~ ~ ~ ¥i"3lI(q~Cb ~ 1f.ItA' ~; Gtij~l\RJ q;1'i1 flZ/£i 8({llR rr!~m.~ iiflT!fi

~ <ti) 3m ~ vrm x-PHitqFh{fr~ ~ ~ ~ 312-??5~ 11092017 m- q'I-q •.r Xl\J'R{>.TR 3TW~.r e,rc:f s:i~IC1~<f$ m.rr ~ mi ~189i:ft ~ocfi ~ 13.09.2017 em ITu:n'~ tf~'iTm 12.15 ~ 3llrnRJio st. ~ <rrc~fcrilW-fcl+:M ~J10'$1CJl'? f.1'O<ilj~il~ f.:1uTzT~ 1fil :-

1. !IJ1f ~ ~ ~ ~ M 1ffiT ~-2016 (f)' ~ It 111"'~1l ~

i'lJllll<'lll.~ &RT lll~Q)I ~ 8310/2017, 8737/2017, 9152/2017 'Q'ii9556/2017 ~ 11.08.2017 ~ 9959/2016 ~ 16.08.2017 It ~~cf;~if~:-

~ bffi ~ fcnm 1Tm fu; ~ ~ ~ Y'£Illll('lll, ~ ;,

~ ~ 8189/2017. 8310/2017. 8737/2017, 9152/2017, 9556/2017.8189/2017. 8439/2017. 9572/2017 9861/2017. 9959/2017. # ~ 11.08.2017-c;ci~ 18.08.2017 G1ffi; ~ # ~ ~ TfC! ~ fc'I; .. In view of discussions. thoughthis court does nOI find any illegaluv or infirmity in the decision of the respondent Board !1l

reducina/lowerinu down the cui off marks for other catecories vide the decision of the Boardtakes i; its XO"'-mcL·ting held on ()3.0i.20 17. H(I\h'\'Cl~ since the sole reason for grantingrelaxation was that sufficient eligible candidates \\ ere not available in the reserved categor ic-,this Court feels that in th e undisputed facts obtaining in the present case, a relook by the Board isimperative. A review of a facts reminds that in the category of Ex-servicemen. only 3 candid.ue-,as againt the total 377 posts were found eligible. as such. it would be expedient and in theinterest of the rights of the petitioners that the respondent board thinks over for reduction of thequili !)'ing marks. as has been done in other reserved categories. This exercise is nor oill~imperuiiv e but nece~,;ar~ to ensure that the petitioners right of seeking appointment can be mademeaningful in light ofmandate given by honblc Supreme court in the case of state of Orris a v,.mohd, yunus &. Ors.

The respondent Board is directed [(I rake appropriate decision in accordance with law. after adenove appraisal of the factual position. within a period of one month from today bUI nOI than t 5'"September 20 I7.

with the direction aforesaid the \\Tit petitions arc dispoesd of."-31<1. ~ \3nJ" "'lI14k111 *~ ~ ~ 11.08.2017 <t ~ -q ~

cnr ~ 11' cRTa'fUT-c;ci~ fcnm fu;m 1Tm I

~ "imT 31lT4T 54 cfj ~Gq, ;$1 ~ ~ 03 c#r ~ ii il ~ R-ri.{i

'T<ID -g ftl; "~ em 31,~Mtmqft \ifR cm;fi q-&t~ 1) ~ ~ 40 ~~ \JfA ~ mf ~tRd m cf; ~ -f{ f.fom ~ 1flIT f<t> ~ 1l ~ ~cf; ~ ~ 40 ~ ~ ~"GfTCf1 ~ ~~ 40 ~3fq; ~ mfcf; CfiRUT ~ ~ -f{ ~ ~ ~ ~ t oT ~ ~ qR ~ W-f{~ ~ 'SIGFfqR ~I"

u~ .~<i ~ fffuq CfW rn-:;n<lffi JrtfiafCl) ~ IT ~ ~QT ~tRrlffi-2016 11 "ID'1 -wren ~. ~ ~mrqlR ~ tRrlffi ~ ~ m 'fl'lm ~(Ve,rtical) ~ ~ em '!mm <$ 3l1ffR ~TI+i ~ 40 ~ 3fcnT -$T ~ (f(f)

~ xm<lT +i 3N1W ~ ~ ~ <$ CfiRUT <iR.l -$T 54cff ~ ~ 22.09.2016 .t?jfRi! 'Tir ~ 3l1fTR <tri ~ 80cft- ~ ~ 03.07.2017 # !lll1fjqq; -c;ci ~ ~

