77
1 B GIÁO D C VÀ ÀO T O I H C À N NG D NG V N LÝ L A CH N C U TRÚC H P LÝ H TH NG CUNG C P I N KHU Ô TH M I I N NAM - I N NG C ( QU NG NAM) LU N V N TH C S K THU T à N ng- N m 2004

Lua Chon Cau Truc Hop Ly Luoi PP

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

luan van cao hoc

Citation preview

  • 1 B GIO DC V O TOI HC NNG

    DNG VN L

    LA CHN CU TRC HP LH THNG CUNG CP IN KHU TH MIIN NAM - IN NGC ( QUNG NAM)

    LUN VN THC S K THUT

    Nng- Nm 2004

  • 2B GIO DC V O TOI HC NNG

    DNG VN L

    LA CHN CU TRC HP LH THNG CUNG CP IN KHU TH MIIN NAM - IN NGC ( QUNG NAM)

    Chuyn ngnh : Mng v H thng in M s : 60.52.50

    LUN VN THC S K THUT

    Ngi hng dn khoa hc: TS TRN VINH TNH

    Nng- Nm 2004

  • 3 LI CAM OAN

    Ti xin cam oan y l cng trnh nghin cu ca ring ti, trn c s

    vn dng l thuyt Mt s vn v qui hoch, thit k, vn hnh cc h

    thng cung cp in th ca Tin s ng Quc Thng v s gip

    trong qu trnh thc hin ca Tin s Trn Vinh Tnh

    Cc s liu, kt qu nu trong lun vn l trung thc v cha tng c

    cng b trong bt k cng trnh no khc .

    Qua y, ti xin chn thnh cm n Tin s Trn Vinh Tnh c nhiu

    ch dn qu bu, gip ti hon thnh lun vn ny.

    Tc gi:

    DNG VN L

  • 4MC LC

    TRANG

    Trang ph ba Li cam oan 1Mc lc 2Danh mc cc k hiu, ch vit tt 4Danh mc cc bng 4Danh mc cc hnh v, th 4

    Chng M u 6 1- L do chn ti 6 2- Mc ch nghin cu ca ti 8 3- i tng v phm vi nghin cu 8 4- ngha khoa hc v ngha thc tin ca ti 8

    Chng 1- Tng quan 10 1.1 Tng quan li phn phi 10 1.2 Cng tc qui hoch,thit k li phn phi 12 1.2.1 Hm chi ph tnh ton 12 1.2.2 Cc phng php tnh ton li phn phi 15

    1.2.2.1 Tnh li phn phi theo iu kin cc tiu phtn tnh ton vi thnh phn tn tht in p kinh t

    15

    1.2.2.2 Tnh li phn phi theo iu kin mt dng in kinh t

    19

    1.2.2.3 Tnh li phn phi theo iu kin ti u bn knh cung cp in

    19

    1.2.2.4 Tnh li phn phi theo iu kin khong chia ph ti kinh t

    26

    1.2.2.5 L do chn phng php khong chia ph tikinh t

    27

    Chng 2- Trnh t cc bc thit k theo phng php khongchia kinh t

    29

    2.1 S khi bi ton theo phng php khong chia ph ti kinh t

    30

    2.2 Cc gi nh 31 2.3 Cc bi ton nh 31

  • 5 2.3.1 Bi ton chn tit din cp 33 2.3.2 Bi ton chn chiu di cp 36 2.3.3 Bi ton chn cng sut MBA 39 2.4 Ni dung chi tit cc bc tnh ton 41

    Chng 3- Xc nh cu trc hp l cho h thng cung cp inKhu th mi in Nam - in Ngc

    45

    3.1 Gii thiu s lc Khu th mi in Nam - in Ngc 45 3.2 Mt s gi thit trc khi tnh ton 47 3.3 Xc nh cc s liu ph ti 51 3.4 Trnh t cc bc khi tin hnh la chn cu trc hp l cho

    HTCCT53

    3.5 Chng trnh tnh ton vit trn ngn ng PASCAL 54 3.6 Kt qu bi ton 54 3.7 Hiu chnh theo nhng iu kin ring 54 3.8 Kt lun 55

    Chng 4- Kt lun v hng nghin cu tip theo 57 4.1 Kt lun 57 4.2 Hng nghin cu tip theo 58

    TI LIU THAM KHO 60PH LC 1: Chng trnh vit trn Pascal PH LC 2: Kt qu bi tonPH LC 3: Chi ph tnh ton li h p Khu th mi in Nam-

    in Ngc

  • 6DANH MC CC K HIU, CC CH VIT TT

    STT NI DUNG,TN VIT TT1 Chiu di hp l cp trc Lop2 H thng cung cp in HTCC3 H thng cung cp in th HTCCT4 H s ph tn vn hnh vhD5 H s tiu chun thu hi vn u t tcD6 Hm chi ph tnh ton Z7 My bin p MBA8 Mt ph ti V9 Ph tn do tn tht in nng hng nm ca

    phng n th i Yi'A

    10 Tit din cp F11 Tn tht in p U'12 Tn tht ngn mch MBA nP'13 Tn tht khng ti MBA 0P'14 Vn u t ca phng n th i Ki

    DANH MC CC BIU BNG

    STT TN BNG K HIU1 Sut ph ti Bng 1.1 2 Sut u t TBAPP Bng 3.1 3 Sut u t ng cp h th Bng 3.2 4 Mt s tiu ch Khu th mi in Nam-

    in NgcBng 3.3

    5 So snh kt qu Bng 4.1

    DANH MC CC HNH V, TH

    STT TN HNH V, TH K HIU1 Mt cu trc li phn phi c bn 1.12 S thut ton phng php khong chia ph ti

    kinh t2.1

    3 th khong chia kinh t ng cp 2.2

  • 74 M t mt xut tuyn cp trc xc nh tit din 2.35 M t mt xut tuyn cp trc xc nh chiu di 2.46 S chi tit cc bc tnh ton 2.57 Cu trc c bn mt TBAPP v li 0,4KV 3.18 Cu trc c bn mt TBAPP v li 0,4KV 3.29 Cu trc c bn mt TBAPP v li 0,4KV 3.3

    10 S ph thuc cng sut MBA c chn theo mt ph ti

    4.1

    11 Minh ha s ph thuc cng sut MBA c chntheo mt ph ti

    4.2

  • 8CHNG M U1 L DO CHN TI :

    Yu cu c bn ca h thng in l phi lun lun m bo cung cp

    in lin tc v m bo cht lng in nng trong phm vi cho php cho

    cc h tiu th v tho mn tnh kinh t. Nhim v i hi cn b lm

    cng tc thit k phi gii quyt nhng bi ton v kinh t - k thut la

    chn phng n ti u nhm t mc tiu ra

    Trong khuynh hng chung, vic la chn cu trc v cc thng s

    ca HTCCT thng cn c vo nhu cu s dng in nng, ch lm

    vic ca cc ph ti in... a ra cc phng n cung cp in, la chn

    cc s cp in, trn c s phn tch cc ch tiu kinh t-k thut, la

    chn phng n thit k hp l. Tuy nhin, phng php ny cng bc l

    mt s nhc im [12]: Ch yu da vo kinh nghim chuyn gia, khi

    lng tnh ton ln, c th t ti u cc b trong hin ti nhng c th tr

    nn t hiu qu trong tng lai, nh s chng loi thit b, vt t trong ton

    h thng c th rt ln, gy kh khn cho cng tc lp t, sa cha, vn

    hnh sau ny

    Vic la chn cc thng s cu trc ca HTCCT i hi phi

    tun theo mt ch tiu thng nht vi tnh ti u tng th. Do vy cn c qui

    hoch tng th trc khi c thit k c th v mi thit k c th phi tun

    theo qui hoch tng th. Cng v vy, vic la chn thng s cu trc hp l

    cho HTCCT l mt bi ton hp nht gia thit k v qui hoch, rt

    phc tp vi nhiu tham s lin quan, bin thin lin tc nh in p, dng

    in... v bin thin gin on nh chiu di, tit din ng dy, s lng

    v cng sut cc trm bin p, gi in,... Qu trnh qui hoch tng th s

    bt u t s phn tch nhng tnh cht c trng ca cu trc mt ph

    ti, thit k la chn thng s cu trc hp l ca trm bin p phn phi v

  • 9li h p, sao cho HTCCT tho mn nhu cu in nng trong mt thi

    k tng i di vi s tng trng lin tc ca nhu cu ph ti. Hm mc

    tiu cn t c l tng vn u t v chi ph vn hnh cc tiu ( xt trong

    c chu k tnh ton ) Vic gii bi ton nh th s gp rt nhiu kh khn

    [10], cc l do ch yu l :

    + a hnh t nhin khng phi bao gi cng cho php hnh thnh li

    tng ng vi s nh trc ( theo li gii ti u )

    + Nhiu thng s cn la chn ch c th trong phm vi hoc nhng tr

    s bt buc (tit din dy dn, thang cng sut MBA. . .)

    + Gi bn in, vn u t trang thit b, chi ph vn hnh . . . lun

    bin ng

    + Tc tng trng ph ti kh xc nh,v tr phn b ph ti khng

    ng u, phi qui lut. . .

    Vi tnh cht phc tp v a ch tiu nh trn, vic gii bi ton la

    chn mt cu trc ti u li phn phi trong trng hp tng qut, ni

    chung l khng th gii c. Tuy nhin, c th c mt cu trc hp l,

    chng ta c th tm cch ti u ho theo mt s tiu chun nh:

    - Tiu chun gii hn la chn tit din ng cp trc

    - Tiu chun gii hn la chn khong cch ng cp trc ( gii

    hn cung cp in )

    - Tiu chun gii hn la chn tit din ng cp nhnh

    - Tiu chun gii hn khong cch ng cp nhnh

    - Tiu chun v gam MBAPP

    S dng cc gi thit theo tnh cht c trng ca i tng nghin

    cu, cc gi thit kh thc ca cc tham s tham gia tnh ton nhm lm n

    gin ho bi ton, p dng phng php khong chia kinh t s cho php

  • 10

    gim nh ng k khi lng tnh ton m vn cho kt qu c ngha thc

    t cao

    2 MC CH NGHIN CU CA TI : ti khng hy vng a ra mt cu trc chun ca HTCCT ni

    chung, m ch nh s h tr ca my tnh v mt s phn mm ph bin

    hin nay, ng dng phng php khong chia kinh t trong thit k

    HTCCT nhm xc nh mt s thng s hp l ca HTCC Khu th

    mi in Nam- in Ngc, c th xc nh :

    + S xut tuyn hp l ca TBAPP

    + Gam cng sut hp l ca MBA

    + S lng MBA hp l cho ton Khu th mi in Nam-in

    Ngc

    + Tit din v chiu di hp l ca cp trc, cp nhnh

    3 I TNG V PHM VI NGHIN CU : i tng nghin cu ca ti l li phn phi th, gm li h

    p v h thng cc TBAPP.

    Phm vi nghin cu ca ti gii hn trong HTCCT khu th

    mi pha bc in Nam - in Ngc (Tnh Qung Nam)

    4 NGHA KHOA HC V NGHA THC TIN

    CA TI 4.1 ngha khoa hc:

    1. ng dng c mt thut ton ti u ( phng php khong

    chia kinh t ph ti ) vo trong thc t

  • 11

    2. Rt ngn thi gian tnh ton v nng cao chnh xc ca

    cc php tnh trong cng tc qui hoch, thit k nhm xc nh cu trc hp

    l cho HTCCT

    4.2 ngha thc tin :

    1. a ra mt m hnh cu trc hp l cho HTCCT Khu

    th mi in Nam - in Ngc, lm c s cho vic tnh ton thit k sau

    ny

    2. Trn c s Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc, phng

    php Khong chia kinh t c th c m rng p dng cho cc Khu th

    mi Qung Nam

  • 12

    CHNG 1 : TNG QUAN

    1.1 TNG QUAN V LI PHN PHITrong h thng in, mng in c th c phn loi nh sau:

    - Mng in cung cp : Mng in c nhim v truyn ti in nng,

    khng trc tip tham gia phn phi in nng. Cp in p tng ng

    110KV.

    t

    - Mng in phn phi: Mng in c nhim v trc tip cp in cho

    cc ph ti. Cp in p U < 110KV (thng U d 35KV, bao gm li

    trung p, TBA phn phi v li h p)

    Do c im lch s li, li trung p hin ang tn ti nhiu cp

    in p ( 35, 22, 15, 10, 6KV )

    Hin nay trong qui hoch di hn, li trung p ca nc ta ang dn

    xc lp cp in p 22KV. Ty theo tnh cht ca cc ph ti ngi ta chia

    mng phn phi lm 3 loi :

    a. Mng thnh ph: Mt ph ti (V ) tp trung cao v tng

    i ng u, cng sut ca ph ti ln. Thi gian s dng cng sut cc

    i ln, thng Tmax t 6000 y 7000h .

