هدم نظرية التطور في عشرين سؤالا. Arabic العربية

" !

& " . . "

8 .

8 C .

&G I! K

. . .

"Q 8 ! G T

8 I & U 8 8 !

&

. 8 " 8

G. C" T " .

" " c " !G 8

"Q G d& e

.

U d " . !" d . & G

T . G & d. 8 &! m! C

&" I . !" n d & . . d

." m& s t 8 ! n. 8. v !" I.

.

3

"" " "

; ; 5 1 .

A D E 5 I .

. D A

; D O A

T ; E

T O . 5 E

.I D

Z A 1

; T ^ ;

.

T Db E

D E E D E E E c

. E E E

E O O:

;

( ) ( E)

E j .O ( )

.O I I b

O Db . D I O

A E E Z

. D I o

; r 5 D

. I D O T

;. D I

2

.

34 1 0/ "

/ 3 / 4.

0/ " F D/ .

4 4 M

.R 0 R0 / 0/

" / / " /

M / /

.

Z/ 0 M

3/ `

c .

0/ " ` /

.M d 0 F

0 3 0/ 0/

0i D/ h 4 .

4` 0/ j 0

k k / 30 R /

i4 l R .

M D i 4 / / R

. 4

" 4 R

4 R j 4

l. h /

h/ / - d3/

" - h M 4

F h h i j

0 D/ .

6

#" 5. ( 0 # ( . 7 C > 8; 8 ( LM. #" I ; M M " 8; . T# "8 ( ; " ( M " M

.

I [ " 8 . #" (

8M # 8 .

" ( # M 0 # " ( "

.

; [ d e LM 8" # I " M

. [ ( ( [ jM[ I 8 M 8; 8 M[ # # I 7( ( LM #

.m8 # 0

8

1

2 3 6 34 2 0 , + %

4 "; 9"

9

9 + V "

10

150 - . K ? & Z - 6 "d $". 6 6 - & K d 6 . 4J & - 6 v K l J 6$ $

- 6$ ... v J 6\ " J (

11

J" " " " " J6 & 6 ". "J J J 6 6- 56 "" & 6

$. & 6 6 5J $ "" J J d v $

.J J 6. \ F v F 6 $ 6J J v $ v 6 . 6 $ 6 ? F J 6 6\

" J" " J".

12

'

1

cJ 6 $ 6 J . & K & K v J . 6 & d $ Z

d F J. J 5 & 56 6 .

6 6 : .

13

6 - K K 6 . K K 6 c J - Z & J J6 6 6 56 J J6 J J J. 6 \ $ $ JZ

6K 6 v J. J $ d 6 Z6 $ 6 $ . 7 6 l 6 6 6 . K 56 \. 6 $ K 6 6 \ J J . 6 J 6 .J \ v 6 J F (

" "). v 6 K $ J J 6 K . 6 F

14

& 5 6 6 Z . - c6 6 Z 6 6 J 56 6 . v - c J 6 $. J J 6 c 6J J 6F

. FJ 6 6v 6 5 $ $ . K v FJ $ 6 v $ . J 6\ J J

6 : 6v . 6 6 $ cJ Z 5 c 6 J J6 6 & 6 K $ $ c . organelles $ ribos- $ 6 mitochondria $

6 cell membranes 6 6 omes

15

endoplasmic reticulum . J 6 6v

.v J 5

.J\ 6 $ (6 J 6 5 ( 7 4 J Z 3.5 . 6 J$ $ J$ 5 ( 6) v J

7 4 3 .

16

B @ : ;

C (B 3) C H H nucleosome ". "

(C). H @

B N3! B . B OB B H ! UB

3 B U @

B 4\ ] B.

J 5 J v . $ 4 Francis Crick J 5 6

J: " 6 F6 6 6

".1 Ali 5 J K

17

v Demirsoy :d

" v 6) v 6 6 J 6 5 ( . K

J ".2 K6 Homer Jacobson

: $ $ " 4 Z 6 effector mechanism 6 ). ( 4 6

& ".36 K .J 6\ $ $ J 56 6 5 J $J $ v6 .J $ 6 d 4 6 & $ $ 7 $ & 6 K . $. & v $ Z$ d 6 6 6 6 . 6J J &

18

B 3

C 3 .

' BB Ch B @

i B . !'

B C C C @

@ BB O .

19

v 6 $ . K 56 6 & v v . J$ d6 6 $ J 6v 6v

.J J J6 v 6 6 6 56 J. $ :v

.

B U

r .

U

H

.

20

2

v cJ :

.J v $ $ 6 6v $6 J" 6 K & 6\ ". J$ K 6 cJ

d . 6 "". $ $ 6 d. v

21

v 6 $ .Z5 F 7 K 6 6 6v & 6 6 $

. 6 Z . K \ \ 6 v \ & . disjunctive inference modus 5 v

.tollendo ponens

J 6\ K 6 6d cJ J 6 K J Z J . 5 - 6 J .

Douglas Futuyma : " 6 $ $ cJ J 6 . K $ J 6 J$ K . 6d v \ $ $ J 6

4".J $ JK $ $ $ cJ 6 6

22

. $ J$ $ 6 $ 6 J Z $ $ 6 J J6 $ "". $ & 6\ J .F v $ $ $ \ J $ 7 $ J $ $ 6 . 56 $ 6 v "" . 5 \: d K \ $ J J6 . $ J

$ . $ Robert Carroll vJ J$ J$ 6 6J J J

v $ : " Z $ J 6 $ Z J J

".5

H $ $ 6 $ $ . & $ J ""

23

H "@ @"

@

65

H

144

208

245

286

408

+408 H

438 3

505 H

550

H

630

H (

(

2500

' UB ! The Book of Life @ H B U H2001 HB . B 4B C C C

. 2500 . @ @ B ( .

! ). @ @ O !' .H

the Cnidaria ) H ). ' 13 @ H C

.U @

C B B @.

B h @ U B B B O ". " (@ 3 OB U ). B 3

3 . U . C C B B U 4 3 B

O .

24

.H @ C B :Marella

Burgess Shale

.H H

phyla . & 6 J & 6( Arthropoda $ v &. ) J6 $K 6\ $ $ $ J . $ Chordata $ 5 6 5. 6 $ $ J 7

J $ J$. $ $ 35 Mollusca $ J $ 6 . 6 Nematoda $& K 4 J $ K .

. & $ K

6 c J 6 v J. $ 7 $ 6

25

BN @:

B :Hallucigenia

C C @

H. U

N O H C

3@ .

H B U

B U C

h

N C .

B 3 C

U N

B .

$ . & 6 v $ 6 6v . $ $ $ 6

5 J . J 6 J 7 d . & J 6 ". " 6 Z J J 6\ 6 6

$ J $ . J. & J$

$ . . $ $

26

C C @

@ 500 B 3

H . @ BO .

.

