แนวทางการประเมินคุณธรรมและความโปร่งใสในการดำเนินงานของหน่วยงานภาครัฐ

L ~ tl ~ LL 'U 1Vl1 ~ n 1'Hh ~ L lJ 'U fl ru 5)) lJ LL~~ fl 11lJ1tl~~1'11'Un1) ~ 1LiJ'U~1'U'lJtl~'VI'U0 1 EH 1'U[)1 fl f \i . .. (Integrity and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~'11ll~utl1~mru vu•L l!:ictbo

L~tl'U ~l111"1ln11~~'Vl1Vl Vln~~'Vl1Vl v •

~~Yi"1~mv11tJ (9). V1u~~mhurn1'U tl.tl."ll. ~1'U~'1vi ~ tl"ll. o<Ol.Ci'.<Ol/1 oo<Olrn ~~1'LI~ rn<Ol ~mfllJ l!:ictct~ • • l!J. LLlJlJ)1tJzjv~tl1~'11m1'Un11tl1~LiJ'Ufl UJi)))lJLL~~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11'Um'Sl'"i1LU'U~1'U'IJtl~tl~rl m v ,

tlnfl1t1~"11'UVJtl~~'U (Integrity and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~'11ll~utl1~mru 'Y'Lf'l. l!J~o

rn . LL lJlJn1)~VJ'111~Utl1~lJ1ru Lfl)~n11tl1~LlJ'Ufl UJ5))lJLL~~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11 'Um11'11L U'U~1'U'IJtl~ • v~ri'mtlnfl1v~"11'UVltl~~'U (Integrity and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~~1ll ~utl1~mru YU'!. l!J~o

mlJ~ mmii~ L'1~lJ m1tl nmt1~Vf v~~'U 1v1''1lt11 ~~~'Vl1vi LL 4~~11! n~ 1'UG'1~ L'1~lJm1tlnmt1~ Vltl~~'U~~'Vl1Vl ~~~LL Vl'U~~'Vl1Vl~~ l!J fl'U L oLJ1 ~1lJtl1~'1llJ;ff LL 'l~ Lb 'U1V11~n11tl1~LlJ'Ufl UJ511lJLrn~fl11lJ L tJ~~ 1'1 v , •

1'Un111'11LU'U~1'U'IJtl~'Vlt11tJ~1'Ufl1fl-rji (Integrity and Transparency Assessment: ITA) tl1~'11ll

~ll tl 1~lJ 1 ru 'V'Ul. l!:ictbo L Yi v 1~~L.LJ1-ru m 1tl 1~blJ'U1v1i1 fl11 lJ ~ fl11lJL .LJ1 h Lrn ~'11lJ 11 m~ ~ tJlJ-ru v v

n11'lh~ LlJ'U 1v1'v ~ 1 ~ ~ nvi't1~'1tlVl fl i{ ti~ rllJ n)tllJ LL~ ~tl 5Vi'Un1 )t])~ LlJ'Utl1~blJ'Uf'l UJ5))lJLb~~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'1

1'Lim11'11LiJ'U~1'U'IJv~mrimtlnmv~"11'LIVlt1~~'U tl1~'11ll~utl1~mru 'Y'l.f'l . l!:ictbo if'U

n1lJ~~L'1~lJn11tlnmv~Vltl~~'U 1v1'Yl'l1)UJ1LLi11 L Ylt1 L lJ'Un11L~ ~tl lJfl11lJ'Y'I ~tllJ 1 'LI Lvn'11)

Lrn ~oLJvlJ~~ L~ tJ1-LJ't1~ nu m1tl1~ LlJ'UV11~ m1tl1~ blJ'U fl ru511mL~ ~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11 'LI m1~1L iJ'U~1'U'lJv~ ti~ rim v ,

tlnfl1t1~"11'UVJB~ ~'LI ~~'IJtl 1 ~~~'Vl1vi"1~ LL 'LI1V1 1 ~ m1tl 1~ LlJ'Ufl ru511mL~ ~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11 'LI m1~1 L iJ'U~1'U , 'IJtl~'VIU1tJ~1'Ufl1fl-r)1 (Integrity and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~~1ll~utl1~mru 'Y'l.f'l. l!Jctbo

1 ~~1un~1'UG'1~ L'1~lJ m1tl nmv~Vf v~~'U~~V11'vi~1 L iJ'U m1 ~~d (9) . Pi mnvi1 fl11lJ L .LJ1 h L~~ tJlJ fl11lJ'Y'lfalJ 1 'LI LB n'111V1~ n\i1'U LL~ ~-rr vlJ~ mmfl~v~i1 v .. v

m1tl1~LiJ'UV11~m1tl1~ LlJ'Uf1UJ511lJ LL~~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11 'LI n11~1L U'U~1'U'IJ'V~'VIU1 tl~1'Ufl1fl-rji (Integrity and

Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~'11ll~utl1~lJ1ru 'Y'l .f'l . l!Jctbo ~~'if mlJ~~L'1~l.m11tlnmv~Vltl~~'U 1v1tJ-ru~1~ Terms of Reference : TOR n~1~ 'IJB~~1un~1'U tl .tl.'ll. LYlmll'LILL'U1V11~1'Un1141~~tl~n'l'}1 mlJ~~Yi~~mv11tJ (9)

l!J. 1 ~~1U rn1'U~~ L'1~lJn11tlnmt1~Vf m~'U~~'Vl1VJLL4 ~)1tJzjtl~'lh~'11'UnU mlJ LL lJlJ)1tJzj ti v

~tl1~'11'U~1'Um1tl1~LiJ'Ufl ru511lJLL~~fl11lJ 1tl~~1'11 'Um1~1LU'U~1'U'IJB~v~r1 mtlnfl1m'11'UVJ v~~'U (Integrity v •

and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl1~'11ll~utl1~mru 'Y'l .f'l. l!:ictbo ~..:i1~m11~..:iLfl~l.mT~tlnfl":iB-llVl'1-ll~'U il1E.JL'U1 'U~ ID 0 lJ n ":i1 fl lJ IDct'b 0 1vi fl 'VI 1-ll 1 'VI ":ifl1":i'VllJ1 m ~ 'll o-IDID<i'.' G)-0 ID blli Lrn ~'VI 1..:i e-mail :

dlaot:<:@[email protected]

I i

- Iv -

htm'l~1LU'lN1'U'U8\l'Vl'll1tJ\11'U.fl1fl~~ (lnte~rity and Transparency Assessment : ITA) tl'l~\i1u.:i'U'lh~:mru

YUL ~ctbo '1a'UmlJ1~~f'l'UVU'l~i.ii'UAru5'l'lllLL"~m1lJ1tl~.:i1'1'llH.:JVl'll1ti.:i1'Umfl~'1 '11i1n.:i1'U tl .tl.'IJ. 'VllJ1tJL"'U u ' ....

1 Vl'll'i'l'l'V1 o-~ct'l!JG-ci'Goo via lvei'.oei'.1 Vl'l'11'l o-~ct'l!JG-Ci'.t'°Y~ct

~\IL~ EJ'Ul.rn ~a 1 tl'lvi~'11'lru1

Pl'U tltl n iJ~ m 1via~1'Um1V1 '111'1 u :..! '

n~lJ.:i1'U~a.:in'Utl11'Utl11lJn11V1'11vi1 ' '

1 V11/1 Vl1'111 o-~~Ci'.<9l-olvbQ'l/

_('U1 ti~'l'J.5 ~11ill1viti1m)

''rn\18G'U~ UDD~'l1'1Jfl1'l LL Vl'U

a5'U~ mlJ~\I L'11lJ n1'ltl nA 1a.:iV1a.:i ~'LI

'1TJn,:nu th.l .'ll. .. 0 ..

tl'U'U'U'UV1'U1 tl1Lfle.JL1J€l\l , ., ., .. :U\lVl1!1l'U'UVl'U1 (9)(9)000 ,

L~tl\l LL~\l LL 'U1V11\l fl11°Lh~ LiJ'Uf)ill6111J LL'1~fl111J 1tH-:i1'11 'Ufl11vl1L ti'U\l1'U'lJ€l\lVltl1tM1'Ufl1fl1~ (Integrity

and Transparency Assessment: ITA) L.l':i~~1lJ-:i'UL.l':i~mru YU'\. lvctbo

L1£J'U v6LJ~mmi-:iL'1~1lm1°L.lnfl1v-:iVfv-:i~'U

~-:i~'1-:imv118 (9) . LLemm1vi'1L ti'U'11'Um1L.l1~ LiJ'Ufltu5111JLL'1~fl111l 1L.l~-:i1'11 'Um1v\'1 L Um1'U'lJ€l\lV1tl1£J\l1'U , .

mflf'i L.l1~~1lJ-:iLJL.l1~:i..nru YU'1. lvctbo 1 'LlmYi':i11l ... h "~1\l" 'll€l'UL'll\Jlvl1LU'U\l1'U (Terms of Reference: TOR) m1~1-:i'1'111:UoLJ€lll'1 iLfl11~"1 ,,

oLJe:J:l..J(l LL'1~'1\l Lfl11~"1-Uvll (l L vi vL.l 1~ LiJ'Ufl ill6111JLL'1~fl111J1L.l~-:i1 '11'Ufl11vl1LtJ'U\l1 'U ,, ,, , 'lleNV1tl1m1'Umflf'i L.l1~~1lJ-:iLJL.l1~1J1ru YU'\. lvcfbo ...

0 t.I tJ.u tJ 0 ""

rn . LL 'U1Vl 1\l fl11fl1'U1ill11 fl1:U1\le.J1'U:U1\l'1111:U'lJ€l1J'1 i ,, ,, ~- L.Ji)Vi'Ufl11°L.l 1~ LiJ'Uf)f:U611l.l LL'1 ~fl111J L LJ ~\l 1'11 'U fl11vl1 L ti'U\l1'U'lJ€l\lVltl1tM1'Ufl1flf ~

L.l1~~1lJ-:iLJL.l1~:i..nru Ytfl . lvctbo

cf. '11°L.lVl~nfl1':iLL'1~n1€l'Un11°L.l1~LiJtl i 1 'Um~111J ,

mll~ '1Tun-:i1'U L.l.L.l.'ll . '1'1i.!n-:i1'U L.l.°L.l .Vl . '11i.!rn1'Uflru~m11lfl11'UL8'U1£Jf'ii'11V1n:u ... '1'1i.!n-:i1'Uflru~ m 11J m1 m1v1111JPl m-J1 LL'1~ m1J'1-:i L'1~11 m1L.l n mv-:iVf m~'U L 1J'UV1tl18-:i 1'U~ fo ~ 111'llv'U , fl1':iD1~LiJ'Uf)ill61':ilJLL'1~fl111J 1L.l~-:i1'11 'Ufl11vl1 L ti'U\l1'U'll€l\l'Vltl1£J\l1'Ufl1flf ~ (Integrity and Transparency

Assessment: ITA) L.l1~'1'1ll-:i'U°L.l1~:i..nru '\"j .fl. lv<f'.tio fl111l'1~LB8!11V111'ULL"1 J'U

'11 i.r n \l 1 'U L.l . L.l . 'll . 11118 fl 'U tl °L.l ':i ~ L ij 'U fl ru 6';j1 ll LL '1 ~ fl 11ll1 L.l ~ '11 '1 'll €l \l VI ti 18 \l 1 'U fl 1 fl f 'i ,, , ... 1vi'vi'1L U'Ufl11~!11 m1L.l1~'llll'U1ru1 m1m1L.l1~ LiJ'Uflruu111JLL'1~rn1111L.l~-:i1'11'Un11 v\'1 L ti'U\l1'U'll€l\l vttl1£J\l1'U , ,, , fl1flf'i~'U ~1'U1'U lv fl#\l Ldv-J'U~ <9l~ fl'U818'U lvcfcf~ LL'1~l'U~ "rno fl'U818'U lvcfcf~ i1~LeU1111lD1~'ll1J ... ,, , L.11~ n tl'Uvl 18 ~LL Vl'UVI ti 18 \l1'U~f'U~11l'll€l'U n 11L.l 1 ~ LiJ'U fl ill61':i1J LL'1~fl111J1L.l~'11'11'Un11vl 1Lu'U\l1 'U'lJ €1\l ,, , Viti 18\l 1'Ufl1 flf 'i L.l 1~ ~ 1U'l 'U°L.l 1~ll1 ru Yi. fl . lvcfbo ~ \l cf V1i.118\l 1 'U LL'1~~LLV1'U'1'1i.1n\l1'U n . YL 1. ... ,, l1-J\JlnL.l1~'1\lAL ~m\Jl~81Jfl11fl1':i°L.l1~ LiJ'U i L.l1~~1lJ-:iLJL.l1~mru Yi .?\ . lvcfbo 1,Xl1m\Jl':i'i1'Um1L.l1~ LiJ'Ui , ... LLemm1v\'1 L ti'U\l1'U LL~~ LL 'U1V11-:im1v\'1LU'Um11,XL1.J'U 1 U1 'UVlflV11\l L~mn'U zj-:i~L.l1~'llll 1vi'l1m 1V11 ~ei~11J fl'U , L~81fl'ULLe.J'Ufl1':ivl1 L U'U\l1'Ufl1':i°L.l':i~ LiJ'U i °L.l':i~~1t.l-:i'U°L.l':i~ll 1ru ~.fl . lvcfbo LL 'U1Vll\lfl11'1111~1\l ~f'U~1\l ,, '1'111~ oLJ€llJ'1 i LL 'U1Vl 1\l fl11ri1'U1 ru11 fl1 ~1\l~f'U~1\l '11':i1:U -if v ll~ i LL(l ~ n ':itl 'U n1':i°L.l1~ LlJ'U i °L.l':i ~ ~ 1 ,, ,, ,, t.l-:i'UL.l':i~mru Yi. !"I . tvcfbo zj-:i~L.l1~'llll 1vil ,X-if v'1-:i Ln \JI L Yill L~ll LL~~ fl'UtlL.11~ LiJ'U Aruu111J LL~~fl111l 1L.l~-:i1'1 , ,, , 'llv-:ivti.11£J-:i1'Umflf 'i 1vi'l1m1L.lfLJL.l1-:i LLm 'll~'Um~~-:i~L.l1~'llll L ,;1'U~v-:i~11Jn'U 1 'ULL 'U1V11-:in 11 vi'1L u'U 1fl1-:i m1 ... , , LL'1~mvLJm1L.l1~LiJ'Ui mll~'1'1i.!n-:i1'U L.l.°L.l .'ll. 1111mdvi''Ufln{~ lv<9l \Jl'11flll lvcfcf~ flru~v'Un111lfl11 , , , 'U~Vl11fl11D1~ LiJ'Ufl ru5111JLL'1~f1111l 1 L.l~-:i1'11 'Ufl11vl1Lti'U\l1'U'lJ€l\lVIU18\l1'Ufl1flf 'i 1 'Ufl11°L.l1~'llllfl#\l~ , ... , tv - lvil!Jcfcf~ i11l~f'UV1':i1'ULL'1~ L ,;1'U'll€l'ULLe.J'Ufl1':ivl1 LU'U\l1'Ufl11°L.l':i~LiJ'U i °L.l':i~~1U\l'UD1~:i..nru '\"j .fl . l!Jcfbo

vl\lfl~11vl1mL"1

'11i.!n-:i1'U ...

[

- \v -

'1TurM1'U tJ. tJ. '11 . ~'il1'Hu1 LL~1L i1'Y11 L ~eJ 1,.Xrn1v11 L u'U m11'Y~1'U~1.:i1 ~ L~cn.if eJ.:inu

m1tJ1~ LlJ'U 1 tJ1~'1'1tJ.:iutJ1~mru YLf'l. lvctbo L lJ'Y 1 tJvi'1tJm1:1.JL~ tJU1eJ tJLL£1~'11m1flV°i1LU'Ufl111vi'Vl'U

\911mL~'Ufl11v11L um1'YLL£t~meJu1~tJ~nm~n1vi'U11111 ~.:i'lJeJ~.:iLeJ fl'111~ L~tJ1.if eJ.:i LL£t~LL'U1vi1.:i ~1L u'Ufl11

1'YL~m~1.:i1 vi'.:i-d'

<9) . LL~'Ufl11vl1LU'U.:J1'Ufl11tl'j~ LlJ'UFlill51'j:l.J LL£l~F111:1.J 1tJ~.:i1'11 'Ufl1)vl1 L U'U.:Jl'U'lJEJ.:JV!'l.b tJ.:J1'U , mFl-ru tJ'j~'1'1tJ.:iutJ'j~:1.J1ru 'W .f'l . lvctbo 1w11"W11:1.J L~eJ1~LlJ'ULL'U1Vl1.:J1'Yfl1)tJ1~LlJ'U"1 \91£ttJ111~.:i 1m.:ifl1'j ... (~.:i~~.:J:l.J1vl1tJ <9l)

\v. Ltlfl'111tJ1~fleJUfl1)~\1141.:i e!-ru 41-:J '1111'51.if EJ:l.J fl l Lm1~i-1.if eJ:1.Jfl LLfl~~.:J Lfl'j1 ~i1.if €1:1.J fl \J \J \J \J

L ~tJtJ'j~ LlJ'U~ill5)1:1.JLLfl~F111:1.J 1tJ~.:i1'11 'Ufl1'jvl1 L U'U.:J1'U'lleJ.:JV!i.l1tJ.:J1'Ui11F1-r] (Integrity and Transparency

Assessment: !TA) tJ)~'1°1tJ.:iutJ1~mru 'W.f'l. lvctbo tJ)~fltJUvl1tJ

(<9l) "~1.:i" 'lJEJUL'lJ\9lvl1LU'U.:J1'U (Terms of Reference: TOR) (~.:i~~.:imvi'1tJ lv)

(lv) LL'U1Vl1.:Jfl1)A1'U1ill11F11~1'le!-ru41.:i'11)1'5J.ifeJ:i.Jfl "1 (~.:i~~.:J:l.J1vl1tJ ro) " " 'i 1 t.I I I O .c:;i,, QJ I.I 'Vil.I t.I 0 t.I 1 " ._, ~ 1 ... V

1\11 EJ'lltl V!V!'U1m1'U'lJ El'lV11'UVl1 L'U'Ufl TEl\115)1.:J ~ 'aJ'ilJnn 'j]'5J'lJtl~fl IV! LLm LffE)f)1cJ 'UL\11€J'U5'U11Fl:l.J lmt'.ctci

\911 :l.J LL~ 'U fl 11 v11 L -u '\..l .:i 1'Ufl11 tJ 'j ~ L D 'U., ~ n 1vi'U11111 ~ .:i .n vi iJ 1 tJ .:i 1'l.l'lJEl'lv11'U'11:l.J1 'j fl LL m 'lJ tJ-r u tJ 'j .:i , )1tJfl~LBtJl111'Y "~1.:i" 'lJEJUL'lJ\9lvl1LU'U.:J1'U (Terms of Reference: TOR) LLfl~LL'l.l1'Vl1.:Jfl11A1'U1ill11F1141.:i

e!-ru41.:i'11115l.if EJ:1.Jfl "1 1,.X'1€J!llF1~ tJ.:JtlU )~LU tJU LL£! ~15tJ nu~'lJEJ.:JV!U1tJ'l1'U1vi' 111ltJ'il~ ~tl .:J hJ m~'VIU ~El " " ;..J

fl)EJU 1~ tJ ~ L 1£11 LL£! ~'111~ '11Aqj'lJEJ.:Jfl1 'jtJ 'j ~ LlJ'U "1

ro . ul)Yi'Y fl11U )~ LlJ'U ~ill5'j'j:l.J LL fl ~F111:1.J 1tJ~'l1'11'Yfl11vl1LUm1'U'll €1.:J V!U1 tJ'l1'Uil1 Fl-r]

tJ'j~'1'1tJ.:iutJ'j~:1.J1ru 'V'J .f'l . lvctbo 'V'J1EJ:l.J'1)UV!~flfl1'jLLfl~fl)EJUfl11U'j~LlJ'Y"11'YD1'W'j1:1.J (~.:i~~.:J:l.J1vl1tJ u: , ~ .. ' ... ) 'i 1 ., ' ' ., 0 ., ::'! "" ' .. ., J ...