    Bng 1.1 Sut ph ti cho mt h gia nh:

    Mc sng ca khu dn c Sut ph ti tnh cho 1 h ( kW)

    Thp 1- 1,5

    Trung bnh 2-2,5

    Kh 3-4

    c bit t 5

  • 13

    b. Mng a phng (mng nng thn): Mt ph ti nh,

    cung cp in cho nng nghip l ch yu, c Tmax nh, thng Tmaxkhong 500 y 3000h. Li phn phi khu vc nng nghip c c im

    ng dy ko di, phn tn, cng sut truyn ti nh, ph ti lm vic c

    tnh thi v, ph ti phn b trn din tch rng, h s thi gian s dng

    thp, thi gian non ti ko di. Kt qu l gi thnh ca mng in nng

    nghip tnh theo cng sut truyn ti kh cao

    c. Mng x nghip cng nghip: Thuc phm vi x nghip,

    phn b trn din tch hp, phn phi mt lng in nng ln ( chim 70%

    in nng c sn xut ra) mt ph ti cao, Tmax ln, thng Tmax6.000 7.000h, thi gian lm vic nhiu, t c tnh cht thi v

    t

    y

    y, trong phm vi lun vn ch cp n mng thnh ph ( H

    thng cung cp in th HTCCT ), v gii hn cu trc cc TBAPP

    v h thng li 0,4KV

    Theo , mt cu trc hp l ca HTCCT bao gm :

    + S lng xut tuyn hp l ca cc TBAPP ( Cu trc TBAPP)

    + Dung lng, s lng, v tr hp l cc TBAPP

    + Bn knh cung cp in hp l ca cc TBAPP

    + Tit din hp l ca cp trc

    + Chiu di hp l v tit din hp l ca cp nhnh

    xc nh s lng, dung lng ti u ca cc trm bin p chng ta

    xut pht t bn knh cung cp in ti u ca cc TBAPP ( Lop ) T xc

    nh c dung lng, s lng trm bin p cn thit phi b tr trn a

    bn cp in

  • 14

    1.2 CNG TC QUI HOCH, THIT K LI

    PHN PHI1.2.1 HM CHI PH TNH TON

    Vic tnh ton kinh t li in l cng vic rt quan trng trong qui

    hoch, thit k li in. Ch trn c s tnh ton kinh t ng mi c th

    la chn c phng n pht trin li in mt cch ti u. Ph ti in

    pht trin khng ngng theo thi gian v trong khng gian, cn cc thit b

    in, li in c tui th kh di, cho nn khi la chn mt phn t no

    ca li in phi xt hot ng ca n trong thi gian di v trong s hot

    ng tng h vi cc phn t khc trong li in

    Nh vy mi phn t ca li in phi c la chn s b trong qui

    hoch di hn (20-30 nm), c khng nh trong qui hoch trung hn (10-

    20 nm) v c nh r thi im thc hin trong qui hoch ngn hn (3-

    10 nm) [1]

    c th lm tt cng tc qui hoch pht trin li in th ngoi vic

    thu thp s liu v tnh hnh v hin trng ca li in, v d bo pht trin

    (pht trin ph ti, pht trin ca tin b KHKT, bin ng ca gi c...) cn

    c vic so snh cc phng n pht trin li in v mt kinh t-k thut

    la chn ra phng n pht trin ti u li in

    so snh kinh t cc phng n pht trin li in, ta phi tnh hiu

    qu kinh t ca tng phng n ri so snh vi nhau. C ngha l chng ta

    phi tm cch cc tiu hm chi ph tnh ton (hm mc tiu)

    tin hnh la chn phng n, ngi ta a ra nhiu phng

    php ton hc, t n gin n phc tp, t nhng bi ton phi chp nhn

    nhiu gi thit n cc bi ton c xt ti nhiu yu t gn st vi thc t

    Tuy nhin cn ch rng khi tin hnh tnh ton so snh kinh t k

    thut ca cc phng n, ta ch c th cp ti mt s yu t c bn m

  • 15

    thi, ch khng th xt ton b cc yu t nh hng ti vic chn phng

    n

    Gi tng vn u t l K v chi ph vn hnh hng nm l Y l hai s

    liu c bn tin hnh so snh cc phng n. Trong giai on chn

    phng n, chng ta khng th tnh tng K v chi ph vn hnh hng nm Y

    mt cch chi tit c. Trong giai on ny ch cn tnh n nhng thnh

    phn ch yu m thi. trnh vic tnh K v Y qu phc tp, ngi ta ch

    tnh ton cho nhng thnh phn khc nhau gia cc phng n v cho php

    b qua nhng thnh phn ging nhau gia chng.

    Tng vn u t K c tnh theo biu thc sau:

    K = Ktb + KxdTrong Ktb : Vn u t v thit b, k c u t lp rp chng

    Kxd : Vn u t v cc cng trnh xy dng : xy dng

    TBA, xy dng ng dy

    Chi ph vn hnh hng nm Y c tnh nh sau:

    Y = Ykh + Ybq + YA + Ym + YcnTrong : Ykh : Chi ph v khu hao

    Ykh = Kkh .D khD : H s khu hao

    Ybq : Chi ph v tu sa, bo qun

    Ybq = Kbq .D .bqD : H s bo qun

    YA : Chi ph v tn tht in nng

    YA= cA.' A' : Tn tht in nng hng nm

    c: Gi tin in [/KWh]

    Ym : Tn tht kinh t do vic mt in gy ra. Nu trong

    hm mc tiu khng tnh n yu t tin cy cung cp in th thnh phn

    ny c th b qua

  • 16

    Ycn : Chi ph v lng ca cn b v cng nhn vn hnh

    h thng cung cp in. Thng thnh phn ny khng khc nhau nhiu

    gia cc phng n nn c th b qua

    Thng thng gia vn u t K v chi ph vn hnh hng nm Y l

    hai thnh phn i lp nhau. Mun gim tn tht in nng, gim tn tht

    kinh t do ngng cung cp in, chng ta phi tng tit din dy dn, thm

    s ng dy v s MBA d phng... kt qu l tng vn u t K. V vy

    cn phi xy dng ch tiu phn nh c hai mt i lp ni trn nh gi

    tnh kinh t ca phng n cp in, ch tiu thng gi l chi ph tnh

    ton Z

    Z = YKhq .D [ /nm]

    hqD : H s hiu qu, ni ln mc s dng hiu qu vn u t

    Nh vy Z chnh l tng chi ph v vn u t v vn hnh c tnh

    phn b cho 1 nm

    Do ch tiu ti u ca phng n cung cp in l:

    Z = YKhq .D = min

    Trong mt s ti liu khc, Z cn c gi l gi tr hin ti ca chi

    ph PVC (Present Value of Cost ). Phng n c PVC min l phng n ti

    u

    So snh kinh t k thut c tin hnh theo cc bc sau:

    + Phn tch v loi cc phng n khng tho mn cc yu cu k

    thut t ra. La chn cc phng n t yu cu k thut ngang nhau

    em ra so snh

    + Tnh chi ph tnh ton Z cho tng phng n. Ch rng gim

    nh khi lng tnh ton, cho php ch tnh ton nhng phn khc nhau gia

    cc phng n

  • 17

    + Chn phng n c Z min. l phng n ti u v mt kinh t-

    k thut

    Trong thc t, bi ton la chn cu trc hp l cho HTCCT l mt

    bi ton phc tp. Trong kh khn ch yu l nhiu yu t kh th hin,

    nh lng di dng gii tch. Khng nhng th, chng cn mang tnh

    ngu nhin, hoc mt s trng hp, chng ta ch ghi chp c mt s

    th hin m khng bit c lut phn phi xc sut ca chng

    gii quyt bi ton ny, trong thc t hin nay thng da vo kinh

    nghim cng tc v kin chuyn gia, phc tho ra mt s (n) phng n

    cu trc, c xem l kh thi, trn c s s tnh ton, chn ra mt cu

    trc cc tiu c hm chi ph tnh ton hng nm ( hm mc tiu):

    Zi = (D vh + D tc ).Ki + Yi'A (i =1,2,...n)

    R rng phng n cu trc vi Z min s ch l phng n tt nht

    trong s n phng n a ra v hon ton ph th ch quan ca cn b

    lm cng tc thit k, qui hoch v theo , tnh chnh xc, khoa hc ca kt

    qu s khng cao

    o

    1.2.2 CC PHNG PHP TNH TON LI PHN

    PHI

    Trong thc t vn hnh, sn xut, cung ng in, tn tht in nng

    trn li < 1.000V chim t l cao nht v sau l cc MBAPP. V vy

    vn gim tn tht in nng trn cc phn t ca li ny c c bit

    quan tm ch khi qui hoch, thit k li th ni chung. tnh ton

    mng phn phi, hin nay c mt s phng php tnh ton sau y:

    1.2.2.1 .TNH TON LI PHN PHI THEO IU KIN CC

    TIU PH TN TNH TON VI THNH PHN TN THT IN P KINH

    T [11]

  • 18

    Vic xc nh tit din dy dn mng phn phi thng xut pht t

    iu kin tn tht in p cho php. Gi tr ny l lch in p t trm

    bin p n ph ti. Vic chn tit din dy dn theo iu kin mt dng

    in kinh t mng phn phi thng cho kt qu nh hn so vi kt qu

    chn theo iu kin tn tht in p cho php.

    Khi xem chi ph tnh ton l mt trong nhng tiu chun c bn tnh

    ton mng vi iu kin hn ch v tn tht in p cho php, ta thnh lp

    phng trnh ph tn tnh ton ph thuc vo tn tht in p.

    T biu thc:

    Z = (D vh + D tc ) K + c.'A (1-1).

    Nu ta xem vn u t K v tn tht in nng A l cc i lng

    ph thuc vo tit din dy dn F th ta c th vit li biu thc (1-1) nh

    sau:

    3103)( 2 cFLIbFLZ mvhtc WUDD (1-2 )

    Trong :

    - Im : Dng in cc i.

    - b : H s tnh n s thay i gi thnh ng dy ph thuc vo

    tit din (/mm2Km)

    - F : Tit din dy dn (mm2).

    - L : Chiu di ng dy (Km).

    - U : in tr sut ca vt liu dy dn.( : mm2/Km)

    - W : Thi gian tn tht cng sut cc i.

    Nu t (1-2) ta thay cc gi tr :

    UU10lPF

    scoU3PI

    2'U

    M

  • 19

    Th ph tn tnh ton s l:

    M

    UDDW

    22

    2

    cos10010iUiPii

    UUPlbZ

    cii

    iiiivhtci

    '

    ' (1-3)

    T biu thc (1-3) nu bit cc gi tr Ui ; li ; M ; Ui ; ci ; tcD ; vhD th

    ph tn tnh ton ca ng dy ch ph thuc vo tn tht in p. n

    gin ta t:

    Ai = ( D tc + D vh )bi Ui L2i Pi /10Ui2 (1-4)

    Bi = W i ci Pi /100 cos2M (1-5)

    Biu thc (1-3) ta s vit c:

    ZAU

    B Uii

    ii '

    ' (1-6)

    Ph tn tnh ton ca mt phn th i no ca mng s cc tiu nu

    tha mn iu kin :

    i2i

    i

    i

    i BUA

    UZ

    '

    'ww = 0 (1-7)

    T (1-7) chng ta c th xc nh c tn tht in p kinh t tng

    ng vi chi ph tnh ton cc tiu:

    i

    ikti B

    AU ' (1-8)

    Thay ga tr Bi v Ai vo (1-8) ta c :

    ici

    blU iivhtcikti WUDDM 10

    Ucos

    i

    ' (1-9)

    Thay gi tr 'Ukti biu thc (1-8) vo (1-6) chng ta xc nh ph tn

    tnh ton cc tiu :

    iimini BA2Z (1-10)

    Hoc khi thay Ai v Bi vo ta c:

  • 20

    3i

    imin 10cosU

    P2 icibl

    Z iivhtci

    ii WUDDM (1-11)

    Chia (1-6) vi (1-10) ta c quan h :

    ''

    ''

    kti

    i

    i

    kti

    mini

    i

    UU

    UU

    21

    ZZ (1-12)

    thy r nh hng ca tn tht in p n ph tn tnh ton ta vit

    li biu thc (1-12) dng:

    '

    ' i*

    i*i* UU

    15,0Z (1-13)

    y:

    min*

    i

    ii Z

    ZZ Ph tn tnh ton tng i.

    kti

    ii U

    UU

    ''

    ' * Tn tht in p tng i.

    T (1-13) ta thy thnh phn th nht l vn u t tnh ton tng

    i, cn thnh phn th hai l ph tn tnh ton ph thuc vo tn tht cng

    sut. T ta c th vit :

    Z*i = Z*Ki + Z* 'Ui (1-14)

    Cc gi tr Z*i ; Z*ki ; Z* iU' u ph thuc vo iU*'

    Khi < 1 ( iU *' ktii UU 't' ) : tit din dy dn cn c la chn theo

    iu kin tn tht in p 'Ui , gi tr ny khng c vt qu gi tr cho

    php.