Z5. 5 J J 6 $ J . 65 56 570 505 $ $ 5 & "J 5". K P. A. Nelson . Stephen C. Meyer . . v Paul Chien J $ v J K 2001 6 "J 5 v

Z 5 ".6 K 7 56 6 $ 5 . $ $ $ $ 6 v J 5. (

27

C@ C B UB @ C

@ H 550 . N BO C

C B . !' B B !

3 C. 3

C @ . ! @ U

500 ' ; B C @ !

.C3

28

!). $ J $ Z $ $ d J . $ Z J 6 K . & K$

J v Z . Richard Monastersky JJ Z Science News journal

:J5 5 J v" ... $ 6v $ cJ 5 .Z J5 5 J J 56 550

$ ".7 6 Phillip Johnson K J 6 6 5 J &

J: v6 " d J "l " J J d d v6 6 $ . $ 6J F l F6

K".8 J d

29

6 $ c $ . $ 6 6 $ 6J .J

$ J .

30

! HB O

' U

3

6 v $ v : J 6 6 cJ K . & $ J4 Z6 6 . 6- 5J $ $ "Z J4"

Mary Leakey 1977 Laetoli . 6J$ & Z. 6J$ J 3.6 . J 6

Russle Tuttle 5 4J Z : J & " 6 Z $ 6J ...

31

J 6Z ".9 Z J$ 6 4J 6 . 4J Z & 20 6 5 & 27 & 6 . & 6 Don Johnson v 6 J Tim White

5J . 6J& : " 6 ... 6 & J 4J 6Z 5 . K 7 6 & J Z Jv 6 J & 7. 6 J 6 $ J \

Jv . ".10 J6 l6 & Z J4 $J64 Z6 J4 J & 6 K 6 K .J K6 & 5 J 6 K . 5J 6 K 6\ . J Z J4 6 6 6 6 J .

B

3.6

.

32

6J J : " 6 4J Z 3.5 G 4J Z 5 ($) $ 6 56 . Z J4 $ 6 J . 6 6 6 J G J&... 56 v 6 c 4J 6Z d 56 "Australopithecusafarensis"11 .J6-

5 $ Z6 Louis Leakey 6Olduvai Gorge 5 $. u 1.7 . 6 5 7 K Z d 6 ( ) Homo Sapiens J 6\ 5. 6 & 6 6 5 6&

J 6J J 6 6. 5 2.3 6 Hadar J 5 6 5 cJ

12.J J 6 v6 \ 6Z 6 $ 6 KNM-WT 1500 .Turkana Child J" "

Donald Johanson J H

U 1.7 .

33

1.6 J$ : " 6 J 5 . 6

J 6 ".13 6 & v . 1.83 Alan Walker 4 6 5 $ J" 6 5J

5". 6 4J "

J".14 $ Z J .1995 6 Gran Dolina 6 Atapuerca J 6 . & 5 800.000J . $ & 6 J6

/h 3 3

3 1997 3

B B B C

U @ !

800.000 ! '

B

3: " "

34

B

@ (2000) h 4/ 2000

@ (1975)

B Neanderthals

C4 @ H 3@. 3 @

B @ BU CB3 . ' .C U B C B U B 3@. UB

B @ 26.000 @ . C B C

h ! B B

@ .U3B

35

- Juan Luis Arsuaga Ferreras 5 $ . v -:

" 6 ... . 6 Z & 800.000 J. ... J ... J $ 6 J Z . -. 6 J6d 6 ... J 6 . 6 . K 6 6 J . K$ 5 & 800.000 .

6J ".15 ." J" $ 6J 6 Z Z

3 !

B !

.

36

\ $ . " J" & J

. $" " C. A. Villie . v $ 6 J J6 P. W. Davis . . E. P. Solomon 5. .

16.5J J 6\ Bernard J Mark Collard J 7J Wood J 2000 "$ J J $ v J

". J J6 5 6 66 K v 4 ". " 2001 6 - v J 6 $ .Kenyanthropus platyops Daniel E. Lieberman .5 - v JJ

:Nature F6 6 .Z 5J J " 4 d vJ 3.5 ... - K. d7 J v$ i 6 5 d v

37

150

B B B h

C B

i @ " 3".

C 3@ U

C B

( H @ 2001). !'

B B B O N

H hB B !

i. ' 3

" 3" B !U

" ". ! ;

HB B;

3@. O B

! B '

\ ! .

B C @ B

?

?

1

8

9

2

3

7

((

6

(

)

4

5

5

1

2

?

8

4

9

3

3

7

((

6

(

) 6

4

5

1.8

5

1

8

9

2

3

7

((

6

(

)

5

4

5

1.8

1.8

5

38

5 - Z 6d 1 \ (hominin species) Z 6 . 6 6 6 J - v $ 6 Z $

$ J 6d ".18 6 6 6 6 J - Sahelanthropus tchadensis

2002. J. & $J6

$K 6 " 6 6 5

19." 6J J v v JJ: " ()

6 ".20 K 6 6 ( " " 7 - 6 ( J J6 Z6" 6 5 Australopithecus d6 J 6 ". K

h 3

@

:

!

National) . B 32

Geographic

(2000

39

J " " J .

6 56 John Whitefield Oldest Member of Human " 6Z " 2002 J 11 / J Family Found J J

J : " : J v "J$ J ". 6 5 J 1963 v J v . 6 c $ 6 . 6 5 J v v v v ...

6 ". 21 5J Henry Gee $ 5 6 v J .

J Guardian v v : " 6 6 " " ... 6 5

22." 6J $ J . & J

40

Z 6 c J4 6 c F J . & J 6 Origin of Species d 6 $. 6J 6 $ $ . 6 $ . K 6 $

6 6J Z 56 6-.

B 6 $ 6J 6 J 6 6 6 6\ 6 .v J

. 6 6d & $ 6 v 5 6 J J J6 56 d 6d .5JK 6 6 & J $. 6 J 6

.

41

'

" "

4

J J6 $ 6 6 ? ... - J 6 6 J 6 J. -. 6 K J6 Arda Denkel 6 6

Z d : 6 "J ? ? 6 v " $ Z J J". K 6 v v (v 5 $ v $ 6 ) J. K

42

. 6 $ 6 ".23

Z 7J \ J 6 " J - ". J Z K 6 & Z . K 6 J d Z $ $ J $ 6\ J. $J

& Z v J . 6 J J6 Z $ . dialectical materialism " " 6 6 .Z -

! 3 B "3

" !. B B

.

43

& . Z6 5 J 6 & Z J4 J

. $ J Z J K $. 5 J J 6 $

v6 l $ . .J J J Z . c 6\ K $ . . 56 J & v 6J G. W. Harper J . .

d : " 6 J J . K $ J

56 ..."24 d6 Z K ? J 6

.

44

' B 3

3

5

6- 6 J J 6 v J J 6 J .J J . v Z 6 : "K 6$ v J K" 6\ J -" $ 6 v Z4 \ $

$ 6- K$ $ "$ 6 J & J 6 . J $ d 6 Z -

"" variation 5 & .

