs% RZ8yt RZY s jsR8s st sA$sk sI$sj 8BI RZZ $R B8s$Aj b$Y Y $tPJZtkI8$tI Ak eJ wdD qY sRBt bYk Y 8BI RZZ $R tB BAZR $t Y$R sR $RYs I$&t 4Z- RZPsR IBt: B88Zt$s %$s RYs VjP%?t R$tsjR qbB BP Y bskR PBY8 B B88Zt$s s %$s sI$sj -ZR$BtR BP s$j BA$R w$tjZI$t kBTBA$RD stI%$s BB$Isj <*T&R qY hR B$Bt bsR -s8$tI $t iP >d(H sR s $8sk stI$IsPB Y $ts$Bt BP VjP%?t ]sRsIR AjBb Y qVe s $t s jsR8s b$Y s R$t$hstBZjs$Bt BP t$ s$jR < b -s8$t Y RBtI B$Bt stI I8BtRs YsY 8st$PRs$Bt BP BB$Isj <*T&R sbsk PB8 Y qVe s $R 8sY8s$sjjk R$8$jsB Ys BP Y t$ s$jR RB Ys ABY &R st A Bt%t$tjk IR$AI Ak YRs8 $t8BI JZs$Bt wR 7 yyyD qY jBR B Y qVe s Y 8B R$t$hst$R Y Bj BP BZj$t Abt Y t$YAB$t BjB$Isj Ys8Bt$R <Bb% Y 8BIRZZ b$Y$t Y qVe s I$&R BtR$IsAjk PB8 Ys BP Bt%t$Btsj qVeR AsZRY 8st$ RYs $R %k R8sjj s Y 8BI jBs$Bt yt 7 yz b Rt s BRBtI$ttsj$9s$Bt BP qVe YBk G sjRB RYBb Ys Y $R s Bt$tZBZR stRPB8s$Bt BPY VjP%?t ]sRsI 8BIR $tB qVe 8BIR sR Y RsPk PsB YstR $t $8 s Y RYs%Rsj B$t qY$R stR$$Bt $R $jjZRsI Ak Y tZ8$sj RZjR RtI $t 7 zyt IR$A$t Y V]R stI qVeR b sIB s Bt%t$Bt z k ( stI BtR$I bs%R

b$Y ABY BR$$% stI ts$% PJZt$R qYR bB sRR BRBtI R$%jk Bbs%R Bss$t sjBt stI BBR$ B Y JZ$j$A$Z8 BB$Isj 8st$ hjI qY qVeI$RR$Bt js$Bt $R s PZt$Bt BP Btjk RB Ys ABY BR$$% stI ts$% PJZtk bs%Rb$jj -$R yt BtsR b$Y qVeR Y V] I$RR$Bt js$Bt Bts$tR j$ts ItItBt bY$Y As,R Y Rk88k Abt BR$$% stI ts$% PJZt$R RB Ys Btjkbs%R BP Bt s$Zjs R$t BP 8sk -$R yt BI B $It$Pk sjj V] $t8BIR Y

;

k ( stI c ( sRR b$jj A $t%R$sI Rssjkyt Y ABIk BP Y - b IR$A Y j$ts 8BIR b$YBZ sI B Y$ -$s$Bt

e-$8tsjjk Y 8BIR Ys% At -$I Ak s YB s$j BZjs$Bt bY$Y $tBIZRsII$$Btsj BtRs$tR Bt Y BAR%sAj 8BIR qY$R $RRZ b$jj A I$RZRRI $t Y htsj7 zy

yy V7y] e+=Vqy!W7

qY$R R$Bt IsjR b$Y s I$%s$Bt BP Y $t8BI JZs$BtR PB RYs VjP%?t TZAs$BtR $t s jsTsRTs$B BZR !Z Bsj Y $R B Rt s PB8sj$R8 Ys bb$jj Yt ZR B j$t, VjP%?t ]sRsI 8BIR B qVeR $t jsR8sR b$Y tBtT8BtBBt$ RsPkPsB Bhj w$ b$Y 8st$ RYs %RsjD qY$R PB8sj$R8 b$jj sjRB A j%st BY sR BP 8BtBBt$ RsPk PsB b$Y st -tII ss BP %k jBb RYs 3B Y Rs,BP R$8j$$k b b$jj R$ Y I$%s$Bt B Y j$8$$t sR BP 9B jsR8s RRZ stIY$Y 8BI tZ8AR G b$jj YPB tj sjj RRZ &R $t Y$R s y RYBZjI AB$tI BZ Ys BZ JZs$BtR b$jj $tjZI RBtI BI B$BtR $t $t%R sR s$BG b$jj Yt I8BtRs w$t 7 yyyD Ys YR B$BtR sjBt st RZB s jBsj$9I8BI AjBb Y qVe s $P Y 8st$ RYs $R RZ^$tjk jBbG YBBR s sZ $t bY$Y Y Rsjs Bt$sj JZsjR 9B RB Ys Y ZAI j$

stI 8st$ hjIR st A b$t $t 8R BP s %B Bt$sj &\ sR PBjjBbRU&o ) d

(&\(0 , &4 ) Zj &\3 w1D

G sRRZ8 Ys Y ssjjj B8Btt BP Y ZAI j$ hjI %st$RYR IZ B Y$YjBt BtIZ$%$k sjBt Y 8st$ hjI j$tR qY ZAI %B Bt$sj &\ stYt A RtI Ak s R$tj Rsjs PZt$Bt U

&\ ) n KwK N nD3 wnDbY K # 4b4 $R s Zt$ %B $t Y I$$Bt BP Y JZ$j$A$Z8 8st$ hjI 4qY$R Rts$Bt j$8$tsR B8RR$Btsj VjP%?t ZAs$BtR Ys bBZjI BYb$R AIR$AI Ak stBY Rsjs PZt$Bt b$Y st sII$$Btsj 8 n K Bt Y $YTYstIR$I BP eJ wnD qY RYs VjP%?t 8BI JZs$Bt PB B8R PB8 Y JZsR$tZsj$kBtI$$Bt

I$% &i L I$% &i ) (, w;D

x

bY &i stI &i s Y B8BttR BP Y ZAI Zt wssjjj stI tI$ZjsB Y I$$Bt BP Y JZ$j$A$Z8 8st$ hjI R$%jkD qY ZAI ssjjjZt $R jsI B Ak Y V8 jsbU

&i ) ;$KwK N Zj &4D )

;$KwK N Zj ZjwKwK N nDDD3 wxD

]sjZjs$Bt BP Y ZAI tI$Zjs Zt $t%Bj%R Y 8B8tZ8 Asjst JZsT$BtU

'(&8(0 ) d >&i 4H L d

;$ >Zj4 &4H wEDb$Y

&8 ) 4 >K &oH ) d

4 >K n H3 wD7ZAR$Z$Bt BP &i stI &i $tB eJ w;D b$Y RB8 sII$$Btsj Rs$YPBbsI sjAs $%R

I$% d~

^K

^n(

(0 K) w4 N nD d4 I$%

4

sI

w d4 wK N nD

W 4

]]

sIw d4 wK N nD

WN n 4 L w4 N nD

d4

w d4 wK N nD

Ww4 N n 4D

]wMD

bY ~ $R Y VjP%?t %jB$k G b$jj j$8$ BZ BtR$Is$Bt B 8BIR b$Y s jBAsj RsjTjtY sjBt Y 8st$ hjI j$tR AZ b$Y js BjB$Isj stI BB$Isj 8BI tZ8AR zstI E G YPB tj Y jsR 8 Bt Y $YTYstI R$I BP eJ wMD stI BAs$t