    Khi )(1* ktiii UUU 't'!' : tit din dy dn c chn theo tn tht

    in p kinh t bi v trong trng hp ny khng c gii hn v tn tht

    in p cho php.

  • 21

    1.2.2.2 .TNH TON MNG PHN PHI THEO IU KIN MT

    DNG IN KINH T [11]

    T biu thc (1-2) ta c :

    3103)( 2 EUDD WFLIbFLZ mvhtc

    Ph tn tnh ton cc tiu mng in s xut hin khi m bo iu

    kin:

    DD ww EW

    2

    2m

    vhtc FI3bL

    FZ 310 0 (1-15)

    T (1-15) ta thy rng: Mt kinh t ca dng in tng ng vi

    chi ph tnh ton cc tiu theo iu kin:

    EUDD W3

    bFIJ vhtcmkt (1-16)

    Gi tr mt dng in kinh t tng ng vi tit din kinh t ca

    dy dn xc nh theo iu kin ca ch lm vic nh mc ca ng

    dy t biu thc :MscoJU

    SFkt

    kt ..310. 3 (1-17)

    Trong :

    -S l ph ti tnh ton ca ng dy (KVA).

    -U: in p nh mc (V).

    1.2.2.3 .TNH TON MNG PHN PHI THEO IU KIN TI

    U BN KNH CUNG CP IN [11]

    xc nh s lng, dung lng ti u ca cc trm bin p chng ta

    xut pht t bn knh cung cp in ti u ca cc cp in p Ropt.T s

    xc nh c dung lng, s lng trm bin p cn thit phi b tr trn

    a bn cp in.

  • 22

    Trong mng in tn ti hai khi nim v bn knh cung cp in,

    l bn knh cung cp in c xc nh cn c trn kh nng k thut ca

    mng in, chnh l bn knh gii hn v tn tht in p cho php R'U v

    bn knh ti u theo iu kin kinh t. Bn knh thng tng ng vi

    cc khong cch sau:

    R0,4 d 3Km ; R6 y 10 d 12Km ; R35 d 20 y 35Km ; R110 d 50Km.

    xc nh bn knh ti u (v tr trm bin p) ta thnh lp quan h

    gia hm chi ph tnh ton Z vi bn knh phc v (R) ca trm bin p.

    Z = f ( R ) o min.

    Ly o hm 0 ww

    RZ , t ta xc nh c Ropt

    Vic xc nh min cung cp in ca cc trm bin p da trn bn

    knh phc v ca trm. n gin ngi ta c th phn min cung cp

    in thnh tng vng theo hnh vung, hnh lc lng, hnh trn....Mi trm

    bin p ph ti s cung cp in cho cho mt hnh nh vy. cung cp

    in cho mt vng no chng ta cn phi xy dng mng cung cp, trm

    bin p, mng phn phi chnh v cc nhnh r nh hnh 1-1.

    Chi ph tnh ton Z ca ton b

    mng in c vit nh sau:

    Z = Z1 + Z2 + Z3Trong :

    -Z1: Chi ph cho mng cung cp in.

    -Z2: Chi ph trm bin p.

    -Z3: Chi ph cho mng phn phi.

    Din tch m 1 trm bin p c th

    RR

    Ghi ch:1.Mng cung cp2.Mch chnh3.Mch nhnh4.Trm bin p

    cung cp l: Hnh 1-1

    f = P1 R2

  • 23

    Trong :

    Pl H s ph thuc hnh dng ca min cung cp in vi:

    - Hnh vung : Pl = 4.

    - Hnh trn : Pl = 3,14

    Nu din tch min cn in kh ha l M th s trm bin p N cn b

    tr trn din tch s l:

    N = M/f (1-18)

    Nu cho bit mt ph ti V th cng sut ca trm bin p s l:

    S = V . f (1-19)

    Chng ta tin hnh xc nh chi ph tnh ton Z

    1) Chi ph tnh ton trm bin p Z2.

    Ta c: Z2 = aT + bT.S (1-20)

    Trong :

    * aT = ( vh + tc )KT. (1-21)

    aT : Thnh phn ph thuc bn knh cung cp in R, ph thuc vo

    kt cu trm v khng ph thuc vo cng sut trm

    * bT = ( vh + tc )Ks. (1-22)

    bT : Thnh phn ph thuc vo cng sut trm bin p. Khng ph

    thuc vo bn knh cung cp in R

    Do khi kho st bn knh cung cp in ta ch cn ch n thnh

    phn aT m thi.Cng thc trn ch ng khi cng sut ca trm bin thin

    trong mt phm vi nht nh.

    Tng qut ha ta ch xt chi ph tnh ton ca trm bin p cho mt

    n v din tch cung cp in s l:

    zaRT

    i2 2 P

    ( /Km2.nm ). (1-23)

    2) Chi ph tnh ton cho mng cung cp Z1

  • 24

    Chi ph tnh ton cho 1 Km ng dy mng cung cp l:

    Z1 = ac + bcF ( F tit din dy ). (1-24)

    Trong :

    * ac = ( vh + tc ) Kcac :Thnh phn ph thuc bn knh cung cp in R, khng ph thuc

    vo tit din dy dn.

    * bc = ( vh + tc ) KFbc : Thnh phn ph thuc vo tit din dy dn. Khng ph thuc vo

    bn knh cung cp in R

    Tng t nh trn ta ch xt n thnh phn ac = f(R), b qua thnh

    phn bc Chi ph tnh ton phn ng dy mng cung cp cho mt n v

    din tch cn cung cp in s l :

    za LNf

    aR N

    c c

    i1 2

    1

    P (1-25)

    Khi xt n min cung cp in ca 1 trm bin p l hnh vung hay

    lc lng th ta c: LN

    R 2 (1-26)

    Trong thc t chiu di ng dy ca mng cung cp ph thuc vo

    nhiu yu t nh: S phn b ca cc trm bin p, ph ti, a hnh

    ...Trong qu trnh tnh ton c th s dng cng thc kinh nghim ca

    Zakharin xc nh chiu di ng dy cung cp:

    L N M D . (Km). (1-27)

    Trong - M: Din tch min cung cp in.

    - N: S trm bin p .

    - D : h s ph thuc mc phn b cc vng dn c nu:

    - Phn b u D = 0,9 y 0,95

    - Phn b khng u: D = 0,7 y 0,9

  • 25

    Gi tr D qua thng k vi cc khu vc khc nhau thng nm trong

    khong D = 0,6 y 1,23

    Khi D = 1 th : NRNRMNL ..2..4. 2 (1-28)

    Trong thc t thy rng chiu di L tng theo s trm N nhanh hn

    theo biu thc L N M D . . Do tc gi Dale a ra cng thc hiu

    chnh sai s nh sau:

    L = L0 + 'L.N (1-29)

    Gi tr L0 l chiu di hnh hc v c xem nh l khng i cn 'L

    l thnh phn ph thuc s trm bin p, a hnh ...do chng ph thuc

    vo bn knh cung cp in. T ta c chi ph tnh ton ca mng cung

    cp trn mt n v din tch cn in kh ha l:

    za L

    Rc

    i1 2

    'P

    (1-30)

    3) Chi ph tnh ton mng phn phi Z3.

    Gi thnh xy dng 1 Km ng dy phn phi c xc nh theo

    biu thc

    Kd = K1 + K2 F (1-31)

    102

    3

    2

    UWDD F

    l

    U

    SCKtcvhz d)( (1-32)

    3

    2

    2

    1021UWDDDD

    F

    l

    U

    SCFKtcvhKtcvhdz .)()(

    t : b1 = ( Dvh + Dtc )K2

    2

    3

    210

    Uc

    b... UW

    T ta c:

  • 26

    lFSbFbkZ tcvh .

    2

    211

    DD (1-34)

    Ta nhn thy thnh phn u ca biu thc khng ph thuc R, khi

    xem chi ph xy dng phn kt cu ng dy khng ph thuc s trm, t

    ta c:

    l)F

    SbFb(z2

    21d (1-35)

    Khi xem tit din dy dn F khng i trn ton b ng dy, ta c

    hm chi ph tnh ton mng phn phi trn mt n v din tch cn cung

    cp in l :

    zf

    b F b SFK

    lr

    Lp

    3 1 2

    2

    21

    1 ( ) (1-36)

    Trong

    - l: di ca mng phn phi.

    - f :Din tch min in kh ha trm bin p m nhn.

    -Kr: H s ph ti trung bnh bnh phng.

    -Lp: Tng di ca mng in phn phi.

    Tn tht cng sut trong mng phn phi l:

    'PSU

    Rii

    n

    i 2

    21

    (1-37)

    n gin ta c th vit:

    'P SU

    RK r

    2

    2 21 (1-38)

    vi

    RRS

    SKR

    RSSK

    ii

    r

    ii

    r

    22

    22

    .

  • 27

    Bin i z3 v dng ph thuc vo bn knh cung cp in khi xem Lp

    = const th constFbpL

    i .

    - ng dy phn phi s gm c mch chnh v mch nhnh trong

    mch phn nhnh khng ph thuc R cn mch chnh ph thuc R vi gi

    thit nh vy ch lm tng tn tht m thi. Nu ph ti ca mt mch chnh

    l S th :

    S = q.V

    Trong - q: Din tch min phn phi in ca mt nhnh mch

    chnh.

    - V : Mt ph ti trn mt n v din tch.

    Ph ti ca trm bin p s l:

    ST = p.q.V = f.V

    Trong p: S mch chnh ca 1 trm bin p.

    T phn tch trn chng ta c hm chi ph tnh ton ca ng dy

    phn phi trn mt mt n v din tch cn in kh ha s l:

    zf

    b S lFK

    T

    r3

    22

    21 (1-39)

    Bin i tip chng ta c:

    zf

    b S lFK

    pf

    q lbFK

    ff

    lbFK

    b RFK

    T

    r r r3

    22

    2

    2 2 22

    2

    2 22

    22

    3 2

    21 V V P V = = 2

    r

    (1-40)

    Trong P2 : H s t l v f { R2 ; l { R

    T ta c

    z = z1 + z2 + z3 = a l

    RaR

    b RFK

    c T

    r

    'P P

    PV

    12

    22 2

    23 2

    2

    Ly o hm z theo R v cho bng 0 ta tnh c Ropt :

  • 28

    RFK a a l

    boptr T c

    23

    2

    1 2 22

    5( )'

    P P V (1-41)

    1.2.2.4 .TNH TON MNG PHN PHI THEO IU KIN

    KHONG CHIA PH TI KINH T [11]

    Trong trng hp s la chn khng ph thuc tit din dy dn. Tit

    din kinh t ca dy dn c th c xc nh theo khong chia kinh t ph

    ti, c xt n khi tnh n c trng phn tn ca s thay i tit din

    dy dn, iu kin c th lm vic v xy dng ng dy ti in.

    Tnh kinh t i vi tit din cho ca dy dn c gi l khong

    chia kinh t. trong gii hn , cc ph tn tnh ton v truyn ti mt n

    v in nng trn mt n v chiu di theo dy dn tng ng vi tit din

    l nh nht so vi bt k dy dn c tit din no khc.

    Ph tn tnh ton ph thuc vo dng in ti ca ng dy I.Vic

    la chn dy dn theo tit din tiu chun Fi , in tr tc dng Ri ca dy

    dn c xc nh theo biu thc.

    Zi = ( D tc + D vh )Ki + 3I2W Ri Ci (1-42)

    Gi tr ph ti gii hn to nn khong chia kinh t ng vi mi tit

    din tiu chun, c th tm c nu cho tng cp gi tr ph tn tnh ton

    ca dy dn c tit din Fi-1 v Fi ; Fi v Fi+1 bng nhau.

    Kt qu nhn c gi tr bng dng in kinh t cc i v cc tiu.

    1

    1min 3

    ii

    iivhtckti RR

    KKIEDDW (1-43)

    ii

    iivhtckti RR

    KKI

    1

    1max 3 E

    DDW (1-44)

    Tit din kinh t ca dy dn c th la chn hoc theo bng khong

    chia kinh t c thnh lp trn c s biu thc (1-43) v (1-44) hoc theo

    th ph tn tnh ton Z ph thuc vo dng in ph ti I c xy dng

  • 29

    i vi cc tit din khc nhau ( Fi) theo biu thc (1-42). im giao nhau

    ca cc ng cong xc nh khong kinh t ca dng in i vi mi tit

    din ca dy dn.

    Vic tnh ton mng in theo khong chia kinh t cho php xc nh

    gi tr ng tin cy tit din kinh t ca dy dn v cp. Tuy nhin khi la

    chn tit din dy dn v cp theo khong chia kinh t dn n nh hng

    qua li gia cc thnh phn khc nhau ca mng in, n chi ph tnh ton

    tng, s phn nhnh ca mng, cng nh cc hn ch khc n tr s tit

    din dy dn c la chn.