45

Z J J $ J $ 6 d 6 J 4. $ J K d. 6 d $ J v $. J v K Z chromosomes $ $ .F d K

$ . $ 5. $ - - - cJ $ J 6 6

K & $ J. K 6 l J. 5K J 6v

B 3@

C C h

B

U 3@

C

.

46

$ J. J 6\ . v 6 v6 l $ 6\ 6

K. 7 : 6 6 genes . 6 $ J . v 7 6 Z F. 6 . K & . Z \ $ & . K 6 J v . J 6\ 6 6

. $ \ $ $ 4 $ K K . Z v . 6 J $ 6 J v . 6 Z4 dv 6 $ v 6 & $6 . $

47

J J 5 $ K \6 J . $ J $ d J &J K \6 . v

6- . K 7 & & : v -

d 5.

48

99 &

0

6

99 . . : ; . . B. F BF . :

M K J :.

49

3 99% 3

J J6 J $. 6 6$ J 6 6 " $ (6 ) 5 " 6 " 99 Z J Z ". $ J c

. J$ 6 6v/ 6 2002 \ 6J J v d K $ \- . K 6 $ " K .J J6 "%99 J %95. 6 J 6 Human,"$ 6 " CNN.com

chimps more different than thoughtJ : " J J 6 $ 5

6 . 6 $ $ 98.5 . J5 Roy Britten d J $ K J 7 J $ 6$ 6 J 6

5 \ 95 .

50

J J base pairs 780.000 5 ( 6) 5 5.

6 3.9 6

(6 ) 5 6 .

& K 5 5 J

". 25New Scientist $ \ $ v d " 6 6) 5 )chimps DNA difference trebled K 6 " 6 5 ( 6) 98.5 7 7

. 66 6F 6. 95 J 5

$ 6".26 & 5J v J

51

$ 56 $ J 6 6v 56 6 J 6

."dJ

H (B 3i U

J $ K $ $ 6 $ 6 .

5.J v 3 J (B 3) H %75

.27 K & 6

50

52

25% ! 6 4 K 6\ ! ' C 6 J$ 6 Z BC 3 C J

28.%60 J $ 6\ Z 56 6J J.29 & 6 6

.J

" N": B 6 5 6

53

$ \ $ 6 & Z $. J 6 . '

.N C B 3 '

K 6 & " " J " 7" 56 .

6 & v: Z $ ( ). K K "J$" . 6 6Z . K$ $ 6.

K J $ .J

J $ 5 J .

54

C ' 3

C !

7

J 6 . J & . J 6 K ?. 6 J 6 v 4 . J 4$ $ . v J $ 6 J- J J J & $ . K 6 $ . 6 $ J v

6 $ . J $ . $ J 6J J . K

55

K .J 6 6 J J6 $ . 6 $J J 6 6 J . v v : " J$ 6" 6 : "K 56 6 J

$"J J6 J $J v . $J 6 & .cursorial theory " " . cJ v J c 6 J$ J & . J$ 6 4 & . K 6 J 4. arboreal theo- "" v 6 .ry$J "6 6:

."F v ? 6 6 6 :J 5 J& \ v . J 6 6

56

.J $J 6 6 6 6 . 6i $

.v $J 6 J J6 J 6 J 6 K $. K $ 6 J $J J J J 6 $ J J6 $. & K .v Archaeopteryx"J6"

$ .

! @ "C

B B "

B

B .

O HB ' ! h

B B .

57

J J Z J $J 6 \ . 150 J Dromaeosaur JJ 6 Velociraptor J c .J$ v F 6$ J d 6 J$ 6 6

v . K 6 J$ v $ J 6 56 6- . 6 J J c d

56 . 6J J 6 J " " . F sternum (6 J) 6 J& . ( 6 J $ . J J J J

$ ). J & K & 6 K 1992. J J 5 6J J 6 .

: " J J v & .

58

K $ J 30 ."v$

6 6 J J& .

K 6 J 6 6 6 . K J J 6 J & & J 6 . &J K 6 v $ J vJ 6. Carl O. Dunbar: " J (J) J J ".31 6

:d ? vJ$ J $ J J " J J J J . 6 ? J J ... ? J J $ $ J Z cJ J J ... J

7 150 ..."32 7 6\ v J J 6 $J 6& .J Z $K 6 J 6J J 6 6 J J Z J $ . \ 6 J J 6 J J 6 . J J J

59

J Z $ J J .$J

B J J 6 7 J 6

6. 6 J 6

C B B O

HB . 3 !

B .

60

& $ 6 56 . K touraco J 7 6d J . hoatzin 4 & $ J 56 $ . 56 6- Z J

. J J 6 . 6J J & $ K . . K 6 6 . $K J d J -J 6 $K J $ 6 v J & J J 7

." "K J$ $K J& J 6 6 6 .$J6 56 6 v. 5. J L. D. Martin . J J K. N. Whetstone 5. J. D.Stewart $J . . 6 J & J 6 theropod Z $K $J J. 6 6 33.J J dinosaurs 6 Z J 6 J

J$ 56 .34 S. J .- v6 6 J$

61

M. K. Hecht . .Z Tarsitano 6 A. D. Walker .5 . $ 6John Ostrom Z 6 6 d 5 6 J J 6 & $J 6J& 6 6v J .5 . 35.$J6 J \ K

J .36 6$ Icons of Evolution J J 6 Jonathan Wells "6" J 6 ? 6 J. 6 $ K 6K $J$ Z J Z $K : "J 6 cJ $ $ 6\ 6

6 $ J."37 & 6 J ." $K J" 6 J .Z $K $J J The Demise of the $J J v" JJ Birds Are Dinosaurs Theoryv. Richard L. Deem J J J

J$ : Z $K $J 65 6 J$ "

62

J 6 6 ZJ JZ ."$J J7 $ 6\ "... J6 ( 6 Z $K " "? 6 J. ) Z $K & J$ . 6 6 J K $ Z Z \ 56 K J. Z K $ Z - () 6F 6\ J . 6\ 6 6

K $ Z $ J J".38 & 6\ 6 J d \ J 6 . $ 6 6d J J$ . $ 6 J Z J J . J J J & d6 6 d 6 c Confuciusornis

.J K

63

B 3: - 3

J" 6 $ 6 J "$J $J

Alan 6 J Z Julie Nowicki J J J Z J J 6\ 6 6J$. J 7J 6$ Eurek Alert

Z Z : 4 J J J Z" Z $J & 6 J 6

...$J & 6 J "6 : v ..."Z $K $J v 6 J J K6 6 $J "65" 6 " : J J K ... v \ J 6 Z 6 " K". J . J 6 $J 6

B

64

6 J J \ v

K "".39 J $ 6

:"$J $J J " $ ". : " & J v" $J 6 K 7 6J& " J $ 25 ! 80

B 7 H U 150 ".

'!" : h

h

3 \ @". "

B C' C @

B B @ . B 4; ".40

"J-" 6 6\ 56 J "6"

.