U # I$% d~

^K

^n(

(0 KL w4 N nD d4 I$%

4

sI

w d4 wK N nD

W 4

]]

sIw d4 wK N nD

WN n 4 ) ( wD

bY b Ys% $tBIZI s RjPT-jstsBk j$ts I$&t$sj BsB U B RYBt YPBYB8$t sjZjs$BtR!Z stsjkR$R BP eJ wD $t st s-$Rk88$ BZR b$jj 8jBk Rs$Y hjITj$t BBI$tsR

b$Y Y PBjjBb$t -RR$Bt PB Y ZtZAI 8st$ hjIU

4 ) 4 RwDn nwR D3 wd(D

bY stI s Y BB$Isj stI BjB$Isj stjR R$%jk $R Y 4Z- BBI$tsRwD $R Y RsPk PsB stI 4 $R Y %sjZ BP Y ZtZAI hjI Bt Y 8st$ s-$RqY FsBA$st O stI Y 8$ B^$tR PB Y$R BBI$ts RkR8 $t s js sR s$BB,s8s, s $%t $t VtI$- V

E

qY PZt$Bt bY$Y $R s $BI$ PZt$Bt BP stI st A RtI Ak s 3BZ$R$R sR PBjjBbRU

w 0D ) -w7z 70D3 wD -w7ED L 33 wddD

bY $R Y 8BI PJZtk stI wD $R Y sI$sj $tPZt$Bt PB Y ETY BjB$IsjYs8Bt$Vt $8Bst PsZ BP Y jBb RYs $t8BIR $R Ys sY BP Y8 Bts$tR tB

8B Yst Y R$t$hst BjB$Isj Ys8Bt$R RB Ys b st Zts Y $YTYstIR$I BP eJ wddD B `ZR Y 8R G b$jj jsAj YR 8R Ak Y RZAR$R E dE stI E L d R$%jk 4$t Y Ps Ys Y BB$Isj &R BZj $8s$jk Yt$YAB$t Ys8Bt$R qY BRBtI$t Y JZs$BtR PB wD, wD stI wDb$jj A PZY IZI B $Y s R$tj JZs$Bt PB wD w$P Y 8BI PJZtk $R tBBB jBR B Y qVe sD B B s R BP bB BZjI JZs$BtR PB wD stI wD w$PY 8BI PJZtk $R b$Y$t Y qVe s B %k jBR B Y sDyt BI B I$% Y JZs$BtR PB wD wD stI wD b 8Zj$jk eJ wD

Ak -w7z L 70 L 7qD bY Y $t q ZtR PB8 E d YBZY E L d stI bs%s Y RZj B% Y stZjs %s$sAjR w D stI B% $8 y $R Bt%t$t B b$Y tRZ$t JZs$BtR $t s 8s$- PB8

U wD ) (, wd1D

bY RZ88s$Bt B% i $R $8j$I b$Y i Ztt$t PB8 E d YBZY EL d qY 8s$-U $R jsI B Y BsB U Ak

U # dp

?Ow D -w7qDU -w7iD# , wdnD

bY Y stZjs As,R ItB Y BjB$Isj stj s%s$t BIZ e%k j8tBP Y 8s$- U $R s RBtITBI I$&t$sj BsB $t qY -j$$ -RR$BtR PBYR BsBR s RtI $t VtI$- stI VtI$- ]!Z s8t BP eJ wd1D b$jj 8jBk Yss$R$ BI$t PsZR BP Y BsBR

U $t s jsTsRTs$B B,s8s, G BAR% Ys sjj Y B&TI$sBtsj BsBR sBB$Btsj B Y $t%R sR s$B bY$Y 8s,R Y8 tsjjk R8sjj Yst stk I$TsBtsj BsB ZtjRR $R s$Zjsjk jBR B # /z ! / PB stk BP Y Y sjjBbIqT%sjZR 3ZY8B $ $R sjjBbsAj B IB Y BsBR U stI U R$t

Y BB$I$$kT$tIZI BZj$t Abt Y BjB$Isj Ys8Bt$R $t%Bj%R $8s$jk Y jBRTR t$YABR yP Y PJZt$R , stI s sjj R$t$hstjk I$&t wPB s$%t %sjZ BP RD Yt Btjk Bt BP Y I$sBtsj BsBR st A ZtYss$R$sjjk R8sjjy $R sjRB BRR$Aj Ys bB BP Y Y I$sBtsj BsBR AB8 R8sjj R$8ZjstBZRjkAZ Y$R JZ$R Ys Y BRBtI$t PJZt$R B8 jBR B sY BY qY sR BPbjjTRssI w$ PJZt$R RZ^$tjk Ps PB8 Y qVe sRD $R j%st B ]sRsI8BIR bYsR Y BY sR RtR qVe 8BIR yt bYs PBjjBbR b hR BtR$IsY BP YR bB sRR Rssjk stI Yt IR$A Y stR$$Bt Abt Y bB

yyy ]V7]V*e !*e7

yt Y$R RZAR$Bt b b$jj sRRZ8 Ys Y Btjk XR8sjj" I$sBtsj BsB $R U GYt stRPB8 eJ wd1D B Y PBjjBb$t RU

U wD L U wD L U wD ) ( wd;D wD ) U

U wD= wdxD wD ) U

U wD= wdEDbY Y RZR$ Xd"ItBR st $t%R BsB qY $t%R$Bt $R s RZ$sAj BTIZ PB Y Xjs" BsBR wU stI U D R$t $ IBR tB $tBIZ XR8sjjItB8$tsBR" G YAk IZ eJR wd;DTwdED B s R$tj JZs$Bt PB wDUU wD ) U

+U U wD= L U

+U U wD= 3

wdDy $R 8s,sAj Ys PB Y BAj8 BP $tR Y$R JZs$Bt $R sZsjjk JZ$%sjt B

s RBtI BI I$&t$sj JZs$Bt IR$ Y Ps Ys Y 8 Bt Y $YTYstI R$I $Rtsjjk st $tBTI$&t$sj BsB G htI Ys Y Btjk I$&t Abt eJ wdDstI s R$8$js RBtI BI I$&t$sj JZs$Bt

U wD ) (, wdMD$R $t Y B^$tR Ys IR$A Y TB$BtR B Y$R BYb$R Xkj$tI$sj" $t8BIJZs$Btyt BI B -j$$jk sjZjs Y $YTYstI R$I Bt$AZ$Bt B eJ wdD b tB Ys

sY BP Y bB 8R Bt Y $YTYstI R$I $R sjsIk JZsIs$ $t Y $t%R sR s$B

M

y $R YPB sjjBbsAj B s sjj Y B^$tR $t Y BsBR Bt Y $YTYstI R$IsR BtRstR sR jBt sR Y PZt$Bt wD $R jBsj$9I $t Y %$$t$k BP Y 9B RYs B$tstI Y sI$sj b$IY BP wD $R 8ZY R8sjj Yst Y 8$tB sI$ZR yt sII$$Bt $ $RsjjBbsAj B ZR Y jBbR BI I$RR$Bt js$Bt

) # ~

p

Xz E

R ~

, wdD

B R$8j$Pk Y $YTYstI R$I BP eJ wdD R$t R8sjj I%$s$BtR PB8 Y$R js$Bt stA RsPjk $tBI $t Y TB$BtR qY JZst$k ~ $t eJ wdD $R Y 4Z- RZPss%sI VjP%?t %jB$k sR IhtI $t VtI$- ] qY IR$AI R$8j$hs$BtR sjjBb ZRB Rs$YPBbsIjk sjZjs Y $YTYstI R$I BP eJ wdD %$s 3BZ$ stRPB8s$Bt $tsI$ZR G Yt Bt% Y 3BZ$ $8s As, $tB s sj Rs Rts$Bt B BAs$tU