    Nhng vn thuc v mng in khng ng nht nhng mng

    vic xc nh cc tham s khi la chn tit din dy dn l tn tht in

    p cho php. 1.2.2.5 . L DO CHN PHNG PHP KHONG CHIA PH TI

    KINH T

    Trong cc phng php tnh ton mng phn phi nu trn, mi

    mt phng php c nhng thun li v kh khn ring

    + Phng php tnh ton mng phn phi theo iu kin cc tiu

    ph tn tnh ton vi thnh phn tn tht in p kinh t :

    Theo (1-3) ta c chi ph tnh ton ca phn t th i trong mng:

    M

    UDDW

    22

    2

    cos10010iUiPii

    UUPlbZ

    cii

    iiiivhtci

    '

    '

    Theo , ng vi mi mt nhnh th i s tn ti mt gi tr tn tht

    in p 'Ui cc tiu c hm chi ph tnh ton

    Phng php ny ch c th p dng thun tin vi li phn phi c

    ph ti tp trung cao

    + Phng php tnh ton mng phn phi theo iu kin mt

    dng in kinh t :

  • 30

    Theo (1-17) ta c :

    M

    cosJU310SF

    kt

    3

    kt

    Theo tit din ca ng dy c xc nh qua cng sut ph ti

    v qua gi tr mt kinh t ca dng in . Ta thy gi tr tit din dy dn

    nhn c cha xc nh c gi tr nh nht ca hm chi ph tnh ton,

    bi v mt kinh t ca dng in cng ch l gi tr gn ng [9]

    + Phng php tnh ton mng phn phi theo iu kin ti u

    bn knh cung cp in :

    Theo (1-41) ta c:

    RFK a a l

    boptr T c

    23

    2

    1 2 22

    5( )'

    P P V

    Bn knh cung cp in ti u l mt quan h tng i phc tp theo

    tit din dy F v mt ph ti V

    + Phng php tnh ton mng phn phi theo khong chia ph

    ti kinh t:

    Khong chia kinh t ca dng in ( v tng ng l mt ph ti)

    c xc nh d dng qua th ph tn tnh ton z c xy dng tng

    ng vi cc tit din F khc nhau ca dy dn , phng php ny d dng

    chp nhn c vi cc li phn phi c mt ph ti tng i u theo

    din tch khu vc kho st, nht l li 0,4KV ti cc khu th mi

  • 31

    CHNG 2:

    TRNH T CC BC THIT K

    THEO PHNG PHP KHONG CHIA KINH T

    Trn y, khi chn phng n cu trc theo iu kin cc tiu hm chi

    ph tnh ton hng nm Z, thc cht bi ton c ti u ha theo 2 ch

    tiu [3]:

    a) Cc tiu vn u t K

    b) Cc tiu chi ph vn hnh hm nm Y

    Ngha l hm mc tiu Z ch cha hai yu t K v Y. Nh bit, y

    l hai yu t i lp nhau, phng n ti u phi c gng dung ho ng

    thi c hai yu t ny

    Vic gii bi ton tng qut cc tiu hm chi ph tnh ton Z nh trn

    l iu kh thc hin c trong thc t, n thuc lp bi ton ti u lin

    tc [8] cc hm a ch tiu. Kh khn ch yu y l nhiu yu t kh th

    hin, biu din nh lng di dng gii tch. Khng nhng th, chng cn

    mang tnh ngu nhin, hoc mt s trng hp ch ghi chp c mt s

    th hin m khng bit c lut phn phi ca chng . D , vic gii

    cc bi ton a ch tiu v lin tc nh dng trn l rt kh khn v phng

    php ny thng t ra km hiu lc, kh thc hin c trong thc t

    Mt trong nhng phng hng gii quyt nhng kh khn trn

    y l xy dng m hnh ton hc ca phng php khong chia ph ti

    kinh t. Phng php ny da trn c s l mt s thng s tham gia vo

    php tnh c chun ho v tp gi tr l hu hn (s chng loi dy, di

    cng sut my bin p ...l hu hn). Hoc ng hn l tm cch cc tiu

    hm chi ph tnh ton tng ng vi mt di thng s kh thc no . Ni

  • 32

    chung, phng php khong chia kinh t thuc lp cc bi ton ti u ri

    rc [8] Ngy nay, nh s h tr ca my tnh s gim nh ng k khi

    lng tnh ton, bng phng php khong chia kinh t s nhanh chng xc

    nh c cu trc hp l ca HTCCT mt mc cho php

    2.1 S KHI BI TON THEO PHNG PHP

    KHONG CHIA PH TI KINH T [12]Vi mt mt ph ti V, gi bn in c, cc bc tnh ton v la

    chn thng s cu trc TBAPP c tin hnh nh hnh 2.1

    Trong :

    + F: Tit din cp.

    + SBm : Cng sut nh mc MBA

    + Tnh k thut : L tnh chn cc thng s cho php v mt k thut

    ng vi cc trng hp sau:

    x Pht nng do dng in lm vic bnh thng

    x Pht nng ngn hn do dng in ngn mch

    x Kh nng chu cc tc ng c hc ca dng in ngn

    mch

    x Tn tht in p ch lm vic bnh thng v s c

    + Thng s cho php l cc thng s c chn la, m bo cc

    iu kin v mt k thut. Cc thng s ny u c s dng tnh ton

    kinh t

    + Cc iu kin ring ca Khu th : l cc c im ring ca

    khu vc cn kho st. Kt qu tnh ton c l kt qu tng qut, tu theo

    iu kin a hnh ca tng khu vc, vic b tr cc MBAPP cng nh cc

  • 33

    hng tuyn cn phi c hiu chnh ( nht l ti cc v tr ng bin ca

    khu vc cn kho st ) ph hp thc t.

    + Kt qu in ra l cc thng s cn phc v cho cng tc thit k,

    y l gam cng sut my bin p v s lng trm bin p, qui cch v

    chiu di cp trc, cp nhnh

    2.2 CC GI NHNh nu trn, vic gii bi ton trong iu kin tng qut s rt kh

    khn khng ch bi phc tp ca cc quan h rng buc m cn v khi

    lng tnh ton kh ln. Trong thc t, bng vic a ra cc gi thit c cn

    nhc k ti c im ring ca i tng nghin cu, xut pht t i hi

    thc t, khi lng tnh ton c gim ng k m khng nh hng ti

    chnh xc ca kt qu cng ngha p dng ca n. Lun vn da trn mt

    s thng s thc t ca vt t thit b hin c trn th trng nh :

    + S chng loi cp

    + S chng loi my bin p

    + Mt ph ti phn b u : iu ny l kh thi v y l c im

    ca li th, hn na Khu th mi in Nam - in Ngc l khu

    th c xy dng mi hon ton, vic b tr cc cn h c tnh ton

    hp l, khoa hc

    + Chiu di cp nhnh ban u tnh s b c ly trung bnh l

    60m [12]

    + Cc thng s tnh ton ca cc loi thit b c a ra trn c s

    cc tiu chun v yu cu hin hnh s dng cho HTCCT

    2.3 CC BI TON NH: gii quyt vn mt cch trn vn v y , ta cn kho st

    ring r tng bi ton c th :

  • 34

    Tnh gii hn kthut ( b phn )

    Tnh ton kinh tk thut

    Tnh kinh t (B phn)

    La chn thng s k thut

    Cc iu kin ring ca khu th

    In ra kt qu

    La chn thng s kinh t

    Thng s tnh ton

    La chn phngn cu trc hp l

    Khong chia kinh t

    Hnh 2.1: S thut ton phng php khong chia ph ti kinh t

    Tp cc thng s khthc (V,F,c,SBdm)

  • 35

    2.3.1 BI TON CHN TIT DIN CP:2.3.1.1 TIT DIN CP NHNH:

    Dng in trong ng cp nhnh:

    dm

    ll U

    SI3

    Trong Sl cng sut tnh ton ca ng cp nhnh. Nu xem ph

    ti phn b u, ta c th vit :

    dm

    dddtkcl U

    kkllI.3

    .... V

    ng vi V = 25 VA/ m2 (i vi th loi 3 th V khng th ln

    hn gi tr ny)

    Ta c I lmax < Ilcp ca cp c tit din 25mm2 ( 112 A)

    Chnh v vy iu kin pht nng di hn ca cp nhnh u c tho

    mn vi mi tit din tnh ton.

    Khong chia kinh t ca dng in, v tng ng vi n l mt ph

    ti, c xc nh nh sau: i vi mt tit din ca ng cp nhnh, hm

    chi ph tnh ton c th vit di dng:

    cRIKZ lllvhtc WDD .3.)(2max

    clrUSKZ

    dm

    llvhtc ...)( .02

    2max WDD

    20

    2

    0....)....(.)(

    dm

    dddtkcvhtc U

    clrkklllKZ WVDD (2.7)

    Trong :

  • 36

    K: Vn u t xy dng ng dy

    K0 : Sut u t xy dng ng dy, tnh cho 1 km

    l: Chiu di cp nhnh

    lkc : Chiu di khong ct

    Trong c cu gi thnh ng dy, ta nhn thy :

    + Thnh phn u ca biu thc : (Dtc + Dvh ).K0.l Thnh phn ph

    thuc chi ph xy dng ng dy ( Gi l Ai)

    + Thnh phn th hai : 2 02 ....)....(

    dm

    dddtkc

    Uclrkkll WV

    2.ViB

    : Thnh phn ph thuc

    vic vn hnh ng dy (gi l )

    Ta c (2.8)2.Vii BAZ

    Da vo (2.8) , ta tin hnh v cc ng cong biu din s ph thuc

    ca cc hm chi ph tnh ton Z vo mt ph ti V, ng vi cc tit din

    cp tiu chun khc nhau

    Z F1 F2 F3

    b a

    1V 2V V (V.A/m2)

    Hnh 2.2 Khong chia kinh t ng cp

  • 37

    th cc hm chi ph tnh ton i vi cc tit din F1,F2,F3 c v

    hnh (2.2), trong F3 > F2 > F1. Cc ng cong ny ct nhau ti a v b.

    C th nhn thy rng:

    _ Trong khong mt ph ti (0yV1) : Tit din F1 l kinh t nht

    _ Trong khong mt ph ti (V1y V2) : Tit din F2 l kinh t nht

    _ Trong khong mt ph ti (V2y V3) Tit din F3 l kinh t nht

    . . . . . . . .

    Nh cng c my tnh v ngn ng Pascal, trn c s tit din dy cp

    c tiu chun ho, ta c th kho st c ton b s bin thin ca Z

    theo mt ph ti V. ng vi mi gi tr F v trong mi di V xc nh, ta

    c mt gi tr F Z t ga tr Zmin2.3.1.2 TIT DIN CP TRC:

    Hnh (2.3) m t cu trc ca mt ng cp trc li th

    Ix TBAPP l

    L

    Hnh 2.3 M t mt xut tuyn cp trc xc nh tit din

    Gi Ix l cng dng in trn ng cp trc ti im c to x

    (xem v tr gc to ti TBAPP)

    Ta cdm

    xx U

    SI.3

    Nu xem mt ph ti phn b u, ta c :

  • 38

    dm

    dtddx U

    KKxLlI

    3.)..(.

    V

    Hm chi ph tnh ton ca ng cp trc c th vit :

    L

    oxLvhtc dxcrIKZ0

    2 ....3).( WDD

    L

    dtdddm

    vhtc dxxLlKKUcrLK

    0

    222

    00 )()...(.

    ...).( VWDD

    Ldtdd

    dmvhtc xllKKU

    crLK

    032

    20

    0 ))(31(.)...(.

    ...).( VWDD

    cLrU

    KKLlLKdm

    dddtvhtc ....3

    )....(.).( 02

    2

    0 WVDD

    Bng phng php khong chia kinh t, tng t nh cp nhnh, ta

    tm c tit din hp l cp trc

    2.3.2 BI TON CHN CHIU DI CP

    2.3.2.1 CHIU DI CP NHNH :

    Chiu di hp l cp nhnh s c tnh ton da trn tit din cp

    nhnh c chn hp l ( xem 2.2.1).

    + ng vi mt mt ph ti V v mt gi in c, bng phng php

    khong chia kinh t, ta xc nh c mt tit din cp nhnh hp l F1+ Chiu di cp nhnh c chn sao cho m bo c tn tht in

    p cho php i vi ng cp nhnh :

    V cp nhnh ngn, in p nh, b qua in dung ca cp, tn tht

    in p trn cp nhnh c th tnh theo cng thc:

    "'.. UUU

    XQRPUdm

    '' ' (2.8)

    Trong : 'U : Thnh phn tn tht in p do cng sut tc dng

  • 39

    'U : Thnh phn tn tht in p do cng sut phn khng

    P,Q : Cng sut tc dng v cng sut phn khng ca ph ti

    R,X : in tr v in khng cp nhnh

    Ti gi tr gii hn : 'Ucp = 'U + 'U (2.9)

    Hoc : 'U = 'Ucp - 'U

    Trong dmU

    lxQU

    .." 0 ' (2.10)

    Vi cp h p, r0 >> x0 .

