8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

1/22

^W_WZ`WVT

STWWZ SbSV

WSV S

STSSZ[[^

TS^

SSZWT S]T[[

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

2/22

Z`^[VaU`[Z[X

Z`^[VaU`[Z[XWS_`SZ

^WZVSZS__[X

ZSZUSU[\S^_[Z[Xc`WS_`SZ

X[^`W\W^[V%

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

3/22

WS_`SZ_S^W`ZY_WU`[^SZ

U[Z__`_[X`^WWU[\SZW_ZSWS_`SZ`S`WWS_`SZSZVS`WS_`SZ

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

4/22

UU[^VZY`[`W_`S`_`U__`WWSVZY

[U[\SZZS_`SZ

SZVcW^WW^YWVZ`[cUcS_^WZSWV`[[ZWU`

Zc``WZWc[Y[[X`WZWc

b_[Z\^[Y^ScS_SaZUWV

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

5/22

T[a`%[X`[`SXa^ZSUW[S^W`_U[Z`^[WVT

[XS_`SZ_VW_WXaWS^W`_ZXaWZUWVT

U[Z`^[_S[_`[X`W`[`SXZ_WVXaW\^[VaU`_S^W`[XS_`SZ

W^W`S_SW_S^W`WTYYW_`^WbWZaW

YWZW^S`[^X[^cU`[\\WVT[ZZ`[SWS_`SZ_S^YW_`U[\SZ

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

6/22

W^WcWS^WU[\S^ZY`W^S`[[Xc`W

`[XZV[a``W_aUUW__^S`W[XZU[\S^_[Z

c`[`W^[U[\SZW_[XS_`SZ

WS_`SZ`W_WU[ZVTYYW_`[S^W`ZY

U[\SZZ`WU[aZ`^

WS_`SZ__S^YW_`U[\W``[^SbZYS

S^W`ZY_S^W[X[^W`SZ

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

7/22

W[\SZS_\[_`WV_%%[ZSX`W^`S

\^[X`X[^`WWS^S_U[\S^WV`[_[Z

X[^`W\^Wb[a_WS^

W[\SZS_[SZZ[aZUWV_%ZUS_

VbVWZVXZS\W^_S^W

`SV\^Wb[a_\SVZ`W^VbVWZV[X_

\W^_S^W

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

8/22

W`[`SVbVWZV\SV`[_S^W[VW^_Va^ZY`W

WS^U[W_`[_\W^_S^W\W^UWZ`

8,08

7488 !7419

507,93!7419

014709,57419

1907%,!7419

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

9/22

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

10/22

%

a^^WZ`S`[

aUS`[

WT`S`[ %

^[__^[X`S^YZ % %

W`^[X`S^YZ %

S^ZZY_W^S^W % a\WW\W^_S^W ^a\WW\W^_S^W

W`a^Z[Z]a`

% [^ZYS\`S [Z^a\WW [Z^a\WW

WUWbSTWa^Z[bW^S`W `W_ %`W_

ZbWZ`[^a^Z[bW^S`W `W_ `W_

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

11/22

!$

$

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

12/22

!$

$

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

13/22

^[__^[X`

[`SWbWZaW_

,0

,0

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

14/22

W`ZU[W

[_`[X[[V_[V

,0

,0

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

15/22

\WZ_W_

WUWbSTW_

,0

,0

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

16/22

__W`_

ST`W_

,0

,0

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

17/22

[`SWbWZaW_

,0

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

18/22

W`SW_

[_`[XY[[V__[V %%%

^[__^[X` %

\WZ_W_ %W`ZU[W %%

[_`[XY[[V__[VS_SSYW[XW`SW_\WZ_W_S_SSYW[XW`SW_ %

W`ZU[WS_SSYW[XW`SW_

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

19/22

W`SW_ %

[_`[XY[[V__[V

^[__^[X`

\WZ_W_ W`ZU[W %

[_`[XY[[V__[VS_SSYW[XW`SW_ \WZ_W_S_SSYW[XW`SW_

W`ZU[WS_SSYW[XW`SW_ %

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

20/22

[`S__W`_

[`SST`W_ %

[`S]a`S\`S

[`SST`W_S_SSYW[X`[`SS__W`_%

[`SS\`SS_SSYW[X`[`SS__W`_%

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

21/22

[`S__W`_

[`SST`W_

[`S]a`US\`S

[`SST`W_S_SSYW[X[`S__W`_

S\`SS_SSYW[X[`S__W`_

8/8/2019 PSO & SHELL Comparison

22/22