U +U

U wD= L U +U

U wD=

) 1

~

l ( (

^ w " L D w1Rz 1ED d L w1 " L D

wEW ^ w " D

w1Rz 1ED d w1 " L DM 3

w1(DW- b B8A$t eJ w1(D b$Y s RssjkTI$%I -RR$Bt PB U wD >R eJ w 1DHstI b sst Y RZj Ak tj$t RB8 BP YBR TBt$AZ$BtR Ys s BtjkRBtR$Aj PB PJZtk TIht$$Bt wR VtI$- D bY$Y $%R((

mt

~ d

p

Xz E

R~ u

(( E

mt

~

Xd L 1 L 1 "

w1Rz 1ED d~ d

p

Xz E

R~ u

) (3w1dD

yt Y$R JZs$Bt Y BB$Isj &R bY$Y RY$P Y 8BI PJZtk PB8 Y VjP%?t Bt$tTZZ8 Rsj sR bYsR Y -$Rt BP qBB$Isj VjP%?t e$t8BIR $R sRRB$sI b$Y Yj$ts $t &R 7$t Y T8R Ys s RBtR$Aj PB Y VjP%?t ]sRsIR s JZ$R8sjj Bt st - Ys st t$ s$j RBtR 8sk B8 b$Y Y BB$I$$k& $t eJ w1dD ytII $ bsR RYBbt $t iP >d(H Ys PsR $BtR Y8Rj%R st A RBtTR$Aj PB Y -$Rt BP Y VjP%?t ]sRsI 8BI !t Y BY YstI $ $R 8B I$^ZjPB Y t$ s$j RBtR B B8 b$Y Y .wD BB$I$$k & sRRB$sIb$Y qVeR k sII$t Y YBk I%jBI $t iP >d(H B BZ stsjkR$R Bt htIR Ys YBt$AZ$Bt PB8 Y PsR $BtR 8BI$hR Y $t8BI JZs$Bt BU

QQ

mt

~ d

p

Xz E

R~ u

QQ E

mt

~ d

p

Xz E

R~ u

) E

~

X1 L 1 "w1Rz 1ED d

~ L ;$

4 E QQ

^ z # X d

p

Xz E

R~?i # #

3 w11D

qY stZjs As,R $t Y$R JZs$Bt ItB 4Z- RZPs s%s$t stI Y bB Bt$AZT$BtR B Y RBtI 8 Bt Y $YTYstITR$I Rt Y ItR$k stI Y ssjjj ZtBP Y PsR $BtR R$%jk 3B Y R BP Y s b sRRZ8 s k$sj $Bt kjBBt RTBtst Ys$t wy]i<D Rts$B b$Y ~ %$'&)( b~ U d RB Ys Y t$ s$j ssjjjZt b$jj A tjIyt BI B I8BtRs Y -$Rt BP st $t8BI $t eJ w11D b -stI Y ssjjj

bs% tZ8A ss8 *pz !,+ -).

Q sABZ Y B$t BP 9B 8st$ RYs ) bY Rw D # R $R Y 8$t$8Z8 %sjZ BP Y RsPk PsBU

dp

Xz E

RwD~

) dp

Xz E

R !~ L ER " " wD

R w D

p

Xz E

R ~3 w1nD

G sRRZ8 Ys Y$R -RR$Bt $R sZs B% s $Bt bY Y 8BI $R jBsj$9IbY$Y JZ$R wD c /zR E/wR bER " " D G st Yt R ) stI js YB^$t $t PBt BP Bt Y $YTYstI R$I BP eJ w11D Ak $R %sjZ s ) B BAs$tU

QQ?; Q

Q? ; ) 1 p

R ~

L 1 " w1R z 1ED d L

p R

~

/0#

E

XQ ' # X'Q

~-213- ,

w1;DbY ? # w DEb $R Y tB8sj$9I sI$sj BBI$ts /4# $R Y YB $Bt kBPJZtk' # stI ' s Y YB $Bt stI Y AZj, jsR8s 8sRR ItR$$R stI Y JZst$k ; w?D $R$%t Ak

; w?D )^1w D R

p

~ wR zED

R " "R E?

3 w1xD

eJZs$Bt w1;D YsR -sjk Y Rs8 RZZ sR eJ wd1D $t iP >d(H bY Y VjP%?t]sRsIR IZ B Y YB $BtR sjBt b IR$AI G st Yt $88I$sjk tsj$9 Y8BI -$Rt $$Bt PB8 iP >d(H B Y PBjjBb$t $tJZsj$kU

< 546 # < $'&)( L< (7&)8 k db;, w1EDbY< $'&)( )

XQ z # X

Q~-213-

;$p R 9

4 R " "

wE zR D #

R p

~ wE zR D

R R " "

^X'Q ' # XQ

~-)13-

/0#

,

w1D

d(

$R Y YB $Bt Bt$AZ$Bt $tBIZI $t iP >d(H stI

< (7&28 ) E

1R p

~ wE zR D

R R " "

w L 1 " D>d w1R z 1ED H w1MD

$R s B8$ Bt$AZ$Bt IZ B BB$I$$kG tB Ys PB s $%t %sjZ BP R eJ w1;D st IR$A ]sRsI 8BIR b$Y I$&tET

%sjZR stI b$Y I$&t PJZt$R w$Y sAB% B AjBb Y qVe sD yt ss$Bt BBZ RZARJZt I$RZRR$Bt BP Y stR$$Bt PB8 Y ]sRsIR B qVeR wR 7 zD b RjbB t$YAB$t ET%sjZR w- stI-dD stI b BtR$I Y st-bz k R k w-dDbzb$Y st -$Bt BP s R8sjj ss sBZtI R :3 ) w- db1Dbz wbY < (%&)8 AB8R R$tZjsstI Y ]sRsI sB-$8s$Bt ZRI B I$% eJ w1;D As,R IBbtD yt BI B $It$Pk sjjY ]sRsI 8BIR Ys s BRR$Aj sR R %s$R b Zt B 3$ 1 Ys RYBbR RY8s$sjjkY tB8sj$9I 8BI PJZt$R ) b :3 sR s PZt$Bt BP R $t Y st BP $tR3$Z 1s $R PB k ( stI 3$ 1A $R PB c ( esY hZ $R I$%$II $tB JZsIstRItI$t Bt R$tR BP < (7&28 stI < $'&)( PB Y BRBtI$t ET%sjZ qY Yss$9s$Bt BPsY JZsIst Rs$t s Y jBb jP Bt stI 8B%$t jB,b$R $R sR PBjjBbRUwsD -bz k R k w- db1Dbz // c d, E )- wAD -bz k R k w- db1Dbz // k d, E )- dwD w- db1Dbz k R k w- dDbz // k d, E )- wID w- db1Dbz k R k w- dDbz // c d, E )- d

qY RBj$I Z%R $t 3$ 1 $tI$s YBb Y ]sRsI 8BI PJZtk %s$R bYt Y PTJZtk $R RZ^$tjk Ps PB8 Y qVe s sRRZ8$t Ys Y BtI$$Bt w1ED $R Rs$RhI]jsjk Y sttB A s ]sRsI 8BI $t Y JZsIstR bY ABY < (7&28 stI < $,&;( sts$% BY < (%&)8 stI < $'&)( s BR$$% $t JZsIst wsD PB k ( stI $t JZsIst wADPB c ( RB Ys $t YR JZsIstR ABY &R Yj RZB s ]sRsI 8BI qB Ys% s]sRsI 8BI $t Y BY JZsIstR JZ$R Bt BP Y <T%sjZR B A RZ^$tjk jsYst Y BY B Rs$RPk eJ w1EDqY RZ8 BP $tPJZt$R PB eJ w1;D $R IR$AI $t iP >d(H qB sjk Ys