LL fl~ '1.:J 'VI '1'l:l.J1 \111 tJ ct 1 \11 EJ 'lJ El VI VI 'U 1cJ.:J1'U'lJtJ.:J'VI1'U5l \11'Yl1 VI 'U .:J fl El fl .:J VI 'U 1EJ.:J1'U'Y11Ufl1) 1 1 ~ L l.J 'U

1 ., ""' ' "" ".I""'""' .I ""' " .I ., .I ""' 'UF111l.JA1.J ~!ll'lltlUVJ flV!'U1fN1'U LYJ tJ LL'il.:Jv i)'Vl'U fl11u1~ L:l.J'U "1 'W1 tll.J'Gf~1J V!{l fl fl 1 A LL{)~ me:iu fl11v1~ Ll.J'U "1

1 cl :1 • I 'i '1 "" ., ., ' ' _,; • I ""' 1 'Ui11 'W Dl.J '"il.:J 5l ~ Lv'Uv 1~~EJ'll'U 'U fl 11 L\911 EJl.J F111l.J'W 1 €1:1.J \111'U\911.:J1 fl El'UL 1l.J fl 111.J 1~ L:l.J 'U D 1fJ 'U

®ct "Wqf'l§fl1EJ'U !Dctctci L\1ltJ'11:1.J11fl\1111'Y1Vl'1\1ltJl)Yi'Yfl1'jtJ'j~LlJ'U"1 u1~'1'1lJ.:iutJ1~mru 'W.f'l . lvctbo

LL'1 ~ L eJ fl '111'1'jtJ vi~ fl fl 1'jLL'1~meJufl1 'jtJ 'j~ LlJ'Y 1 1'Yn1'W )1:1.J 1 vi'~ Liu 1 '"il \;]'11Ufl'l1'Y 'Li . tJ . '11. ~1-U'e:i !TA , (https://www.nacc.go.th/main.php?filename=ITA)

eJ~'l vi1mLuu'11'j1'5J~'il~1~tJ'j~LiJ'U1 tJ1~'1'1lJ.:iutJ1~:1.J1ru YJ .f'l . lvctbo 1vi'iifl11tJ-rutJ).:i/ , LLm 'lJ \911:1.J F111:1.J L i1'1..l'lJ €1.:J Fl ill~vl 1.:J1'Ul'l11fl11 LL '1 ~~ ~'\..l 1 'j~ UU fl 11 tJ 'j~ LlJ'U Fl ill5)1:1.J LL'1~Fll1:1.J L tJ ~'l 1'1 , 1'Ym1 v11L'LI'U'l1'U'll eJ.:i vi tl1tJ.:i1'YD1 Fl-ru L '1~'51 i 'ULL~1 '11Ufl'l1'Y u . tJ . '11 . 5l ~ ~.:i LL uu '11)15l vi' .:i fl~ 11m cJ'.:i

"' vitl1tJ.:J1'Y'lltJ.:Jvl1'Y L ~eJv11LU'l.lfl11~111~.:i1,.XviiJ1tJ.:i1'U~-rum1tJ1~ LiJ'U 1'YF111:1.J-ru~111'1JeJU~eJ1 tJ

~.:JL~tJ'U:l.JlL~tl 1 tJ)\11~'5111ill1vl1LU'Ufl1)1'U~1'U~L~tJ1.ifeJ.:J~tl1 tJ Sl~'lJEJUFlill:l.J1fl ,

(mtJtJ1~vi8111 YJ1.:i'11tJ1)

1€J'lL'1'lJ15fl1'j "1 i.Jl)~'j1'1Jfl11LL'Vl'U

L'1'lJ15fl1'jflill~fl':i1:1.Jfl11 tJ.tJ.'11 .

f'l'U~tJ'j~ LlJ'UFl ill51111 LL'1 ~ F111:1.J L tJ ~'l 1'1'lltJ.:JV!iJ1tJ'l1'Ui11 F11'u " , ... 1 'Yl'j. o \vct\v~ U:~oo ~tl \vU:oU:

1 'Vl)'11':i 0 \vcr\v~ U:"11\vct

bb 'U'U n-aei n-a1£J~ei ~th~~1'U .:i1'U n1-at.h~aihJ fl ru cr-a-a:ll bb!;l~ wn:ll 1th .:i 1~1'Un1-a~1 b ii'LI .:i1'U"ll ei.:i \I q

eJ.:lfln-a't.Jnfl-aei.:i6i1'UVteJ.:l~'U (Integrity and Transparency Assessment: ITA)

d ft'U'Vl @

d '!Iv - an" •

rX.:in~ '

tJ-a~"il1u.:i'U't.J-a~"1ru w .A. l§:J<:t'bo (IT A l§:J<:t'bo)

'VIU1V.:JTU ....................................•....•.............................................•...........

c:f I I 0 Q,I I 1tJ c:.I tf 'Vlv~'Vl'U1V./J1'U (li11'Vl':i'U!i1.:J ':i'tiWV) •.•.............................•.....................................................•...........................

LUvTI 'Vl':iA'W'Vi (Luei1a1i.Jn.:i1'U)

LUvTI 'Vl':iA-w'Viiieitiei

E - Mail

ID Line

Facebook

d ft'U'Vl l!J

rX.:in~ .••....•...............•................................................•.........................................•..........•.•.....•...........

d • ' ( 0 "' • 1tl d ~ 'VlvV'Vi'U1V.:J1'U li11'Vl':i'Uli1.:J ':i'tiWV) .......................................•...............................................••.•. .•....•...•........•.. ...

mail 'Vl':iA-w'Vi (L uei1a1i.Jn.:i1'U)

mtiil 'Vl':iA-w'Viiieititi

E - Mail

ID Line

Face book

~

'lliltJL'lJV1~1LUlJ'11lJ (Terms of Reference: TOR) 11 0 " <Clit. ,,., aJ ~"

fi1'i'11'1 '11'i1'1'llil1.rn 1 Lfl'i1~'WlJ mm LL a ~'1'1 Lfl 'i1~'\.1'll illJ a \J \J \J

L yjmh~Luu fl ru 5'i'i1JLLa~m11J t th .:i 1'11 uni 'i~1 L iJu .:i1u'IJt:1.:iwu1EM1u111fl1\i , ....

(lnte~rity & Transparency Assessment: ITA)

th~'11l'.l.:iuth~1nru 'W .fl . l!Jct'bo

<O). V1anm'iLLa~mV1i:.ia , n 1'itJ1 ~ L iJ u fl ru 511 J.J LL '1 ~ fl 11J.J1 tJ 1.:i 1 '11 u n 11 v11Luu-:i1u'IJti.:iVIti1 tJ -:i 1 u 111 fl 111 (I n t es r it y a n d

T ra nspa rency Assessment: ITA) iii' VI ritJ 1~'1.:i rlL ~a 1 ~111ti1 t1-:i1u ~ L iii1u n11tJ 1~ LiJu 1vl' c.in n1'lU1~LiJtJLL'1 ~ , LL u1Y1 1.:i 1um1~ vuu1 LL'1 ~ti m~vi'uV1u1t1-:i1u 1uvl'1uflru5'l1lJ Lrn ~m1J.J 1t11.:i1'11 um1v11Luu-:i1u1vi'mh:a V!lJ1~'1J.J . ,

'tvm 1 u ninh~'lll.JA ru~-r ill.JU Iii 1 L~fffo~ er J.J m1 AlJ 19crcr~ 1vi'iiJ.J~ L '!:1u·tmu 1 ~111u1cM1umri1 ilYl n111u1t1-:i1 u . , ~ .u ,

L ii 111 J.J 1 u n 11 tJ 1 ~ L iJ u fl ru 511l.JLLn~fl11lJttJ1-:i 1'11un11v11 Luu .:i 1u'IJti-:iVIu1tJ-:i1un1 A -r il 111ll-:iuti1~J.J1 ru , ~

l!Jcrcr~ - 19crtio V11l.J~'1'1um1u tJ .tJ.'IJ . L'1uti ilnrr-:i t1Yl6P11'1vi1'!J1~11vi'1t1mTuti-:in11Lm~'-h1ut111J.Jm1Y1'11V1 , ,

1~CJ~~ rn (i"i . f'l. l!Jctbo - l!Jctt>cd 1vi'ri1V1u\ll1~ni1tl1~LiJtJflru511l.JLL'1~f111J.JLU1-:i1'11uni'lvl1LUU'1111'lJtl'1 ,

V!tJ1CJ'11Un1flf il L llunntJYlB~'1'1ri'ru 1 um1Utl'1 nu n11Yl'11VJ L ;u-:i1n L ~tl 1 ~V!tJ1tl'11tJI11flf \i~'1iim llunn 1nV1~'11 u .u , "' , , .u

n 1~U1U n11Yl'111i1Ju 1vl'ii n11vl 1LUU'11Utlti1'1LtJ1.:i 1'1 LLn ~ Ln \ll n 11Utl '1 nutl'l ~ L~ tJ L~ tl'1Vl°1ti'liti'1Yl1'1~ tl1'1 '1 ~ , n tl 1~Ln\lln1 1Yl '11 Iii LL '1~'11lJ11fl fJ tJ J '1n11Yl '11 Iii~ tl1'1LnVI~tJ1v) tl ti 1'1Lvl1Yl U '1fllUn11 ru ; '1 L~tl V!U 1tJ'11UI11fl1 il , , ~

rt1tJ1~L YlP1Dm1ll tN rltJn1WJ'11tii L :a.:i 1nn'1~vi11 ~ n11Yl '11vi 1 tJ1l1i"111l.J'IJtl'11.h~L Ylf'lnllln'11vi1 U~'1VI , , , ,

1UU'1tJiJ1~lJ1 ru Yi . Pl . 19 ctb o ij V! U 1tJ'11Ufl1flf11Lii1-51l.Jlfl'Hn11 vY '1 ~ U d, l9 ~Ci' VI tJ 1 tJ '11 U

11ilt1 ...... .L~.~-~1JJ~H}~~-fo_C)_~l_'JWlJ.O.D1J.1~~jJ_l)L ................ L llu~ -ru~ \ll'!JtltJ'1U th~lJ1 ru LL'1 ~vl1 Lu tJ n11U1~LiJU '11U1U ............... VltJ1tf'11U U1~ntltJvl1tJ .... ... ... ........ ........................................... .. .. ....................... ... ... ........ .

vi' .:iJu L ~ti 1 ~ ni1 tl1~ LiJu fl rui511lJLL'1~f111ll t ti 1-:i 1'11um1vi' 1L iiu-:i1u'IJti'1V1 u1 tJ .:i1u111 fl fo tJ 1~~1u , ~

Yi . Pl . 19crtio D fl11ll ~ n~ti'1VJ 1l1V! '1ni'ti1 m1LLn ~~._, c.i n '1ll ~Yl~ ... ....... .C~~Y.1.\l.?.v.~ .11J.~l'UH~'.IJ.~.\H11~.\.1 '.l:;:.~ij1J)._ .... . ~.:iDm1J.Jtl 1~'1'1A'1~ivi'11-:ic;'111'1-U'tiJ.J'1 1Lm1~1'1-U'til1'1 LL'1~ '1.:i Lm1~v1-U'til1'1L~tit!1~ LiJtJfl rui5'l1l1Ltn ~fl11l.J t tl1'1 fa

" " " .

l!J. -1vi ntl1~'1.:iY1 , 19 .(j) L Yiti tJ 1 ~ LiJuc.i'1 v11u fl ruli'i 1ll LLn ~fl11lJ t ti 1-:i 1'11uni1vi' 1LuU'l1U'IJB'1VIU1tJ.:i1u111 flf il~ L-01-ru , ~

n11th~LiJU

hl!J L ~tl 1 mvi'iim'1tJtlLL u~1 uni1t11rnh.:i/~VlJU1vl1Ufl[Ui)')')lJLL'1~fl11lJL i..11.:i 1'11 Un11vl1L UU'11U'IJtl'I , ,

V1u1t1'11U111fl 1']~L-U1-51lJ1'u m1tl'l~LiJu

l9 .rn L ~ti 1111'1vi'il ti L'1uti LL u ~ 1un11ivivi1lJ1vi1nl11 u n11u ti.:i nuLLa~ t111utl 11J.J n11Y1'11virr.:i 1u1~ ilu ,

m. i.h:: lv'IJU~'1:: 1vi~u m . Ci) V1 ,j 1 EJ ,:] 1 'U .fl 1 f11 \i 1 ii f u V1 ') 1 u ') ~ i1 u f1 ru 6 ') ') lJ ll n :: f1 11lJ1 ti -i,:] 1 '11 u n 11 vi 1 l ii lJ,:] 1 'U yj 11 ~ l n Vl

~ , m1lJm~'l·nTrnLn:: 1 ~m1l.J'11 A'cy lu m1t1Blliiwu1vh ~Lnvi riru5Trnlln ::m1l.J 1tlci-:i1'1ll1n~-i~u

m.19 V1 i.11 EJ'11'U i11f1 f \i 1vi' f rnl u1vi1-i1 t1 m1-W Vl.l'U11'Ui11t1f1ru511l.J Lln ::m1l.J 1tl1-i 1m yj a 1 if L llt1 LL t11V11 '1 ~ ,

tl1::m:iu m1n1V1t1V1t1 LE.Ju1f1 Lrn~ m1vi1L ut1-i1t1'llv-iV1u1EJ-i1t1mAf ~i;lt11 tl1il

m.m V1U1 E.J-i1t1~f ue4vi'!Jauni1tl1~Ljjt1 1i!fuilm'1t1t:lll ti~ 1 t1ni1'1vivi1l.J1m n111 t1 ni1\1a-i nuLLn~ t111ut111lJn1'n1'1·1v1i-i 1u1::ilut11vu1rmn~1 m::ilutlfru~

m.Ci'. V11i1 EJ'11'U~ f ue4vi'!Jauni1tl1~ Ljjtl 1ilf uilm'1t1t:lll ti~ LL t11vi1-i011L ~t:llJ LEJ-i LA~u-:illu ni 1tl1 ::Ljjtl

f1ru511lJLLn~m1lJ 1tl1-ifa11.m11vi1L iit1-i111'llv-i\11u1 EJ-i1t1n1Af \i num1EJ m~v1uv1'!Ju{1vi ni1f u1'm1V1'11vi (CPI) , .u " ,

Ci'.. n"mi:l1V1l.J1EJ ,

V1UlE.J-i1t1n1Af~~---···· __(~~~-1.iJU~_Jll_~fof)_~_\l_~_llDJ'.i_1-lA~~~JJ). ______ f u i'.J vi 'll v u -i u ti 1 :: lJ 1 ru LL n ~ 011tl1::Liit1 '11t11t1 _ -·- ·· -· ··---- --_____ V1U1EJ'11t1 11EJn~lBEJV1Vl1l111EJ~ml tlU

v

~·ru~1-i\l::vl't1-ivi1L ut1-i1t1 il-iu ,,

c;:'. .G) 11-iLLc-.Jt1m1vi1L ut11m-im11~'11L1'1vi1 lJLL~'U'11t1'llt1-i 1m-i m1

c;:'._19 tl1::'lJ1~lJ'W'1151 ~V1U1 EJ-i1t1~ L ihf u m1tl1:: Liit1Y111u LRE.J1 nu11E.Jn~ LBEJV"l Lrn ~.ff uviuu m 1vi1Lu'Um1

11lJ0'1UV1U1VlV1U1~i;l1-i1 'llu'1\11U1EJ'11t1~Lil1fom1tl1::LDu 1t1m1'1111\lmlJllUU'1111\l Internal External lln~ Evidence - Based

c;:'._ rn Pin '1:}1 LLn ~ll A 11 ~vi' ncilJtl1~'lJ1n1 L U1V1lJ1 EJ'llt:l'1lli;ln::V1u1EJ-i1u 111Ji -ll lfl 11:: v1 'lltl1 vi v11t1 Ei1-i , .

~ L 'v1lJ1~'1lJLrn:: L llt1v11 Lrnu~~ il-il1' mt1uAnlJmuvinn11n\l'llt1'1 LLi;in~V1u1E.J -i1t1 Lln ~ n1vt11vi16 011'1lJ v11v81-imlJ , , ,

(GJ) n"m_h~'lll n1L \11V1lJ1 v'11'v1fULL uu'1111-v Internal vlu'1fl1BUf1nlJVl1lJ 1m-i'111-i '11 EJ'11tl , ,

n cimi1 LL wu-i'llv-i LLi;i-n ~viu1 v-i1u Lrn ~ ri1'v1t1 vi16 m1c1l.Jv!1t1 Ei1 -i ml.JV1 '1 n '1 n~ , . . '\

(19) nc=ll.Jth::'!J1 ml i11Vll.J1EJ '11Vlf ULL uu '1111-v External vi'u-i mauAnlJVl nn11n -v LLn ~vi mh:: Lnvi , . , , ,

'!Ju-i m 1ilc11u 1vi' c11u L~ EJ'llv'1 lL~'1 ~ vii.11 EJ LLn~ n1Vlt1vi16m1c1lJ v11v Ei1-imlJV1'1 n'1 n~ · . ,

c;:'..Ci'. t11~'11lJ'11tltlUV1U1EJ'11tl~L -U1fu m1tl1~ LjjtlV1~vV1U1EJ'11t15t11 ~LREJloLJtJ-l l yjv 1 mvi'lJ1~'1ii'Bl;jn ~'11L llt11 t1m1tl1:: LDu

c;:'. .~ '1viLnu-U'vlJn'11nLLuu'1111\l Internal External Lln~ Evidence - Based 1V11vi'mmht11t1v11t1fi1-i " cl 0 v -....i d .., - ..,

Vln1\11t1Vl mEn5n11Yll V1lJ1~'1lJmlJV1nnm11-vv

c;:'. _b n-i1~'1lln::ut1Yin-LJ'alJn '11V1fULLuu'1111-v Internal Lrn~ External u-n~vi11'1C1t1uFi1vit1uLLn~ ,, mn'111/V1'1nti1'U vi1lJLluuci111-v Evidence - Based lyjt:JlLA11~"1-U't1l.Jn '1-iLm1::"1-U'vlJn LLn::i.h::mmrnA~LLt1t1

~ " ,, c;:'. _ C") '1 vi'1-i ~ n fl~ ll ti ti E vi den ce - Based 1 ~ n UVIU1 EJ'11tl~ l iJ1f uni 1tl1:: llJ t1-W'111 ru1 11l.Ji-i

tl1~'11t1-i1t1 ~-v11ru1 Lrn ::LL ~-i~-nm1t1YJ61 ru1 ~ml1EJ-i·1t1~L-LJ'1fo m1tl1~Ljjt1 ,

ct . ~ L Ul.JlYl EJ1n1'v1~uU11EJ1 fl L~ EJ1 nu n11U"i~ LiJ l.Jf\ nJ5"i1lJLln ~ f\11lJ l tl1-:i1'11'Unl1\111LUl.J'l11.J 'lJB'I , 'v1U 1EJ-:i1 u111 A f \i L ~u '111-:i f\11 lJ~f\1 llJ L -U1hLLn~1~A1tl1 rn:n LLn ,,,,j 1EJ-:i1u111 A f \i VJ1 lJ~ ( ~r.:l'v1U1 EJ-:i1u

~ " J.S --- - - - - - - -- -- - - - -- - -- ---

.Jv - .I - • YJ)JJC:!.~.'1.f.t:n.JD.1~1.J'.Hi~~lJJ .. , .. ___ ______ n1Y1l.JVI

ct.rX 1'11 L Ul.J m1ilu '1.:J L ~u'I m1tl '5 ~ LiJl.JCJn 1 u mru~ . ------ ---.. (~!Jxn.h. unlJ.~{11 ~YJ.'1W.V O.l}.1J ~~~jjJ,J). _ -. ---.