B C -

$ J J6 $ J 6 J 6 v 6 J. . 56 J J6 $ J $ J$ "J

65

Z $ ". J$ J J J 6 "$J-J" 6 K . $ 6 6

. J v6 Sinosauropteryx J .1996 K J" & 6J $J J" . K J 6 J 6J J J 6 "J "

. J " Plucking the Feathered Dinosaur " 5K

:Science" Z 6J $ v J 6 "K J J" J6 d 5 7J $J . J $ Yixian K J Formation 6J\ 6 v J 5 Z J $ d .J 6 : v F $ $

66

J ... $ 5J J - J 6 J 6

41."J 56 1999 6\ "- ."JK ."J " 6\ v National Geographic 6 $J" J 5K J " J & J J . 6 v d Archaeoraptor liaoningensis JJJ6

5 125 . J $ K J6 6 . Z $ & . -J 6 6J J . K -J 88 . 6 JJJ 6 K J6 $ . $

: " " JJJ " J 6 J 6 J 6 .Z 4 $J d6 $J Z JJJ 6 ... J 5JJ JJJJ 5

67

J 5 K .... $ J JJJ 6 6 6 6

J $ ..."42 v 6 Z & " J" v 6 J. Z6 v J 6 Z 56 6 \ 6

.Piltdown man scandal "" v J Z J J6 . 6 J -Jv. 6 J Storrs L. Olson 6 J J J . J 6

:J Peter Raven v 6 6" / $J" " J v 1998 National Geographic 4Society J $ 6 6 K . 6 7 $ 6 v 5 6 5 v

43."$J J J : . -. USA Today 5 v 6

68

0 -...

h / 1999

/ 1999h

29 '/ 2001

h

"-C" U

1999

U 3 .

B '

HB U

.

...

69

" 6 v $ 6 & $ ".44 J 6\ v v

.J 6 J v 6 6 .J & v6 Ernst J J K . v? J J6 J J. J Haeckel F 40 Z ."J 6 " 6J J " " Nebraska man " " J J 6 . reconstructions $ cJ6 "$

" 6 " ". v 6\ J J6 Z J 5 K . d \ J J . J J J J 5 F 6 d6 J J6 6 6

.

70

! HB

B " "

8

6 $ 6 J6Z 6 J $ J K .J 6 J J6 6$ recapitulation ""

6 .

"" 56 & 6 " J J " 5JJ 6 & c .

71

J 6 . Z & $ & 6 ZJ6 6 6 7 $ $ . &

6 "" 6 &. K & . K 6 J$ - $ J$ v - ? 6 6 J$ & . v \ &

6- \ $ 6J J $ . 6 c "" 6 K 5

! B .

72

.thymus parathyroid J J " F 5 "K 6 6 F Z . 6 K 5 6 6 "K" 5 5

J. & 6 George J J 6. J J

Gaylord Simpson 6 J : d . K 5J 6 " J J J 6

".45 J $ J 16

6v/ 6 1999: K () "6 ZJ - . 6 5 \ v . 7 6

".46 American Scientist $ 6

6: " 6 J 6-. 6 J $.

c d 5 $..." 47 v d ? $J 6J

73

& 5 6- . K J "" 6 K $J

.

Z ? v6 J N B . J6 ! 6& 6

J J : c $ 5 "" " 6 6 6 J6 Z $ c . 6 6 Z 6 J "" J

".48 6v/ 1997 ZJ 6 !3@ "B J .

:Haeckels Embryos: Fraud Rediscovered "h JJ v" ) ZJ) 5 d " : J d "... 6\ JJ6 J 6 J J &i

74

d J . "$ " 6 JJ F4/ 6

".49 $ :

6 6 &i " 6 JJ d $ 6 6 6. 10 $ 6\ $ K 6 d . $ $ 6 &i JJ J 6 7 . JJ 6: "(JZ ) 6

6 6 6 Z ".50

5 / 1997

75

$ ZJ 6 6 J J6 $J J d 1901 F . 6 $ J 6 J v 6 : J 6 &

.

3 3 8 / B 2001 N

B

3 William Dembski. !

@ B .

@ B BC .

76

'

"3 "

;

9

u Z ? v v K " J" 6 J& J J6 & . - . 6 d u 56 J J 5 6 Z J 6 . K v 6 J 6 l6 6 4 56 F $ 6 u

.J J

77

' (6 ) u Z 56 (6 ) . Z egg cell 4 c K .d J Z.

Z. K & .

' J Z K . J u ( . 6 6 ). 6\ u J Z J K . v 6\ J 7. J J "" &

@ (B 3) Bh @

. ! HB

. h ; B H B .

78

! C

3@ ! 3@

HB U .

B @.

" ". u J . K 5 c 6- J . " 6 " 6 6 ? 6 Louis Pasteur J F . u J

.Z \ d 5 6 Z . & 6 J J 6J l .Z J d 6 & 6J J $ 6\. 6 6v Z "u" 6 "6v "

.J \ 6J J - $ 6 K J

79

\ u Z Z v 6 . 6 6

. 6

B

C

B !

B B h

@ B

h

C7 .

3 B

C @

. 3

B HB

h

C B

.

' B

. h

U 3

.

' .

80

B CO 7 4 - u 6 6u "6 ". K u . K 6 u $ J 4 6. v J $ K . J 6 4 56 J 6. K

6 "6 " 5 6$ $ J. 6 - u .u v J6 K6 J v - 6 6 J & 30 J 4 & 30 Z. d u v . K " Z6" 6 Z u 6 J .(Z J 6\ J (

." " K 6 6 56 4 J 6\ Z &. 6 6 v $K Z

Z 4 : C i !' B h

( J / 117 )

81

? J v6 6\ J 6 . 6 6 J 6 K . FJ . 6 $ J " " 6 6 $

.J J 6 " " 6 6 6 7J

B @ B

10

82

6 J. .Chandra Wickramasinghe J Fred Hoyle "$J" 7 6 J . J & J 6 $ 6 6 $ v

cJ 6$ . Francis Crick James Watson 5 ( 6) 6 6 6 6 6 v 6 J. 7J6 6$ K 6 cJ 6

."cJ J " J\ 6J 6$ J J. $ $ v 6 . J 6

J J 6.

? " J" J cJ meteorites J . 56 6 $J J6 $ 5 Z 6 cJ. 56 6 56 $ macromolecules

6v .

83

d J K Z $ . c $ K $ ("$ 6 6 6 " optical isomers) . K $ \ c $K $) $ . J ) $

6 6.51 $ v v 5 & J Z 6

B N4 C ! i @ @ @

3 7 H . :

@ @ N B. !' 3 C

h4 B H BO .

84

6$ cJ. 6 J 6 J Z K cJ J . K J & J 56

.v 5 "J"7 v 4 : J J 6 v cJ $ d cJ

6$ . 6 J 56 6 & $ 6 6v 6 6 cJ. $ $

.J & J56

' " ] i" 6 6- 6J cJ 6 $ J. 56 $ K 6 . K 6 ?

& K J . cJ 6 & . 7J6 6 6 cJ v6 6 $ dJ.