YBk Y b Btjk tI B js Y JZst$k < BP iP >d(H Ak < $'&;( L < (7&28 y $R sjRB$tRZ$% B sjk s G stsjkR$R B eJ w11D B $tP Y 8BI PJZtk RY$P PB8 YVjP%?t Bt$tZZ8 w$tI$sI $t 3$ 1D G Yt htI PB8 eJ w11D

dd

> - ) E

ld L

^ w L 1 " D>d ;wR zED H

1E

Q ' # X'Q

/4#

R p

> w DR p

L ~ EwE zR DwR R DH

Mw1D

bY > - $R Y sI$sj bs%tZ8A qB BAs$t s 8BI $t G YBk b tI > - B ABR$$% b$Y$t s $Bt BP 8BI jBsj$9s$Bt stI B A ts$% BZR$I Y$R $Bt GYt< (%&)8 L < $,&;( k ( Y -RR$Bt $t Y As, st $tII A 8sI BR$$% PB R $t Y%$$t$k BP R b$Y s RZ$sAj YB$ BP w Db G$Y s %RI RYs Bhj b RYs R R $tsRR sbsk PB8 Y RYs %Rsj RZPs RB Ys Y s 4$Bt B$tRw> - ) (D Bt ABY R$IR BP Y RZPs bY$Y $R tII PB s RstI$t bs% B -$R qYRG BtR$Is$BtR jsI B Y PJZtk RY$PR BP PB8 Ys s RY8s$sjjk RYBbt$t 3$ 1qB BtjZI Y$R R$Bt b tB IBbt Ys $ $R tB sjbskR tRRsk B Ys% 8st$

RYsT%Rsj $t Y jsR8s B RsAj$RY s 8BI BZR$I Y qVe s e%t s 8BtBBt$RsPk PsB Bhj st RZB RZY 8BIR B%$II Ys Y$R Bhj $R RZ^$tjk 4s $tY jsR8s B qY$R BRR$A$j$k s$RR $t Y sARt BP YB $BtR IZ B st $tjsk AbtY sI$sj ItIt $t Y T8 $t eJR w11D stI w1D stI Y sI$sj ItIt $t RwDbY$Y sR s XBt$sj bjj" B RZB s sI$sjjk jBsj$9I $t8BI qB I8BtRsY$R & b tB Ys Y $YTYstI R$I BP eJ w1D st $tII A BR$$% bYt w DstI R R s RZ^$tjk R8sjj WB Ys R R $R BR$$% PB s 8BtBBt$sjjk $tsR$t RBhj qYt b$Y w Db R8sjj stI BR$$% Y RBtI 8 $t Y As, $R BR$$%Iht$ $P EbR z k ( G sjRB tB Ys Y$R 8 $R R8sjj ts Y B$$t wbY stI <>= ?A@,B< - sBsY 9BD stI $ $R R8sjj Ps sbsk PB8 Y B$$t wbY R R $R jsD VR sRZj > - $R ts$% $t YR ABZtI$t $BtR yt Y $t8I$s $Bt > - st A 8sIBR$$% Ak s B YB$ BP bY$Y $tI$sR Y -$Rt BP s sI$sjjkTjBsj$9I 8BI

yz qVe7 WeVi 7<eVi iezei7VN _!yWq

qY Bj BP BB$I$$kT$tIZI BZj$t AB8R Z$sj bYt Y PJZtk BP Y ]sRTsI 8BI sBsYR Y qVe s <Bb% Y Bt%t$Btsj stsjk$ IR$$Bt BPqVeR IBR tB B% Y RYs %Rsj sR bY$Y B$tR BZ Y tI B 8BI$Pk Y YBk$t BI B sZsjk Btt Y ]sRsI 8BIR B qVeR

d1

qY Bt%t$Btsj qVe 8BIR s ,tBbt B A sRRB$sI b$Y XR$sj" %sjZR BP R >R )R :3 # w1E dDb1zH Ys Rt Y RBtR j$ts BZj$t Abt Y ETY stIwE dDTY BjB$Isj Ys8Bt$R B$%sI Ak Y -$8tR b sRRZ8 Ys Y RTBhjYsR s 8$t$8Z8 s RwD ) R b$Y$t Y jsR8s BRRTR$Bt stI Ys R IsRR $t $8yt $R 8B$Bt Y jBbR B$t $t Y RTBhj st B PB8 sAB% B AjBb R :3 !t 8$YsZ Ys Y RYBZjI A tB qVe 8BI Zt$j R sYR R :3 stI Ys Y RYBZjI A bB8BIR bYt R $R AjBb R :3 <Bb% Y sZsj $Z $R 8B RZAj sR Y qVeR IB tB8 RZIItjk s Y BRR$t ytRsI b htI Ys Y $R s Bt$tZBZR stR$$Bt PB8]sRsITk 8BIR B qVeR qY Bt%t$Btsj qVe YBk $R $tRZ^$t B IR$A YstR$$Bt AsZR Y RYs $R -sjk 9B s Y BRR$t stI Y RjB BP Y RTBhj sttB jBt A sI sR s BtRst s Y 8BI jBs$Bt V BtZsjjk j%st sBsYB Y sR BP %k jBb RYs bsR I%jBI $t iP >d1H bY $ bsR B$tI BZ Ys YsI$sj 8BI b$IY $t Y$R sR $R k$sjjk js Yst Y BjB$Isj bs%jtY VtBY$8Bst PsZ BP Y jBb RYs sR $R Y -$Rt BP 8Zj$j qVeR $t Y Rs8 syt bYs PBjjBbR b sIs Y sBsY BP iP >d1H B sIIRR Y stR$$Bt PB8 R k R :3B R c R :3 !tjk bB BP Y Y BjB$Isj Ys8Bt$R s R$t$hst $t Y qVe sR G b$jj YBBR

Y$ BjB$Isj 8BI tZ8AR B A E stI E d qY RRt BP Y BAj8 $R sZIAk Y PBjjBb$t R BP JZs$BtR PB YR bB Ys8Bt$RU

QQ?; Q

Q? ; L L " 1 " " L 1 "

1 " L " 1 ) ( wn(D

QQ?; QQ? ; L L "

1 " " L L 1 " 1 " L "

1 ) (, wndDbY$t ? # w DEb Y RZAR$ "(" PR B Y 9B RYs B$t stI Y JZst$$R; stI ; s $%t Ak

; )^ R p

~ wR zED wR zED

R " "R E?

, wn1D

; )^ R p

~ wR zEL dD wR zEL dD

R " "R E?

, wnnD

3B Y sI$sjjkT-tII 8BIR b$Y s 8BI b$IY ? ( d b st PB8sjjk s sjjY I$%s$% 8R $t YR JZs$BtR sR R8sjj B8sI B tBtTI$%s$% 8R qY$RsB-$8s$Bt sjjBbR ZR B -j$$jk -RR $t 8R BP stI $R I$%s$%R stIBAs$t s 7Y[BI$tTk JZs$Bt PB U

dn

w L 1 " D;

Q Q?

mtwd 1

eeeezR EL d1eeeeW w

R zEL d1W R " " ?