'1~ 1 ~lin11tl1~~lJ:ff u '1-:iLLn~u1vi11 m~m11Jni1 L ~1V1U1~ h11~v1uvi1-:i 1 ~~1L llu vifluV1'1l.JV1U1EJ-:i1u~L~ff1iia-:i do "'11.,J tl -LY'IBY11m1rn'lJ1 '1 uL1v-:i1~uuni1 'l~Ll.Jl.JC.Jn

ct. Glo ~ vivi1 '11tl CJ n n11tl 1 ~ LiJuvi~u L tf uvi1'111~ '11 A' ru'llu-:i n11tl1~LiJuflru5'5 'llJ LLn ~A11lJ 1tl1-:i 1'1 , u ,

1uni1if1LUl.J'11U'lJB'l'v1U1EJ'ITUJl1Af] 11lJ~'lloU111lJ'l1l.J 1umru~ ... . C~~'.\'.IJAJJJJ_l).j_~fv~i;J~_r)_1,.!fl}'jJ,h~.~~).)} ... .. . -:S'vi 1~lin11uor1-:i'll11vi~u-:i1ut11~'ll1~lJ~tJ6vi1-:i 1

ct.GlGl -:S'Vlvl1"i1EJ'l11JoLJBLC1UBLL l.J~n1'5~VIYi1lJ1Vl"ln111 u n11'Uu'lnUlln~tl11lJU11lJfl11V1'11Vl~.:J1 tJ1~vl'U ,

'\.J 1EJu1mLn~ 1 u1~vi'utlfilli1

ct.Gll9 ~ vivi111 EJ'l1UoLJBLC1UBLL U~ll U1V11'1 n1'5 l zjulJ lu.J lfl~u-:iliu n1'5U'5~ llJtJfHU5"i"ilJ lln~f\11l.J 1tl1-:i1'1 ,

1 u ni1if1 l UU'11U'lJB'IWU1EJ.J1UJl1f\f \i num '5EJn1~ vllJvl'llu:ff 1 VI rn1f u ~n11V1'11vi (CPI) .. " . , ct.Glen 1~fl11lJ11lJliu1umru~ __ __(~-~-!1J.:i.1JJ_~:rn~.iv~~'.l)!.)\l_Q_J_1V_'}.~_L_~_'HL ____ l ii 111 lJ ~'I L n VI n 11 ru

0 -. vv v

m1vi1L tJtJ.J1l.J'llu-:imu'11-:i "

ct.me£ cHu~1'1'1~vlu.:J-:S'vivi'111EJ-:i1u 1~muo1uvi1lJ~'5~U111. tJ'llulJl 'lJVln1'51'11L UtJ-:i1u " ,

vi mm Vlvi : m1n'1m1if 1L iJu-i1um'1l'i m1L tl~ EJtJLL tln-:i 1v1mlJfl11lJ L vilJ1~'1lJV11lJm1~L i1u"lluU'lJu-:i ( ~avil11 u.-:i1u~ , ---- -------- --- ---------

iv~YJ'.IJ.IJ.\J.01i.1.h~J~).))_. __

0 ~

b. 'llvUL '!JV1011Vl1ll.JU'l1l.J

~f u~1-:ili'llulJ L 'lJVl'lJB.J m11'11 L UtJ-lll.JVlllJlVl ()U"i~C1'1Afl'5 BlJflnlJU'5~ l~l.J via 1 utf " , , b .m L tf avi1ni1tl1~LiJtJ vi1 L Du m1tl 1~ L~tJC.Jn vil11EJ..l1u111f\f \i 1vi EJ 1-U 1~uutl1~LDtJAru511mrn ~ f\'11l.J1tl1-:i1'11tJni1vi1L iJu-:i1u

'Uu-:iviu1EJ-:i1u111Af] ~'11un-:i1u tl.tl .'ll . ~vi~1~u ;fi-:iLlia,,ntl1~n~u1tlvi'1EJ ct vi''llli f1a vi''lluA11lJLtl1-:i1'1

vi''lflim1lJY'l1u~ f u~vi vi''llli m1lJtln BV1'11nn11YJ'11vi1 u m1tlfiu~-i1u vi' 'lfu1Vllu 511lJ~ ru51'5lJ1 uu-:i F1m Lrn ~

vi''lfliAru511lJ m1vi'1-:i1tJ 1 tJ'\11u1 EJ..lltJ ,

b .19 i5m1Pirn~n

m1tl1~ LDuAru5'51lJLLn~ m1lJ 1tl1-:i1'11 u ni11'11L iJu-:i1u'Uu-:ivil11EJ-:i1umflf \i 1'ii15i~EJ~c11A'ru 19 15 fiu , ~ u

b .hm m1i~EJ'11nLunC111 (Document Research) LVJEJ~V1Lnu-Uu;in'11nLunC111 vi~uvi~n]lllvi1-:i 1

Vl1lJLL uu'1111\J Evidence - Based LVIEJ 1 ~,,,i.11EJ-:i1u~L ii1fum1tl1~LiJuviauri1mlJvi1-:i 1 L~mnui6tlfiu~-:i1tJ n '5~ lJ1un11V1~Bn\)n1 "ilJ ~'v1U 1 EJ'l ll.J\111 l Ul.J n11\J 1-1 LLn ~ l'ivi ~ n \i1l.J tl "i~ n BU~ l'ifl ru~ n ljnJ ~~~VJ 1lJ'v1~ n 51'5lJ 1 nu1 n

~ ,

f\ru511lJ '11 EJ511lJLLn~ m1lJ 1tl1-:i1mf 1vifuviu1m1umflf 'l , ~

b .hl!J m1i~EJ\JlnLLuuc111T\lnn'lJi;l1ati1-:i (Sample Survey Research) lVJEJ~VILnui!ulJnLRmnu , " .., - G I ..., I .d 0 0 • ,,.,; d .... v

'UtlflVl L 'vll.J\11 nnnlJVllu EJ1-:iviviau fl1()1lJV11lJLL UUC11'51'1 External Lln ~LL uu'1111\J Internal •zmn mnum1m , " fl11lJ L-if 11 '1 Lln ~U"i~C1Un1'5 oJ'lJB'I q VlulJ ll UU'1111'1 l~ Ell rlU n1 '5UDU~'l1 l.J 0'5~U1l.J n1 "i lln ~Yi C)~ 0'51lJ'UB '1'4 flfln

1uviu1EJ-:i1umAf\i1uL~a-:im1lJ1tl1-:i1'1 m1lJfo~vi'llau m1lJtlnuV1'11 nm1vi'11 vi 1VlltHi1'5lJf\ru611lJ LLn~A ru511lJ -.. , , "

b.cn -ffal;Jnit-u'luni1iJ1:::LDu

-U'aJJn~.JVIJJVlit m un11tl1:::LDu \)::; 1-U-U'aJJn'!JCl.JVIU1£J.J1U~LoLJ1~1Jfl11U1:::LiJu 1 UU.J1JU1:::lJ1(U ¥1 .f'l. 19~o " "

b .Ci'.' ~u~lUfl11vl1LU\J.J1U n11u1::: LiJUflillli11lJ LL(! :::fl11lJ l '\.h.:i fa fl11vl 1L U\J.J 1U'!JCJrnu1£J.J1Ufl1fl 1'1 \J:::vl1L uu.:i1uu1:::LDu~rn . , ....

V11i1£J.:i1ufl1fl1''1 ~1:::uvnJJ-U'a ~ ~.:iiiLLVlcl.J~~.:i~.:i 1 um.:iL Y1YiJJV11UmLLn:::vi1.:i~.:iwJ'vi .... , ,

b.ct ni1iJ1:::'lJ1~JJ~u6

vl1 Luu n111 "1-U'aJJn LLn:::v11 L iiu fl11U1:::'lJ1~lJ~U61::: Vil 1.J fl11v11Liiufl11U 1::: Lii 1.J ~nllfl :::Vlcl.J fl11tl1::: LiJu~n "

.,J ""~v.I .I -b . b Lfl')tJ.JlJClYl L 'lJ L lJfl11 u1:::LlJ\J

~f u'11.:i~a.:i~1L U'Ufl11'1111'11111lJLL uutl1::: LD'Uflillli11lJLLn:::fl11lJ 1u1.:i1'11 u fl11vl1L UlJ.J1U'!JCl.JV1U1 £J.J1U " , "1 V o do "1 o "°'

mm] mmLUUC1111'1 en LLUUl1111JY1'11lln.:i1u iJ.u .'lJ . fl1VIUVI flti

b. b.G) LL u u'1111'1 Internal L llu fl11iJ 1 :::LDU\11 n-ilaf1vi L ~U'!Jtl.J L '11WU1~fl1£J1 \J'!JCJ.JV1i.l1 £J.J1U

mfl~,ll ~iJfru~.:i1lJ1uu.:iuu1:::JJ1ru Yi.Pl . 19crbo 1-in5m1'1111'1 LV1£Jfl1'l~JJml:fruLLurn~iifl!V1U1 (Face - to - Face

Interview) Y11.J 1 u11:fruu Y11.J 1 YlWlYivl Y11.J 1 u1l'Jruu5rnnvi1uunc1 Yll.JLL uu'1uu fl1JJCJtiu 1m.J V1~tii6m1~~f u'11.:i . "

L~ui1iim1rn V1111:::C1JJ 1 um1i~£J

b . b.~ LL uu'1111\J External L lllJfl11U'l:::LDU'11 floLJClAVl l ~U'!JCl.J ~fuu1m1V1~a~ii'11lJ 1v1 '11UL~f.J " "

'!JEMV1U1£J.:i1un1flf'5 h.iu.:iuu1:::mru Yi .Pl . 19ctbo lvi£Jn11~JJfl11:fnJLLU'\.JL~iiruV1u1 (face - to - Face Interview) .... v

Yl1.J 1 U1l'JcUEJ Y11~ 1 Yl1Pl¥1vl Y11~ 1 U1l'JcU u5rn flY11tlU nci Y11~LL '\.J'\.JC1Cl'\.Jfl1lJtlilU la-LI vt~ui6m1Yicr1u'11~L ~ui1ii "

fl11lJ L VllJ1:::C1lJ 1 U fl11i~£J

b.b.cn LL'l.J'l.Jci°111'1 Evidence - Based LlJum1iJ1:::LiJu~r1m1u5u~.:i1u'!Ja~V1U1£J~1lJI11flf]

1 uu~ mh:::JJ1ru Yi. f'l . l!Jctbo 1vi £J 1-tivic1 n '51UL ii~ u1:::~ n~ fa £JVIU1f.l~1un1flf 'lvi v'\.JA1 fl1lJV11JJfl11lJL lJu-.v1 ~ .... ....

mJJLL uu'1111-.v LL~1LL'LJULanC111vi~uV1'1n'51uV1~aB'1~5~'1.h:::nau 1vi£J Hu uuci'111-.v Ci) 'l.IV1 via Ci) V1U1£J~1u .... , b ."11 flclJJu1:::'ll1mL ll1viJJ1mLr1::: nftJJvi'1tici1~ , . ,

b ."11. (j) flclJJ'l.l1:::'l.l1mL U1VIJJ1£J'1°1Vl1''1.JLL uuci'111'1 Internal 1v1 uri L'11VIU1~fl1£J 1 U'!Jtl.JVIU1 EM1'LJ ,

111fl1 ~ ~f u fl11U 1::; Liiu ;~ iJ Bu~~ 1U 1uti~'\.Ju1 :::JJ1 ru Yi. f'l. 19 ctb 0 LLn::; ii Cl1~n11vl 1~1 'LJ ~~LL vi (j) u~u 1 iJ

1vi£Jii'lJ111V1v11a ci1~EJci1~ua£J Ci)oo v11aci1.:i mBUflnJJmJJ 1m~C1{1.:i C11£J~1u mi:u vi1u V1U~'!JB~LLvin:::V1u1 £J~1u , , Lln::: n1V1uV115fll1'1:u vl1aci1~VJ1JJVl'1 n'1 Ci~ VI 1 fl'VIU1 EJ ~1\J ii--51u1uiJ 1 :::'l.11 n1u a EJ fll1 (j) 0 0 11 £J 1 "1 er fu'11 ~ , . " Lrl u-iJtilJn\11flU1::: 'll1fl1i~ VllJ Vl

" b."11.19 nc=IJJ'l.l1:::'lJ1 mL Ul'Vll.J1EJ'!l'El~ LL uu'1111-.v External 1vl'LLri c!fuu1m1V1~EJ~ii'11u1il'11m~EJ

, " " '!J'El .JVIU1 £J ~1uI11fl111~1''1.J n11tl1::: LDu ;.:iii fl11 iJ l~ EJ1-U'a~ B'uii'11u 1v1 ~1U dfo 1 u ti~ '\.J u1::: lJ1 ru Yi. f'l. 19ctb 0

lvlEJii'lJU1 Vlvl1 v LJ1~ il LJ1.JU tl £J C9lOO vl1Cl LJ1~ fl') tl'\.J fl n lJYl flfl11 n'1 LLn :::YlflU 1:::LI1Yl'!Jtl.Jfl11ii'11U1v) '11 UL~ f.J'!Jtl.J LLlfi n::: , , ,

,,,111EJ.:i1u LLn :::n 1V1u vi15m1'1JJ v11 uci1.:im:uV1'1 n'1 o ~ 'llv~ LLvin :::viu1 EJ.:i1u V11nviii1 £J~1uiJ~1u1u iJ 1::: 'lJ1mu v £J ni1 ,

(9)00 11£J 1~c!1u'11~Lnu-iJEJJJn'11niJ1:::'ll1m~.:i,,,:uvi " "

b ."11. en nriJJu1:::'ll1mL U1V1l.J1 £J'!Jtl~ LL uu'1111'1 Evidence Based 1vi'uri viu1£J~1u~L-il11'u , m1iJ1:::LDuvi1:uiti Ci:'

~~if fl 1 ru~ crf u'11 ~hi C11l.J 11 fl~ VIL rl UoLJtllJ n '11 n LLvln::: LL UU ci' 111'11vlVl1lJ ~ fi 1V1 UVl LU tl.J '11 fl " "

L V1~'1Vli~£JV1~tlYiC]~fl1')nl~1:u1 -dm1lJ~Vl'!JCl.J~fo'11.:i 1 ~~fo'11.:i LLC1Vl.J 1 "1L ~\Jl1 hi1.-Um1lJ¥1£J1£J1lJtlLJ1-l L~lJ~Ll~1 mJJi~wuti.:ii'll1:UYiYJ1.:im1i~£J Lrn:::LLC1vi.:i 1 "1L ~ui1~1u1uv11tici1.:i~~viLnu 1ilJuiJfl ruC11JU~fl11lJL uuv11LL YJU~~ , mJJvi~ni'll1m1

n.c:: 1:::EJ:::L 1cn 1 um1~1L ii1N1u

'l:::EJ:::L1m~1L UU lfl'l ·m11 GlGO lU (UUnV1'11ffJu~'1-JU1lJ 1uc1''1J '1J1'11-J) lVJEJlJlLt:.J1.Jn1111i1L UU·nU vl-JD

.. cl LVltl'UVl

c1.:i11EJ.:i1uuuu~u (Inception Report) I

- G v o

~ '1V1LnU'llulJ'1'11nLLurn1111'1 Internal External Lln::: v

Evidence - Based ,,

~ c1.:i11EJ.:i1uuuu-Uunn1.:i (Interim Report) '

r.

rrl tl1:::lJ1nc.Jnfl:::LLuu ~Lm1:::v1-ii'ulJ'1 c1.:iLm1:::v1-ii'u11n Lrn::: v v ,,

e11tlt:.Jn m1tl1::: LDu , Q -. d "" '

mL uum1LnEJ1 nun11BV15'5rufl:::LL uu Evidence , Based 1 iXvii.11EJ.:i1u~L-ii'1fom1tl1:::LDu

c< c1.:i11m1uuuu~viYi'1EJ ouu11.:i (Draft Final Report) •)

(

~ . r:il. t:-HHl lJ C]Vl ~ 'lJ v ·H TLJ'Vi fl 1Vl'VI1.:i

<nl.Gl C-JC'lt:.Javi

<nl. Ci) . Ci) UV1'11tl c'.Ju 1vi11 '51EJ-J1UC-J'1 n1'ltl1::: LDu flru Li 1111 Ll'1::: fl11lJ l tl 1.:i 1e11un11Iii1Luu.:i11.J'!Jtl.:J ' v '

vii.11EJ.:i1un1A1'~ (fl1Y'l11J.J) tl1:::nuuvi'1EJ11v.:i1uuuum'tf1L VJEJLLn:::m1:rn).:i nrp~ Y'l~BlJLLc..iu;~ '1'1u1u Gloo '!!VJ

rrl .Gl . \9 11v.:i1uc.rnm1tl 1::: LDu fl ru 51111 LL"::: fl11ll 1tl1.:i1e1m1 lli1Luu.:i1u 'llu.:iviiJ1EJ.:J1u n1A1 '1 ' -

(fl1Y'l11J.J) Y'l~vlJLLc..iu;~ ~11.J11.J GlOO 'llVl , rrl . Ci) . m 11EJ.:J1u t:.1'1n11tl1::: LDu A ru 5'51lJ LL" :::fl11lJ l tl 1.:i1e1n1111i1.L u u.:i1u 'lltl-JVIU1 u-:i1un1 A f \i

. , -(11tJVIU1EJ-l11.J) wfalluc..iu;~ ~1U11.J\.1U1EJ-:i1uci::: ~ 'llVl

' rrl . l9 c..i nti' Y'IB

rrl h Ci) .....,,J1v.:i1umAf'11vWuvi11u LLn::: Ln vim111vi 1:::V1u nii-:imnu m1ru ~11.Jfl ru 511J.JLLCl :::m111ltl1-:i1e1 - , 1 um1~1L iiu.:i1u

<nl.l!J. l!J 'VIU1EJ-J11.Jfl1 flf~ lvi'ti1-ii'me1umL u:::'31nm1tl1::: LDu 1 tl~vivi1LLt:.11.J-J11.J hn.:i n11\.1"1u n'l n"l1lJ

L ~titlfotl1.:iV11u~Vl.JU1'l :::vlUflClJ5'51lJLLCl:::fl11lJ 1 tl1-:i fa'lJu.:J\.1U1 EJ-J11.J , '

C:::. n1')ci~lH:lU·:J1'LI

d .G) ·nvivi G) ')1LJ'1T\Hluuvl'u (Inception Report) tnu1u1~u~L1n1 mo 1u UUOVl\l1Vll'Uvin~'U1l.J lu'1ruru1 1m.1'1viv11L llu11EJ-J1u'11u1u l!:i o 'lJVI L iivV11t11~ m:iuv11 EJ n'lvUA11l.JAVI 'UBUL 'llvi n1')PJ nlj1 u u ,

LL~uvi'1L U'U'11'U vinvvi Lm-Jm'l LL u1VJ1-Jm1tl1~'lJ1'1l.lwu61m-J m11 ~V1u1 EJ-J1uviL i11'u m1tl1~LiJu 1~ L uuu15

n111'1 LJ n1'l1 Lfl'l1~i1" fl11l.J L ~ LJ -JU CUVl 1/vtl C1'l ')fl LLn ~ n1')LLm'lJ1 'U n1'lvl1 L U'U'11'U ~n n1 ')PJ nlj1 Lln ~1LA11 ~i1" u ,

n~l.Jtl'l~'lJ1mLU1Vll.J1 EJLL·n~ fH'll.Jvl 1v V1'1'llv-l LLvin ~Y1U1 EJ--111.J ni1n1V1uvi15m1'1l.J v11 v LJ1'1Vl1l.JY1~ n'1Ci~ LLn~ , , ,

m1ri'1Y1uvi15m11um1Lnu-U't1l.ln1 ~L llt11 tlmm.,~ n1'll1m1 L vlv 1 ~Aru~ n'l'll.J m1m1\lf uwC1vi 1 ~A11l.JL i:1u'!luu ,, ,

LDvA ru~ n11l.J n11vi11\l1uw'1vi 1 ~A11l.J L ~ U'!.lt1ULL~1 r'.i11~1-J\l~iiY1u-J~vLL ~'1 A11l.JL i:1u'!.lt1u L Ylv 1 -UL lJuV1ft' nu1t.J . , " ....

tl1~nvUn1'lLUff:ci1EJA1~1'1 '11Vlvi G) viu1tl

c:::.l!J '11vivi l!J ')1EJ'111.J\luu.ffunn1-l (Interim Report) mu1u'l~EJ~L1n1 f.'(o 1u uuovi\l1n1'Uvin-llJ1l.J

1 u'1 ruru1 lvi u'1 viv11L lJu11 EJ~1u~1u1u \!Jo 'lJV! L lf vY11tl 1~ nvuv11 LJ 11EJ-l1uA11l.Jn 111t1u1~ nm1'1vi Lnu-U'ul.ln .... ... ' '\J

'l.ltl-lLLuuci111\l Internal LLn~ External 1,j~1n111vE.Jn~ cro 'l.lt1-J'11u1uv11uci1~~\l~vlv-l'1V1Lnu~'1Y1l.JV1 LLn~ LA 1LA1~ 11EJ~1u~nn11tl1 ~ Liiu A ru5'l'll.JLLn ~A11l.J 1ti1~ 1'1n11~1 L U'U'111.J'l.lv'1VIU1 EJ-J ll.J n1A1u (n1w11lJ LLn:; , ~

'l1EJVIU1EJ-l1l.J) LL uu'1111\l Evidence - Based 1v)l,j~1n111t1E.Jn~ cro 'llv-J'11u1uV1ti1EJ'111.Jn~lJL tl1vim EJ L'~tl 1 ~ , fl ru~n'l'll.J n1'lV1'l1\l1UW'1Vl 1 ~fl11lJ l ~l.J'lJEJU L~EJAru~ n'l'llJ n1'ltil'l1\l1UWC1Vl 1 ~fl11 lJ L i.'.1u'lJEJU LL~1 r'.:111~1'3\l~ii , , ,, VlU-l~VLL ~-lfll1lJL i.'.iu'lJvUL Yiu 1-ff L U'UVlft n]1'Utl1:;ntJUn1'lL un-'11ufi1~1'1 '11Vlvi l!J vltl hJ

C::: .m ~1vivi rn 'l1f.J'111.J\lUUC1Vl~1EJ auu11~ (Draft Final Report) i11f.J1'U'l~EJ~L1'11 Glcro 1u UUOVl\l1n

l'U~n~'U1lJ 1 u '1 r1J ri.J1 LVIEJlJ')1EJC1~ LBEJ~vl-lvlEl 1 t1-d'

c::: .m . GJ 11f.1'111.J~nn11tl 1~LiJuAru5'l 'll.J LLn:; A11l.J 1ti1~1'1n11 vi'1Liiu-:i1 u'Uv-JVI i.11EJ~1u n 1 A1 u , ~

(n1w11l.J) auu 11-J L if vV11tl1:; nvu~1 EJ oLJt1l.Jn~'Uu1'U'llv'1 ni11.h~ Liiu 'l~L u uu15 m1tl1~LiJu mrn11t11~Liiu " ~

1 u i11W'l1 l.J LL n ~ '1 'ltl ~ n n1 'ltl'l ~ Lii'U'l.J LJ ~ LLvl n ~ VlU1 EJ-31 'U n111LA')1 ~~LL n ~'1 '1 L fl ')1:; ~-v v lJfl 1 un1w ')1lJ -if v LC11.Jv , " 1 u ni1tlfoth'3Wlil.J'U1vl1'Ufl(\Ji)')')lJLLfl~A11lJ1tl1'11'1'llv'1VIU1EJ'111.JJllfl1u1 'Ui11Yi'l1lJ oLJVLC11.Jtl 1 u n11Wlil.l'U1'l~UU , , . . ......

ni1tl1~Liiu flnJ5'l'llJLLn~A11lJ 1i.J~-J1'" 1 'LI m1vi'1L uu-J11.J'l.lv'1VlU1EJ'111.Ji11A1u -if m'1umL u~ 1 uni1'1viv11mmm1

1 u ni1Ut1'1n~ LLn~i.111utl 11lJ n11Yl\l1vi~-l 1u1:;vl'uu1uu1EJLLn~1 u1~vl'utlDu~ -if m'1 'LIB LL 1.J~LL u1Y11-l m1L ~vl.J lu-J