.J J J K 6 J : \ J

85

"i3 ] C "B \4

@ 0 @

"D E "

. I

@ I

K

"IO N".

PI . I

O D

D Q

PI

. @ 0

0 D

" E D" -0

-

0 -0

. I -

"D E "

-0 0 @ V

VI " :

Q - ". D E

Q

Q I . IO

Q @.

86

J$ 6 . 7 6\ 6 6 6 56 6 J . 6 6v 6 6 J6 . 6 6 cJ $6 6 J dJ

J. 6 d v K

B ! B:

3@ + = ; @

! 3 BU B

B '! .

C C' C

3 @ !

. @ ;

7 B

. U

B B

( ". " " "

).

B "" !

] B

B . ]

" " HB B

B h @ C

: U

"B

B O

3 i ".

H C B

HB HB

.C

87

dJ \. Z 6 J " J 12-15 $ .the Big Bang " J. 56 6 cJ 4 6v 6 J K J . K 6 .J 6\ ? :" " " J (

.("J 6J "Z J" J 56J J Z 4 dJ. 6 6 i

J. "cJ J "$ 6 6 K . 6 66 v J cJ" "$ 6 6 K K) .dJ 6 ). K 6 5 J

.

88

i B '

B

11

$ J$ J J6 . \ J J 6 v .considerable time " " J 6 J . 7J \ 6 J J6 K

" ". Z 6 J 6 & v J . v J 6 d

89

Yaman -J6 Z. v J K J & 6 $J6 K" :rs

".52 . . K 6 J 6 - c K . J .spontaneous generation " " $ - 6 6 $ 6 d (J) $ $ &

N N @ @ B

B C B C B

C 7 @.

cytoplasm

mitochondria -

microtubules Z

nucleus 0

endoplasmic reticulum

Golgi apparatus

lysosome

vacuole 0

90

cJ . 6 6 6 -

F 6 l F .

K 6 6 Francesco Redi 5J F F $ & . . K J . F

6\ $ . 6 6 J 6 " " 6 6 6 .

. 7 J 6 $ \ $ 6& K . 6 6 Z FJ $ 6 6 6J- v6 J J6 6

.

91

6 $ 6 controlled experi- J FJ . 6 cJ6

ments 6 $ 6 J v K K \.

Z Z J $JK J 6 J J6 ? K . K J$ J J . J & 6 J$ & 6 6 J J $ J J d 7J

Z J$ . K 6 $ J J6

& . K v 6J J & $ " ". 6 ? . d v J d $ . F J . J J Z FJ FJ K FJ .

92

. FJ J J. & 6 v FJ

.Z v J 6 J dJK v. 6 J K J. K J 4J . . K entropy 5J " J" K 7 6

Z . Z cJ v 6 & 6J J .

.dJ Z 6 6 v v J 5 v 6 4 d d 6 & ". \ " 6 FJ 56 & $. K cJ . J K K . J 6 l 6 K$ $ . 6 . K $ J J 6 6 56 $ F . $

93

56 . K J& $ Z J J 6

. 6 K $. J J 6 J 5 J . K $ $ . 7 6 - 6\ 6 . d . FJ J d " " 6 $. J 4 6 40 6 400 Z 6 $

J cJ6 .

@ 7 B h ! B 4

. 7 B @ 7 7

h ! 3@. 'C

B; C C .

94

'

3

12

" J d 6 \ 6 6 J J6 K .vestigial organs " & 6 J $ J J6 6 K. : " 6

$ 6 ". 6 J J6 $J 6 c 5 \ J K - . K $ $ 6. 6 . 6 K .J J6 6

95

$ . 6 6 Z J J J $. K 6 c J 5 - 6 J

" ". 6 Z $ Z . . J J6 6 6 J J6 6 6 6 5 $ J

6 . J6 J- . J6J 6 & c &. J K

- 6 . J J6 6 6 - 6 6 - 5 c 6 5 J 6 \.53 K 6 $ 6- Z Z \. J$ 6\ 6 - 6 6\ 6- .54 $ - 6\ K -.55 d 6 - 5 \ 6

.c 5 J56 - $ - K K - $ 6 d . 6$ $ $

96

C .

J $ J& 6 Z . 6 v $ 6 $ v $ $ 6 . 6 $ -

$ $ . J4 $ 6 6 6 \. v 6\ 7 $ v - \. K & 6 "$" . K$ 6 - . K $

."5J J 56 "$

97

. + * & % 0 %6 4 0 . 0 ; %; 0 ;% ; B* 0. D G J % M J% * J% N% 0 0 %; + 0 % P .Q G % ; 300 0D

#!

13

98

K 6$ J K. v :Aykut Kence

K $ K J " 6 Z 56 5!

J ".56

! @ . K $ 5J -J v6 v6 $J $ 6J J 5 v v. -J 5 Frank L. Marsh J .v K6 6J J 5 $

Variation and Fixity in Nature C 6

! .57

6 J6 $ 5 K . J $ $

c 6J J . trilobites $

6 $K $ $

99

$ J$ 6? 6Z 6 . v $ . $ $ 5 \ $. . v JDavid Raup F 6K $ J J : " $ 450 J

58."Z

4 3 H H 3

h@ ' . C C @

334 4\ 3 h U .

.Zdenek Burian 34 H:

100

7 4 F 6 6 6\ J K. v

. \ 5 J J .d 6 $ 6 $

$ 6 5 \ $ J$

J. J v d . d $ J v" c 5J" 6

( K 5): " v 5 6 $ J 6 5 $ 6 $J 5J 5 J 56 6 v K ... J $ 6

3

101

J \ 5J $ 6 v K $ . 6 v J Z J $ $

6Z ".596 K" J: vv 6 $ 5J". 6 v J Z $ $ J v 6 Z v $ K J " $ ". $ ? 6$ 5 6. K 6 6 ". "K : 6 J J

$ J . v 6 v 6 J 7 v 4 6 . 6 v $ 6 $ $ . 400 & & $ 4 v 7 . 6 $ $ $

cJ $ .

B ;

102

6 6d 6 .

v6 v J$ 6 & $ 6 -J v . $ $ \ $ $

.(J 6 $ ( K \ $

U. C @ C @ 3

3C .

103

J " K Z J . K\ $ ". K \ $ 6 K

. K 6$ J$ J . 6 6 $ ($) $. \ 46 \ $ J copepodes $

\ $ $ 800 .

C "B"

6 $ J $ $ 6 $ . 6d J $ J Zi

.cJ$ $ K 6 v cJ 6Z 3.5 . K 6 $ K J J v 5 5 $K . J $ J. J 530 6 . ( 7 $ K .)

v $ . J v 6 $

104

$ $K . \. $ v

- J 6\ " ". 6J J $ K 6 J " " \ v . K 6 $ d J 6\

J . J $ . $

$ \ . & 6 7J 6 6\ J 6 "" . Z $. K 6 ( . & K

.("J : "J F d v d 6 6 J J6 J6 K4 K 6 $ $ J 6 & 5 6 J J .cJ K . d v$ 6 J$ 67 6 7 6 J $ J K. $ 6

105

J J 6 $ v . J 56 Z . v6 56 J K Derek W. Ager 4 J $ J J J" $

F \".60 Z J 6 $ J $ . K $ J$ 4 " $ 6

:"Z6 O B i C H

. 3 B

( J / 4 ) J . 6 J "Z" $ 6 4 6\ . K v J

$ .