    Vi li h p , sin M thng rt nh, ta c th b qua thnh phn 'U

    Vydm

    cp Ulrp

    UU..

    ' 0 '|' (2.11)

    i vi cp nhnh , ta c

    MVM cos.....cos. dddtkc KKllSP (2.12)

    Th (2.17) vo (2.16) , ta c :

    dm

    dddtkccp U

    rKKllU MV cos...... 02

    ' (2.13)

    T (2.18), c th tm c :

    MV cos......

    0rKKlUU

    ldddtkc

    dmcpcp

    ' (2.14)

    i vi li h p, tn tht in p cho php trn cc ng cp nhnh

    = 1%UcpU' dm

    Vy chiu di hp l cp nhnh s l:

    l = min{60, lcp} (2.15)

    Trong 60 l chiu di trung bnh cp nhnh

    2.3.2.2 CHIU DI CP TRC :

    Chiu di hp l cp trc s c tnh ton da trn tit din cp trc

    c chn hp l ( xem 2.2.1).

  • 40

    + ng vi mt mt ph ti V v mt gi in c cho trc, bng

    phng php khong chia kinh t, ta xc nh c tit din hp l ca cp

    trc

    + Tng t i vi cp nhnh, chiu di cp trc c chn sao cho

    m bo c tn tht in p cho php i vi ng cp trc :

    Hnh (2.4) m t cu trc mt ng cp trc xut tuyn ca mt

    TBAPP x TBAPP l

    L

    Hnh 2.4 M t mt xut tuyn cp trc xc nh chiu di

    T (2.11), mt tn tht in p du ti im x c dng :

    dmUdxrxPdu .).( 0

    Trong P(x) : Dng cng sut tc dng trn cp trc ti im x, ta c

    th vit :

    dmUdxrxS

    du..cos).( 0M

    Nu xem mt ph ti phn b u, ta c:

    dmUdxrxLl

    du..cos)...(. 0MV

    Tn tht in p trn ton b cp trc c dng:

    'L

    dm

    dxxLrU

    lU0

    0 )(.cos... MV

    L

    dm

    xLrU

    lU0

    20 )(.cos..

    . ' MV

  • 41

    2.0.2

    . LrU

    lUdm

    V ' ( 'U < 0 : in p gim )

    MV cos.....

    ..2'

    0 Ldddt

    dmLcp

    rKKlUU

    L'

    (2.16)

    Trong :

    H s 2 th hin ph ti phn b u

    LcpU' : Tn tht in p cho php i vi cp trc ( 4%U| dm)

    l : chiu di trung bnh cp nhnh

    R rng ta c quan h L = f(V,FL)

    + Chiu di cp trc c chn theo phm vi phc v ca cng sut

    MBAPP: Cu trc li h p nh ta chn l hnh tia, chiu di cp trc l

    khong cch xa nht m mt TBAPP c th cung cp vi cc rng buc v

    mt k thut

    Cng sut truyn ti ln nht trn mt ng cp trc c xc nh

    theo biu thc :n

    KSS qtBdmL

    . (2.17)

    Mu s n biu th s xut tuyn ca TBAPP

    Mt khc, cng sut truyn ti ln nht trn mt ng cp trc li ph

    thuc mt ph ti theo quan h :

    V.... dddtL KKlLS (2.18)

    Thay (2.18) vo (2.17), ta c chiu di cp trc nh sau :

    V.....

    "dddt

    qtBdm

    KKlnKS

    L (2.19)

    R rng ta c quan h : L = f(V,SBdm)

    V chiu di cp trc c chn l:

    L= min{L, L} (2.20)

  • 42

    2.3.3 BI TON CHN CNG SUT MY BIN P :

    Trong cc tnh ton trn y, ta thy cc thng s cp u l hm ca

    cng sut TBAPP . iu ny cho ta thy rng trong khi i tm cu trc hp

    l li h p, khng nn tch ri phn ng dy v phn trm bin p.

    Cng sut TBAPP do s c chn trn c s cc tiu ho c hm chi

    ph tnh ton ca ton b li h p, bao gm ng dy v TBA 2.3.3.1 LA CHN S LNG TBAPP:

    Trn din tch kho st D, s TBAPP c th c xc nh nh sau:

    Bdmqt

    dtdd

    Bdmqt

    tt

    SKDKK

    SKSN

    ....

    .1V (2.21)

    Trong :

    Stt : Cng sut tnh ton ca ph ti trong khu vc kho st

    Kqt : H s qu ti ca MBAPP, nh gi thit , Kqt = 1,3

    R rng ta c N1 = f(V,SBdm)

    Mt khc, s TBAPP cn c th c tnh da trn phm vi phc v

    ca n : lL

    N.42

    D (2.22)

    Trong : L Chiu di cp trc, c xc nh t (2.20)

    l : Chiu di cp nhnh, c xc nh t (2.15)

    Khi chn s lng TBAPP, quan im l chn sao cho cc TBA khng

    b qu ti lin tc. Do vy, vi mt gi in c, mt mt ph ti V, s

    TBAPP s l: N = max {N1 , N2 } = f (V, SBdm, c ) (2.23)

    2.3.3.2 LA CHN GAM CNG SUT MBAPP:

  • 43

    Hm chi ph tnh ton ca 1 TBAPP cng sut SBdm c xc nh

    nh sau : cPSScTPKZ n

    BmMBAvhtcMBA .....)( 2

    max0 WDD ''

    2

    Trong : (Dtc + Dvh )KMBA :Thnh phn ph thuc chi ph xy dng

    TBAPP

    KMBA : Gi thnh xy dng mt trm bin p cng sut SBdm

    cPSScTP n

    Bm

    ..... 22max

    0 W'' : Thnh phn ph thuc chi ph vn hnh

    TBAPP

    Cng sut TBAPP s c la chn trn c s cc tiu ho c hm

    chi ph tnh ton ca ton b li h p:

    ZHA = N.( ZMBAPP + ZL + Zl) (2.24)

    Trong : N : S TBA trn khu vc kho st( din tch D)

    ZMBA : Chi ph tnh ton lp cho 1 TBAPP

    ZL : Chi ph tnh ton lp cho ton b cp trc ca 1 TBAPP

    Zl : Chi ph tnh ton lp cho ton b cp nhnh ca 1TBAPP

    2.4 NI DUNG CHI TIT CC BC TNH TON Ni dung chi tit cc bc tnh ton trong tng khi s c th

    hin trong hnh 2.5

    Trong :

    + Z1l : Hm chi ph tnh ton lp cho 1 ng cp nhnh

  • 44

    122

    23

    1

    32

    2max

    1

    10.......

    10...

    10...

    clrU

    KKlllKZ

    cRUS

    KZ

    oldm

    dddtkcolvhtc

    dm

    llvhtc

    WV

    DD

    WDD

    Trong :

    K0l : Vn xy dng 1 km ng cp nhnh, [triu ng/km]

    rol: in tr 1 km ng cp nhnh [ :/km]

    Udm = 380V

    l: Chiu di cp nhnh, [m ]

    W : Thi gian tn tht cng sut cc i, [h]

    c : gi in thng phm, [ng/KWh]

    lkc : Khong ct, [m]

    V : Mt ph ti, [VA/m2]

    Slmax : Cng sut ph ti cc i trn 1 ng cp nhnh [KVA]

    Ta thy Zl= f(V,Fl,c)

    + Fl : Tit din cp nhnh

    + FL : Tit din cp trc

    Vi mi cp (V,c) ta s c mt dy gi tr hm Zl tng ng vi mt

    dy gi tr tit din cp nhnh Fl . Trong s c mt gi tr Fopt lm cc

    tiu hm Zl+ Chiu di cp nhnh theo tn tht in p cho php:

    lcp= MV cos.....

    0. rKKlUU

    dddtkc

    dmcp'

    Ta thy lcp = f(V,Fl)

    Vi mt cp (V,c) ta xc nh c Fopt( nh trn ), tnh c lcp v

    chiu di hp l cp nhnh l : lop = min {60, lcp}= f (V,Fl,c)

    + Chiu di cp trc cho php L c tnh theo (2.20)

  • 45

    + SB : Cng sut MBAPP

    + m : S cp nhnh r ra t cp trc , c xc nh sau khi c Lopt+ N : S lng MBAPP thuc khu vc kho st, c xc nh theo

    (2.23)

    + Zl : Hm chi ph tnh ton ca cc ng cp nhnh trong mt

    TBAPP

    Zl = m.Z1l [ triu ng ]

    + Z1L : Hm chi ph tnh ton cho 1 ng cp trc, [ triu ng ]Fl,c,V

    Tnh ton kinh tdy dn nhnh

    f(Fl,c,V)La chn F1

    Tnh bn knhphc v TBAPP

    Tnh L theo 'Ucp

    Tnh ton kinh tng cp trc

    Tnh ZB

    Tnh lcpTnh l theo 'Ucp

    Chn S NCc iu kin

    Tnh kinh t kthut chung

    Chn FL

    Tnh Lop Tnh ZL

    Tnh Zl

    Fop(c,V)

    f(Fl,c,V)

    m

    L

    L=f(SB,V)

    L=f(FL,V)Fop=f(V,c)

    ZL=f(FL,V,c)

    ZHA=f(SB,V,c)

    ZB=f(SB,V,c)

    FL,V,c

    D,FL,V

    SB,V

    lop=f(c,V)Fl,V

    lcp=f(F,V)

  • 46

    Hnh 2.5 : Chi tit cc bc tnh ton

    12022

    31

    32

    2max

    11

    10...3

    ....10....

    10..3

    cLrU

    KKLlLKZ

    cRU

    SKZ

    Ldm

    dddtoLvhtcL

    dm

    LLvhtcL

    WVDD

    WDD

    Trong :

    . KoL: Vn xy dng 1 km ng cp trc, [triu ng/km ]

    . r0L : in tr 1 km ng cp trc, [:/km]

    . L : Chiu di cp trc, [ m ]

    + ZL : Hm chi ph tnh ton cho cc ng cp trc, xut tuyn t 1

    TBAPP

    + ZB : Hm chi ph tnh ton cho 1 TBAPP, [triu ng ]

    622max6

    0 10...10... '' cP

    SScTPKZ n

    BdmMBAPPvhtcB WDD

    Trong :

    . KMBAPP : Vn u t xy dng 1 TBAPP, triu ng

    . 'P0 : Tn tht khng ti ca MBAPP, [KW]

    . 'PN : Tn tht ngn mch ca MBAPP, [KW]

    . T : Thi gian vn hnh MBA = 8.760h

  • 47

    R rng ZB = f (SB,c,V)

    + ZHA : Hm chi ph tnh ton li h p c xc nh theo (2.24) .

    ZHA = f(SB,c,V)

    + Vi mt gi tr c v V xc nh, ta xc nh c mt gi tr ca

    cng sut MBAPP ZHA min

    CHNG 3:

    XC NH CU TRC HP L CHO H THNG

    CUNG CP IN KHU TH MI IN NAM-

    IN NGC

    3.1 GII THIU S LC KHU TH MI IN

    NAM-IN NGC3.1.1 IU KIN T NHIN-KINH T-XHI:

    Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc nm trn phn ln a bn ca 2

    x in Nam v in Ngc ( in Bn- Qung Nam)

    + Pha ty gip trc ng tnh l 603 v 607

    + Pha ng gip sng C c

    + Pha bc gip phng Ho Hi ( qun Ng Hnh Sn- thnh ph

    Nng)

    + Pha nam gip x in Dng

    Din tch 2.400 ha. Giai on mt d kin xy dng 520 ha

    (Lun vn ny ch tp trung cp n giai on I )

  • 48

    Khu nghin cu nm trong vng ng bng Nng- Hi An, vi

    nhng c im ca vng duyn hi Min Trung, ch yu l vng ct kh,

    tng i bng phng, t ngp lt.

    Kh hu khu vc nghin cu nm trong vng kh hu Trung b, nng,

    m v ma nhiu.