Lfl~tl-llivn1'l\h:; LlJ1.JflnJ5'l'lJ.JLLn~A11lJ 1tl1-l1'111.J n1'lvl1 L U1.J'111.J'l.JEl'3VlU1 EJ'311.Ji11A f u nu n1'lEJ n'l~vlUvl'lJU~lVI , -m1fo1n1'lVl\l1til (CPI) '111.J11.J \!Jo 'I.IV! ,, , ,

c::: . m. l!:i 11 EJ-311.J ~fl n111.J 'l~ Liiu A ru5 'l 'llJ LLn ~ A11lJ 1tl1-l1 '111.J n11 vi'1 L ii'U '111.J 'lJ B-J VIU1EJ-J11.J n 1 A f u , . -( 11 EJVlU1 EJ'11'U) auu11-l L lf vV11U'l~ nvUvl1 EJ ~n n1'lU'l ~ Lii'U n1'l1 LA'l1~~ Ltn~c1'-lLA'l1~i1" -if vlJn ElLJ1-Jn:;L a EJVl'l.Jtl-l ,, V1u1unu LLn~-Vm'1LJv1 LJni1ufutl1-JWlil.lu11'11uAru511lJLLn~A11l.JL i.11-l 1'1 V1u1 u~1un ~ er 'lJVI , . , ,

L ~B 1 ~flru~m1lJm1m1\lfuw'1vi1 ~A11lJL ~1.J'lJvu LDvAru~m'll.Jn1'ltil 11\lfuw'1vi 1 ~ A11l.JL i.'.1u'lJvULL~1 , , r:J-J1~1'1\l~lJVIU-l~tlLL~'1fl11lJLi.'.11.J'lJvUL ~tl 1-il'L lJuvift'nu11.JU'l~nvUn1'lL un-'11ufi1'11'1 '11Vlvi rn vltl 1u ,, ~

c::: .~ '11VI~ ~ 'llEJ'111.JQUUM1~1EJ wUUC1l.JU'lru (Final Report) i11EJ11.J'l~EJ~L1n1 GJC:::o 1u uunV!\l1n , " ·fovin~tnl.J 1 u er r1J ri.J1 LVI EJii'l1EJn~LBEJVlvl'1vlv 1 u-d'

c:::.~.G) UY1'11u~u1Y11'l 11u-J1u~nni1u1~LiJ'UAru 5'l'llJLLn~m1iJL tl1-J 1C11 LJ m1vi'1L uu-J11.J'lltl-l , ,, , viu1EJ-J1un1Af] (n1vi11lJ) tl1~nvuvi'1f.l'l1EJ'111.JOUun11~n1 Y1mrn:;mlj1tJ-lncp:J wsumL~u;a~ '11u1u G)oo ~vi

c::: .~ . l!:i 11f.l-J1umrn 11'\.J 1~ LiJu fl ru 51 'llJ LL n ~f\11lJ1ti1'11'1m1vi'1Liiu-J11.J'll B'1VIU1u-J1u 111 fl f u , ~

(mvi11lJ) auu'1lJu1ru LiivV111h~ nvuv11EJ -ifvlJn~'Uu11.J'llv'1 ni1t11~LiJLJ 'l~L uuu15m1tl1~LiJu ~n ni1u1~LiJu ,, " ~

1 un1w'l1lJLLn~C11u~n ni1i.J1:; LlJU'llu-J LLvln ~viu1 f.1'1111 m11 Lm1~~ Lrn~'1'1Lm1~~oLJvl.Jn1 umw11l.J -if m'1u u , ,,

1LJni1ufoth'1Wlil.JU1vi'1uAru5'l'llJLLn~A11lJ1 i.11-J fa'llu'1Vli.h EJ-J1u111rt1u 1 un1w11lJ -if mmrn 1 uni1wlil.l'U11:;uu , , ~

n1'lth::aDUF1 ru5'l'llJ LLfl~rn1JJ 1 i.J~'11'11 i.rn1'lvi1L U'l.1'11'LI'llv\IVIU1 EJ'11'LIJl1fl1\l im'11.1tJLL u::: 1 'Uni'l'1vivi1JJ1mm':i , .. 1 u n1'lUv\ln'ULLfl~U')11JU'l1lJn11Yl\J°1VlvY\11'LI'l~vl1J'U1vu1EJLLfl~ 1 ifi~vllJUDU~ oLJtJL'1'UtJLL 'U~LL 'U1Y11\ln1')L ~tllJ LEJ\I

Lfl ~v'liiv n1'lU1::: LD'U fl nJi)') ') lJ LL fl::: fl11lJ 1tJ1'11'11'Un1') vi 1 L ij 'U \11'U'Utl\IVIU1 EJ\111.1Jl1fl1 :\i" nu n1 ')EJ n'l ~!ilu Iii' '!Juif 1 VI , .. n1'l11Jfn1'lY1\J°1Vl (CPI) Y'lfaJJLLc..i'U;g~ i11.11'U moo 'IJVI " , ,

d .ct . en 11 EJ\l l'U ~fl n1 ':iU 'l ~ LD'U fl ru511 lJ LLn ~fl11JJ 1 i.11 '11'111.1n11vi1 L U'U\111.l'U v\IVI u 1EJ\111.1111fl1 :\i" , .. ( 'l1EJ111u1 EJ\111.1) t:iULJ'1lJu1ru L if ti1111i.J1::: ntiutil1 EJ cm ni1i.J 'l~LDu ni1iLm1:::v1 LL fl ~cr\I Lm1:::v1-U'tilJfl ti ci1'1fl~ L5 EJVI

" " 'llv\IVI i.i1 EJ\111.1 LL fl~ -U ti L'1Uv1 un11tJ1utJ 'l '1Yi vuu1ti!1u fl ru5':i1lJ LL fl~ fl 11JJ 1tJ1 '11'1 YI :rvlJ LLc..iu;zi~ i 11.11 u , ,

' Vl'U1EJ\11'Ufl::: ~ 'UV! , l~tl 1~flru~n'l1lJn1')Vl')1\J11JYi'1VI1 ~fl11lJL ~'U'lltllJ L~tlflru~n1'llJn1')Vl')1\J1uYi'1VI 1 ~fl11lJL ~'U'lltl1JLL~1 , ,

~11'11'1\J~lJVIU\l~tJLL~\lfl11lJL ~'U'UtllJL ~tl 1-UL llu111~n:\i"1'UU'l:::nv1Jn11LUff~1EJA1:5'1'1 \11Vl~ Ci'. vlv 1u " .. <X. ft1~1\ILL":::m1\J1t1L~'U

m'lL u n-'1°1EJr1i-'11'1~-ru~1\I \J ~LL u\IL ll'U ct \11vi !il'lvi v 1 ulI

<X .m \11VI~ G) n1~UVl~1EJrl1:5'1\lfaEJn::: 190 '1Jtl\IL~'UA1i1'1vY'1VllJVI Jl1EJVl~\1~~1ui1'11vl'1'1lJtlU\11U "

'11VI~ m ~ii n1'lvi1L uu\111.1muo1umJJL~t:Ju1 'llni'lcl\llJtlU'111.1Vl1JJ-llv d. m LLfl~i1ni'lm1\J-5'u'11u 1vi EJflru~ m'lJJ ni 'l

m1\J1uYi'1VIL U'U~L~ EJ1J1tiEJ 1vi mHui1'1\J::: 1vHur11i1'1 nvim~vi1n1'lLLm 'lJLLfl~'1'1lJtJU-l 1'Ufl')lJ 011..JL llu~L~ EJU1v EJ , " .

<X .19 \11Vl~ 19 n1Vl'l.JVl'11EJrl1'11'1faEJfl~ Ci'.o '1Jtl\IL~'Ufi1i1'1vY\!VllJVl Jl1EJVl~\1~~1ui1'11vlc1'1lJtl1J\11'U "

'11VI~ 19 ~i:Jm1vi1L U'U\11Umun1uvnm~tiu b ni1'1~JJt:JU\11u mJJ-if v d.19 Lrn :::iim'lm1\J-5'u'11u 1viEJAru~ m'lJJnT)

Vl11\J-5'UY{'1Vll lJu~L~ EJUfaEJ 1VIEJ ~4fui1'1\J~ 1tiJfor)1i1'1 nvim~viJn11LLm 'lJLLfl~c1'1lJtJU\l 1'Ufl1U 011.1 L lJu~ L~EJUf v EJ , " <X.cn \11Vl~ en n1Vl'LIVl'11EJA1i1'1fvEJfl::: 190 'Utl\IL~'Url1i1'1~\IVIJJVI Jl1EJ'Vl~\1~~1ui1'1 1vi'cl'1lJtlU\11U

\11Vl~ en ~iimwi1L U'U\11'Ufl'l1J~1'U VlllJL~tl'U 1-uni'lci\llJtlU\111.J mJJ-if v G .'11 LLfl:::iJ nl')VJ 11\J1U'11'U 1vi EJAru~ n11lJn1')

Vl11\J1uYi'1V:L U'U~L~ EJUfa EJ 1vi EJ~foi1'1\J~ 1vi'for11'11'1 nvim~tllJn11LLm 'lJLLfl~'1'1lJtJU\l 1'UA1U 01'UL llu~L1 EJU1vEJ

<X .Ci'. \11VI~ Ci'. n1Vl'UVl-'1°1EJA1i1'1faEJfl~ 190 '1Jtl\IL~ufi1i1'1vY\IV1lJVI Jl1EJVl~\1~~1u'11'11vi'c1'1JJtl1J\11U "

'11VI~ ct ~iJm1vi1Luu'11um1Jn1umm~vubm'lc1.JJJt:JU\11u vnJJ-ifu d .Ci'. LLfl~iJni1m1\J1'u'11u1viEJ11ru~m1lJni1 m1'11'uYi'1viL lJ'U~L~ EJuf vEJ 1vi EJ~fo~1\l\J::: 1tilfo r11'11'1nvim~viim1LLm 'llLLfl~'1'1lJvrn 1umuc11uL uu ~L1EJu1uEJ VIJ.J1EJL 'v1Vl : ' G) . mru~~ru~1'11~'11lJ11ClU'l::: LDU~flVIU1EJ\ll'U1vi 1vi'mm~tl'U b~1~u 1 u TOR \J~infi1i1'1 LVJEJAVI

\J1n11fl1~tl~EJviuWU1EJ\l,,1'U'Utl\l\IUU1~J.J1ru11lJvtlvi''1vii1'1 1 ufi1i1'1\11Vl~ Ci'. ,

h mrucHu:il1\I hl'11lJ11ClU1~LD'l.J~flV1U1EJ\11'U 1vi 1vi'mlJL~tl'U 1'lJ~')~U1 u TOR LVIEJLnVl\J1 nLVIVl'1Vli'1EJ " ' , , 111~uw~~ m1ruvhlJ '1-iim1JJ~V1'llu'1~1'ui1'1 1 ~'11EJr11i1'1mJJ~lvi'vi1 L uuni1\J°1'1

CO) 0. 'FIL~'U\!Ulh:::1n ru v v

\IUU1~J.J1ruvi1Luum1 11JJYJ\l~'U ········· ·········· ···· ········-------1J1Yl ,

CO)CO). m1lJaYJB o V ~ - ' cl .c:. ..J t LI ,,J tJV V

LLUU'1111\J 'IJtllJfl Lvn'111 11EJ\11'ULLfl~~fln11Plff'tJ11Lfl11~VI 11lJC1\1'1\IY1'1\llJtlUVl1lJ'Utl d Y1~1U\J1\I " "

-:5'vivi1~1.1'11nm1u5u~'11'UmJJ1m'1 ni11 1 ~nrnhun\111.1 tJ . tJ. 'll . \J:::vi m ll'U m1lJ~YJ~ Lrn~ft'll~YJE'llti\lchun .. nu

tJ :J. 'lJ . 1vi EJ~f 1J:il1\l\J::: ~tl'11iic1'1lJtJU Llfl~ hJ L~ EJLL Y'l 1LL UU"111\J oLJtllJfl Ltl n'111 11 LJ\111.lLLfl ~~fl n11Pl n'tlll L m1~v1

!il'1n"111 ~L~ricrlwv1 ~mi1lUl-Uu1~ 1v'llu1vi EJ lJ.J 1vi'fom1lJu'UEJt:JlJ\J1n~ ___ (~JJJnJ:rn~J.\J.~1\J_~-~-'il.tn.JffDJJi;:(~~:ul __ _ "

..,ca. "u "" 0 v '"""' ~ " u ~ " ..:ii Q,.

G) 1!J. fl nHI lJU Vl 'lJ tl ,:i r.J ')lJ \l 1·H111'J \I'll tl lHl 1Lfl')1 :::VI 'lJ tl lJ" LL '1 :::'1-:i Lfl "l1 :::-.., "U tl lJ" L vrn tJ ')::: LlJ lJ fl ru i:i ') "llJLL"::: , "' u 'U " ,

A11111tJ1-:i1C11 uni"lv11 LUlJ-:J1lJ'lJITTVIU1fN1lJfl1fl1;i tJ1:::'11ll YI .A. l!Jct'b o ...,

c'.Jfo~1-l\l:::vi'ti-:iiiAruC1lJU~ vi'-:illit11 utf \J ,

Cil'9 . Cil L UlJ C101u1.m11Pi mn C1()iuun111 '1 fJ J.rniJ5 -..,1viJ ~uAfrn~~'UYl::: L ti fJlJ L U'\.J ~ u1 n"CT111 nu \J ,

m :::Yl 11-:J n11fl~-:J ~iiiJ1:::'1Un1"loJ Llfl:::c.Jfln11v1'1L iJ'LI-l1'\.Jvl1'\.J m1'1111'1-LJ' tllJfl L vh:in11i.J1:::LDucrnni1fi n"CT1l'1 t!Y11-l \J

'1-:i fllJP11CW1{ LLfl :::'1 G~

Cil'9 .19 jj U fl fl 1n1 c'.J~ jj fl11lJ1 fl11lJ C111J11() 1 ~ L VllJ1 :::'1lJnUvl1 LL V1U .:i-..,iJ 1~1u;J1'\.J1'\.J~ L W tl-l 'Wtl L ~ti n11 , \J \J

v11L iJum1tA1.:i m "l 1v1t1ci1-ljjiJ1:::~Y1En1vmfl::: Lnviu1::: 1 tJ'l!l.fo-l'1VlvnlJ1vi()u1:::'1-lrl'lJt1-:i LA 1-l m1

Cil'9.r.n 11.iLlJ'l.Jc'.i()m:::uzjtl 11l lJUfU~11tlzjtJc'.J~-l-l1~'lJ~Wl1-l11'lJ~11 Lrn:::lvi'LL~.:] LitJ'U~tlLL~1 V11t111.iL lluc'.l~ "~ ' u " "

1vi'f ur.ifl'!Jt1-ln11i.:i 1 ~u~uAflflVl1BuAAfl5uL lluc'.i~-:i-l1u vnlJ"l:::L UEJU'!Jt1-lY11-:i11'l!m1 , , \J

Cil'9 . Ci'. 11.i L llu 0v1fo L tl n~Y1B-.., 1Bfl111J~lJ nu zj-ltll\JU B LC1Li 11.i fJtllJ~'UPrn~ 1vrn L 1uLLvlf3iU1'1 'Utl-l ~ LC1Utl

11m 1v1iiri1i-l 1 ~'1fl:::~Y1Efl11lJA1Jnu L-du11Ju , Cil 19 . ~ 1 li L lJ 'U ii jj r.J fl iJ 1 ::: 1 fJ 'lJ -LI~ 1 lJ n 'U nu ii L '1 '\.J ti 1 1fl111 fJ 5 '\.J ~ L -u 1 L C1 '\.J tl 11 fl 11 ~LL n ( zj ti VI ii 1 tJ.:] 1 'U "' " ----- ----------- --- --- ---

~foi4vi'!ltlUn111.h:::LDuJ ru 1uu1:::ni!'lu1:::mm1m Vl1a 11.iL lluirn1:::vhm1auL llum1-ilvi'U11-l ni1 LL-ii.:i-Uu11A1 ----- ---------- ------ -- -- ------- - " a ci1-:iL lJu5111111.m11u1:::mm1m~1-lA~-ltf

Cil'9. b 11.i L lluc'.J() m:::uzjtll1L UlJl•i'1 ruru1v11ii1v1LL'1Vl-lUfU~11 £JfU11tJ~1fJ Vl1tJLL'1Vl-lUfU~11 EJf U11fJ~1 fJ '\J"' , \J ... ... ... ....

11.i () nvi' t1 -:i mu c11u1 u '111::: '11 A' ru 1111 lJlh::: ni Pl fl ru::: n 111.in11 iJ . iJ . '!I . L ~ B-l ,,, ~ mn ru'Yl LL fl :::15n11'1 vi v11 LL fl::: \J u

LLC1Vl-lU fU~11 fJ n1"l-ru~1 fJ'lJtl-:J LA'l ·rn11~UflflflVI 1au~u flfl'1 L llufi'1ru fU1 nUV1U1 fJ-:Jll.J'lJtl-l-r'5 'W .PL ID~~Ci' LLn::: u , ' " .... u .u

~LLrll 'lJL ~lJL~lJ

G>m. f11"l~vivi1-lim'1u-v Lfl'l-l n11

irfo~1.:i~C1u 1\l1 ~'1-l-U't1 L'1'UB Lfl'l-l ni1LC1uaviaflru:::m1lJ m1m 1v11L fru m1'1111 ~1-ltl1::: nauv11 EJ \J

Cil"1.C9> 'IJ B-l LtJ n'111Y1 ~ n\i1tJ'UB-l c'.Jfiu-U'm'1u a .... \J

c'.f 1u41.:ivi' tl-:J ti lJL v n'111 LL '1 Vl-l fl ruC1 lJiJvi L da-l vl'\.J lVl fJ ti ti 1-:JU tl fJ vi' tl-:J iJ L tl n'111vl'1 if \J ,

Ci) r.n . Cil . (9) L llmrn1uu n11Pi n"CT1 C1 ()1 U'\.J n11l'1EJ lJ fl u5 VI 1 BU~ u AA'1 ~\!Vl'Vl::: LU EJU 11 nu \J ,

.,j ·' ~ • 1 ., C9lm.Cil.19 11EJ'lJtlllfl:::u1:::1viniwn-:i1u'lJt1-:JUflflln'l '\.J'Utl <9l'9 . ,

C9lm.Cil . r.n riu-l~t11Jt1uB1u1\l zj-l lJvim m LLC11'11JUVl1lJ f1!)VllJ1EJ 1 umru~~tiu-Ua LC1ut111t1u 1 ~'l! A m15u

fl-:JtJ1lJ 1 uL anm1-V'm'1umL YJtJ

Cilr.n .19 'llcWUBLC1lJB~1'UL YlflUA

c'.Jfo 41.:i vi't1.:i '1 viv11-V'm'1ut1YJ1-lv11u L Y1 AiJA a ci1-:iii ti EJvi'a-ith::: nt1u i;l1 EJC111::: '11 Fi' ru vl-l if \J u

Cilm .h Ci) 11tJfl:::L BfJVlU1:::'1Un11oJ~'1tlVlfl~tl'1 nu~ n'l'Jru:::-:i1uvnlJ TOR 'lJt1-:icHu ~1-l 1 ua ~Vl EJtl'\.JVl~-l \J

C9> r.n .19 .19 11 fJ fl::: LB tJ VI 15f111vi1LU11-l 1 '\.J LL fl::: LL c.J '\.J v) 1LiJ'U-l1'UVI111-LJ' tin 1 VI l1 Vl 'U ti U L '!J 111'Uti-:J-l1 'U

th:::nvUvl1fJ n'l"tlUfl11lJAVl 'UBUL'Ul'lf111flf1"cl1 LLc.J'Uv1'1LU'l.J-:i1tJVlfltlVl lfl'l-:Jn11 LL l.J11'.11-l n11th:::'ll1'11J~lJ51fl 1-l f111

1 ~V1li1EJ.:i1u~L -U1-runi1u1~LD11 1:::L uEJu15 ni11'1EJ ni1i Lm1:::vi"m1rn~u-li:lruV11/-vu'111ALLfl::: n11LLm'U1 um1 u ,

v11L iiu-i1u 15n11Pi n"t!1LLfl :::1LA11::: vi"n~11u1:::'lJ1n1L U1V11J1 EJ'llt1-:iLLvifl:::V1u1 u.:i111 n11ri1V111vi15n11ci11v11aci1-l , ,

vn11V1~n'1i1~ LLci::: m1 n1V111vi15 ni1hm11Lnu-Va11'11 ~ L llu hJvnJ.Jvi~ni'l!1 m1 15u1:::l.J1'1c.ici m11Lm1:::vi"ila11fl \J \J

'""" d I LIV V d.id - q - 'V V 0 V

CilCJl. h r.n ')1 tJn::: LB fJ Vl Lfl'l tl'U 1EJ'!Jtl-lc.J1U\l 1-l Y1 lJ fl11 f)\1.....,1 an\) f1111J'1 Bl'lflfl tl-:J nu f111'1111\l'U tllJfl Vl11J TOR u \J

(9)Q1 . \!).c( rl1Vl'Um:::E.J:::L 1'111 'Ufl11~1L 'iJWl1'U'lJB·m~'U~1LiiWl1'ULLvJ":::~'U\;lB'l.l~~B'l 1 m 'Un11