R E LX R " "C ? 1R E

~ L w L 1 " D

1 R " " ?R E

uwn;D

) TzZ^ R p

~

wzR ED ^ R p

~ wzR EL dD

X " 1

~ [` 3

G tBb BAR% Ys s Yst $t R PB8 R k R B R c R :3 YstR Y RZZBP Y XBt$sj tk" 8 PB8 s R$tj bjj B s IBZAj bjj sR RYBbt $t 3$ n qYIBZAjTbjj sR RtR bB PI jBs$BtR PB qVeR Bt Y BBR$ R$IR BP Y9B RYs B$t qY R$tj bjj sR $tI$sR Ys st $t8BI st -$R %t APB R BRRR Y %sjZ R <Bb% Y jBtTbs%jtY sB-$8s$Bt YsR s sY R$$%sj$sA$j$k BtI$$Bt $t Y R$tjTbjj sR y JZ$R 9 E ( ;wR zELdb1D - * !)D D! bY$Y$R I$^Zj B Rs$RPk ZtjRR Y 8BI $R %k jBR B Y qVe s B Y RTBhj $R tsjk4s RB Ys R " " U R qY &R Ys sjjBb Y 8BI B RZ%$% BZR$I Y qVe sYs% sjsIk At I$RZRRI $t 7 yyy

z qiVW7yqy!W 3i! VN3z?eW ]V7]V*e7 q! qVe7

yt BI B s Y stR$$Bt PB8 Y tsjk kj$tI$sj sRsI 8BIR B qVeR bsII Y YB s$j Bt$AZ$Bt < $'&;( B Y XI$sBtsj" BsBR $t eJR wd1D stI RBj% sZtsI wbBTYs8Bt$D %R$Bt BP YR JZs$BtR tZ8$sjjk PB s 8BIj %RITRYsJZ$j$A$Z8 b$Y $Zjs 4Z- RZPsR G YBBR s h-I sI$sj Bhj BP Y BB$Isj ZtstI %sk Y Bsj %sjZ BP Y Zt bY$Y YstR Y %sjZ BP Y RsPk PsB s Y9B RYs B$t qY$R sjZjs$Bt $%R s RJZt BP $tPJZt$R stI sI$sj $t8BIRPB Y RjI %sjZR BP R sR R YstR $t $8 qY$R IZI tZ8$sj 8BIj YsR At%$hI b$Y Y PZjj B8k BIR y7<V >dnH stI ]V7q!i >d;H qY jBtTbs%jtYsB-$8s$Bt B%$IR s j%st JZsj$s$% Z$Ist PB BZ tZ8$sj stsjkR$ResY sjZjsI $t8BI st A jsAjI Ak $R BB$Isj 8BI tZ8A z s s$ BP

BjB$Isj 8BI tZ8AR wsRRZ8$t Ys Y 8BI Bts$tR IB8$tstjk ETY stI wEdDTY BjB$Isj B8BttRD stI s sI$sj jsAj q bY$Y $R Y tZ8A BP 9BR wtBIRD $t YsI$sj $tPZt$BtR PB sY BP Y ETY stI wE dDTY BjB$Isj B8BttR R$%jk

d;

3$ZR ; stI x RYBb $tPJZt$R PB jBbR sI$sj 8BIR b$Y Y Rs8 %sjZR BP z stIE qY bB RBj$I Z%R s Y PJZt$R BP Y 8BIR b$Y q ) w( dD wjBb Z%D stIq ) wd (D wZ Z%D sR s PZt$Bt BP R qY IBI Z%R $t Y hZ 8s, Y VjP%?tBt$tZZ8 PJZt$R PB Y RjI %sjZR BP z stI E qY$R hZ I8BtRsR s RBtsRk88k $t Y 8BI PJZtk AYs%$BU Y 8BI hR RskR jBR B Y Bt$tZZ8PJZtk Zt$j R sYR R :3 stI Yt IsYR PB8 Y Bt$tZZ8 stI 8B%R $tB YqVe s sY Yst s,$t Y Bt$tZZ8 bY$Y bBZjI %R Y I$$Bt BP PJZtkY$$tqY$R st $R BtR$Rt b$Y Y %BjZ$Bt BP Y Bt$sj bjj $t eJ wxD stI Y Rs8

tsj tI $R jsjk Rt $t Y -$8tsj Iss $t 3$ d qY sjZjsI %BjZ$BtBP Y 8BI RZZ sjBt Y RBj$I Z%R BP 3$R ; stI x B%$IR sII$$Btsj %$ItYs Y ]sRsI 8BIR $tII Bt% XsI$sAs$sjjk" $tB qVeR 3$Z E $jjZRsR YBbY $t$$sj kj$tI$sj ]sRsI 8BI b$Y s BjB$Isj 8BI tZ8A E ) d1 w$tI$sI AkY $tPZt$Bt RZAR$D s$tR s RBtI B8Btt IZ B BB$Isj BZj$t sR Y 8BIPJZtk sBsYR Y qVe s !t $t Y s Y 8BI Yt -Y$A$R Y k$sjR$tsZ BP qVe $ bB tsjk JZsj stI RBtjk BZjI BjB$Isj B8BttR VtBYYss$R$ PsZ $t 3$ E $R Ys Y 8BI sJZ$R s IBZAjTYZ8 RZZ bYt Y&$% XBt$sj tk" $t eJ wxD YstR PB8 s R$tj bjj B s IBZAj bjj Ns$t $R %BjZ$Bt Y TB8Btt ZtR B s R$tj YZ8 RZZ Ys $R tBb RY$PIPB8 Y 9B RYs B$t qY RY$P B8R PB8 st sRk88k BP Y IBZAj Bt$sjbjj bY$Y PBR Y jBb PJZtk 8BI B Btts IB8$tstjk $t Bt BP Y bBsI`st bjjR qY Z PJZtk 8BI BA%$BZRjk XPR" Y BY YsjP BP Y bjjstI $ $R YPB RY$PI B Y jP PB8 Y 9B RYs B$t VjRB Y Z PJZtk8BI YsR st st$TAsjjBBt$t BjB$Isj RZZ $t Y qVe s wY BBR$ R$tR BP YBjB$Isj B8BttR sZR 8BI jBsj$9s$Bt Bt Y $tt s BP Y BZRD bYsR YjBb PJZtk 8BI -Y$A$R s AsjjBBt$t RZZ w8BI jBsj$9s$Bt Bt Y BZ sBP Y BZRD 3$Z RYBbR Ys ts$% PJZtk 8BIR BP 3$ x ZtIB s %k R$8$jsstR$$Bt $t Y 8BI RZZ

dx

zy *y7]=77y!W VW* 7=ViO

yt Y$R bB, b Ys% -tII Y YBk BP VjP%?t ]sRsIR >d(H Ys Ys% At BAR%I$t s %s$k BP B,s8s, -$8tR b$Y %RI 8st$ RYs yt$$sjjk Y$ -$RtbsR s$AZI B Y RBtR BP js BA$ YB s$jR qY 8BI$hI YBk tBb $tjZIRBB$Isj <* &R $t sII$$Bt B t$ s$j &R y I8BtRsR Ys Y]sRsI 8BIR st sjRB -$R b$YBZ Y t$ s$jR sjYBZY Y t$ s$jRst RZARst$sjjk Ps$j$s Y$ 8st$PRs$Bt yt sII$$Bt Y -tII YBk I$RYs Y ]sRsIR st -$R %t b$YBZ 8st$ RYs %Rsj $P Y RTBhj $R tsjk4s $t Y t qY RtI YBk sjRB IR$AR Y sI$sAs$ stRPB8s$Bt BPVjP%?t ]sRsIR $tB qVeR sR bjj sR 8BI$hs$BtR BP qVeR Y8Rj%R ts Y RYs%Rsj B$t y $R B$tI BZ Ys PB s $%t BB$Isj 8BI tZ8A Y VjP%?t ]sRsIRZ8 sB88BIsR ABY BR$$% stI ts$% PJZtk 8BIR sAB% stI AjBb YqVe st BP PJZt$Ryt BI B I$RZRR -$8tsj Iss bYt V]R stI Y qVeR s -$I Ak t$

s$jR st sII$$Btsj Rj$Bt Zj PB Y 8BI -$s$Bt tIR B A sj$I yP BtsRRZ8R Ys Y -$s$Bt $R IZ B Y Zt$%Rsj $tRsA$j$k I$% >dxH PB st t$s$j Bhj Ys IsRR sI$sjjk Yt $t Y tBs$Bt BP Y$R s Btjk Y BR$$%PJZtk bs%R RYBZjI A RjI WBtYjRR $ RYBZjI A , $t 8$tI Ys $ $R BRR$AjPB Y sI$sj Bhj BP Y t$ s$jR B A $t%I stI Ys st sII$$Btsj $tRsA$j$kI$% IZ B YB s$j st$RBBk $t YsR Rs st Bt$%sAjk jsI B Y -$s$Bt BPY ts$% PJZtk bs%RVR sjsIk B$tI BZ 3$ d I8BtRsR Ys Y V] 8BIR AjBb Y qVe PJZtk