106

'

14

. $ " " 6 v 6 Z J . Z "J" . K Z& 6 . 4. K J

v cJ 5 v . 6J J $ Z 4 . v " $

107

J". ( K 6 6 J Z. $ Z $ ). K J J $ d6" 6 Z". 6 6 $ v d6 Z J$

.

B

B J J6 6 6 J J6 v J Z J 6 Z 6

. Z \ 6 Leonardo da Vinci 3 3 7 . Galileo Kepler Copernicus Cuvier $ $ !\ $ Z Linnaeus Edwin !3 K Isaac Newton 4 $ 5 Hubble

108

4 . Albert B CB v: 6 6 Einstein

K J6 6 6 " J v .

: 6".61 Max Planck v

: 56 l 56 7J"$ 6 d6 d 6 : $ F .

".62 Z 6 J 6\ . J6 6 J$ v

v 6 5 6 . 6? 6 6 Z J 6\ 6 "". J Z 6 & . J

3 3

109

K 5 5 5 6 & 6 7J6 . $ 6 4 J 4 . J 6

& : C i B B

B

.

( J / 30 ) ! .

(J J$ / 47 ) v 5 Z 6? 6 . 6 . 6 5 ( 6) 5 Z . F \ 5

& 5 4 \ . K

h

110

.J 150 $ 6 J 6 J Z J . - 6 . K 6 J Z 6 J J

6 6- .

111

0/ + ' @ 0 = ; : 8

/ C ;. / . ; M C M: ; . + : M C 0N / 0 Q) ' (;/

& !

15

112

. J " 6

."J4 4$ v6 v 56 56 5 . .J $

$ $ 6 4 J 6\ 56 6 $ .J

"". "J " 6 6 $ 6$ v d 6 $ K . J $

. J 6\ d . Z J 7 " J" . Z 6J F . v 6 5 . K K 6 . 6 J K J- . J . 7 v

@

! B .

113

C

C3: .

C N 110

4.

K K. J Z v6 7 6\. v 6 4. d v 6 6 6 $ d 6 $ $ . K $ $

\ . J$ c 6 $ $ $ . K 6 $ 6J v d. 6\ $ v 7 $ $ v

6 & . 6 c J.

114

100 ! 150 .

.UB

! B B C

3BU

400

HB .

B C

C B

B B7 .

U B

B .

!

135 .

C

115

K 6 6 d v d 4. 6J $ 6 $ $ & Z . 6 6 J 6 $ 6

6 J$ . K 6 $ J $ 6 & "".

.cJ$ 6 " 6 6 $ J" "" J. 6 K . K v Z J . d J d 6 d 6 J v 6\ J . &J v $ 6 d. 6 "J6 " . J v ? 6 J & 150 . 6 5 J J 5

& 56 J6 .

116

3

B

16

J - $ K "

J Z J$ ". 6J J : " Z. J 6 C .

O ! ; ! ".

. - 6 Z 6 J K .Z 6 J- $.

117

6 "" 6 J 6\ 6 $ .

K 6J J J - 6 c 6 .

: 6 J v 6 6:

1. $ 6v 2. d 6 v d 4

3. 56 $ 6 $

65 v v & ?. K 6 6 J .

K v . " v" v .1 6 d v 6 .J5 6v Z "".

K : 6v & ? " 747 J

".63

118

.J J 6 5 Z v 5 Z Willian Paley Z 6 . J 5 \ 100 6 F K .cJ v56 ? 6 . F 6 J& 6 K. $ . \ J 6 K. 5

6 . . Z J$ v \ J $. v J6 iJ J 6 ?. \ 6 6J J 5 K 100 . K 6 Z 6 K J. J \ "5J " 5 . K 6 J$ $ $

119

\ 3 @

B h 3 3

B

B B

@ B

B B;

B C B .

v J " J F ( J "). $ . $ J J i

6. d 6 d 4 6 J J2. 6 d v 6 . Z .d 56 5J 56 5 6

120

Colin Patterson $ J & $ :

. 4$ 6 " v F 6 K J

J v & ".64 5 6 v 6 B. G. J . . J v J.

:Ranganathan

. J 6 $ "6 6 $ J $ $ 56 Z J v F K . 6 J Z 6

J ".65J d 6J $ $ 6 Z . J 6 56 6 J Z\

$ 6 J. 56 J 6 6 $ 3. $ "" . K $

121

. Niles Eldredge J $ JJ J 6

56 v J 56 $ : "7 $ $ 6 J 6 $ 6 K

$ 5J ".66 6 4 J$ Robert Wesson Beyond Natural J J 1991 $ "$ 6 Selection

". :" K $ . 5 6. $K $ 56 5 Z $ J 6 d d J d J v d J

" .67 v J ? 150 $ J$ . J 6 6 v . $ ? .

122

6 J J J.

J Z J. J$ 6 6 .

$ J 6 & v 6 Z & . J 6 $ & 56 $. 6 5 6 $ 6Z $ J \ J .

6 . J " 6 cJ " " Z 6

".

123

h'

3

17

$ $ & . v .metamorphosis v v 6 6J J 6 J J& .J & J J 6 "J v " 6- 6 6 $ d 6 6J J 6 J 6 . J J $ 6 $

124

J \ .

... F $ v $ 6 6 d . 4. v J J $ $ 6 . $ v K v J 6 . v J $ . d $ J v . J v J $ J . K$

$ v .

C h :

; .

125

h 3 6$ v v 6 d v . $ 6 12 . & $ v K 6 & $ . irreducible "& "

complexity 6 v . $ Z " " K Michael Behe

.J 6 Z 5 v 6 $ 6 K 6 6 6 6 . 6 $ & $ J J. v .

& v $ $ $ J $. . & 6 6 6 . J6 6 " "4 J .JK 56 6

J . Z d 6 & 6 6 56 J c - J

'

126

J 6 K . v v $ 6

.

! B h "3 "

" . ' B h "

3 C H "

3". ! h h " " B 3

.

127

6 Z 5 \ 6 $ . v "d Z 5" 6 $ \ 7J

$ . $ d J 10 $ 6 \. (6 ) 5

'

(B 3) "3"H

18

129

$ $ .

6 J 6 J & 5 Z d 6- 5 Francis Collins 5 $ \

.(6 ) $ $ 10 J 6 $ & $

.(6 $ 5 (

(B 3) H

3 $ 5 ( 6) . K d ( 6) . 100 K Z Z v K . 6 K J J 6) $ 5 ( . 5 1000

6 Z . K 6 $ 6 100 7 100

130

. $ & \ 5 J J6 K 6 6 Z 56 v . K 1000 Z : 100 J 6F! $ . K K cJ 56

J J $ . . $ & 6 6 $ $. & (6 ) 5 J K \ 6 6

J . 6 6 Gene Myers J J Z d Celera Genomics 5. $ 6 d 5 ( 6): " B' B @... ... !'