~1L 'iJ'U fl11 (Ttme Schedule) 1 'Ua n'l.'}ru:::LlJ'U(;l111'1L1"1tlU'l1'U 1 ~iiri11lJiKlJ~1.JB nm lJu'li1.:i 1 mlJci'1v1u

m1lJ'11fi'ru'lJa.:i.:i1'U'Yi~BlJA'1e:i5u1mh:::nm.Jvin.:i1umlJvian1'lf1m1 u ,

(9)Q1 . \!) . tr rl1vt'U\1l 1::: El::: L 1 "11 'U fl11~1 L 'Ll1.1.:i1'U L\11 E.J~ wv1111 E.J" ::La E.J\11~ \!:::~1 L \iu fl111 'LI fl11

u5iJ~.:i11.1'lJa.:i-yri"1m'lJB\lLLvi":::ri1.1 Lll'U'11u1'Ufl'U - L~B'U (Man - Month) vi~mll'LI'11'U1'Ufl'U -1'U

(Man - Day)

(9) Q1. \!). b ~~ 'U if BL '1'UB'11l.J11 fl\!::: L '1 'U B if BL '1 'UBL~ lJ L ~ lJ 5 'U <i ~ 'U B n L VI U B \11n~1::: U 111 'U " I ,

if tirl1Vl'U\1l'lJBUL 'lJ(;l'lJtl\l'l1'U~ L i'.1u11L lJ'UtJ1::: LEJ'lfUvlB~11-;J1.:i 1~ ,, (9)Q1 . Q1 '1!B'lifBL'1'UB~1'U11fl1

~1u-;J1.:i ~B\l~'UoUB L'1U B~1'U ':i1fl1(;1" B\111::: E.J::: L 1" 1~1L 'Liu m1 Ll'lE.J ~ e:i.:iii11E.J"::: L 5 E.J t'lB ci1.:iue:i CJ vY.:i-d ,, '

(9)Q1 . Q1 . (9) fl1(;lt:JULL 'VllJ'1JB'l'Ufl"1nd , (9)Q1 . Q1 . \!) Fi11-ff~1E.Jm.:i L'li'U Fl1Yflvt'U:::L~'U'V11'1 Fi1'1111'iJ Fl1~~(;1LtJn'111 Fl1~t'lvi111E.J'l1'U

fi1511m ifo:1.Jm1u"1m11'lf1m':i'1lB'l'1mu'U~'UiK.:inl'l L ll'U~'U

(9)rn . Q1 . Q1 Fi11 -tl~1E.J5'U I vtlJ1E.JLVI(;) : 11Jm~ClJ1(;11~'1lti'1.:immn1L~lJL~lJ1'UmCJvia.:i1lJ11miiill'l 1 i1u~'lLLvi1'LI~u'l!e:i.:i

(9)((. LnruonmTYi'il11ru1

m1-;J1\l~tJ~n'l.'}1-Vi'iJ11ru1m:::vi11~ !!) 15 fie:i

15~t'lL~Bn - ...., d I.I - QJ .c!ij ,,, d. !.I 0 ~ ~ SJ'

(9). n1d'\f'J\!11(U1fl\1l L" B nt:.J L'1'U Bd1fl1'il :::Yi\!11ru1 fl\11 L" B n (:.! L'1'U B 11 fl1Ltl'Yi1:::11E.J'Vl(:.!11.J'lJ B fl1vtlJ\1l'lJ'U (;11 LLm ,, ,, ~.:i'Vi \!11ru1A\1l L~ Bnd1E.J~iiri::: LL lJ'U'V11'1 L 'Vlfliifl~~'1\1l LL"::: L'1'U B11fl111lJ 11J Ln'U1 \l L~lJ\l'UU1:::lJ1 CU'IJB'l Lfld\l fl11 , 1 um ru~ ~ L'1'U B 11fl1~ljfl::: LL 'U'U'V11'1 L 'Vlfl'iJ fl~~'1\1l LLvl L'11.J B11 fl111lJLnlJ1\l L~'U\l 'UU 1::::1.J1 ru'IJ B'l Lfld'l fl11 ,, , 'iJ:::'Vi\!11ru1fi'l'lL~Bn~L'1'Um1m~nf1::: LL lJlJ'V11'1L 'Vlfliiflm 'Uci°1v1uc11'l 1tJ~L'1'UtJ';i1fl111lJ11J Ln'U1'l L~'U'IUU1:::lJ1ru ,, 'lJB'l Lfld'lfl11(;11lJci°1v1'U Lrn::: 1 'Umruii~ L'1'Um1ri1nf1::: LL 'U'U'V11\l L 'VlflUflL vh fl'U'il:::'Vi'iJ11ru1fi'l'l L~ tin'il1nd1fl111lJ ,, '1JB\l~L'1'Utl';i1fl1~1ffJ1LL"::: 1lJLn'U1\lL~'U\l'UU1:::lJ1ru'lJB\l Lfld'l fl11 LL":: 1 u mru~Yl nd1E.JL'1'U Bd1fl111lJLn'U1\l L~'U ,, , 'lutJ1:::lJ1ru'lJB\l Lfl 1\l m1\!:::~1 L -Du m1vie:i 1B\l11fl1(;11lJci°1v1u m1-Vi\!11ru1.U1\l~u L\11 m '1t1'lci'1v1u(;l1lJfl::: LL U'U

'V11\l L viri\i fl~'1.:ina'U 11.1m1-Vi'il11ru1~1u 11f11\l::: fj l'loU m'1'Um1 m~'lVllJl'l L lluvta n 1 'LI m1-Vi'il11 ru1 ,, h oU B L'1'UB~1'UL YlflUfl~ B\l LL'1 \11\l Ci'ltJ 1::: '1'U fl11ru Lrn::: t:.J" n11~1 L 'iJ 'U\l1lJ ~1'U n11'1111'il1~tiL~BU1::: LlJlJ t:.J"

m1Pim:t11~t1'V11.:iiK.:irilJPl1'1(;lfa":::'1'1~

rn . Lnruonm1'Yi'iJ11ru1.Ue:i L'1lJB'V11\lL 'VlflU fl LL" :::.Ue:i L'1'U BB'U I 'il:::'Vi\!11ru1.Um'1'UBY11\l L 'Vlfl'LiflLL":::.Um'1'UB

51.JI 'lJB\l~L'1'Um1ri1Lu'Yi1:::~nflru'1lJu1iLL":::V1an]1'Urnn'111~n~a.:i Ll'lCJnLnruonm':i'Vi\!11ru1 Q1 tJ1:::L~u v1'l-d

Q1.(9) tJ1:::'1um1ru~1'u-;J1\l (!!)o ri:::LL u'U) 'il:::'Vi\!11ru1'iJ1ntJ1:::'1um1ru'1Jti.:iriru:::cHu-;J1'l 1 'LIB~\;l ,, ,, EJB1.JV1a.:illJ~1n-J1 !!) U ljf111lJ~~'1Bl'lfl'1ti'lnuan'l.'}ru:::.:i1'UmlJ TOR 1:::UU':i1'lfn1':i fl11'U°1vt111'\in\l m11~t1 ,, ~

LL":::th::: W'Ut:.Ji:l LLi:l:::f111nu ':i:::'1'U m1ru ~ 11.J m1vi 11 ~ tllJ1 ri B'U Ll'ltl'il:::TI \!11(U1fl CUil1Yi'lJB'l\l1'U1 ~ti~ ~1 L iJ lJ n1':i~1 ti , L'li'U \l1'U1~t1ffi~1'u11.:i1''1\!1n'1mu'Uvi1\l1 Lll'U~'U

Q1 . \!) Ufl'11m (!!)o fl:::LL'UlJ) TI'il11ru1\!1mvilni1Pim11 tJ1:::'1'\Jfl11ru'lJB.:Jflru:::~-¥u-;J1.:i~L'1lJBlJ1 , , . \I

q v ...., -. u ...,.. ~ o .dcv -

lJfl11lJ'1Bl'lf1"B'lnu.n11n\lfl11lJdU~l'l'lfBU\;11lJ TOR 11l.J'Vl'l'il1'U1'U Man - Month 'V11Ut:.J\1l'lfBU

•

<9)0

i;ru;n 15fl11 ~1btJ't.M1'W (b o fl~ bb 'W'W) Vi "II 1'HU 1flf1Lfl1'V'l'1.1e:J\ll6fl1''.l ~ 1 b tJ 'W \l1'WbbG't ~ b VJ fltJ fl '

fl1 'j"'th ~ biJmrn b "li'W m e:i u fl11:J.J f1 ~ 'I.I e:i rn 'I.I~ fl 11 Pi fl 't:l1 bbl!-1'W~1btJ'W\l1'W ~ G't e:i ~ 1fl 1 \l fl11 bb 'Wl VJ1\l fl11

tJ1~'1l1~:J.J~'WITTfl1\l m11 V!V1't.i1M1'W~b-if1-ru m1tJ1~biJ'W 1~ bu tiu15m11~ ti m11 bfl11~~fl11:J.J b~ti\!Uf\JV!1/ e:itJi;'111mbG't~ m1 bbtil '1.11 'W m1 ~1btJ'W\l1'W 15m1 Pi fl't:l1 bbG't ~1bfl11~~fl~:J.JtJ1~'111mbiJ1V!:J.J1 tJ'l.le:J\l bb~G't~V!'t.h tJ\l1'W ' '

15~n~.:i

fl11~1\l~U~fl"t:t11~ti15~nG't\l ~1btJ'Wfl11l1~1\l 1~tJ~1'1 (Direct Hirino) b'<\11~'<\1'1bO'V'l1~~1'UflflG't~:Um1:J.J~ ::, ' 'U

fl11:J.Ji;'l1:J.J11mbG't ~tJ1~i;'lun11ru b V1:J.J1 ~ i;'l:J.J nu fl 11n-;u bbG't ~ b lJ'Wu fl flG't~ ~11 ~1\l bfltiVJ11uV1~e:i bfl ti b ~'W ' 'U

fl11:J.Ji;'l1m1mbG't~l!-IG't\l1mb~1 bbG't~bumTIVfu~m1~bzje:i~e:i1~ 1Vfm~v111~'Wmru1~mru'Vl~\l ~1m~butiu 'U

0 CV Q.J d I 11 V ii

i;'l1'Wfl'W1tim:o:J.J'W~111mtim1'V'li;'I~ 'V'l.131. ®ct:i;nct: 'l.le:J ~i;n .. '

a II o II - ' "' .., f"'1 'i1 Vi'l::LlJV~n1'i'11 ~'il1'i1'1'1JlJU!1 1Lfl 'i1 ::-.,'1JlJ U11LLll::'il~Lfl'i1::-.,'IJCl U !1 - - -

- ~

LvJ ut11 :: LiiuRCUli 'l"l'ULLll ::R 11u1t1~~1'111'Um'i~1LU'U~1'U'IJll~\1U1V~1'Ul11f'lf~ (Integrity & T ransparency Assessment: ITA) tl1::~1\J~tJ\.i'i::mcu YU 1. 2560

fl 1~iltJ W't'l'U'4 fli11 n'i

fl1~il\J LLVl'U ~1~N ~ :: u ::

~mn"d1 C~L~v1'1J1ty) L 1!11vi1~1'U

-.,iJ1vi'lu~1uihn;iLLtJtJ\.i'i :anu (tJ1Yl/L~il'U) ~1'U1'Ufl'U

(R'U- L~Cl'U) 'i1U (tJ1YI) -.,u1m..,~

1. ..;'1...,u1Lfl 'Hn1'l" 46700 2.64 1 6 739728 - f'i1~lltJLLYl'U\jfl111n'i ,j'!J 1 LLll:: 2 R~~1UrJ~'l"1

fi1~lltJLLYl'U~mmfl1YIV mU\1U~~llm::Yl'l"1~n1'l"flft~

19iim'iPim:11: 'i::~tJtflcycy1Llln ..I "' .I -YI nfl0903/1. 99 11~1\JYI 20 YHlf'l'1n1V\J 'r'Lf'I . 2546

i.h::i1tJn1'iru: hluuvn-11 10 tJ - fi1~lltJLLYl'U'4A111m ,Jll 3 !i'1~ii~;i1n...,..r~~mi1un~1u ' ..I ..I ... .J ...

nwJijtJ~~1'U: ~llll~'i::V::L1111Lf1Hn1'l" n.Yl. m'UYI~~ YI 'U'ilOOB.1/13 11~1\JYI 21 U'U1flU

«~ii1u,j1u1u : Lfl'l"~ni'i11:: 1 Au 2555 L~ll~ n1'in1\1'U~rJ~'l"1L~'UL~ll'Uii1'1ftJ~ClJ19ii~ n.Yl. fmll~

2. ~L~m'!l1cyl111uni'iWmL11::i.h::Ujw:.m 31300 2.64 x 6 x

- ,j 1 \J1 'U'4 fl"1n'iLL11:: 'i:: V:: L 1111tl ij\Jvi ~ 1\Jcl1 ~ii~ 'il1n

19iin1'iPim:11: 'l"::~tJtflcycy11 wff'U1 ti '4fl111n'l"~tlij\Jvi~1\J'il~~'!Jll~ Lfl'i~n1'i ITA tl~tJtl'l"::u1cu Yl .f'\. 2559

tl'i::i1tJm'iru: h 1umm11 s \'J

m'itlB\Jvi~1u : ~11ll~'i::v::L1111tm~m'i • v ..J • \1U1VL\1~: \.lfl111n'i111~tJYI 2 \1\J1V~1\Jil1U1'it1

«~ii1\J,j1u1u : tl'i::mcu 100 wu1v~1ul'illfl\J tlfrn ti~ V\J 111i'mum1u,j1L U'ULL11::fl11UL \1U1::i1u

3. unWv 15000 2.64 x 6 x

19iini'iPim:11: 'i::~tJtflcycy1~~;1u 1 ti

tl'i::iltJn1'inJ: 0 - 5 ti

n1'itlfrJii~1\J : ~llll~'i::V::L1111Lfl'l"~n1'i

«~ii1'U,j1\J1'U : tl'l"::mcu 20 '1u1v~1'Ul'illfl\J .., .., ~ "' ..,

4. L'il1\1'U1VILntJ'!JCll;Jll 11500 1 x 2 x

19iim1Pim:11: 'l"::~tJtl'i::nii'luvu~'l"i'll1ii'r'l (tl1'1J.) 1fu1tl

tl'i::iltJn1'l"nJ: 0 - 5 tJ m'itlBtJ~~1u : 'li1m111Lnu,Jm;J11 2 L~ll'U

«~ii1u,j1u1\J : tl'i::u1cu 3 A'Ul'illunWv 1 fl'U

DllflJ21DlJll'.!'.ll'1jflllJD1 xxx

~11'li~1EJV1'5.:I (Direct Cost)

5. ~1~Vlvi1LL\J\Jth::Lihm'1 '51 m ~ tJ ·w1.h EJ ~1'U'l'U"vlt11EJ.:11'U ~1'\J 'l'U'tl VILE ff'11'5 . '511J (\J1VI) "vllJ1EJL"vlVI • (\J1VI) ~tJ"vlil'lEJ.:11'\J

5.1 ~1~i9V!Lvmnrn-uutJ~~LD'\J Internal 2 x 100 x - D'1.:iu.:i'11m1f11m:.iYiv.:iV1mm1mth~mru'llviri~ 2 u1vi . Integrity & Transparency Assessment (\i1'U1'U 4 "vl~1) (L"vll.J1~1EJ)

5.2 ~1c.ii9V!LvmmLLtJtJth~LiJ'l.J External 1.50 x 100 x - D'1.:iB.:i'11m1mV11lJYitJ.:iV1ri1V1~1A1tJ~~mru'tlviri~ 1.50 ,

Integrity & Transparency Assessment tJ1YI (\i1'U1'U 3 "vl~1) (L'v1lJ1~1EJ)

5.3 ~1~i9V!Lvf1~1~LLtJtJU'i~LiJ'l.J Evidence - 5.50 x 1 x tl'1.:i B .:i '11nn1~~tJ~1F11VI1lJYl'il'lVI ri1 VI ~1 f11tJ WlJ 1 ru'tlvi ri~ • Based Integrity & Transparency 5.50 tJ1YI (\i1'1.Jl'U 11 "vl~1)

Assessment

:rnJ~1~~IiJlllllllJ~~1~lJc.i£i xxx

6. fi11.U.i1!Jri111~fi1f'l"\J11J

6.1 "l-1U1!J~1\J~ii~oY~u~L\J~\J~vi1~~~wl'i1l (uu

~1n~~Wl\1\~11~1~)

fi11um~ !J~

11R1Piu"l-11l1!J

(tJ1Yl/ f'l\J/1\J)

240

;i1\J1\J1WA\J I ;i1\J'l\J

"1-1u1!J~1\J

x x

fi11.U.i1!J\1\H (Direct Cost)

;i1\J1\J

~t1Bllii~1\J 111J (tJ1YI)

x x

~·~~~~·· · ·········································· · ········ · ······ · ····· · ·· ·· ··· · · · · · ··· ······r·· ······ · · · · · ····5·00·· · ···············r·················~···· · ·············r···--· · ···~············ · ·· · · · ·· · ····· · · · · ·· · · · · ··· · ·· · ·· · ·· l· ···· · ···· · ················ ··· ··· · ········ · ·········· l x x

.............................................................................................................................. .. ......................... . ........................................ . ........................... . ................................ ... ~ ............................................ ......... j

A1L~\JYl1~

6.2 fi1L~\JY11~1 tl-n ft'tJ"l-1U1!J~1\J~ii~~u~1 \J ~\J~m!JL\J~~"l-1111\

1200

600

111Jfi1ri111~n1f'l"u11J

x

x

x x x

x x x

xxx

"l-1"1!JL"l-1~

. ' ' ' - "1-1U~~um::wrnm1f'lft'~ viwYi~l1l Yi nf'I 0409.6/1 42 <1~1'uYi 26 n1n!J1f'l1J 2550 L~u~

"l-1ft'n 1n ru'1n111Dnfi1vn"1-1u::~u~1~-U11JL'!J\11~~"1-11'1i1 L~U'Uli1L'll!JU.<1::1'i11-U.i1v~\J~~1Lllu~u~ ~1m ~u~ 1um1L~uY11~1 tl11'1Jm1

ri1ti'~1EJvi~.:i (Direct Cost)

7. ri1'1vivi1~1EJ'11'-I ~1fl1~tl'l-ltJ'W ~1'1J1'1J ~1'1J1'1J'UVI ~1:1.1 (U1YI) '1-1:1.11EJL'l-IVI • • (U1YI) 'l-ltJ1EJ'l1'1J Ltiml1~~tl

'l-ltJ1EJ.:11'1J

7.1 ~1EJ'l1'-l\lUtJvl'-I (Inception Report) 50 - 20 1000

7.2 ~1EJ'l1\JilUU~\Jmrn (Interim Report) 100 - 20 2000

7.3 ~1EJ·:rnJouu~vi~1EJ ouu~1.:i (Draft Final Report)

- mvm:1.1 (~1EJ'l1\JilUUL~l.l) 200 - 20 4000

·································· ............................... ................................ ....................................... - ~1EJ'l-1"11EJ'l1\J ('i'1EJ~1\JilUUL~l.l) 40 x 5 x

7.4 'i'1EJ~1tJouu~vi~1EJ ouu~l.l\J~ru (Final Report)

- il1Yi'i'1l.J (UYl~'i'tl~u~m~ ~1EJ~1\JQU1.JL~l.J LL'1~;~) . ~ 500 - 100 50000

.. ........................... ..... ............................... ································ ....................................... - 'i'1EJ'!-1\l1EJ~1\J ('i'1EJ'11'-lilUUL~l.J LL'1~;~) 50 x 5 x

:rn1~J~~1b:rnmY xxx

rl11'l'f~1EJm~ (Direct Cost)

8. rl11'l'f~1f.l~'U'l 'i1f'l1~tlVIU1f.I (U1'V1) \i1'U1'U \i1'U1'U't!V1 'n'-l (U1'V1) Vl'-l1f.ILV!til • • VIU'J f.1~1'U Ltln£'l1'i~tl

VIU1f.1~1'U

8.1 r11~Vl~·mimnrn1..i1tJ'i~rue! LL'U'UtJ'i:::Lij'LJ Internal 10 x 200 x O d I.., U I

- * '11'U1'1.J'!JV1Ltin~1'i'll'l.Jtif!n'U'll'LJ1Vlmm.1wllti~ . ~

Integrity & Transparency Assessment LL'1::: External LL~'1:::Vl\l-W'11'1.J

Integrity & Transparency Assessment

8.2 r111'U~1muV1Lvi~V1 L~'U r11ci1mtin-~1'i r111'~VltitJmru i'1i 'i1'-loLJtl 1 - 8.1 = xxx xxx fafJ'1::: 5 'llti..i..iutJ'i:::mru-U'ti 1 - 8.1 .. '.DlJElJl~~JEl~lJ ~ xxx

I t II I 1::n:J fl1_j!::J1 fJVll~ xxx .. '. ~ · .:

l'.Ul~~JJl=::ti1W'V1~£l'U . xxx ..