    Khu vc nghin cu (520 ha) thuc a gii hnh chnh x in Ngc

    (in Bn) c 4.950 h dn vi 3 thn

    Dn c ch yu sng bng ngh nng: Trng la, trng mu (khoai

    lang, u, ng ...) nhng sn lng rt thp do t xu (ct pha). Mt s h

    ang chuyn sang lm dch v, kinh doanh, thng mi. Khu vc bun bn

    pht trin mnh nht gn trc cng Khu cng nghip in Nam- in

    Ngc v ng t T Cu-in Ngc. Thu nhp bnh qun 352.000

    ng/ngi/thng

    Hin khu vc c cp in t Nng, t trm trung gian 35KV

    Vnh in v trm 110KV Khu Cng nghip

    Trong khu vc nghin cu hin c 7 TBA 15/0,4KV :

    - Trm bin p 30KVA:1 trm

    - Trm bin p 50KVA: 1 trm

    - Trm bin p 100KVA: 5 trm

    ng dy trung th ang c cp in p 15KV v s dng dy

    3xAC-95

    H thng in chiu sng cng cng hin ch tp trung dc ng tnh

    l 603 v 607, dng loi n cao p 125W v 250W

    3.1.2 NH HNG PHT TRIN:

    Qui hoch chung ca Khu th mi in Nam- in Ngc c

    Th tng chnh ph ph duyt ti quyt nh s : 124/1999/Q-TTg ngy

  • 49

    18/5/1999 vi mc tiu l xy dng mt khu th mi vi cc tiu ch :

    xanh, sch, p, sng, mang sc thi ca mt th hin i nhng gi gn

    c cnh quan sinh thi v bn sc vn ho dn tc

    D n Khu th mi in Nam- in Ngc cng nm trong vng vi

    hai d n ln :

    + D n xy dng Khu Cng nghip in Nam-in Ngc (420 ha)

    c xem l d n trung tm, l mt tin hnh thnh khu th mi

    + D n i hc Nng: nhm xy dng mt Trung tm o to

    i hc cho Min trung v Ty Nguyn (mt Trung tm nghin cu khoa

    hc, chuyn giao cng ngh. . .) vi qui m 300 ha nm trn t phng

    Ho Qu v x in Ngc

    C 3 d n thuc v tr thun li v t ai, tn dng c cc iu

    kin v c s h tng ca Thnh ph Nng v tnh Qung Nam pht

    trin

    Ngoi ra khu vc cn c cc d n du lch ven bin: Khu du lch ven

    bin in Ngc, Khu du lch th k 21, Khu Du lch i dng xanh, Khu

    du lch ven bin H My. . .

    Vi cc thun li v tnh tt yu khch quan, vic xy dng khu th

    mi in Nam- in Ngc l cn thit

    xy dng Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc, cn phi xy

    dng hng lot cc c s h tng nh: giao thng, cp nc, thot nc, cy

    xanh, cp in, chiu sng cng cng, thng tin lin lc. . .

    Trong vn cp in cn phi c quan tm v xem xt nghim

    tc, sao cho vic u t mang li hiu qu cao nht m vn m bo c

    cht lng in nng

    3.2 MT S GI THIT:

  • 50

    + Gi thit v dy cng sut MBA : Th trng thc t hin nay ch

    yu tn ti mt s gam cng sut MBAPP nh sau : 100,160, 250, 320, 400,

    560, 630KVA

    + Gi thit v cu trc TBA phn phi : Chng ta bit rng, cu trc

    TBA phn phi c qui nh bi phn b ph ti.

    Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc l khu th c hnh thnh

    trn c s qui hoch mi hon ton. ng ph trong Khu th ny c

    dng bn c. Cc ng trc l cc ph ln chy song song nhau. V ni

    gia chng l cc ph nh m chiu di on ph ny l b su hai ng i

    ra hai ph chnh v do thng khng ln. c im chung ca li phn

    phi hin nay l vn hnh h, hnh tia hoc dng xng c . tng cng

    tin cy cung cp in, c th s dng cu trc mch vng kn nhng vn

    hnh h. Cc nghin cu v thng k t thc t vn hnh a n kt

    lun nn vn hnh li phn phi theo dng h, bi cc l do sau:

    + Vn hnh, qun l n gin

    + Trnh t phc hi li kt cu li sau s c d dng hn

    + t gp kh khn trong vic lp k hoch ct in cc b

    Theo cc quan im nh trn, cc cu trc li sau y u c xem

    xtTBAPP

    Hnh 3.1

  • 51

    TBAPP

    Hnh 3.2 TBAPP

    Hnh 3.3

    Trong cc phng n cu trc li trn, phng n hnh 3.1 v hnh

    3.3 d gy qu ti nng cp trc khi dng TBA c dung lng ln, v

    phng n hp l nht vn l phng n hnh 3.2

    Nh th c 4 tuyn trc chnh xut tuyn t mi TBAPP (Vic t

    TBA ti cc gc ng t l iu bt tin trong giao thng, nhng ta c th

    hiu chnh v tr trm i mt on nh v xem l c 4 xut tuyn h th ti

    mi trm. Tt nhin s c sai s trong tnh ton, nhng on hiu chnh l

    nh, nn c th b qua)

    + Gi thit v dy dn: Hin nay, theo qui phm trang b in, c th

    c cc phng n i ng dy h th cho Khu th nh sau:

  • 52

    - i theo phng n 4 dy trn khng : Theo phng n ny, s

    chim hnh lang tuyn ln, s lng dy nhiu gy mt m quan ng

    ph, gi thnh tng i ln

    - i theo phng n cp ngm : m bo m quan ng ph ,

    nhng gi thnh ln, chi ph u t cho khu th ln, s kh thu hi vn

    - i theo phng n cp vn xon: y l xu hng pht trin chung

    ca cc li th, do hai yu cu chnh : Tnh an ton cho cc cng trnh

    xung quanh cc tuyn ng dy v t chu tc ng ngu nhin ca mi

    trng, cng vi vic tit kim hnh lang tuyn, bn c hc cao v tng

    m quan th. Hin nay cp c dng rng ri l cp nhm vn xon

    Trn th trng hin nay ch yu tn ti mt s chng loi cp nhm

    vn xon, cch in Polyetylen lin kt ngang (XLPE) nh sau: 4x(35, 50,

    70, 95, 120, 150)

    - Cc ng cp nhnh s dng cp vn xon, cch in XLPE i

    ni, c tit din 4x(35,50,70)

    - Cc ng cp trc s x dng cp vn xon, cch in XLPE i

    ni, c tit din 4x(70, 95, 120, 150)

    + Mt ph ti phn b u : iu ny hon ton c th chp

    nhn c. V Khu th mi in Nam -in Ngc l khu dn c th

    c quy hoch mi hon ton, vic phn l c tnh ton hp l, a hnh

    tng i ng nht, bng phng, i tng dn c tng i ng u v

    mt i sng v thu nhp

    Qua s liu thng k mt s nm gn y trong cng tc xy dng c

    bn, kt hp n gi vt t , thit b hin nay trn th trng, cng nh cc

    ch hin hnh ca nh nc qui nh, ta xy dng c sut u tca

    mt s TBAPP v ng cp h th nh sau:

  • 53

    Bng 3.1 Sut u t TBAPPCng sut TBAPP Gi thnh

    100 KVA 118.000.000

    160 KVA 132.000.000

    180 KVA 138.000.000

    250 KVA 152.000.000

    320 KVA 173.000.000

    400 KVA 198.000.000

    Bng 3.2 Sut u t ng cp h th XLPE

    Qui cch cp Gi thnh

    4x35 205.000.000

    4x50 232.000.000

    4x70 263.000.000

    4x95 310.000.000

    4x120 339.000.000

    4x150 403.000.000

    3.3 XC NH S LIU PH TI:Do th mi in Nam -in Ngc l khu th c xy dng mi

    t u, nn c s liu v mt ph ti, c th s dng cc s liu thng

    k ti cc th Qung Nam v tc pht trin ph ti in thng

    phm, kt hp vi Qui chun xy dng Vit Nam ta c th c s liu nh

    sau:

    Bng 3.3 Mt s tiu ch Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc [6]

    STT NI DUNG TIU CH GHI CH

  • 54

    1 Loi th 3

    2 Dn s 32.417 ngi

    3 Din tch qui hoch 520 ha 5,2km2

    Trong : t 202,7 ha

    t giao thng 114,5 ha

    t cy xanh 138,7 ha

    t d tr pht trin 17,3 ha

    t cng trnh cng cng 46.8 ha

    Trong :

    t trung tm hnh chnh 6,02 ha

    t trung tm vn ho 3,66 ha

    Trung tm thng mi , dch v 8,55 ha

    Trung tm th thao 13,92 ha

    Trng hc 14,65 ha

    Theo :

    + i vi th loi 3, tiu chun ri tnh trung bnh cho cc

    ng giao thng : 0,5 lux (theo [2]), tng ng vi cng sut in : 0,95

    W/m2

    + Ph ti chiu sng giao thng:

    0,95 W/m2 x 114,5 ha x 104 = 108,8 x 104 W

    + Ph ti chiu sng cho cc dch v thng mi dch v:

    1 Trung tm hnh chnh 6,02 ha x 18 W/m2 = 108,36 x104 W

    2 Trung tm vn ho 3,66 ha x 15 = 54,9 x104 W

    3 Trung tm thng mi dch v 8,55 ha x 25 = 213,75 x104 W

    4 Trung tm th thao 13,92 ha x 12 = 167,04 x104 W

    5 H thng cc trng hc 14,65 ha x 15 = 219,75 x104 W

  • 55

    Tng ph ti chiu sng cho khu vc dch v thng mi:763,8x 104 W

    + Ph ti ng lc cho khu vc dch v thng mi ( theo [4]) thng

    chim khong 4,3 ln ph ti chiu sng = 3.284,34 x 104 W

    + S h dn c bnh qun: 32.417 : 4 = 8.104 h

    + Sut ph ti tnh ton cho mt h dn c, th loi 3 [2] :

    2.500 W/h

    + Ph ti tnh ton cho sinh hot khu dn c :

    8.104 x 2.500 = 2.026 x 104 W

    + Mt ph ti tnh ton :

    2,1310.9,0000.200.5

    026.23,284.38,7638,108 4 x

    V VA/m2

    + Ltb : Theo [12 ] , vi li th, Ltb = 250m. Nhng trong thc t

    qun l , vn hnh, kinh doanh in , Cng ty in lc 3 pht hnh Tiu

    chun cng tc li phn phi ( trong phm vi qun l ca cng ty) vi

    chiu di cp trc hp l l Ltb [400 y 600] . y chn Ltb = 600 m

    3.4 TRNH T CC BC TNH TON KHI TIN

    HNH LA CHN CU TRC HP L CHO HTCCT 1/ Thu thp, x l cc thng tin cn thit lin quan n khu vc nghin

    cu v xc nh V

    2/ T V v c, theo gin khong chia kinh t cu trc li h p, tm

    cng sut hp l TBAPP cho khu vc

    3/ Vi SBdm , V v c theo cc gin khong chia kinh t cp trc v

    cp nhnh, xc nh thit din cp trc v cp nhnh hp l

  • 56

    4/ T SBdm , V , c , FL v Fl chn chiu di hp l cp trc v nhnh.

    Nu tit din c qui chun, chn s lng cp chy song song cn thit

    5/ Theo din tch thc t cn qui hoch, xc nh s lng TBA phn

    phi

    6/ Da vo cc c im ph ti v a hnh c th, sp xp thch hp

    cc TBAPP

    7/ Tnh ton cc ch tiu kinh t k thut ton li. Hiu chnh li v tr

    trm, chiu di cc l cp c ch tiu kinh t- k thut tt nht

    3.5 CHNG TRNH TNH TON VIT TRN NGN

    NG PASCALTrn c s phn tch t 3.1 y 3.4, lun vn s dng ngn ng

    PASCAL lp trnh cho bi ton la chn cu trc hp l H thng cung

    cp in Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc, ni dung chng trnh xem

    trong ph lc 1

    3.6 KT QU BI TON Bi ton la chn cu trc hp l h HTCCT Khu th mi

    in Nam-in Ngc vi cc s liu u vo : D = 5, 2 km2 , V = 13.

    VA/m2 ,

    c = 630 /KWh, cho kt qu v cu trc hp l HTCC Khu th

    mi in Nam in Ngc nh sau:

    + S lng cc xut tuyn hp l l 4 tuyn

    + Gam cng sut MBAPP hp l l 250 KVA

    + S lng MBA hp l l 102 my

    + Tit din cp trc hp l l 120 mm2

  • 57

    + Tit din cp nhnh hp l l 35 mm2

    + Chiu di cp trc hp l l 426 m

    + Chiu di cp nhnh hp l l 60 m

    3.7 HIU CHNH THEO NHNG IU KIN RING: Sau khi c kt qu tng th ca bi ton xc nh cu trc hp l

    HTCC Khu th mi in Nam-in Ngc nh trn, bc sau cng l

    b tr v hiu chnh theo cc iu kin ring ca Khu th, c th :

    1/ Phn khu pha bc ca Khu th l Khu i hc dn lp Qung

    Nam, d kin b tr 1500 SV v h thng cc phng ban chc nng ca

    trng

    Ti khu vc ny c mt ph ti ln , c b tr 2 my 400KVA

    2/ Tng ng s lng MBA cn li l 98 my

    3/ Phn b s b s lng MBA ( 98 my) trn din tch kho st

    4/ iu chnh v tr mt s TBA ti cc vng bin cho ph hp vi

    thc t

    5/ Tin hnh tnh ton phn b dng cho cc xut tuyn ti cc MBA

    vng bin ca khu vc kho st v tnh chn li cp trc, cp nhnh cho

    cc MBA ny

    3.8 KT LUN : 3.8.1 : Sau khi c kt qu bi ton c th, i chiu vi s liu

    trong Bo co nghin cu kh thi ca Khu th mi in Nam - in

    Ngc, chng ta nhn thy :

    Gia s liu qui hoch v s liu tnh ton bng phng php

    khong chia ph ti kinh t c s sai lch .