68 ."

131

6 6 4 7 6v K . & 6 6 $ 6 5 ( 6) . 6v $ 6 Z 6

J . $ . K

$ .

3) H3@ C '!

B) 7 !

.

132

6- 6 K \. J "" K $. 6 Z J J c "\ $ : 6 K J . ". K 6 6 6\ J $

. 6J J $ 5 ( 6) v J 6 . K 6 5 ( 6) 5 6 d $ $

133

. $. $6 d 6F 6 5 ( 6) . 6 5 $ J6 6 . 6 v J d J

$ 6\ v " ".

134

'

C3

19

J J6 v 5 - 6 - $ . K J 6J J & $ v J $ $ . $ $

.DDT 5 5 .d v6 K J J

$ " "$ J $ 5 v6 6\. $

135

.1928 Alexander Fleming J6 5 5 5 J 6 7J6 . v StaphylococcusK $ K $

. 6 K . $ J . : $ c $ 5 . $ .

K "J 6 J J6 v ".

. K d v 6 6 6 Lee Spetner .1997 5 Not by Chance " " 4 6

J. : 1. $ .

2. $ J .? K $ 2001:

$ & Z $ $ " . 6 & 5 5

136

E. coli H

6 & ... $ & $ 6 4$ 6 6. 6\ 5 c $ $

6 $ ".69 :"J "

... $ F " $ 6 K 5 d K ...J 6 $ J 6 6 $ Z 6 biocosm 5. $ 6 $ v $

70."d

! C3

3

.

137

6 56 J Z $ KJ $ J

. J 5 d

6. : 6 6 5 " nucleotide v v 5 5 Streptomycin ... Albert Schatz 6$ Selman Waksman v 1944 5 . 6 6 5 6 $ d 6 K J . K 6 d Z Z

5 5".71 " " v ? . ? 6\ Z . Z Z .Z Z 6 " " 6 K & \ J .

v & :

138

5 5 ZJ " Z 5. 6 J $. 6 ...J 6 $ d . K 6 J 6

$ \ ".72 JZ Z "" K J . . K 6 $ J . ( "". 56 Z 6 6 JZ 6 J JZ 5). 6 "" 5

Z K 5 " 5". J6 Z". J $ " v6 J 5 6 J

.v d 5 $ $K Z $ . $ 5 5J . $ J $ 6 " : & Francisco Ayala 6 $ d6 6 73." $ $ & $ 6 \

139

J 6& J Z v " () $ J" $.

4$ & & 6 K .J $ 6 $ J v $. K ? 6 $ 56 6\

v :$ 6 K . J $ " - 6 \ J $ J - 56 $. v 5 6 : $ 6 5 d

!"74

140

;

20

J 6 & 6 K . $ \ $

. 6 6 J J6 6 6- . 56 K $ d " v J Z J& ". \ 6F J . K J 6 "J " J . K 6 6

141

, J 6 6 6

J4. K J .

B 3@

B 3 6 J -J . 6 . v v 6 K .

. 6 \ . K & v 6 . 6 & 56 6 J- Z

. K J d " : $. K J 6 ". 6 J- "J " " J ". K 6 5 J 6 7J -J 7J 6 6 . 6

142

dJ 6 K iJ

. v . K 6

3 ; 3

Democritus B 3@ 3@

B h4 N 3@.

143

K J \ J \ 6 6 7 K K . J J J c . iJ 6

6 & 6.

3 v. K -J 6 6 . K Z 6 7 & 6 5

6& . FJ $ 6 6 6$ 6 . FJ 6J J & . K 6 J . 6J $ Andrew Scott v d

144

K 6 . & $ 5 J-

:d v 6 6 7 " $ & . v & v c 6 6 . $K 5 d . J d d 56 $ ($ \ Z ) c. 6 J . 6\ $ 6 c6 J

".76 66 K. 6 6

145

:" . & 6 c . i \ "" K \ ... & 4 $ 6\ v d

75".Z7 J 6 v 6- v 6 K . 6

3@ 3@ @

' 3

; @

7 . '

H H !]

!] .

'

146

. K $ 6. 5 J 5 K 6 $

. K 6 . "" v $ . "J J J6 6 . " 6 7 6 J$ . K $ 5 6 6$

7 3

4 3

27 4/ 1998

" ".

147

6 . 6 5 Science Finds God " " Newsweek J J 27 / 1998

d 5 .