. Fii 131~1 ~H~~fi ~~vr]J] fJ~ J:Y .. . .• . 32,258.29

d fl'U'VI @

d ·1m - '1n~ ,

Vit.hV\11'Uil1fl~~ (Integrity and Transparency Assessment: ITA)

't.h~'11u.:iuth~~nru cw .fl. lfilct'bo (ITA md:bo)

ViU1V\11'U _________ _______________________________________________________________________ __ ____ ________ _

t'l1bb VIU\l : __ -------- ----- -------- --- --- ---------- -----. -. --. --- . ------ --- ----------- --- . ------ ---- --- --- . ------ ----- ---- --------- ------ --- -- ---- -- ------------ -

i!1'\l flVl ----- ----- -- -- ---. -. --- --- --- ------. ---- ---- --- ------------- ------- ---- ------------- ------ ------- -- ----- ---- ---- --- --------- -- -------- --~eiciviti1cM1'U ('11V1fo'1'l 1 \J1'l'}ru~)

"

LlJBTI 'V11Pl'Y'l'Vl (btid'1TUn\l1'U)

LlJBTI 'Vl)Pll'll-1ijei~ei

E - Mail

ID Line

Face book

t'l1bb V1ti\l : ________ __ __ _____________________________ ___ ____ ____ ________ ____ ______ ______ _____________ _________________ __ _________________________ ___ _ . __________ _

i!1'\lnV1 -- -------- ----------- ----------- ------- ------- ------- ---------------- -- · ------ --- ------ --- --------------- ------------ ---------- --- --- ---

~eiciV1ti1 CJnu ('11V1fo'1'l 1 U1'l'}ru~) "

LlJBTI 'Vl)Pll'll-1 (b ueii'11un\l1'U)

LlJBTI 'Vl1Pll'll-1ijei~ei

E - Mail

ID Line

Face book

(9) . eru1~'11'U\l1'U IT A '1JB\lVIU1CJ\l1'U :V~vl1V!-U1~L iJ'U'VIU1 CJU1~'11'U\l1'U)~'Vfl1\l'VIU1CJ\l1'U " ~fo n1)U)~ LlJ'U tllJ~U~ n'l'}11 'U n1 )U)~ LlJ'ULL~ ~'1111:voff m.m LL~~VIU1 CJ\l1'U~fo~V1'11BlJ

'IJ

m1LJ1~LlJ'U

l!:J. '1'loffm.meru1~'11'U\l1'U ITA G'i1V1~U'Vlii1 V\l 1'U~ '11un\l TU ti .ti. 'YJ . L'Vi1'1t.1 'IJ 'IJ

eJ1'U-dB\l'Vl1\l 1 'Vl1'111 ol!:J -ctl!:Jc::;-ci'.~l!:Jct LL~~ E - Mail : ita _ [email protected]

.rrn.11 'Ui''U~ rno B'U11flll l!:Jctct~ ('1BtJmm1CJ~~L~CJV1L~BL~ll~ ol!:J-ctl!:J~-ci'.c::;oo \Jle:i l!:Jci'.o®-ci'.)

Lb 'U'U fl'rn n 'a1 Cl ~u ~~'U'U ~f11'a1,1,~ ~~~a 1'U 1v1a 1'U b~ Cl nuinh Cl -!l1'U ~1V! ~'U f11 cr1.nu6!J'u ~~ \11 f) ~b 'U'U~1<j1\)fl11~ A~ b iim.Jna'n.J 1v1~ 1'U b~ Cl.fl 1m.Ju f) 'U 'U 'U 'U

(External Integrity and Transparency Assessment: EIT) th~'11l1.:irn.Jcr~~-nru Vt.fl. klct'b.o (IT A !§:lct'bo)

V1'i..l1e.i..:i1'U ........................................................ ....................................... .

(i). -l!:J. -bTl. -er. -cf. -b . -~--c;:;, -~--

<ilO.

V11J1mVI~,.:_ (i). L tltJoU'ill.J'1~-ruu~f11'iLL'1~~n~1u 1vi'~1tJL~ tJtlUVIU1 tM1\J 1 \JU.:JUU'i~l.Jl ru Yi. Pl. lDctbo \) \) \)

l!:i. ~1\JltJ/'1V1~1\J'U'il.:JoU'ill.J'11 \JLL~'1 ~tJ'i~LilYl'U'il.:J f11'ilJ~1tJ 1~~1\J L~tJtlUVIU1tJ.:J1\J ~ fo'11.:i~1'i1'1oU'ill.Jff'1 ~ L tJu~n1VltJV1 LL'1~LL~.:J1-JV1iJ1v.:i1u~ -rum 'itJW Ll1tJYl'i1U \J \I \I \I

Yl1.:J E - Mail

bTl . ~.:JoU'ill.J'1'iltJzj'il~-ruu~f11'iLL'1~~n~1u1v1~1tJL~tJtlUVIU1tJ.:J1\J 1-X~fo'11.:i~1'i1'1oUtll.J'1Yl1.:J E - Mail illtJL\Jl\J~ \DC:: f1.'W. lDctbo \I \I \J \J v

(VIU1tJ.:J1tJ~fogjvi'!l'ilUf11'iU'i~Ln\J'1~LL'1.:i E - Mail 1-XYl'nU)

bb tJ'U fl1Bf111~zjm~1'\.1qj'1~.fl'WL \J'\.1U1~-:JTU ~1'\.1~'Uf111bn'U6liB1J~ 'OJ1fl bb 'U'Ucl111'0JF1111JA ~ b i1i.i~ii~hi.i1~ri1i.Jb~Wl 1~1 \J ~ ~

(Internal Integrity and Transparency Assessment: llT) 'lh::~1tl.:iu'l11::1.11ru YI.fl. klct'b~ (ITA lact"oo)

V1ti1~.:i1i.i ............................................................................................... .

G). -h -'11. -ct. -cf. -\:l. -"11. -c:::. -r;t;,

-G)O .

V!1l1mV!~ G). v\Ju-LJ'CJlJ'1 L~1V1u1~mv L 'U'Vtl~V1\J1v~1u~iJn'1.J1\~1u L 'LJU~'l.Jtl~~inru YI. PL lDctbo LL'1~i1ti1Em1~v\'1~1'LJ'tlluti vn11 m tJ \J ;,.J I

ID. '11\J1\J/~V1'11'Ll'VCJ~cLJCJlJ~ 1 \JLL~~~ii1LL V!U~/~~nvi tr-r'l.J~1~~1~1\l-LJ'CJlJ~\l~LlJ't.Jern1V!'UV1 LL'1~ LL\l~L ~V!U1tJ~1'U~fom~tJ~~LiJ'U'Vl~1'\.J'Vl1~ E- - Mail \J \J \J \J

rn. '1~cLJtilJ'1~1tJzjm~1V1u1~mtJ1'LJVIU1tJ~1't.Jd 1~tr-r'l.J~1~~1~1\l-LJ'CJlJ'1'Vl1~ E - Mail mv1u1u~ \DC::: n.YI. \Dctbo \J \J \I

(V!U1fJ~1\J~fo~V1'!1CJ'\.Jn1~iJ~~LiJ'LJ\l~LL'1~ E - Mail 1~'Vl~1'1.J)

I:.

mo i'i.l'l . l!J<~ctci "v1tl1v·rn.JY1r'l.m1'ltl'l~Li)'IJ~lilri.:i-V'til.J1"1'l1EJ~ti "

~tl'l~'11'\J.:i1'\J ITA 'llti.:i"v1tl1v.:i1'\J h1'"v1tl1v.:i1'\J " .Ju - tJ -Yl'l'\.Jt.J\il'lltl'\.Jnl'l 'l~Ll.J'\JY11'1 E - Mail

(11UW.J711~futJrwifvunrn.1J::Li111v::LL~.J E - Mail

1innuJ

Q'l(i) l.J .l'l . l!ictl:lo ~r'l.J'~li.:iri1'l1'1-V'til.lmL~.:i'11'U1'U/~1i1ri1'1J'!Jti.:i-V'til.Jl"1 " " "

d " " ..J 1 d ""' -'l1EJ'lltlL'11"v1'\J1Y1111EJ 'U LLl"l~'l1EJ'lltlt.J'l'\.J'\.J'lf11'l/ "

~ilri1'U 1vi'ri1m~v ri1"v1rrn11Ln'l.J-V'm.J1"1'11n " " LL'l.J'Uri1'l1'1 Internal LLl"l~ External 1i1'"v1tl1v.:i1'1J

IT A '!lv'l"v1tJ1EJ.:i1'\J I dcv al Q U' I I.I d

WU1EJ.:11'\JV1'l'\.J nl'l uW Ll.J'\J'11i1'1.:i'!Jtil.Jl"l'l1tl'lltl "

L~l"v1i11vlmt11 'IJ"v1tJ1tl'l1'\J vliJ'11'1J1'\J/~lilri1'U 1 'IJLLvll"1~~1LL "1tJ'l/~.:i tl\il \illl.J.yj~fo~1.:iri1'l1'1oVtll.J'1

" " ri1"1'U\il 1 i1~fo~1.:iri1'l1'1oVtil.J'1Y11'1 E - Mail

(mhV.J711~fufJwlfvUmJt.l;::Li1Uv::LL~.J E - Mail

1innuJ

0 .Ju tJ Qi U' I s.f d "v1'U1 t.1'11'\JYl'l'\.J nl'l 'l~ Ll.J'\J'1\il'1.:i'!J tll.J'1 'l1 tl'lltl

" ~fo'l.J~ f11'lLL'1~~iJri 1'1J Lvl ri1'1JL~EJ n'\.J"v1tJ1 t.1.:il'IJ " " vlil'11'1J1'\J/~l'lri1'1J1 'IJ LLvl '1~U'l~ LJlYl'!JtJ.:i rmilri1'1J 1vi'

ri1\JL~t1n'\.J"v1tJ1t1.:i1'\J ml.JvlcW'U~1.:iri111'1-V't1l.l'1 " "

ri1"v1'\J\il 1 -X~r'\.J~1.:iri1'l1'1-V'til.J'1Y11.:i E - Mail " "

(11UW.J711~rufJPJ'ffEJUn7Jt.11::Li1Uv::U~.J E - Moil

linnuJ

oVvl.J'1~U'l~'11'1J.:i1'U ITA '!lt1~"v1tl1v.:i1'1J ;.:i'1~ " " • ., .J !"1 ' 'll ' Y11"v1'U1Y1Lu'\J"v1'\J1EJ 'l~'11'1J.:i1'\J'l~"v111.:i

I ..,J ..... • I - u .J. Id "v1'\J1EJ.:i1'\JYl'lUn1'l u'l~Ll.J'\J n'\.JYl u'ln1=t1

1 'Wrn'lU'l~ Ui'IJLL'1~ri1'l1'1oV tll.J'1 LL'1~'.1tJ1EJ.:i1'\J " .Ju - .I - .I " Yl'l'\.Jt.J\il'lltl'\.Jnl'l uWUJ'\J u'l~ntJU\il1EJ

);;;:- ~ti - '1~'1 ~1LL"v1tJ.:i ~.:in\il > vlt1ti"v1tl1v.:i1'U <ri1..,r'l.Jri.:i 1 'll'l1=truv)

" > L'l.Jtiflmf'i'"r'lvl (LUt1{ri1iTn.:i1'1J) LL'1~ L '1.Jvfl Yl'lf'i'.,..,Yiiltinv

);;;:- E - Mail

);;;:- ID Line

> Facebook

mm10Pin uT 11'1PJ" uuwv1J.Jl~~L 1u l 'lfi

'htlm711 t.J. ti. 'if. https:l/www.nacc.ga. th

"11.Yv IT A

-V'vl.lm ~i..,iJ1vlmv 1 'IJ'!lt1.:i"v1tl1v.:i1'U " .J.1-~- 1:;'1 .I

Ylu!]Ulil.:il'U '\J u<IUu'l~l.Jlru YU'!. l!Jctbo

LL'1~ilm~nT~vi'1.:i1'1J 1lii1tiEJffJ1 (i) ti tl'l~nti'l.Jvi'1v ~ d 0 ' .., ..... r 'llti - '1~'1 mLL"v1'\J<I '1.:in\il

> vltiti <ri1"v1rm1.:i 1 tl'l1=truu) " > L 'l.Jtifl mf'i'"r'lv1 (L 'l.Jti{ri1irn.:i1'1J)/

L 'l.Jtifl mf'i'"r'lv'iiltinti/L 'l.Jtifl Yl'lPl"r'lvlU1'\J

);;;:- E - Mail

ff7JJ7 JCJPJ rnJ[ '11'1PJLL uuYlvfal~iL 1ul'lfi

ff7Un.J711 t.1. t.1. 'ff. https://www.nacc.go.th

J.11.Yv !TA

oV tll.J'1~-r'\.J'\.J~ nl'l LL'1~ ~iJri1'1J 1.vi' ri1'1JL~tl " " "

n'l.JY1ii1t1.:i1\J 1 'Wu.:i'U'll'l~l.J1ru "r'l .!'I. l!:>ctbo

'll'l~m1uvi'1t1 "- d 0 ,..,..,

r 'lltl - '1~'1 \illLL....,'IJ.:i '1.:in\il

> 'll'l~LJlYl'!lti.:im'lilri1'W1vi'ri1m~t1 > vlm.i <ri1w~'uri.:i1'1.!11=truu)

" > L 'l.JtiflYl'lPl"r'IYi (L uti{ri1irn.:i1'1J)/

LU ti fl Yl'lPl"r'lvliltinti/L U ti fl Yl'lPl"r'lvlU1'\J

);;;:- E - Mail

ff7JJ710Pi niJ[ m1PJLL uurlv 1J.JM~t ?ul'lfi

fl7Un.J711 t.1. t.1. 'ff. https.//VWvW.nocc.go.th

J.11vv !TA

(i) ll.fl. -~

L).J .El. l!Jctbo

- ID -

wu1tm'UYl'f'IJ fl1'l'lb~ LiJ'U~Vlci.:iLL 'U'Url 1'l1\J'lil" mi1'\J

L=8.:itl'l~~fl'l:f EBIT 'ltl'\J~ m ~1\J1'\J (i) ~VI vltl (i) ..

'\iltJ1EM1\J Yi~tll.JLL \J'\JLtl fl'11'l'\il"fl!1'U/Ltlfl'11'l

tl'i"~fltl'\Jfl1'i"Vltl'\J 1 ~~'f'IJ~1.:irl1'l1\JoLJ€ll.J'1Yl1'1

1tl'l'clru8 ,,,1v'!lv.:iY11~g'\J1 " ' .,/., :l • I iJ ,, d ' ('J111?CN711YJ1Ufl(?)'tftJUn7fo1::L Uv::Ltv.JYJ()Ef

'lftJ.JtJfu{f7.,ci7n11imm urv-dv.JYJ7.Jn71~1'Jd.Jd11'1 v v I

1innuJ ..,..,vo 1.1 oa. dv

c.J'l'\.J\11'1 '11'l1\J'lJ €ll.J'1VI 1L'\J\Jfl1'i"Lfl'\J'1Jtll.J'1\J1 fl " " " LL'\J'\Jrl1'l1\J Internal LL'1~ External

\!:)~ L).J.EJ . l!Jctbo '\iltJ1EJ\111.JYl'f'Ufl1'ltl'l~LiJtJ~Vlci'ILL'\J'\Jrl1'l1\J'\il"fl!11.J

L=8.:itl'l~~fl-J EBIT 'ltl'\J~ l!J ~1'\J1'U m 'llVI vltl '

fl1'lci'ILL '\J'\Jrl1'l1\J'\il"'f1Ji1'UL =8.:itl'l~~ n'l:f EBIT .J 11.... ... '

'ltl'\JYl (i) \!~ l.Jl.Jfl1'i"Yi\J1'lCU1'!lYlli'lCU d ~I ~ :; .J

L \Jtl'l\11 f1L u '\J fl \I fl'l'll.J/'lJ\JVl €l'\JYlfl1'l

~1L \Jum'lvY.:!LL~L~l.JvltJlJ.:iutl'l~l.J1CU ~'I~ flJ .J I ..., I ... IV .J 1\JYl"v1\J1EJ'l1\J\J VI '1'1 \J~\J'\J\J 1 fl1'UY1

tl'l~l1um11 tl'l'l:lruu 'li!1fl-Wuri1'liluV1 m'lci.:i

171.:ifl~11LL~1 \)~ hll1 fl1'l-fl\J1'lCU1LL'1~neJ11

'\iltJ1EJ'l1\J hJ1~fl~LL \J\J 1 'Uci1u-d vu I.I o V Clo. -.::i1 " d c.J'l'\J\J1'1'11'l1\J'lJ €ll.J'1\J~Yi\J1'i"CU115fl1'l\JVI Lfl'\J " " -U'vl.J'11 ~L 'lill.J1~"1l.J ti'u~nl'fru~m'ln\J'llv.:i

" I I 'f ............ U .3 LLV1'1~'\il'U1EJ'l1\J ~VIEJl.J15Vl'l'U

);;> Yl1'11 Yl'i"PlYiYl );;> Yl1.:i1t1'l'\:lruu

);;> Yl1'1 E - Mail

);;> Yl1'1LL uurl1'l1\J eJeJtJ 1m1

);;> Yl1'1fl1'l~l.Jfl1'clnJLL '\.J'\.JLc.J=8(\JWU1

~'I~ \J~~tl'IL {J'Ufl1'i"Lrl'\.JoLJ tll.J'1LVIEJ1 ~~Vltl'\.J " "

LL'1Vl'lfl11l.JAVIL ,:;'U~ 1EJ Vl'ULeJ.:i Llft~\J~vl €1'1 hJl1 fl1'l'l~'\J~1viu'llv.:i~viv'\JLL uurl1'l1-;i

' " LVI EJ~'f u ~h.:irl1'l1 '1oLJ€ll.J'1 tl1v~ VI vi€) nu

" " c4tl'l~"11'U'l1\J ITA '1Jtl'l'\iltJ1EJ\11\J L~vri1'lil\JVI " ., .J1 " v 11.J/L 1'11/'1fl1'UY1 \J fl1'lfl1'i"Lfl'\.J'lltll.J'1

" ru 'lil'U1EJ.:i1u ... I ... I -.I CV cJ ._, 1'UYl'liltJ1 EJ.:i1uvvi '1.:i \J~uuv1n1uYJtl'l~Ylu

m11tl'l'clru8 mfl-Wuri1,,,uV1m'lci.:i\71.:in~11LL'91

v~ hill m'l-flv1'lru1LL'1~nti11,,,\J1 m1u1l.J1til

tl'l~m:rum'lvim.1 1 ~~·~\.1~1.:irl1'l1\JoLJeJl.J'1Yl1'1 fl~LL 'Uu1 mhu~ hbl'fruv ,,,1v-Uv\!Yl1~g'\J1 "

' .,/., :l .I iJ "d ' {'J111?CN711YJ1Ufll'J'iftJUn7fo1::L 1.Jv::Ltv.JYW{f

'l/tJ.JtJfo{f7.Jff7r?vYlfJJ.ifl urvYiv.JYJ7.Jn71~"1ff.Jdu'I v v I

1innuJ Ql(i) Yi.fl . l!Jctbo ~'fu~1.:irl1'l1\JoLJm.JmL~'lt:J'1fl~LL \J\JLL'\J'\Jrl1'l1\J

~"f1!11.JL =8.:itl'l~~~'l:f EBIT 'ltl'\J~ l!J 1 ~LLri'liltJ1EM1\J ~'fum'ltl'l~LiJ'U ,,,\J1 EJ\11uYJ'f u m'ltl'l ~ LiJu~V1ci.:ifi 1~v.:i'll v vYltmu

' c.J'1fl~ LL \J'ULL '\J'\.Jrl1'l1\J'lil"f1!1'UL =8.:itl'l~~ n-J EBIT

.J .., ., 'ltl'\.JYl \!:) Yi'ltll.JLL 'U'\.JLtl f1'11'l'\il'1f1!1'U/Ltl f1'11'l

tl'l~fltl'\Jfl1'i"Vl tl'\.J 1 ~~fo~1.:irl1'l1\JoLJtll.J'1Yl1'1

1tl'l'clru8 ,,,1v'!lv.:iY11~gu1 "

(uiJw.,711if fofJ(i)'tfvUmrtlr::tiJ1111::u{f.,if vd

'l/fNtJfo{J7.Jff7r?vifmm urv?ifNY/7.Jn71v"'l'Jd.Jdl.J'I v v I

linnuJ ~of '\J~ 1'1rl1 'l1 \JoLJ tll.J '1 ~VI ci.:i 'l1EJ'I1\J'1'ltlc.J'1fl1 'ltl 'l ~ LiJ'U " " ' fJCU5'l'll.JLL'1~fl11l.J L tl~.:i 1'11 'Ufl1'l~1L iJ'U.:11'\J'lltl'I

'\iltJ1EJ'l1'Ufl1fl'f! tl'i"~~1~'1'\Jtl'l~l.J1CU Yi.f'I. l!Jctt>o

1 ~'\iltJ1EJ'l1'U~'fuelV1'1ltl'\.J fl1'ltl'l~ LiJ'U

'\iltJ1EJ'l11.JVlf'\.Jf11'ltl'l~LiJ1.Jv~'11l.J1'lrl ..i "1 .., .., • ..1-i v EJ\J'lYlli'l ru ~VIL QYi1~ '1Jtlfl1r\ 1l.JY1 LVI Vl tl'\.J LL '1~

ci.:i L tlfl '11 'l/'lil" fl3J1Utl 'l~ nvu fl1'i"Vl tiu L vh~u '\il1flhJllfl1'i"Vl v'\.J LL'1~ ci~L 'i1 f1'11'l/'\il" f1Ji1'U

tl'l~nvun1'lvivu 1 u-Uvfi1rnl.J1V1 v~ hill

fl1'l-flv1'lru1tiYJLi'lru1u-Uv~'U1

nT~'lh~ LiJt1~ru151·nrn'1~fl11lJ1'\.J~..:i1'11 i.lfl11vl1 L Ui.l..:Jli.l'l.leNVl'l.ht1..:i1t1.rn fl1'~ (Integrity and