Rb ZbsI bYt R IsRR $t $8 qYR 8BIR s B8s$Aj b$Y Y sR RYBbt$t JZsIst wsD BP 3$ 1s yt Y$R sR Y R$tR BP ABY < (%&)8 stI < $'&;( s Ps%BsAj PBY -$Rt BP Y 8BI stI Y Zt$%Rsj $tRsA$j$k 8Yst$R8 B%$IR s I$% PB Y8BI G sjRB R $t 3$ d Ys RB8 ZbsI Rb$t 8BIR Bt% $tB qVeR bY$Y $RB8s$Aj b$Y Y AYs%$B RYBbt $t 3$ ; sjYBZY $t -$8t Y s sRR bYRB8 8BIR I$Rss sR Y PJZtk sYR Y qVe s ws YtB8tBt Ys R$jj tIR-jsts$BtDqY ]sRsI 8BIR Ys Rs Bt B B sAB% Y qVe s $t 3$ d stI Rb IBbtbsI

sR R IsRR ss B A B8s$Aj b$Y Y 8BI RYBbt $t JZsIst wAD BP 3$ 1s

dE

bY < (7&28 $R js Yst /< $'&)( / y R$jj 8s$tR B I8$t bYk YR IBbtbsI Rb$t8BIR 8$ts sY Yst sIZsjjk Bt% $tB qVeRqY 8BR t YB$sj I$RZRR$Bt BP Y 8BIR -$I Ak Y Zt$%Rsj $tRsA$j$k

I$% $R RtI $t iP >dEH Ys IsjR RBjjk b$Y Y BR$$% PJZtk 8BIR ytY bB, RtI Y b Ys% RYBbt Ys Y sII$$Btsj RBtI BI BB$Isj <*& sjjBbR PB ]sRsI BIR B -$R %t b$YBZ t$ s$jR VjRB Y 8BB8j RZ8 BP VjP%?t 8BIR Ys $R IR$AI bY$Y $tjZI ts$% stI BR$$%PJZt$R st A 8jBkI $t <* RBRBk >nH AsRI Bt 8BI -$s$Bt b$Y st-tsj sttts qY BAR%s$Bt Ys <* &R sjBt st RsAj$RY st V] $t8BI$R s$Zjsjk j%st B Y -$8tsj sR b$Y s %k jBb ItR$k BP YB $BtR sjYsTI$%t V]R $t q3qi *q -$8tR b$Y s tsjk 4s tsj RTBhj >dH BY Y Is$jI j$ts RsA$j$k stsjkR$R stI tBtj$ts YBk BP VjP%?t ]sRsIR B

AkBtI Y j$8$I RB BP Y$R s qYR -tR$BtR bBZjI A s$Zjsjk IR$sAjPB I$stBR$ sj$s$BtR BP VjP%?t ]sRsIR y $R tBbBYk Ys Y ]sRsIR sjsIkB%$I s %sjZsAj I$stBR$ BBj %t s Y Rt j%j BP Y$ ZtIRstI$t Vt$8RR$% -s8j BP Ys $R Y BAR%I Bjs$Bt Abt Y ]sRsIR stI Y $ttsjstRB As$ wyq D $$t %tR $t %RI RYs I$RYsR $t Feq >dMH qY$RBjs$Bt YsR At RZRRPZjjk ZRI B B$8$9 Y I$RYs ss8R PB Y stRBAs$ PB8s$Bt >dH

d

VtI$- VU 7s$Y hjI j$t Rts$Bt

yt Y Rs$Y hjI j$t Rts$Bt >eJ wd(DH Y Y $tI$%$IZsj 8R $t eJ wDYs% Y PBjjBb$t PB8U

I$% d~

^K

^n(

(0 K) d

O((

^O d~

^wnD (

(( (0 L wn N nD (

(( (0

LdO((

^O d~

^wnD (

(( (0 L wn N nD (

(( (0

L d

O((

^O d~ wnD (

(( (0

4 O

X (( L

dR((

~ dO

d4 ~

X (( L

dR((

~ ( (0

wVdD

w4 N nD d4 I$%4

sI

w d4 wK N nD

W 4

]]

) 4 O

X (( L

dR((

~ d4

l dO

((

^O4 ^(B

( wnD L (B( wn N nD

M

L4 O

X (( L

dR((

~ d4

l dO

((

^O4 ^(B

( wnD L (B( wn N nD

M

L4 O

X (( L

dR((

~ d4

l dO

((

^O4 (B

( wnD 4

O

X (( L

dR((

~ dO

X(B( L

dR(B(

~M

wV1D

sIB N4 ) (B( wn N4D (B

( wn N4D (B( wn N4D3 wVnD

yt YR -RR$BtR Y FsBA$st O Y sARBjZ %sjZ BP Y JZ$j$A$Z8 8st$ hjI4 stI Y RZj8tsk PZt$Bt B s $%t AkU

O # d>n nH N n , wV;D

4 # 4 lwnD wnD wn N nD = L d

R wnD wnD =

M, wVxD

B # d4 w4 N nD ) 4

O4 ^(( L

dR((

3 wVED

yt s js sR s$B B,s8s, b$Y $Zjs 4Z- RZPsR Y PBjjBb$t -RR$BtR YBjIPB Y FsBA$st stI Y 8$ B^$tRU

O # d>n nH N n ) p

wd L 1

p BR W

wVD

dM

n N n ) d L 1 " BR wVMD

n N n ) d

d 1

w p L "

WBR

]wVD

n N n ) R$t w p L w " D "

WwVd(D

n N n ) dp

wd 1

p BR W

wVddD

n N n ) n N n ) ( wVd1DbY$t p $R Y sI$ZR BP Y 8st$ s-$R wD $R Y 7YsPstB% RY$P stI Y $8ItBR s sI$sj I$%s$% yt Y sARt BP jsR8s RRZ " $R R$8jk BB$Btsj B PB $Zjs 4Z- RZPsR y $R YPB 8$RR$Aj B js w " D " Ak 1 " $t eJ wVddDstI $t Y RZARJZt -RR$BtRy RYBZjI A tBI Ys b Ys% B8$I sjj RBtITBI 8R $t $t%R sR s$B $t

eJR wVMDTwVd1D W%YjRR $ ZtR BZ Ys YR -RR$BtR s R$jj sZs tBZYPB Y sjZjs$Bt BP Y j%st T8R $t Y $t8BI JZs$Bt qY Btjk & PB8Y tjI Bt$AZ$BtR B eJR wVMDTwVd1D $R st $tR$t$hst tB8sj$9s$Bt BP Y$t8BI PJZtk

d

VtI$- U *$sBtsj 8s$- j8tR

qY I$sBtsj 8s$- j8tR wU , U , U D s BAs$tI Ak sjk$t Ys%s$t BIZ >R eJ wd1DH B Y B8BttR BP Y $t8BI JZs$Bt IR$AIAk eJR wVdDTwVnD 7$t n N n R$t $R st BII PZt$Bt BP sjj Y 8R b$Y n Nn$t eJR wVdDTwVnD %st$RY sR s RZj BP s%s$t qY 8s$t$t 8R s, Y PBjjBb$tPB8U