    Bng 4.1 So snh kt qu

  • 58

    Kt qu ca vic gii

    bi ton bng phng php

    khong chia kinh t

    S liu qui

    hoch

    Gam cng sut MBA 250 KVA 400 KVA

    S lng MBA 102 46

    iu cho ta thy trong cng tc qui hoch, kho st thit k cung

    cp in cho khu dn c, khu th cn phi quan tm ng mc vic tnh

    ton hp l, tnh chn ti u thit b

    3.8.2 : Kt qu trn ch l kt qu lm c s cho vic lp Bo co

    nghin cu kh thi. Trong qu trnh thit k c th cho tng hng mc ca

    d n, vic cung cp in s c tnh ton cho tng trng hp, nhng vn

    phi tun th theo ni dung c bn ca Bo co nghin cu kh thi

  • 59

    CHNG 4 : KT LUN V HNG NGHIN

    CU TIP THEO 4.1 KT LUN

    1/ Trong qu trnh nghin cu bi ton chung cho cc trng hp,

    chng ta nhn thy

    + ng vi mt gam MBAPP c chn l mt di gi tr mt ph

    ti V xc nh ( xem hnh 4.2)

    + Ti min V chuyn tip 2 gam MBAPP xy ra s dao ng trong

    vic tnh chn MBAPP ( Xem hnh 4.1) :

    Qua chng ta thy rng, vic tm kim mt phng php khoa hc

    trong vic xc nh cu trc hp l cho HTCCT l cn thit

    S

    S4

    S3S2

    S1V

  • 60

    V' V' V' (VA/m2)Hnh 4.1 S ph thuc ca cng sut MBAPP c chn theo mt phti 2/ Phng php khong chia kinh t vi thut ton v ni dung chi

    tit cc bc tnh ton nh trnh by , mt mc cho php l c th

    chp nhn c trong vic tnh chn cu trc hp l cho HTCCT ni

    chung v Khu th mi in Nam in Ngc ni ring. Phng php ny

    cn c th vn dng cho mt s khu th mi, c qui m, c im tng

    t nh Khu th mi in Nam - in Ngc

    050100150200250300350400450

    0.5 5.5 10.515.520.525.530.535.540.545.5

    Hnh 4.2 Minh ho s ph thuc ca cng sut MBAPP c chn

    theo mt ph ti

  • 61

    4.2 HNG NGHIN CU TIP THEOKhi tnh ton kinh t-k thut li phn phi th, chng ta cn phi

    xem xt c li 22KV, TBAPP v c li 0,4KV trong mt th thng nht

    v chng l nhng phn t c bn cu to nn li phn phi th v lin

    h cht ch vi nhau v ch vn hnh cng nh cu trc (tnh phi hp

    gia cc li trung v h th trong cng mt tuyn, s b tr cc TBAPP

    cng quan l n li trung th ...)

    Hin nay, bi ton xc nh cu trc hp l li trung th cung cp

    in khu th trong mt s trng hp xc nh cng c th gii quyt

    c

    Tuy nhin, vn phi hp c li trung th, h th v cc TBAPP

    trong mt bi ton chung xc nh cu trc hp l li phn phi th

    vn cn l mt vn cn phi quan tm, v y cng l hng nghin cu

    tip theo ca bn thn ti.

  • 62

    CC TI LIU THAM KHO : [1] Trn Bch (2002), Li in v h thng in, NXB Khoa hc v

    K thut

    [2] B Xy dng (1999), Qui chun xy dng Vit Nam

    [3] ng Ngc Dinh, Nguyn Hu Khi,Trn Bch (1981), H thng

    in I v II, NXB i hc v Trung hc chuyn nghip

    [4] ng Ngc Dinh, Nguyn Cng Hin, Nguyn nh Ho (1987),

    Cung cp in trong cc lnh vc kinh t quc dn, NXB

    i hc v Trung hc chuyn nghip

    [5] Nguyn Vn m (2001), Mng li in, NXB Khoa hc-K

    thut

    [6] Nguyn Sn Hi (2003) Thuyt minh qui hoch chi tit Khu

    th pha bc- th mi in Nam in Ngc Vin Qui

    hoch th-nng thn

    [7] Nguyn Cng Hin, Nguyn Mnh Hoch (2001), H thng cung

    cp in ca x nghip cng nghip, th v nh cao tng,

    NXB Khoa hc v K thut

    [8] Nguyn c Ngha (1998), Ti u ho, NXB Gio dc

    [9] Ng Hng Quang, V Vn Tm .(1980) Thit k cp in, NXB

  • 63

    Khoa hc K thut

    [10] Trn Vinh Tnh (2001), p dng cc phng php ti u ho

    nhm nng cao hiu qu kinh t vn hnh h thng cung

    cp in, (Lun vn tin s khoa hc)

    [11] Trn Vinh Tnh (2001), Bi ging Qui hoch in, ( Lu hnh

    ni b)

    [12] ng Quc Thng (2003), Mt s vn v qui hoch, Thit k

    v vn hnh cc h thng cung cp in cho th, (Lu

    hnh ni b)

    [13] Mandal, S. (2002), Distrib. feeder conductor selection

    optimization, IEEE Transactions on power systems Vol. 17

    PH LC 1 CHNG TRNH TNH TON VIT TRN PASCAL

    program DIENNAM_DIENNGOC;

    uses crt;

    const

    Kdd=0.7;Kdt=0.7;Kqt=1.3;anfa1=0.125;anfa2=0.04;Lkc=40;t0=1600;T=8760;Ltb1=60;Ltb2=450;var F1:array[1..3] of integer ; (*Tietdien*) K1:array[1..3] of real; (* gia thanh cap nhanh*) F2:array[1..5] of integer ;

  • 64

    K2:array[1..5] of integer; I1:array[1..3] of real; I2:array[1..5] of real; r1:array[1..3] of real; r2:array[1..5] of real; Sbdm:array[1..6]of integer; Smax:array[1..6]of integer; dPo:array[1..6] of real; dPn:array[1..6] of real; Zmba:array[1..6] of real; Z2:array[1..5] of real; Z1:array[1..3] of real; ZL2:array[1..6]of real; ZL1:array[1..6]of real; Zha:array[1..6]of real; K: array[1..6] of integer; (* gia thanh 1 TBA*) Nb:array[1..6] of integer;(*So TBA*) D,T1,T2,T3,xima,Fb,Fa,K02,K01,r01,r02,L1ph,L2ph,L2,L1,Lcp,min,Z:Real;N1,N2,N,S,a,m,c:integer; begin ClrScr; (************************************************) BEGIN (* CHI PHI TINH TOAN 1 TBA*) (************************************************)Sbdm[1]:=100;Sbdm[2]:=160;Sbdm[3]:=180;Sbdm[4]:=250;Sbdm[5]:=320;Sbdm[6]:=400;K[1]:=118; K[2]:=132; K[3]:=138; K[4]:=152; K[5]:=173; K[6]:=198;(*gia thanh TBA*) dPo[1]:=0.32;dPo[2]:=0.5;dPo[3]:=0.53;dPo[4]:=0.64;dPo[5]:=0.7; dPo[6]:=0.84;

  • 65

    dPn[1]:=2.05;dPn[2]:=2.95;dPn[3]:=3.15;dPn[4]:=4.1;dPn[5]:=4.82;dPn[6]:=5.75;Writeln(' KET QUA BAI TOAN LUA CHON CAU TRUC HOP LY HT CUNG CAP DIEN '); writeln(' KHU DO THI MOI DIEN NAM- DIEN NGOC'); writeln('*************************************************');write('Nhap dien tich khu vuc khao sat D(km2) = ');readln(D); write('Nhap gia dien c = ');readln(c); write('Nhap mat do phu tai xima = ');readln(xima); writeln(' HAM CHI PHI TINH TOAN CHO 1 TBA'); writeln(' Theo cong suat MBA'); writeln('Sbdm(KVA) Smax(KVA) Gia thanh(trieu dong) Zmba(trieu dong)'); writeln(' '); for a:=1 to 6 do begin Smax[a]:=round(Kqt*Sbdm[a]); T1:=(anfa1+anfa2)*K[a]; T2:= dPo[a]*T*c*1.0E-06 ; T3:= (Smax[a]/Sbdm[a])*(Smax[a]/Sbdm[a])*dPn[a]*t0*c*1.0E-06; Zmba[a]:=T1+T2+T3; Writeln(Sbdm[a]:5,Smax[a]:10,K[a]:20,'',Zmba[a]:11); end; readln; END; (**************************************************) BEGIN (*CHI PHI TINH TOAN CHO CAP TRUC *) (**************************************************)

  • 66

    begin F2[1]:=70; F2[2]:=95; F2[3]:=120; F2[4]:=150; I2[1]:=213; I2[2]:=263; I2[3]:=298; I2[4]:=336; r2[1]:=0.533;r2[2]:=0.385;r2[3]:=0.305;r2[4]:=0.248;K2[1]:=263 ; K2[2]:=310; K2[3]:=339; K2[4]:=403;min:=1000;(*chon gia tri ban dau de tim gia tri cuc tieu*) writeln(' HAM CHI PHI TINH TOAN CAP TRUC'); writeln(' Theo tiet dien cap truc'); writeln('F(mm2) Z2(trieu dong)'); writeln(' '); for a:=1 to 4 do begin T1:=(anfa1+anfa2)*K2[a]*Ltb2*1.0E-03; T2:=Ltb1*Ltb1*Ltb2*Ltb2*xima*xima*Kdd*Kdd*Kdt*Kdt*r2[a]*Ltb2*t0*c*1.0E-12; Z2[a]:=T1+(T2/(3*380*380)); writeln(F2[a]:3,' ',Z2[a]:11); if Z2[a]

  • 67

    Writeln('CHI PHI TINH TOAN CAP TRUC DA CHON UNG VOI Smba ');writeln('Sbdm(KVA)Ham chi phi tinh toan cap truc(trieu dong)'); writeln(' '); L1ph:=sqrt((2*0.04*380*380*1000)/(Ltb1*xima*Kdd*Kdt*r02*0.9)); for a:=1 to 6 do (* 6 chung loai may*) begin min:=4*Ltb1*Kdt*Kdd*xima; L2ph:=(Smax[a]/min)*1000; if L1ph

  • 68

    writeln(' '); begin for a:=1 to 3 do (*3 loai cap nhanh*) begin T1:=(anfa1+anfa2)*K1[a]*Ltb1*0.001;T2:=Ltb1*Ltb1*Lkc*Lkc*xima*xima*Kdd*Kdd*Kdt*Kdt*r1[a]*Ltb1*t0*c*1.0E-12; Z1[a]:=T1+(T2/(380*380)); writeln(F1[a]:3,' ',Z1[a]:9); if Z1[a]

  • 69

    else L1:=Ltb1; for a:=1 to 6 do (* 6 chung loai may*) begin L2ph:=(Sbdm[a]*Kqt*1000)/(4*L1*Kdt*Kdd*xima); if L1phN2 then Nb[a]:=N1 else Nb[a]:=N2; end; readln; end; END; (**************************************************) BEGIN (*CHI PHI TINH TOAN LUOI HA AP*) (**************************************************) writeln(' CHI PHI TINH TOAN LUOI HA AP'); writeln(' Theo cong suat TBA'); writeln('Sbdm(KVA) Nb Zha(trieu dong)'); writeln(' '); Z:=9.0E+20; for a:=1 to 6 do (* 6 chung loai may*) begin Zha[a]:=Nb[a]*(Zmba[a]+ZL1[a]+ZL2[a]);

  • 70

    if Zha[a]

  • 71

    PH LC 2

    KT QU BI TON XC NH CU TRC HP L HTCC KHU TH MI IN NAM-IN NGC

    ******************************************************

    Nhap dien tich khu vuc khao sat D = 5.2 [km2]

    Nhap gia dien c = 630 [d/kWh]

    Nhap mat do phu tai xima = 13 [VA/m2]