Transparency Assessment: ITA) L Ui.1m1'\.J1~ L ili.!'VIU1tl..:J1i.l.fl1fl1'~~hl1~ L'U i.lfl11U1~ dJi.lfl11~\l~ vi

'l.IB..:J'VIU1 t1..:i1t11vi t1 m..:i LL~ L Ui.1 m1'\.J1~ LiJ'l.liJ~'l.I au L 'l.I (;)fll1..:i n11 LL'1 ~ L Ui.I m1'\.J1~ Lili.I 1 i.lfl ru-a n~ru~ ~ L Ui.I , ' ' ' U .c::il IV .Q. q q I Cl.I 1,1 tJ .::I Q..I 4 I.I .q

(;11 LL Yli.1Lf1 CJdf1Uflilll511lJ \! 1 tll511lJ LL'1~15))lJ1.flU1'1 Yl'Vli.11tl..:J1i.l.fl1fl1~LL'1~L\l1'WU1Yl'l.1€l..:J1~YM \! ~ (;) €1..:JlJ LL '1 ~ , ~ ~

flviiie:i'\.J!)u~ zj,.:i L lJt1~ru-a n~ru~~'1~~at11 ~ L 'i1t1-a n~ru~Y11..:iu1n'l.le:i..:iV1tl1 t1..:i1t1 1vi t1V11 nV1t11t1..:i1t1~i11~v1u fl~ LL i.li.I fl11'lh~ Lili.I I '1..:J n\l ~ '1~ ~Bi.11 ~ L 'i1i.ll1'VIU1f.M1i.!i1f11)vl1 L Ui.1..:J1 i.I ~iJ flrul51)lJ LL'1~fl11lJ1'\.J~..:i1'1

'IJ ,

LMt11nrn~a..:i~1..:i 1 L-tli.1 m11 ~ LtJvi L~tl LL'1~ L-U'1n..:i-U'e:ilJ'1'l.Je:i..:iV1tl1 t1..:i1t1 m1 L Dvi fa m'11 ~e4'i1'11t11vi''11t1 L~tl 'IJ 'IJ

L oLJ1mi1'11t1~llJ fl11lJ'W ~BlJ1'U e'.l Vl'l.1€1..:J L ~1'VIU1~ LL(;l ~'V!Ul tl..:Jli.I f11) LL'1 vi..:i L \) (;1 '11i.l..:J'1\l ~(;11i.In11U~'Vl1)..:J 1i.I , 'l.le:i..:i ~u~V111 fl11lJU'1tivi\l1n n 11Y1 \! ~ (;)'l.Jti..:i L ~1'VIU1~ LL'1 ~ e4u ~Vil 1 lJl(;lli.115113.Je:i..:irlm~~ LL'1~LUi.IU11YJ vi~1t1

'\J , '\J """

1 i.I n 1 ) '\.J !) u~ ..:i 1 i.I €l 81..:i iJ fl ru 15) ) lJ iJ n 1 ) vi 1 L ii i.I n 1 ) L ~ El i1 El ..:i n i.I ~ '1 U ) ~ 1 ti 'lJ tl Y1 u i €l i.11i.l'VIU1 ti ..:i 1 i.I

i1m1v11 L 'Llt1m1L ~e:iua..:i nuLL'1~'\.J11u'\.J11i.m11'1\l~ (;11 t1V1t11t1..:i1t1 i1mm~1i.ILL'1~flrul511lJ 1t1n11'\.J~u~..:i1t1 11lJ~..:i i1m1u~V111..:i1'1Juflfl'1 u~V111..:iu'\.J1~mru LL(;l~lJa u'Vlm t1 ..:i1t11 ~ LLn ~~u..:i A'uuru'll1e:i 81..:iL -Ut1l511lJ

, 'IJ v

vr..:i'1t1 rl1irn..:i1t1 u . u .'ll. ~..:i 1~n1V1t1vimaum1u1~LiJt1flrul511lJLL'1~m1lJ 1u~..:i1'11 t1m1v11 Lum1t1 , 'l.IB..:J'VIU1 EN1t1.n1fl1'~ e:i e:i rn Ui.I er vi''ll\1 L ~e:i 1~V1tl1t1..:i1t1~1'um1'\.J1~ LiJt1i1fl11lJ~ fl11m-U1 h LM t11nu

~ 'IJ

m1u1~ Lili.I 1 LL'1~i1m1L(;)~tllJf111lJ'W~e:ilJ 1t1vi'1t1~1..:i 1 ~LMt11-Ue:i..:i vr..:id

(CQ>) ~"ll\jf1111lJLtl1..:i1~ (Transparency Index)

L Ui.1v1''llti~t11~ LilmMmnUL~€l..:J~1..:J 'l vr..:id

~ fl11lJ'1llJ11fl 1t1m11 ~LL'1~ L Dvi Lm.1oiltilJ'1 ~i..:i 'l 'l.IB..:J'VIU1tM1i.I aci 1..:iivi L \Ji.I ti n~a..:i LL'1 ~ 'IJ 'IJ

fl1Un1'1J )llJtl..:J fl1) 1~tl1~'ll1'lli.l'Vl~B~i1ci1'1J1vi''11i.1 L~t1'11lJ11tl L ·ihn..:i-Umm~1..:i 'l 'l.I EJ..:J'VIU1tl..:J1'1J 1vi1vi t1'1~V1'Jf) 'IJ 'IJ

~ m1v11 L -Ut1m1 LMt11nu m1~vi~e:i ~vi~1..:i~\l~ ~e:i..:iv11L 'Lli.1m1 LL'1~'1..:i L'1~lJ 1 ~Lil vifl11lJ 1tl~..:i1'1 1t1Y1ni'lJ(;)tJ'lJ(;11lJ~n~V1lJ1t1n1V1'1Jvi , "

~ m1 L Dvi fa m '11 ~~i1ci1t11~'11t1L ~ m -U1mi1ci1t1~llJ1 i.1m1 v11 L 'Llt1..:i1t11 i.1ii.1 (;)tJ 'lJ ~i..:i 'l I ~I <C:\." I CLIO I Qq I q

'IJ€l..:J'Vl'lJ1tl..:J1i.I (;1..:JLL(;lfl1) LL'1Vl..:Jfl11lJflVlL Vii.I 11lJ11..:J LL~i.1 LL'1 ~\! V1Yl1LL~i.l..:J1i.I 11lJV11 L '1Ji.lf111 LL'1~111J (;lVJ(;JllJ

(;111\!'1aun11v11 L 'Llt1..:i1t1'1Jti..:iV1t11t1..:i1t1

~ f11)vl 1 L U'1Jfl1)/ft1)~Vl m1nu L~EJ..:i~e:i..:i L~tl'lJ LM tlltlU n1 )U !)u~'VIU 1~'llrN L .J1V1U1 ~ at11lJ1tl~-:i1'1V1~BY1\J~{;}IJle:iV1u1~ ,

(kl) ~"11\jfll111l'W~BlJ~'U~Vl (Accountability Index)

L Ui.lv1''llu~t11~ LiJmMmnu L~B..:J~1..:J 'l vr..:id

~ 'Wfj~fi))lJLL(;l ~Ylf"li.lfl~'lltl..:J ~U~'Vf 1) LL(;l~ L .J1V1U1~'lleN'VIU1ti..:i1 i.I~ LL'1 vi..:i n..:i n 1 )U !)u~..:i 1 i.I

m1l'VIU1~€l 81..:i L~lJ 1 \! LL'1 ~ L ~lJtl1~~Yl~.fl1'W ~ f11)U !)u~..:i1t11 i.1'1 nii.l{;ltl'lJ'l.ltl..:JL .J1V1U 1~~ij fl11lJ ~fl ~e:i..:i IJ11lJn~'VllJ1 tlLL'1~ )~ L UtJU

-Ue:iu..:i AU ~1-:J 'l tl 81..:i fl1'lJn1i.ILL'1~ Lfl~ ..:i fl1'Vl n~ 1'Vl1ty~\l~1'ue'.lvi "lltl'lJ 1mmf111tl ~~..:J1i.1'1J€J..:J(;)i.1LtJ..:J

-~-

);;:>- f111fl1 '\ll'U VJVl P!Vl 1\ILL'1~'U1t1i.J 1 ti 'lJ B\I ~ iJ ~VI 11~ "ii~~ B\I lJ L "ii\;\ :ii 1'U\l1 'Uf111i.J ~Vf 11\11 'U \)

I ~ CV ' .::lo V U Q .d ~ Q ~ V ~ ~ ICLI I CL.I cf Btl1\1'1lB'1\;ltl'1"il1\;l LL'1~'V'l1BlJ1'Uc.J VJ LlJB L f1VJl"l11lJ ~ VJ'V'l'11VJ L 'V'l B'111\I fl11lJ L 'lJBlJtl LLf1'1\I fllJ11f111'!J'U Lfl'1 B'U , '\llU1tl\11'U"il~ L U'U 1 LlB~1\lllflUJti))lJ LL'1~5)1lJ1i1i.J1'1

' (m) ~"lfiiR'J1l.ltlmJVl\11nn1'a\'l\1~~1'Uf11";iU~u~-:i1'U (Corruption - Free Index)

L u'Uvi''llil~i.J1~ Li3'ULMt11ni.J L~B-:iv11-:i 1 vr\111

> m1tJ5iJ~-:i 1'U'lJB\I L ~ 1viu1~1 'Wviil1t1\11'U~ L U'U'V'l{)&1m1lJ~ L-if 16ll1 t1 m1vi "ii ~\;lvlBV1u1~ L 'li'U fll) L ~ti n~'UL~'U ~\l'!JB\I VI~ B c.J'1tJ )~ 1t1'lJU1VJ I "ill n ~3J'11'U 1~ ~1'UL~ ti L ~BLL'1nrli.Jfl11LlDD~\l1'U 'lJB\I ~'U LB\! Vl~B m1i.J!)iJ~/'1~ L l'Ufl11i.J!)iJ~viu1~/m11-tl\Ji1 LL viil-:iviu1~ 'lJB\I IJl'UL B\I B ci1-:i hJ L U'U511lJ

L~BL~BtJ1~ 1t1'lJULLtl~'ULB\I 'V'l1f1~B\l'lJB\llJl'U '\ll~B~~'UmVJ \) \)

> n 11i.J !)iJ~'\11u1~ 'lJ B\I ~ iJ ~'\111 )~ L iJ 'U 'V'l {) ~ n) )lJ ~ L-if 1-ll1EJn11V) "ii~~ 1'UL:U\l'U1CJi.J 1 EJ

zj\liJ~ n't}ru~ L iJ'U m1vi"il~ (Jl~ Lii VJ'OJ1nm1lJ~lJ~'U5L~ B'\ll'U'U n'U1~vi11-:i ~u ~vi11 'lJB-:ivii.11 CJ\11'U ni.J ~n~1'U 1~ , , \.I \J

~1'U L~ CJ~ L U'UVIU1CJ u1n -o;i LB n'lJ'U L ~BL ~mrni.J 1~1EJ'lltl1 'U~ ru ru11fl1-:im1'\11~ B~lJtJVJ 1'U'lJB\IV1u1EJ\l1'U , u u

LL'1 rn Ll~ EJ'Wnum 1n1V1'UVJ'U 1EJu1 CJVl~B m1m~~1VJ 1 'lJB\I ~u~vi11'!JB-:ivii.l1CJ'l 1'1.J

(Ci.') ~"lfii1't9ll'Uli";i";ilJ~ruli";i";ilJb'UB\lf'lm (Integrity Culture Index)

L tl'U vi''ll\l~tJ1~ Li3'1.J LM t11nu L ~B\I 1'11-:i 1 vi'-:itl

);;:>- 'V'l q~ f111lJLL'1 ~VJ Pl'Ufl~1'Uf111Ll !)iJ~\l 1'U~ll fl11U'J n ~\I ~\1'1B'U Vl~B ri1 tlYltlVJ LLrl n'U

'lJB\I L ~1'\llU1~1 'UVIU1tl\l1'U 'OJ'U f1'11 ti L U'U LL 'U1V11\ltJ!)iJ~i.J1~-;J1vi~Bll'll 'U5))lJ'lJB\l'\llU1 ti \11'\.J zj\111'll'l.Jli))lJ

L vi"11'1'1.JflT~'OJ~L U'Uf111tJ!)tm\;l'\.J'\ll~BVJPl'Ufl~~~ L U'Uf1Trn"1t:ilJ Lf1'11Y11\l~\lfllJ (Socialization) 1 m:llt1 mJ fo 'V'l{)~f111lJf11'~V)'OJ~IJlvl1\l I 1 'UVIU1tl\11'\.J 'OJ'Uf11~~\l 1:livi'U~Bfl11V)'111Jl LL'1~ n B 1 ~LflVJ f111'1\l 1 Vl't}V11\l~\lfllJ (Social Sanction) '1'1~ffv'h1iXL~1viu1m'Uviti1t1\11mnVJfl11lJmt1vi~e:im1lJn~1~-o;i~n1~v\'1m1wil~1J11~ ,

> f11~ U1'Uf111'lJB\l'\llU1 tl\11'\.J~"il~ ~B\IU'1 ne:J-:i LL'1~'1~1-:i1 ~ Ln VJ1t9ll'l.J5))lJV11 \lfl11lJA VJ \)

LLtlf1 LLCJ~ ~mi.J1~ 1t1'llU'11'1.JIJl'Un'Uc.J'1Ll1~ 1t1'llU'11'1.J11lJ 1 m~ zj\lnti L U'Uf111UB\I tl'\.Jf11)Vl'OJ ~~~\I LL~)1f1~1'\.J'lJ B\I , ... 'V'lq~m1lJf111V)'111Jl

);;:>- f11~U1'Uf111'lJ B\IVIU 1tl\l 1'\.J~ll n 11n1'\ll'U VJ LL~ 'Un 11U B\I tl'ULL'1~ti11ui.J 11lJ n11Vl"il 1 \;\ ,

);;:>- f11 'ill f11~U1'\.Jf1111Jl11"il'1Bi.J n1\IVJ'1flltl1 'U~ L-iflJ LL ~\I LL'1~lltl 1~ ~V15fl1'V'l zj\l"il~vl11 ~ , L~1viu1m 'Uvii.l1t1-:i1'1.JL i1'1.Jm1lJ'11fi'ruLL'1~ LnVJm1:wm~viirnn-:ic.J'1'lJB\lm1vi-o;i~\;l 'OJ'UnB 1 ~L nVJ L u'U1~'Uu11lJ

u , .

1'Wf111~1lJvlB~1'1.Jf111Yl'OJ~(;)1~ ,

(er) ~"l.lii~ruli";i':ilJf11':ivl1\11'\.Jb'UVIU'JtJ\11'U (Work Integrity Index)

L iJ'Uvi''llil~t11~Li1'1.JLMmnu L~B-:iv11\l 1 vr-:itl'

> m~'U1'\.Jf11)'lJtl\l'\llU1tl\l 1'\.J~ LL'1VJ\ln\lf11) 1 ~m1:w'11fi'tiJ nu f111tl!)tm\11'U 1VJCJf111rl1'\ll'UVJ

1 ~ilrjli B'\ll~Bm \;)) j11'1.J m1tl!)tm\l 1'U~6if vi L 'OJ'U

> 'V'lq ~ n 11ll'llti\I L ~ 1viu 1~1 'U vii.11EJ\11'1.J~iJn11i.J !)iJ~\11'U \;) 1lJ ti ii e:ivi~ B:W 1(;) 1ji1'\.J

m1Ll!)tm-:i1'1.JB ci1-:i Lfl~\I fl~VJe:i ~ L'1lJB LL'1~'1~ ~e:i-:i L tJum1tJ!)tm-:i1'1.J B ci1-:i L U'U511lJ LL'1~ L vi1 L Yi CJ:W n'W

> m~i.J1un11'll v'lviil1CJ-:i1'1.J~ LL'1VJ-:in-:i ni1ilfl ruu11lJ 1'Wn11u1vi11-:i1'1.Juflfl'1n1 t11 'U , , '\llU1tl\11'U ~-:ilu~1'\.Jf111U~'\1111Vl~'V'ltl1f))Uflfl'1 L'li'U fl11'U1";i'OJ LL~\l~\l 1t1mJ1EJ ~'OJ1)UJ1fl11lJ~fl11lJ'lJBU , , L U'U~'U m~U1'Uf111'1~1\ILL 1\1'1\I h LL'1~m1lJn11viu11 'U'11CJ\11'U LL'1~ 1 'W~1'Uf111~~'U1'1lJ11fl'U~L~1viu1~

\)

> m~u1um1'llv\IV1u1t1-:i1'U~ LL'1VJ-:it'i-:im1iifl ruu11lJ 1 'Llm1u~vi11-:iut11~mru m11 i~1t1 , L~'U\lui.J1~mru-o;i~ ~m L tl'U 1 tlvci1'11 tl~-:i1'1 LL'1~"il~~v\1~'111ru11-tl~1CJ 1 'W~-:i~:ii1 L U'Uvivm1~1L U'U\11'Um:w

-m-

~ Yl(j~ff'.i1lJ'llfJ\l~1VIU1\l1'U~LL'11'Nn\l m1i1~ruli111J 1 'LI011~\l\l1'UVl~fJlJfJUVllJ1CJ\l1'U1 ~ LLrl

0~u.:i Flu'Li '1J'll1 ~'1~ ~fJ\lrl1U\ln\l'llfJUL 'lJ ~tJ1'U1'1VIU1~ ~11J nuv1m CJ'llfJ\l ~-rulJBUVllJ1 CJ\l1'U iJ fn11JL U'U5111J

LLri r:r-rulJ fJUVllJ 1 CJ\l1'Ui'l nfl'UfJ tl1\l L vi1 L Vi CJlJ i1n11~ fJ'111 LL'1~ L v11 '11 ~ ~ l'1Vl11J1'LIn111J BU VllJ 1tl\l 1'U v ,

vhl'i'lJvUVllJ1tl hJ ~'1Bl'l'1'U-rue'.11'1'1lfJU 1'Ue.J'1'1JfJ\l\l1'U~11'i'lJBUVllJ1tl1 tl~1tl ~ ff'.i~U1'U011'llfJ\lVIU1tl\l1'U~ LL'11'1\ln\l n 111 ~fn1lJ'1°1rlfY tlU'1 fl1'W LLJr;ilK fJlJ~ L ~fJ eJ 1'U1CJ

LL'1~ '1-:i L'1~1J m1tl D~\l 1'U'llfJ\l L ~1VIU 1m 'UVltb tl\l 1'U.

kl. n'HJUnTatl-a::dhJ"'I m1tl1~LiJ'Uriru511lJLL'1~m1lJ 1tl~.:i1'11 'Un111'11L U'U\l1t1'llB'lV1ti1t1.:i1t1mri-r~~.:i L U'U m1tl1~ LiJ'U , ...

w.ht1\l1'U[)1fl-r~vtl1\lfl1fJU fl'11Ji'l niJ~ ~\l LLvln11U~Vl11\l1'U'llfJ\l ~U~Vl11 011tln'Li~'l1'U'llfJ\l L~ 1VIU 1~ .a , , \J dJ

1 t1wu1t1.:i1'U ~t1\PIB1.JLL'1 ~n1~u1'U011v\'1 L iit1.:i1'U'llv.:iV1ti1t1.:i1'U l\;i.J'Uli111J'llti.:iv.:if1n1 111J 1 tlfi.:ie.i '1'1YI~ 'lJB\lVIU1tl\l1'UvlfJ~lJ~1'U 11'i'~1'UL~tl vl\l~'U ~.:ii1m1tl1~LlJ'U~\l'11 n m~U1'Ll\l1'U'llfJ\lVIU1tl\l1'Uzj\l'1 ::~ '111ru1

v

'11 nVI '1 n ~1'U vi1.:i 1 LL'1~'11nn11-ru i 'll B\l ~iJ ~1'U 1al~1 'UL~ tizj .:i~ '111 ru1 '11 n e.J'1'llB\l011tl 1 ~ Lii t1'11n

LL UU'1fJUfl1lJ zj\l LnUoUBlJ'1~\l'11n ~lJ~1'U 1Jl~1'UL~CJ[)1tl 1 'LIVIU1tl\l1'U 11'1 LLri L~1VIU1~'1JfJ\lVIU1tl\l1'U LL'1~ v v

'11n~iJ~1'U 1a!'11'UL~ tim tl'UvnVlti1t1\l1'U 11'i'LLri ~-ruu~n11Vl~B ml'i'-rrnrn'11nn11 vl1 L U'U\l1'U'llfJ\l VIU1tl\l1'U v v v

'11i!n.:i1'U tl .tl.'ll. ~.:i 11'ln1V1'U1'1Lfl~fJ\l:Liv 1 'Um1tl1~LlJ'UfJfJnL U'U m Lfl~v'l:Liv 11'i'LLri

(<0>) bb'UtJGl111\lVl"n~1'Ub:U.:itl1::~n,; (Evidence - Based Integrity and Transparency

Assessment: EBIT)

15nTah::d'.i'U VIU1CJ\l 1'U~-rum1tl1~ Lii'U~ 1'1vi1 LL uu'1111'1V1~ n ~1'U L 'U.:itl 1~~ n,; vd'vv wuu ... rno'111V1"mnu/rnm1111h::miunT'iYJt1tJ Ll'1CJ~l'lvi1LLuu'1111'1 '11'U1'U (9) '111'1 ~ti (9) VIU1CJ\l1'U zj\l'1~LL'l.J.:i

M '