U ) ((

rO

p ~ wnD Xz E

R~

p O wnD S (

(

E

rO

p ~ wnD Xz E

R~

p O wnD S 3

w dD

eJZs$Bt w dD $8j$$jk $tjZIR Y JZ$I .w D Bt$AZ$BtR $t Y $t%R sRs$B -stR$Bt qY tjI 8R Bts$t $Y st sII$$Btsj PsB wdbED U d B b$Y R B Y s$tI .w D 8RqB 9BY BI $t Y JZst$$R $t Y hR stI Y RBtI 8R BP eJ w dD s

JZsj B sY BY V %st$RY$t As, $%R Y VjP%?t Bt$tZZ8 I$RR$Bt js$BtqY B8$sj BB$Isj B$BtR B Y s%sI -RR$BtR $t stZjs As,R s.w D R$t Y .wD 8R s BII PZt$BtR BP y RYBZjI A B$tI BZ Ys stkR8sjj B$BtR Ys Bt$AZ JZsjjk B Y bB As,I -RR$BtR IB tB s& YRZZ BP eJ w dD sR YR B$BtR st A sARBAI Ak s $%$sj TIht$$Bt BP G YPB tI B Rj Y B$BtR Ys s s I$&t Abt Y As,I8R V R$8j stsjkR$R RYBbR Ys sjj RZY B$BtR B8 Btjk PB8 Y BIZR BP Yj$ts w$t D Bt$AZ$BtR B Y FsBA$st stI B Y 8$ B^$tR qY$R BAR%s$Bt8stR Ys Y sZsk BP eJR wVMDTwVd(D $R sZsjjk RZ^$t B sjZjs Y JZ$IB$BtR qY RZj$t -RR$Bt PB Y I$sBtsj 8s$- j8t YsR Y PB8UU E ) (

(X

~ wd L ; " D wzEbRD

p

~ ((

E

X

~ wd ;wL " DD wzEbRD

p

~3

w 1D

1(

VtI$- ]U !&TI$sBtsj 8s$- j8tR

qY s PBZ B&TI$sBtsj j8tR Ys s j%st B Y $t8BI JZs$Bt qYRs U U U stI U qY$ %sjZs$Bt $t%Bj%R Y Rs$YPBbsI$ts$Bt BP Y -RR$Bt $t eJ wdnD b$Y U stI O IhtI Ak eJR wD stI wVMD !tjkjBbR BI tBtT%st$RY$t 8R $t $t%R sR s$B -stR$Bt tI B A s$tI $tYR sjZjs$BtR Vt sII$$Btsj R$8j$hs$Bt B8R PB8 Y BtI$$Bt E ( d bY$YsjjBbR Bt B tj Y I$&t Abt E,E d stI E L d %kbY - $t YJZst$$R z ! , z ! stI z ! sR YR JZst$$R s k$sjjk BP Y BI BPZt$k wtB BP Y BI BP ED PB Y 8BIR BP $tR qY RZj$t -RR$BtR PB YB&TI$sBtsj j8tR s I8$tI Ak Y PBjjBb$t JZs$BtRU

U ) ((w1L " D

~(( d

p

Xz E

R~ (( " ((

Xz E d

R~

L

~ "

E dp " L

E Xz E dR

~Xz E

R~

~ E wL w " D " D (

( L dp E

Xz E

R~wL w " D " D (

(Xz E d

R~

w]dD

U ) (( w1L " D

~(( d

p

Xz E

R~ (( " ((

Xz EL d

R~

L

~ "

E dp " L

E Xz EL dR

~Xz E

R~

L

~ E

pL wD " Q (( d

p E

Xz E

R~wL w " D " D (

(Xz EL d

R~

w]1D

U ) ((w1L " D

~(( d

p

Xz E d

R~ (( " ((

Xz E

R~

L

~ "

E dp " L

E Xz E dR

~Xz E

R~

L

~ E wL w " D " D (

( dp E

Xz E d

R~wL w " D " D (

(Xz E

R~

w]nD

1d

U ) ((w1L " D

~(( d

p

Xz EL d

R~ (( " ((

Xz E

R~

L

~ "

E dp " L

E Xz EL dR

~Xz E

R~

~ E wL w " D " D (

( L dp E

Xz EL d

R~wL w " D " D (

(Xz E

R~ 3

w];D

yt YR -RR$BtR b ZR s tBs$Bt ~ PB Y 4Z- RZPs s%sI VjP%?t %jB$kbY$Y $R Y VjP%?t %jB$k sjZjsI PB s jBsj 8sRR ItR$k 'wD AZ PB Y BtTs-$R8st$ hjI 4 G s$t Y sI$sj ItIt BP ~ wD sR bjj sR Y sI$sj ItItBP Y $t%R sR s$B # bp Y 7YsPstB% RY$P PsB " wD stI Y RsPk PsBRwD

V,tBbjI8tR

qY$R bB, bsR RZBI Ak =7 * BP etk ]Bts WB *eT3p(nTEeiTx;n1E AkqY =t$I $tIB8 et$t$t stI _YkR$sj 7$tR iRsY ]BZt$j stI Ak eZsB8qY bB, bsR BtIZI sjk ZtI Y eZBst 3ZR$Bt *%jB8t V8t

11

iPtR

>dH N GBt i F 3Bt, 7 3 _sZj * i iBAR e * 3I$,RBt i Ws9$,$st < _s, jj W N 9 i ZItk 7 ]BYt p G <s88 3 ] FBAR * sI 7 7 Ijk * Zjj O Wssks8s * !btR stI e F 7kts,BbR,$_YkR i% N EE dM; wddD

>1H yqei _YkR$R e- pBZ Bt et$ _s$jR <s$t stI ]Zt *$% yqei_YkR$R sR$R eI$BR WZj 3ZR$Bt n 1;d wdD

>nH F _ pBIAjBI < V <Bj$R 7 _BIR p q V <ZkR8stR G t _jsR8s_YkR ]BtBj 3ZR$Bt nx 1 wdnDV 3sRBj$ * qRs 7 7YssB% < N , W $98st V pBtIYsj,s i 3< stR$tt stI Bt$AZBR B Y e3*VTFeq GB,Bs88 _jsR8s_YkR ]BtBj 3ZR$Bt ;; dx w1((1D

>;H ] ]Yt N ]Yt 7 ]Yst Vtt _YkR dEd 1d wdMxD] ]Yt stI 7 ]Yst _YkR 3jZ$IR 1 nEx wdMED

>xH * G iBRR p N ]Yt stI 7 sYs`st _YkR 3jZ$IR 1x Ex1 wdM1D>EH V _jsR8s _YkR ]BtBj 3ZR$Bt 1; dd; wdM1D>H < $8Zs O ZRs8s 7s$ZRs pF s8 qBA$s W8BB q BtIBY

q W$RY$st$ ! *s ]BRs q !9,$ q !$,sbs 7 B$ks8s V B$B,s pO 3Z] ]Yt stI zy VPstsR:% WZj 3ZR$Bt nM dn(n wdMD

>MH 7 e 7YssB% * qRs Vj * W BAs V 3sRBj$ W ] <sb,R i 3< stR$tt p zBt <jj8stt stI Bt$AZBR B Y e3*VTFeqGB,Bs88 _YkR N V 1M d1 w1((dD

>H 7 e 7YssB% Vj < N , * W BAs W $98st ] * ]Ysjj$RV 3sRBj$ W ] <sb,R q ] <tI F s$jjBZ- 7 * _$tYR * qRs stIBt$AZBR B Y e3*VTFeq GB,Bs88 _YkR _jsR8sR 1(1 w1((1D