    ******************************************************

    Dien tich khu vuc dang khao sat la : 5.2E+00 km2

    Gam cong suat MBA la : 250 KVA

    So luong MBA la : 102 may

    Chung loai cap truc la : 1.20E+02 mm2

    Chieu dai cap truc hop ly la : 4.26E+02 m

    Chung loai cap nhanh la : 3.5E+01 mm2

    Chieu dai cap nhanh hop ly la : 6.00E+01 m

  • 72

    ******************************************************

    PH LC 3

    CHI PH TNH TON LI H P

    KHU TH MI IN NAM - IN NGC

    ( Theo mt ph ti V (bc nhy 0.1 VA/m2 ) v SBdm )

    Din tch khu vc kho st D = 5,2 km2

    Gi in c = 630 [ /kWh ]V 100 160 180 250 320 400 (KVA)

    5.00E-01 9.104E+03 9.898E+03 1.023E+04 1.166E+04 1.352E+04 1.622E+04

  • 73

    1.00E+00 9.302E+03 1.013E+04 1.047E+04 1.192E+04 1.380E+04 1.652E+04

    1.50E+00 9.292E+03 1.014E+04 1.049E+04 1.194E+04 1.380E+04 1.651E+04

    2.00E+00 9.596E+03 1.044E+04 1.080E+04 1.228E+04 1.419E+04 1.695E+04

    2.50E+00 9.910E+03 1.055E+04 1.091E+04 1.241E+04 1.432E+04 1.710E+04

    3.00E+00 1.025E+04 1.050E+04 1.087E+04 1.235E+04 1.425E+04 1.700E+04

    3.50E+00 1.058E+04 1.077E+04 1.115E+04 1.266E+04 1.460E+04 1.741E+04

    4.00E+00 1.073E+04 1.087E+04 1.124E+04 1.276E+04 1.470E+04 1.752E+04

    4.50E+00 1.105E+04 1.103E+04 1.142E+04 1.296E+04 1.491E+04 1.774E+04

    5.00E+00 1.125E+04 1.120E+04 1.139E+04 1.303E+04 1.500E+04 1.786E+04

    5.50E+00 1.154E+04 1.140E+04 1.165E+04 1.309E+04 1.504E+04 1.787E+04

    6.00E+00 1.175E+04 1.170E+04 1.176E+04 1.326E+04 1.523E+04 1.810E+04

    6.50E+00 1.204E+04 1.191E+04 1.212E+04 1.320E+04 1.517E+04 1.802E+04

    7.00E+00 1.239E+04 1.208E+04 1.212E+04 1.326E+04 1.523E+04 1.808E+04

    7.50E+00 1.270E+04 1.240E+04 1.254E+04 1.354E+04 1.553E+04 1.843E+04

    8.00E+00 1.297E+04 1.248E+04 1.261E+04 1.360E+04 1.559E+04 1.849E+04

    8.50E+00 1.407E+04 1.327E+04 1.316E+04 1.339E+04 1.383E+04 1.547E+04

    9.00E+00 1.418E+04 1.350E+04 1.335E+04 1.353E+04 1.387E+04 1.543E+04

    9.50E+00 1.472E+04 1.370E+04 1.352E+04 1.346E+04 1.400E+04 1.539E+04

    1.00E+01 1.485E+04 1.400E+04 1.380E+04 1.371E+04 1.410E+04 1.553E+04

    1.05E+01 1.537E+04 1.415E+04 1.392E+04 1.377E+04 1.431E+04 1.561E+04

    1.10E+01 1.543E+04 1.428E+04 1.415E+04 1.397E+04 1.437E+04 1.586E+04

    1.15E+01 1.586E+04 1.439E+04 1.424E+04 1.416E+04 1.455E+04 1.583E+04

    1.20E+01 1.587E+04 1.478E+04 1.469E+04 1.433E+04 1.476E+04 1.580E+04

    1.25E+01 1.635E+04 1.485E+04 1.475E+04 1.448E+04 1.491E+04 1.577E+04

  • 74

    1.30E+01 1.683E+04 1.523E+04 1.489E+04 1.462E+04 1.505E+04 1.609E+04

    1.35E+01 1.675E+04 1.527E+04 1.522E+04 1.474E+04 1.517E+04 1.614E+04

    1.40E+01 1.715E+04 1.573E+04 1.522E+04 1.508E+04 1.528E+04 1.642E+04

    1.45E+01 1.762E+04 1.572E+04 1.564E+04 1.518E+04 1.538E+04 1.630E+04

    1.50E+01 1.745E+04 1.608E+04 1.561E+04 1.526E+04 1.567E+04 1.655E+04

    1.55E+01 1.789E+04 1.604E+04 1.602E+04 1.559E+04 1.575E+04 1.673E+04

    1.60E+01 1.921E+04 1.717E+04 1.671E+04 1.611E+04 1.621E+04 1.684E+04

    1.65E+01 1.960E+04 1.753E+04 1.711E+04 1.643E+04 1.627E+04 1.706E+04

    1.70E+01 2.005E+04 1.743E+04 1.741E+04 1.646E+04 1.654E+04 1.706E+04

    1.75E+01 1.975E+04 1.777E+04 1.739E+04 1.678E+04 1.658E+04 1.725E+04

    1.80E+01 2.018E+04 1.820E+04 1.769E+04 1.678E+04 1.685E+04 1.743E+04

    1.85E+01 2.061E+04 1.855E+04 1.799E+04 1.709E+04 1.687E+04 1.760E+04

    1.90E+01 2.099E+04 1.837E+04 1.792E+04 1.740E+04 1.714E+04 1.757E+04

    1.95E+01 2.143E+04 1.871E+04 1.821E+04 1.737E+04 1.714E+04 1.793E+04

    2.00E+01 2.187E+04 1.905E+04 1.859E+04 1.767E+04 1.755E+04 1.788E+04

    2.05E+01 2.140E+04 1.939E+04 1.889E+04 1.761E+04 1.753E+04 1.806E+04

    2.10E+01 2.182E+04 1.914E+04 1.875E+04 1.791E+04 1.778E+04 1.818E+04

    2.15E+01 2.219E+04 1.947E+04 1.904E+04 1.821E+04 1.774E+04 1.835E+04

    2.20E+01 2.258E+04 1.986E+04 1.939E+04 1.838E+04 1.797E+04 1.843E+04

    2.25E+01 2.292E+04 2.011E+04 1.960E+04 1.820E+04 1.815E+04 1.853E+04

    2.30E+01 2.326E+04 2.036E+04 1.981E+04 1.841E+04 1.833E+04 1.880E+04

    2.35E+01 2.360E+04 2.061E+04 2.010E+04 1.863E+04 1.851E+04 1.889E+04

    2.40E+01 2.388E+04 2.086E+04 2.031E+04 1.884E+04 1.836E+04 1.889E+04

  • 75

    2.45E+01 2.422E+04 2.111E+04 2.060E+04 1.906E+04 1.854E+04 1.899E+04

    2.50E+01 2.455E+04 2.136E+04 2.081E+04 1.927E+04 1.871E+04 1.909E+04

    2.55E+01 2.489E+04 2.093E+04 2.049E+04 1.949E+04 1.888E+04 1.935E+04

    2.60E+01 2.522E+04 2.123E+04 2.070E+04 1.970E+04 1.906E+04 1.944E+04

    2.65E+01 2.551E+04 2.148E+04 2.098E+04 1.946E+04 1.923E+04 1.942E+04

    2.70E+01 2.584E+04 2.172E+04 2.118E+04 1.967E+04 1.941E+04 1.951E+04

    2.75E+01 2.618E+04 2.196E+04 2.139E+04 1.988E+04 1.922E+04 1.976E+04

    2.80E+01 2.535E+04 2.220E+04 2.166E+04 2.009E+04 1.951E+04 1.986E+04

    2.85E+01 2.567E+04 2.244E+04 2.187E+04 2.020E+04 1.968E+04 2.010E+04

    2.90E+01 2.594E+04 2.268E+04 2.214E+04 2.041E+04 1.984E+04 2.020E+04

    2.95E+01 2.626E+04 2.292E+04 2.235E+04 2.061E+04 2.001E+04 2.014E+04

    3.00E+01 2.658E+04 2.322E+04 2.263E+04 2.082E+04 2.018E+04 2.024E+04

    3.05E+01 2.689E+04 2.347E+04 2.283E+04 2.103E+04 2.035E+04 2.034E+04

    3.10E+01 2.721E+04 2.371E+04 2.311E+04 2.123E+04 2.052E+04 2.058E+04

    3.15E+01 2.749E+04 2.395E+04 2.331E+04 2.144E+04 2.029E+04 2.068E+04

    3.20E+01 2.780E+04 2.419E+04 2.352E+04 2.113E+04 2.046E+04 2.091E+04

    3.25E+01 2.812E+04 2.443E+04 2.308E+04 2.133E+04 2.062E+04 2.101E+04

    3.30E+01 2.844E+04 2.467E+04 2.328E+04 2.153E+04 2.079E+04 2.092E+04

    3.35E+01 2.876E+04 2.491E+04 2.354E+04 2.173E+04 2.095E+04 2.102E+04

    3.40E+01 2.903E+04 2.438E+04 2.374E+04 2.193E+04 2.112E+04 2.124E+04

    3.45E+01 2.935E+04 2.461E+04 2.400E+04 2.205E+04 2.128E+04 2.134E+04

    3.50E+01 2.967E+04 2.484E+04 2.420E+04 2.225E+04 2.145E+04 2.144E+04

    3.55E+01 2.998E+04 2.507E+04 2.447E+04 2.245E+04 2.161E+04 2.167E+04

    3.60E+01 3.030E+04 2.530E+04 2.466E+04 2.265E+04 2.187E+04 2.177E+04

  • 76

    3.65E+01 3.057E+04 2.554E+04 2.486E+04 2.285E+04 2.204E+04 2.199E+04

    3.70E+01 3.089E+04 2.577E+04 2.513E+04 2.304E+04 2.176E+04 2.209E+04

    3.75E+01 3.121E+04 2.600E+04 2.533E+04 2.324E+04 2.192E+04 2.196E+04

    3.80E+01 3.152E+04 2.623E+04 2.559E+04 2.344E+04 2.208E+04 2.206E+04

    3.85E+01 3.184E+04 2.652E+04 2.579E+04 2.364E+04 2.224E+04 2.228E+04

    3.90E+01 3.211E+04 2.675E+04 2.605E+04 2.326E+04 2.240E+04 2.238E+04

    3.95E+01 3.243E+04 2.698E+04 2.625E+04 2.345E+04 2.256E+04 2.259E+04

    4.00E+01 3.275E+04 2.721E+04 2.651E+04 2.364E+04 2.272E+04 2.269E+04

    4.05E+01 3.306E+04 2.744E+04 2.671E+04 2.383E+04 2.288E+04 2.279E+04

    4.10E+01 3.338E+04 2.767E+04 2.691E+04 2.395E+04 2.304E+04 2.301E+04

    4.15E+01 3.385E+04 2.857E+04 2.800E+04 2.508E+04 2.373E+04 2.385E+04

    4.20E+01 3.417E+04 2.886E+04 2.821E+04 2.528E+04 2.389E+04 2.407E+04

    4.25E+01 3.448E+04 2.909E+04 2.847E+04 2.548E+04 2.406E+04 2.368E+04

    4.30E+01 3.480E+04 2.933E+04 2.868E+04 2.568E+04 2.422E+04 2.390E+04

    4.35E+01 3.511E+04 2.956E+04 2.894E+04 2.588E+04 2.438E+04 2.400E+04

    4.40E+01 3.539E+04 2.980E+04 2.915E+04 2.608E+04 2.464E+04 2.421E+04

    4.45E+01 3.570E+04 3.003E+04 2.827E+04 2.628E+04 2.480E+04 2.432E+04

    4.50E+01 3.602E+04 3.027E+04 2.847E+04 2.647E+04 2.496E+04 2.453E+04

    4.55E+01 3.633E+04 3.050E+04 2.867E+04 2.667E+04 2.513E+04 2.463E+04

    4.60E+01 3.665E+04 3.079E+04 2.892E+04 2.603E+04 2.529E+04 2.474E+04

    4.65E+01 3.692E+04 3.103E+04 2.912E+04 2.622E+04 2.545E+04 2.495E+04

    4.70E+01 3.724E+04 3.126E+04 2.938E+04 2.634E+04 2.535E+04 2.505E+04

    4.75E+01 3.752E+04 3.236E+04 3.034E+04 2.765E+04 2.642E+04 2.613E+04

  • 77

    4.80E+01 3.783E+04 3.260E+04 3.060E+04 2.785E+04 2.658E+04 2.624E+04

    4.85E+01 3.815E+04 3.283E+04 3.080E+04 2.804E+04 2.675E+04 2.645E+04

    4.90E+01 3.842E+04 3.307E+04 3.106E+04 2.824E+04 2.691E+04 2.656E+04

    4.95E+01 3.873E+04 3.331E+04 3.126E+04 2.844E+04 2.708E+04 2.678E+04

    5.00E+01 3.904E+04 3.355E+04 3.146E+04 2.864E+04 2.724E+04 2.689E+04