148

Francis Crick, Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature, New .1

.York, Simon & Schuster, 1981, p.88

Ali Demirsoy, Kaltm ve Evrim (Inheritance and .2

Evolution), Meteksan Publishing Co., Ankara, 1984,

.p. 39

Homer Jacobson, Information, Reproduction and the .3

.Origin of Life, American Scientist, January 1955, p. 121

Douglas J. Futuyma, Science on Trial, Pantheon .4

.Books, New York, 1983, p. 197

Robert L. Carroll, Patterns and Processes of .5

Vertebrate Evolution, Cambridge University Press, 1997, p. 25,

((emphasis added

Stephen C. Meyer, P. A. Nelson, and Paul Chien, The .6

.Cambrian Explosion: Biologys Big Bang, 2001, p. 2

Richard Monastersky, Mysteries of the Orient, .7

(Discover, April 1993, p. 40, (emphasis added

Phillip E. Johnson, Darwinisms Rules of .8

Reasoning, in Darwinism: Science or Philosophy by Buell

Hearn, Foundation for Thought and Ethics, 1994, p. 12,

((emphasis added

Ian Anderson, Who made the Laetoli footprints? .9

.New Sceientist, vol. 98, 12 May 1983, p. 373

D. Johanson & M. A. Edey, Lucy: The Beginnings of .10

.Humankind, New York: Simon & Schuster, 1981, p. 250

.R. H. Tuttle, Natural History, March 1990, pp. 61-64 .11

.D. Johanson, Blake Edgar, From Lucy to Language, p. 169 .12

.D. Johanson, Blake Edgar, From Lucy to Language, p. 173 .13

.Boyce Rensberger, Washington Post, 19 October 1984, p. A11 .14

Is This the Face of Our Past? Discover, December 1997, pp. .15

. 97-100

Villee, Solomon and Davis, Biology, Saunders College .16

.Publishing, 1985, p. 1053

Hominoid Evolution and Climatic Change in Europe, .17

Volume 2, Edited by Louis de Bonis, George D. Koufos,

Peter Andrews, Cambridge University Press 2001, chapter 6,

((emphasis added

149

Daniel E. Lieberman, Another face in our family .18

(tree, Nature, March 22, 2001, (emphasis added

John Whitefield, Oldest member of human family .19

.found, Nature, 11 July 2002

D. L. Parsell, Skull Fossil From Chad Forces .20

Rethinking of Human Origins, National Geographic News,

.July 10 2002

John Whitefield, Oldest member of human family .21

.found, Nature, 11 July 2002

.The Guardian, 11 July 2002 .22

Arda Denkel, Cumhuriyet Bilim Teknik Eki (Science .23

and Technology Supplement of the Turkish daily Cumhuriyet),

.27 February, 1999

G. W. Harper, Alternatives to Evolution, School .24

.Science Review, vol. 61, September 1979, p. 26

http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/science/09/24/ .25

humans.chimps.ap/index.html

http://www.newscientist.com/news/ .26

news.jsp?id=ns99992833

Karen Hopkin, The Greatest Apes, New Scientist, .27

(vol. 62, issue 2186, 15 May 1999, p. 27, (emphasis added

(Hrriyet, February 24, 2000, (emphasis added .28

Harun Yahya, Darwinism Refuted, pp.207-222 .29

.Nature, vol. 382, August 1, 1996, p. 401 .30

Carl O. Dunbar, Historical Geology, John Wiley and .31

.Sons, New York, 1961, p. 310

Robert L. Carroll, Patterns and Processes of .32

Vertebrate Evolution, Cambridge University Press, 1997, p.

.280-281

L. D. Martin, J. D. Stewart, K. N. Whetstone, The .33

.Auk, vol. 97, 1980, p. 86

L. D. Martin, J. D. Stewart, K. N. Whetstone, The .34

Auk, vol. 97, 1980, p. 86; L. D. Martin, Origins of the

Higher Groups of Tetrapods, Ithaca, Comstock Publishing

.Association, New York, 1991, pp. 485-540

S. Tarsitano, M. K. Hecht, Zoological Journal of .35

the Linnaean Society, vol. 69, 1980, p. 149; A. D. Walker,

150

.Geological Magazine, vol. 117, 1980, p. 595

A. D. Walker, as described in Peter Dodson, .36

International Archaeopteryx Conference, Journal of

.Vertebrate Paleontology, 5(2): 177, June 1985

Jonathan Wells, Icons of Evolution, Regnery .37

.Publishing, 2000, p. 117

.http://www.yfiles.com/dinobird2.html Richard L. Deem, Demise of the Birds are .38

.Dinosaurs Theory. http://www.yfiles.com/dinobird2.html

Scientists say ostrich study confirms bird hands .39

unlike these of dinosaurs, http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_

releases/2002-08/uonc-sso081402.php

Scientists say ostrich study confirms bird hands .40

unlike these of dinosaurs, http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_

releases/2002-08/uonc-sso081402.php

Ann Gibbons, Plucking the Feathered Dinosaur, .41

Science, vol. 278, no. 5341, 14 November 1997, pp. 1229

. 1230

Forensic Palaeontology: The Archaeoraptor Forgery, .42

.Nature, March 29, 2001

Storrs L. Olson OPEN LETTER TO: Dr. Peter .43

Raven, Secretary, Committee for Research and Exploration,

National Geographic Society, Washington DC 20036,

.Smithsonian Institution. November 1, 1999

Tim Friend, Dinosaur-bird link smashed in fossil .44

(flap, USA Today, 25 January 2000, (emphasis added

G. G. Simpson, W. Beck, An Introduction to Biology, .45

.Harcourt Brace and World, New York, 1965, p. 241

Ken McNamara, Embryos and Evolution, New .46

(Scientist, vol. 12416, 16 October 1999, (emphasis added

Keith S. Thompson, Ontogeny and Phylogeny .47

Recapitulated, American Scientist, vol. 76, May/June 1988,

.p.273

Francis Hitching, The Neck of the Giraffe: Where .48

Darwin Went Wrong, Ticknor and Fields, New York, 1982, p.

.204

Elizabeth Pennisi, Haeckels Embroys: Fraud .49

151

,Rediscovered, Science, 5 September

Elizabeth Pennisi, Haeckels Embroys: Fraud .50

(Rediscovered, Science, 5 September, (emphasis added

Massimo Pigliucci, Rationalists of East Tennessee .51

.Book Club Discussion, October 1997

Evrim Kuram Konferans (Conference on the Theory .52

of Evolution), Istanbul Universitesi fen Fakultesi (University

.of Istanbul, Faculty of Economics), June 3, 1998

Leonard M.S., 1992. Removing third molars: a review .53

for the general practitioner. Journal of the American Dental

.Association, 123(2):77-82

M. Leff, 1993. Hold on to your wisdom teeth. .54

.Consumer reports on Health, 5(8):4-85

Daily.T 1996. Third molar prophylactic extraction: a .55

review and analysis of the literature. General Dentistry, 44(4):

.310-320

Evrim Kuram Knoferans (Conference on the Theory .56

of Evolution), Istanbul Universitesi Fen Fakultesi (University

.of Istanbul, Faculty of Science), June 3, 1998

http://www.icr.org/creationproducts/ .57

creationscienceproducts/Variation_and_Fixity_in_Nature.html

David Raup, Conflicts Between Darwin and .58

Paleontology, Bulletin, Field Museum of Natural History,

.vol. 50, January 1979, p. 24

Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species, 1859, p. 313- .59

(314, (emphasis added

Derek A. Ager, The Nature of the Fossil Record, .60

Proceedings of the British Geological Association, vol. 87,

(1976, p. 133, (emphasis added

Science, Philosophy and Religion, A Symposium, .61

published by the Conference on Science, Philosophy and

Religion in Their Relation to the Democratic Way of Life, Inc.,

(New York, 1941, (emphasis added

Max Plank, Where Is Science Going?, Allen & .62

(Unwin, 1933, p. 214, (emphasis added

Hoyle on Evolution, Nature, vol. 294, November .63

.12, 1981, p. 105

152

Colin Patterson, Cladistics, Interview by Brian .64

Leek, interviewer Peter Franz, March 4, 1982, BBC, (emphasis

(added

B. G. Ranganathan, Origins?, Pennsylvania: the .65

.Banner Of Truth Trust, 1988

N. Eldredge and I. Tattersall, The Myths of Human .66

.Evolution, Columbia University Press, 1982, p. 59

R. Wesson, Beyond Natural Selection, MIT Press, .67

.Cambridge, MA, 1991, p. 45

Human Genome Map Has Scientists Talking .68

About The Divine by Tom Abate, San Francisco Chronicle,

(February 19, 2001, (emphasis added

Dr. Lee Spetner, Lee Spetner/Edward Max .69

Dialogue: Continuing an exchange with Dr. Edward E. Max,

2001, www.trueorigin.org/spetner2.asp










Francisco J. Ayala, The Mechanisms of Evolution, .73

Scientific American, vol. 239, September 1978, p. 64,

((emphasis added




Andrew Scott, Update on Genesis, New Scientist, .75

.vol. 106, May 2nd, 1985, p. 30

Fred Hoyle, The Intelligent Universe, 76

.Michael Joseph, London, 1983, p. 20-21