>d(H < N , * W BAs W $98st 7 * _$tYR stI 7 e 7YssB% _YkRi% N M dMx((1 w1((dD

1n

>ddH < N , W $98st stI 7 _,, _jsR8s _YkR i 1n M wdD

>d1H F ]stIk W $98st F G zst *s8 stI q !9,$ _YkR N V 1dx 1wdED

>dnH p q V <ZkR8stR 7 e 7YssB% V $,Ys$jB%R,$$ stI G t _YkR_jsR8sR M ;11 w1((dD

>d;H G t F _ pBIAjBI p q V <ZkR8stR 7 _BIR stI e 7Ybs9 F ]B8_YkR d;1 1d wdMD

>dxH N y iZIs,B% stI i 7sI% 7B% _YkR *B,j E ;dx wdEdD

>dEH 3 Bts 7 $Zj$B N ]Yt 7 *$, p 3Bs$s * qRs stI p zjsI _YkR_jsR8sR ;n w1((1D

>dH i Ws9$,$st p F s8 < N , W $98st stI 7 7YssB% Zjj V8_YkR 7B ; n1 w1((1D

>dMH e FB&$t p pB$t$ ] * ]Ysjj$R W ] <sb,R q ] <tI * 3 <Bbjj _s _ st$s * s9Bt 7 e 7YssB% p qRR stI Bt$AZBR B Ye3*VTFeq GB,Bs88 _jsR8s _YkR ]BtBj 3ZR$Bt ;; dn w1((1D

>dH e FB&$t ] * ]Ysjj$R p * ]Btbsk psA V pZI 7 pZtY W ]<sb,R q 7 <tI * <Bbjj p q V <ZkR8stR e Ns99sB _ s ssY, V p _R 7 * _$tYR 7 e 7YssB% stI Bt$AZBR B Y e3*VTFeq GB,Bs88 yttsj stRB As$ $$t Ak s$Btsj 8st$ 4Z-RZPsR $t B,s8s,R 3ZR$Bt etk 1((1 w_B dY yVeV ]BtPt NkBt 1((1DyVeV z$tts e\_dTdn RZA8$I B WZjs 3ZR$Bt w1((nD

1;

3yp=ie ]V_qy!W7

3yp d VjP%?t ]sRsIR BP Rb$tTZ stI BP Rb$tTIBbt kR BAR%I $t s FeqI$RYs R$8ZjstBZRjk b$Y qVeR qY $Y s BP Y hZ $R s 9BB8 BP YjP s y RYBbR qVeR RB8 BP bY$Y s$R PB8 Y V]

3yp 1 7Y8s$ jB BP Y V] 8BI PJZt$R PB bB RjI BjB$Isj 8BI tZ8AR- stI-d qY I$&t JZsIstR BRBtI B I$&t R$tR BP < $'&;( stI < (7&28 7Bj$I j$tR $tI$s BRR$Aj V] 8BIR IsRYI j$tR $tI$s Y VjP%?t Bt$tZZ8Y $jR $tI$s Y $BtR bY Y ]sRsI 8BI sB-$8s$Bt Ps$jR qYj%st %sjZR BP E s RYBbt $t sY JZsIst 3$Z 1s RtR BR$$%PJZt$R stI 3$ 1A $R PB ts$% PJZt$R

3yp n qstRPB8s$Bt BP Y &$% Bt$sj PB sI$sjjk -tII 8BIR PB8 s R$tjbjj wzR EL db1 k (D B s IBZAj bjj wzR EL db1 c (D

3yp ; qstR$$Bt BP VjP%?t ]sRsI 8BIR B qVeR PB BR$$% PJZtk 8BIR 7Bj$IZ%R Rt $tPJZt$R PB jBbR BI sI$sj 8BIR b$Y z ) ; E )wd1 ddD stI b$Y Y PBjjBb$t %sjZR BP $tZ ss8RU R " " bR ) (31x < $'&;( )1 ) (3dn " ) (3(n qY$t IsRYI Z%R 8s, VjP%?t Bt$tZZ8 PJZt$RqY$, IsRYI Z% RtR Y 8BI RYBbt $t JZsIst wD BP 3$ 1s

3yp x qstR$$Bt BP VjP%?t ]sRsI 8BIR B qVeR PB ts$% PJZtk 8BIR 7Bj$IZ%R Rt $tPJZt$R PB jBbR BI sI$sj 8BIR b$Y z ) ; E )wd1 ddD stI b$Y Y Rs8 $tZ ss8R sR $t 3$ ; qY$t IsRYI Z%R 8s,VjP%?t Bt$tZZ8 PJZt$R qY$, IsRYI Z% RtR Y 8BI RYBbt $tJZsIst wID BP 3$ 1A

3yp E 7tsRYBR BP Y 8BI RZZ PB s BR$$% PJZtk 8BI b$Y z ) ; stIE ) wd1 ddD IZ$t Y stR$$Bt PB8 s ]sRsI 8BI B qVe qY jP BjZ8tRYBbR Y sI$sj BhjR BP Y E ) d1 stI E ) dd BjB$Isj B8BttR PBY jBb >q ) w( dDH 8BI BP 3$ ; qY $Y BjZ8t RYBbR Y Z 8BI>q ) wd (DH qY %sjZR BP R PB Y RtsRYBR sU wsD R ) 13dx wAD R ) 13MxwD R ) 13ME wID R ) 13M;

1x

3yp 7tsRYBR BP Y 8BI RZZ PB s ts$% PJZtk 8BI b$Y z ) ; stIE ) wd1 ddD IZ$t Y stR$$Bt PB8 s ]sRsI 8BI B qVe qY jP BjZ8tRYBbR Y sI$sj BhjR BP Y E ) d1 stI E ) dd BjB$Isj B8BttR PBY jBb >q ) w( dDH 8BI BP 3$ ; qY $Y BjZ8t RYBbR Y Z 8BI>q ) wd (DH qY %sjZR BP R PB Y RtsRYBR sU wsD R ) 13dx wAD R ) 13MxwD R ) 13ME wID R ) 13M;

1E

200

190

TAEs

TAEs

Cascade

180

170

160

150

140

6.2 6.4 6.6 6.86.0F

requency

(kH

z)

JG0

2.4

31

-3c

Time (s)

200

160

120

80

40

TAEs

Cascade

Cascades

6.54.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0

Fre

quency

(kH

z)

Time (s)

3yp dU

1

(b) m=M-1

(d) m=M-1

(c) m=M

(a) m=M

Q <0

Q >0tor Q <0tor

Q >0tor Q <0tor

hot

Q <0hotQ >0hot

Q >0hot

Mn

M-1n

M-1/2n

q0

Ω

1

2

ω>0

no mode

3yp 1sU

1M

(b) m=M-1

(d) m=M-1

(c) m=M

(a) m=M

Q >0

Q >0tor Q <0tor

Q >0tor Q <0tor

hot

Q >0hotQ <0hot

Q <0hot

q0

|Ω|

1

2

ω<0

Mn

M-1n

M-1/2n

no mode

3yp 1AU

1

0

0

nq0-m+1/2<0

nq0-m+1/2>0

U

x

3yp nU

n(

2

1.5

1

0.5

03 2.95 2.9 2.85 2.8 2.75

Safety factor q0(t)

l=(1,0)

l=(0,1)

Ω

ω>0

3yp ;U

nd

|Ω|

2

1.5

1

0.5

03 2.95 2.9 2.85 2.8 2.75

Safety factor q0(t)

l=(1,0)

l=(0,1)

ω<0

3yp xU

n1

)(b

(c)

(a)

(d)

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

No mode

Strong continuum damping

-8 -4 0 4 8

x-8 -4 0 4 8

x

Φ11 Φ12

Φ11

Φ12

3yp EU

nn

0

)(b

0

(c)

0

(a)

-8 -4 0 4 8

x

(d)

0

Φ11

0

-8 -4 0 4 8

x

Φ12

Φ11

Φ12

No mode

Strong continuum damping

0

0

3yp U