011~1'1LntJv'fJOLU'U lD 1BU vl\l~ . 1°""d GJd

1t!Ubb10 Cn.:i111t1 'Y1'Yi'l kl~ Q11fl1'W'Y5 ki<t'bo)

iJmvum1tl1~ Lii'ULMmnuL~v.:ivi1.:i 1 vi'.:i~ ~ 011 LL'11'1 \l "L '1 ~'11'U\l'1'1 ~ ~" 'lJ fJ\l ~u ~VI 11VI~ fJ r!tl 1m .. hCJ \l1'U vim~ 1VIU 1~.fl 1tl 1 'LI , v v

V1ti1CJ\l1'U LL"~ '11511ru'/l'U.fl1CJ'UfJnViti1CJ\l1'U zj \l L tl1 CJtJ L'1:LIfJ'U011 LL '11'1\l fl111J ~ .:i 1'1VI~fJFi1 ~ti~ '1~ i.11

V1ti1t1.:i 1'U1'11CJ ri11lJzjB'1\Pl8 '1 '1 ~\Pl iJ riru5111J m 11J 1tl~.:i1'1 tl 111"1'11n011i'l'1 ~ ~ LL'1 ~'W-r BlJ~ '1~1v1-ru , , , 011 ~1'1 \Pl11J \Pl11'1'1Bu m 1tl!J~.:i1'U \Pl11J L '1\Pl"ii1'U.:i~11'1 LL'11'1\l Hv tJ1.:i'1~.:i 1 '1

~ n11~ r:J U~V111Vl~fJ ~tl 1Vlti1CJ\l1'U 1 ~ fn11J'11rl ill tlU 011tJ-rutJ 1\l~ \;i.J'Ul Vlti1tl\l 1'U 1 ~iJ 'U '\J .., ,

flruli11mL'1::m1lJ 1tl~.:i1'1 ~.:i Lb~m1n1V1'U1'1VJl"li'l1.:i LL'1~'U 1t1u1CJ'llv.:iV1ti1CJ.:i1'U '1t1fi.:io11n1V1'Ul'1mm011 , Vl~B 1m .:in 11 mmLe.i'Uu!)'Li~11'/l011 ~'1~-tl1CJ'1.:i L'1~1J 1 ~V1ti1t1.:i1'UiJ011v11 L iit1.:i1'UvtJ1.:iiJ flU.lli11lJLL'1~ fl11lJLtl~.:i1'1mn~t11'LI cf 1'11'U 1vi'LLri ((9)) 1'i'1'Ufl11lJLtl~.:i1'1(ID)1'11t1ri11lJ'W~ern-ruC'.ll'1 (m) vl1'UFn11Jtl'1Bl'1

'11no11vi'1~Vl1'U011tl!J'Li~.:i1'U (Ci'.) v11t1l\;i.J'Uli11lJ!1ru511lJ 1 mJ.:if1m LL'1~ (cf) vl1'LlflUJLi11lJ m1vi1.:i1t1

1 'LIV1ti1m1t1 u'1~111Jfi.:i0111~ri111J'11Fi'C1Jnu011~B'111LMmnum1'1.:i L'1~1J 1'LILL~'1~1'11t1.LJ'1.:i~'U1 ~L ~1VIU i~ .fl1ti1'UV1ti1CJ\l1'U11'1-rui'l11U L ~B 1~L~1VIU1~'1JfJ\lVIU1tl\l1'U 1a! Lill'1fl11lJVl1~VIUn LL'1~ 1 ~fl111J'11AC1Jn'l m1tl!Ju~.:i1'UvtJ1.:iiJ~ru511lJLL'1~m1lJ 1tl~.:i1'1mn~'U

1BtJ~'1v\l (~'l.01tJLUJ'Y~ k.IW: b1l't!1tl'Y bct'bo) ' ' .,

iJmvum1u1:: LiJ'ULnCJ1nuL~v.:ivi1.:i 1 vi'.:i-U

~ m~U1'Uf1111'Uf111vl1LU'U\l1'ULMmnU011~1'1~fJ~l'1~1\l

- Ci'.-

> m::'U1'Um 1'1~1-:i m1:r'U~rLJv:W'1 ~1\l C) LL'1:: rii'v:w'1 m1 ~1 L 'Ll'U'l1'U'IJti\l'VlU1 cM1'U 1111 n-:i " " I "

f\111 ~LL'1::L\JVJ Le.J tJrLJtl:W'1'1Jv\l'VlU1tJ\l1'ULLn~iJri1'U 1v1'11'UL~ tJ 1vi':ruv111'\Jtl ~ 1\ltl flt1lv-:i fl 1'U tl1'U (;)) -:i 1tl\;11\l111 \J \J \J

LL'1:: hJiJrn1DVJ L Uv'U.LJ'ti:w'1 \J

> m::'U1'Ufl11LDVJ 1e:im'11~~iJrii'U1vi'ri1'UL~m .LJ'1miJri1'U~1:w 1 'Ufl11 ~1LU'U\l1'U1 'Uoff 'U\;lv'U \J

\;]1-:i 1 'llti-:iV1i.11tJ-:i 1'U

> m::'U1'Ufl11LDVJ 1e:immL'1:: 1~f111:w~1A'run'Um11~~iJri1'U1v1'11m~tJ L .LJ'1miJri1'U~1:w v \J

1 'Ufl11\Jl11~'1tl'U LL'1:: LL '1-:i L~v\l~v\l L~ l'.J'ULM tJ1 tl'Ufl11tll)lli1V1iJ'1~'1Jtl\l L '11V1iJ'1~ > m::'U1'U m1'1-:i L'1~:w 1 ~L '11'VliJ' 1~1'UVIU1tJ\l1'UlJf111lJ L .LJ'11 ~ LMcnn'U m1 m::vi1~L ll'U

e.J'1tl1:: ltJ'UuYl'Uiti'U'Vl ~e:imm 1 mm fl LLl'.l ::e.J '1tl1:: LtJ'llU~1'U\Jl'U LL'1:: e.J'1tl 1:: LtJ'lltlri1'U11lJ 1v1 zj-:iGe:i L ll'U11 fl~1'U .... .q 0 ..., Q

'Yl'11 flill'IJtJ\l fl11Yl~1\;I v ,

> m::'U1'Ufl111"Um1ue:i-:in'Ufl11Vl~~vi 1 'LIVIU1tJ\l1'U LVJtJ m1~VJvi1 LLe.J'Utll)'U~fl11uv-:in'U

LL'1::U11'U'th11lfl11Wil~\;l'IJtJ\l'VlU1tJ\l1'U 111ln\lfl11lLfl)1::"1 LLe.J'U i 1'UtJ~e.J°1'UlJ 1 Lrn::u:r'UU1\l/~ \;ll'U 1 LLe.J 'U i , , 1~'1vVJf1'1ti-:inrn.1'Y15Pl1'11'1{'1J1~--J1vi'1tJfl11Uv\ltl'ULL'1::tl11'Utl11:wm1'Yl~~\;I 1::1'.J::~ m (Ytf'l . ~ctbo - l9crbei'.) , ,

> m::'U1'Ufl11\;111~'1ti'Uri1-:i VJ'1fl1tJ 1 'ULM mn'Um1~ 1L U'U\l1'U~iJfl11m~EN'Vl~viJ1e:im'1 , ~~:: LnVJrn1'Yl~~\Jl 1VJtJm1~VJ~\lfl~:w'IJe:i-:i L~1V1iJ1m 'UV1u1tJ-:i1'UL ~e:i m1'U~V111-:i1'U~1tl~-:i1'1 , ,

>- m::'U1'Ufl11n1n'U~ LLmM mn'Um1tll)lli1-:i 1'U 'IJti\l L '11V1iJ' 1~1 'UV1i.11 tJ\l1'U v11tJ fl 11~VJ Vi1

~iJe:iV1~e:i:w11'11~1'Ufl11tll)lli1-:i1'U

>- fl 1:: 'U1'U fl11m1n1 n'U~ LL" LM l'.J 1n'U fl 11tl l)iJ~-:i 1'U'IJe:i-:i L '11V1iJ'1~1'UV1i.11tJ-:i1'U 1 ~iJ fl 1 1 tl Dir~ \l 1 'U v ~ 1 \l L lJ 'U 51 1 lJ L Yi 1 L Vi EJ lJ hh ~ v fl tl B ir~ \Pi v 1fl1 fl 'U 1 VJ fl 'U VI~ \l 1 VJ EJ fl 11 LL '1 VJ -:i off 'U VI v 'U

fl11tlD~\l1'ULL'1::1:: l'.J:: L 1mm m 'Ufl11~1L U'Ufl111 ~ m-if'U~ fl11'Vl~v 1~~iJri1'U1v1~1'U L~ tJ'Y111'Utl ~1\loif VJ L ~'U ;..J \J \J

11110-:iiJ 1::'U'U fl11Uv\l tl'U fl11'1:: L l'Ufl11tlBlli1V1iJ'1~

(im) bb 'U'U6i1-a1~ri1111~vib~'U~ihi·m 1~cl·;mL~tJJl1tJ 1 'LI Onterna l lntegrity and \J

Transparency Assessment: llT)

15nTai.h::biJ'U ~ :r'U ~ 1\l ~ 111 ~.LJ' till '1 i L n 'U .LJ'e:i 11'1~1flL~1 V1iJ'1~ Jl1E.11 'U 'llv\l VIU 1 EJ\l1 'U \J \J \J

'Yl1\l L 'Y11Pl'WVi 'Yl1\l 1 tl1\'Jru8 Yl1\l 1 tl1\'Jru8a L~ fl'Yl 1tJUfl'1 'Yl1\l LL'U'U~111~tltl'U 1'1tl fl11r.r:wm\'JuJLL'U'U Lt:.!'8t1JV1iJ'1

V1~e:im1~111~'Yl1-:i5'U C) ~iJm1m V1111::'1:w 1vitJ~::t1\e:i-:i L ll'Ufl11Ln'UoiJmm1vi EJ 1 ~~ l'l ti'U LL'1 vi-:i fl11:WAVJ L ,;1'Uvi'1EJ I " "

\;l'ULtl\l LL'1::~:: ~e:i-:i 1lliJm11::'U ~11'l'U'lltl\l ervie:i'U LL 'U'U'1111~ zj\l~::~1L U'Ufl111 m~e:i'UiJ'U1fllJ - L:W\'!1 l'.J'U , \J

n-ae:iurn-ai.h::biJ'U tl1:: Li1mM EJ1n'U m1:w'W~v:w:ru ~VJ 1'Um·nJl)iJ~-:i1'U fl11lJ'W~v:w :r'U~vi 1'Ufl11U~'Vl11\l1'U L~l'l~1'U\l'1~~1'11 'Wfl11'U~'Vl11\l1'U m-a:r'U~'U'U'U fl1) 1-l11'11Lb 'VlU\l'V!iJ'1~1 'Un1) Ltm_h:: 11'.J'Utl , fl11:1.Jtl '1vVl~1flfl11Yl~~ \JI L '8-:i'U LtJ'U1 EJ fl1 )~'l.JYl v VJ1\;ll 'U51 )lJ'1 ~~\;I fl1) 1l.J'Yl'U ~B fl1 )'Yl ~ ~ l'l fl11B 1 tJLL'1:: , , , Lfl)\lfl'11~~::i1~~\Jl fl1)~1L 'Ll'Ufl1) L ~tJUv\ltl'Ui:.J'1U):: LEJ'lJUYl'Uiv'W 1 'WVIU1EN1'U LLmJtll)'U~fl 1)U tl\l n 'ULL(I::

'tJ)1'l.Jtl)1:1.Jfl1)'Yl~~\Jl fl1)1'111~'1ti'Uri1-:iVJ'1fl1E.J1'UVIU1tJ\l1'U fl1)'l.J~'Vl1)\l'l.JU1~:1.J1ru flruo)):i.J , , , 1 'U fl1):i.Jv'U'VllJ1 l'.l\l1'U LL'1:: m-a'U~'Vl1)'1 mmnvi" v:i.J 1 "W fl1)vi1-:i1'U

(m) bb uu6i1-a1~fl'J111~Vlb~'U~i'.icl·m1~cl1'Ub~tJJl1tJ'Uflfl (External Integrity and \J

Transparency Assessment: EIT)

15m-ai.h::bi1'Y ~:r'U~ 1-:i~111~.LJ'v:w"., Ln'U.LJ'm.rn ~ 1fler:r'U'U~ fl1)'Vl~v~iJ~1'U1v1~1'UL~ E.J '\I 'U " \J 'U

m l'.l'U v n'llti-:iV1i.11 t1-:i1'U 'Yl 1-:i 1 'Yl)Pl'WVi 'Yl1-:i 1tl-a\'Jru8 'Yl 1-:i1 U)"1ru8a L~ fl 'Yl 1vu fl'1 'Yl 1 -:i LL u u'1111~ e:ie:i 'LI 1m1

fl11r.rlJf11\'JuJLL 'U'U Le.J=8qJV1iJ'1 'Vl~tlfl1)~111~'Yl1\l~'U 'l ~lJfl11lJL 'VllJ1~'1lJ LVJtJ~~~tl\lL ll'Ufl1)Ln'U.LJ'v~'11vi l'.J 1 ~

- er-

1m~BL.JlJ'U1flll - Lll~1tl'U l!Jct'0o

O'H:l\J011'lh::bih.J u 1~dJ'ULMti1nu0111 ~ L lJ vH ~w LL"~ L -rr 10\1 <if €1 ll'a 'lltl 'l"vnh ti \11 'U "

011lJ'11'LI~1ll l 'U011vl1L frtN1'U 011~1'1fl11L~tl'l~tl'I L~tl'U fn1ll~~tlll-r\J~l'11 'Ufl11Ul)U~'l1'U fl11ll~~tlll -ru~ 1'1 L 'U fl11'lJ ~Vl11'I1'U L '1\Jl'1'1'U'l'"1'1~\Jl1 'Lifl11'lJ ~Vl11'I1'U n 11-r'lJ~'U'lJ'U m 11-ff ti11 LL V1U'IV1u1ffi 'LI 011 L ie:i , U1~ Ltl'lltJ fl11lJU'atll'1'11 fl011Vl'1~\JlL ~'l'U Ltl\J1tl lJ1\Jl1~1'Ufl11Ul)tM'11'U LL'a~fl11'lJ~V111'11'U~flfl'a

" 'li'l.lJ=il~lila-n.:imh:::arnu tfl'l'I n1'l'1.h:::ti31u'!Wii'l'l:1JLLil:::fl11:1J ttli,;i 1a11m1'llii1Lil'IN1ut1MMfln'ltln fl'lrHa1u"tl'a.:i~u (IT A)

tl'l~1u,;iutl'l :::mw vut. 2560

~1U1U ~1U1U

(LLoH'I) ( LLoH.:1) ( LLoH'I) (u-H.:i) ( u-H.:i) ( LLoH'I) ( LLoH'I) ( 'IJl'tl)

1 0 1 12 48 0 62 1,984,000

1 0 2 47 72 0 122 3,904,000

1 0 2 77 71 0 151 4,832,000

4 OlLLVNLW'll'i 1 0 3 22 64 0 90 2,880,000

5 'IJfflJLLOtJ 1 1 6 77 140 0 225 7,200,000

1 0 5 42 34 0 82 2,624,000

7 \l:::L:a'IL'l'l'il 1 0 1 33 74 0 109 3,488,000

1 2 10 35 50 1 99 3, 168,000

9 ~fJtJl'l'l 1 0 1 38 20 0 60 1,920,000

1 0 1 35 106 0 143 4,576,000

11 'llJJW'i . 1 0 2 25 51 0 79 2,528,000

12 L:iffJ'l'ilfJ 1 1 0 72 70 0 144 4,608,000

1 4 116 89 0 211 6,752,000

1 1 1 20 77 0 100 3,200,000

15 ~'il61 1 0 1 13 29 0 44 1,408,000

16 ~10 1 1 1 17 49 0 69 2,208,000

17 ummfln 1 0 1 5 39 0 46 1,472,000

1 1 4 18 93 0 117 3,744,000

1 0 1 21 81 0 104 3,328,000

1 1 4 85 243 0 334 10,688,000

1 1 3 50 130 0 185 5,920,000

1 1 2 18 121 0 143 4,576,000

1 2 4 11 28 0 46 1,472,000

24 u11ii11a 1 0 3 13 72 0 89 2,848,000

25 ii1u 1 0 1 18 80 0 100 3,200,000

1 0 3 59 146 0 209 6,688,000

1 0 0 18 41 0 60 1,920,000

28 lllJJ.Jiilil 1 1 9 17 37 0 65 2,080,000

1 0 2 14 44 0 61 1,952,000

1 0 1 12 56 0 70 2,240,000

1 0 2 15 96 0 114 3,648,000

1 1 4 31 121 0 158 5,056,000

33 ~'I'll 1 0 2 13 36 0 52 1,664,000

1 0 1 47 25 0 74 2,368,000

uty=ili11Hf'i"i./JtJ'l.h::mWLFl'i./Jtn"ith:ailu~Wli'iWUn::fl113JLu·fo1a1un1'itii1LUU./J1U'7.lrl./Jrl./JAfl'iUflfl'irl./Ja1unri-1,1~u (ITA)

U'i:!~1U./J\JU"j:!3J1W 'W.A. 2560

~1U1U ~1U1U ~1U1U ~1U1U

(UH./J) (\J1l1)

1 0 3 25 73 0 102 3,264,000

1 1 1 24 76 0 103 3,296,000

37 LW'll'i\J~ 1 . 0 2 13 69 0 85 2,720,000

' 38 lVi'll'i\j'itlJ 1 0 3 22 102 0 128 4,096,000

39 LLWi 1 0 1 25 57 0 84 2,688,000

40 w::Lm 1 0 2 33 36 0 72 2,304,000

" 41 .IJlfl\;l 1 1 2 9 6 0 19 608,000

1 0 1 18 123 0 143 4,576,000

1 0 1 6 42 0 50 1,600,000

44 J.jfl(;ll'lfl'i 1 0 1 24 29 0 55 1, 760,000

1 1 2 13 47 0 64 2,048,000

1 0 1 23 63 0 88 2,816,000

~ " 47 'jfltJLf)(;l 1 0 1 72 129 0 203 6,496,000

1 0 2 10 18 0 31 992,000

1 1 2 27 37 0 68 2,176,000

50 'i1'11'4~ 1 0 4 30 77 0 112 3,584,000

1 0 3 20 102 0 126 4,032,000

52 ~1th" 1 1 3 38 61 0 104 3,328,000

1 0 1 39 17 0 58 1,856,000

54 ma 1 0 2 27 71 0 101 3,232,000

1 0 2 35 179 0 217 6,944,000

56 ammm 1 1 0 65 74 0 141 4,512,000

1 2 11 35 92 0 141 4,512,000

1 0 1 6 34 0 42 1,344,000

1 1 4 13 30 0 49 1,568,000

1 0 1 8 26 0 36 1,152,000

1 2 1 9 25 0 38 1,216,000

1 0 4 34 70 0 109 3,488,000

1 0 3 13 49 0 66 2,112,000

1 0 2 43 81 0 127 4,064,000

1 0 2 6 33 0 42 1,344,000

1 0 3 18 69 0 91 2,912,000

1 2 3 35 97 0 138 4,416,000

1 0 1 27 144 0 173 5,536,000

Utytii6la"i'H1.J'lh:::in ru tl'l"i.:J t11"i1.h:::LilUf>lWli"i"imLi.'1:::1'111:ll t ui.:i 1a1u111"ifiil LUU.:J1U'llrNiNflt1"iUt11'1"itl.:Ja1unt1.:i~u (IT A)

U"i:::~1U.:JUU"i::::ll1W 'W.A. 2560

~1U1U ~1U1U ~1U1U

( u-H.:i) ( LL-H.:J) ( LL-H.:J) (LL-H.:i) ( u-H.:i) (U1l1)

69 lllltl~YllEJ 1 0 2 17 48 0 68 2, 176,000

1 0 1 23 43 0 68 2,176,000

1 0 1 20 43 0 65 2,080,000

1 1 3 67 109 0 181 5, 792,000

1 0 1 25 53 0 80 2,560,000

74 ~nvli1u 1 0 1 13 49 0 64 2,048,000

7 5 ~Ui.'l'll'l1lilU 1 1 4 54 179 0 239 7,648,000

7 6 clllll<JL<J~qj 1 0 1 23 39 0 64 2,048,000

76 30 178 2,233 5,334 1 7,852 251,264,000

mnEJ Llllij 1 '11a1irn ·mHi~Ltf~).Jfll'ltlflY1"HNna~au~~lllY1"1:1Jl'Hl~l L UlJ fll"i hinuii tYJEJ"i::tj 1 llu"i:::fll~~Yl~fl

~Y1~1~i1 " fll"i~Yl~a~Y1~1~Y1r~~ ~::ii fll"ii.'1~u1" 1 ullir~aaa(JJ(\Jlll~a?iaYJ ni.'l~Lllullir~aa 1~ Lrla 1~fofll"i

~Yltl'l"i~Utl"i::>.nru<J·1nn"imt~Ltf~).Jfl1'ltlflYl 'l v~na~i\u a1l!~Ufl'lW~hil~fofll'l~Yltl"i"i~Uth::).JlCU'llfltl~1ll

al1B~<J::L~nn11~Y1~v~Y1~1~ ·

Education

แนวทางการประเมินคุณธรรมและความโปร่งใสในการดำเนินงานของหน่วยงานภาครัฐ