¥1f-

ITI'll UnT<lTxl Jltl1!!-Ffi ~1;S IT ~~fTI1 ~ttn ~nil tRTIHl--201G <li :\.t~rf-('j l1Pl ~1<Fll r::<i q-qRri'!~4 I:f"i <I; ~-iJ If-ften q1~uJTl1 ~ film \i!~ if; <TD'-T 11 iR 1r:r~JfuQen J1' ;?l~d,JlTft'\ \'<:T ~fu-ct \il-::wllnl -~ 5 >ffi'r{ltj ~-(I 4HT f01~T iM ~"fl ;)fW,'" \J'frR'r .>i.ruTIB :30\l"fmru tRe;l qij AuhT ~n:TT 'Tm I ~ 0T]mx ~lj~1firRar~ ~ 3l~('f vrrf(r tf 10Qf?r~1(r ~JXXffl\1 ,\iFl\:i11'fcl if 15 ~rFrmR \'<:1 ~'I['IiRJ ~~~ 5 !fmm cf,) ~c 7.='l <fir t~f6rm rrzn I

Llf. ~ C:~(f (vertic<ll) .1fr.mm qG'f "* ~ cfi If:t m I -'1:l'f. ~ Vertical3fRaM ct "ffl~-~ \ff11 ~ i{ i!tfiwl .1f1'fe{l'T~~l i:i ~ rj; ~ .n eft ~ t I3!R: ~ t'lf;rq:ii q') ~ 1:\1 ':F.fxlql'n::rX:R 'R 0T]~iFIC'f ~El ii ~ ~ ~q¥~ \JFT\J'fTR1 if 5 ~ t:!CT':r>:f ~1c;J ml ~~ ~~\:nfc1 ~ ~ 30 ~~ Gl -Ir~ t. I ~ Wff'1 3l:Fiftid an 11 1~~- ~q;r <fiT ;)f-;:J~lJaCT;-,iTm 1{ 10 mmm.,~ R1 ,. ~. '...A p.,... -A ?,1' .' -"'~c\\t..'~"! ~!H;:nl 1115 >41(']"111 ~ TWfF:,[f 9"jvl1 5 ~lmTR ·<n1.~ ,,11~ (:1 ~If,' 3R1T<TT~ '4T.~ it ~ ~ t1 ~ t I~ (Vertical) 3TReTUT.Tm'Crrf.i'q) .31T'(ffi'Ul t I fi.tm ..nI:f"i <l> 11"<::1CliT 3rr~&fUT cf>T -WfIT. "* ~ cpfhf>--(tTf ~ (Vertical) ~e1ur. If,' 3fJffR(\') t?tm r.I ~ (Horizontal) 3lR&fUT 3WJ1T f.! m ~ ~ (Vertical) 3fRernT If~~ 'Wn t. I ~ <$'I 54m ~ if ~ f.1tITft1 \3(\1101IQi 40 ~ 1{ 'i{C G~

(Vertical) 3-lRaM <Fr u:J'F! l'j ffl ~ f.J <';-'1 em frruf<:I fW:rr rrm m I ~WH1CJQi 10i .~~ (fm t§1?lICJI'!'l 3l'JTe1<fim~ +m1 ~e1T-2016 l'j l1Fl ~ 10i ~ ~ q'j CRT~ +m1 t.g ~ 3ffiaTUT q'j ~TTffi ~ ftcrrr crm ck x:mm cii WfR titr<:l ;w:<T(>"n

~ f.1tITft1 "ffijuliQi 40 ~ <tt ~ oq, ~ ~ 1R ~ <tt 80m .~ ~'1iQ)03 07.2017 l'j \3 q fl CffilJfTR W em frr'ofu ~ rrat I ftf:r SJ4'uit l'j W t1 ~. \3"::r'i ~~ ct fc;rD: 1ff ~ tT ~ ~ I

mt ~ it ~ ~1l11l1('F1 ct ~ ~ ct WPm it ml1 mr-cn q w. mmrml1 ~ 10i t§1?lICJI'<i 3-l~e1<fi m~ 'lffiT ~e1I 2016 cf> ml1 '&cJq; I:[Ci ~ Tffirq iG''Bg ~ ~ if ~ ~ c!; ~ 3fRfaffi 377 rrc:'r c!; fcffi& l1T?I 3 ~ 1R tr~ ~ em mR 51 liA c.l> Tf'q'tf if ~ ~ f.! "\j(ffl cRterr cf> ~ 1{ ~

~ q;T \j.fci> ~ 12.5 ~ ~ 3fRernT ~ ~ '1tt -.:R \i'!'R cj:; Tiq''C.T if "fr..j')

~ cr ~ ~31T em ~ f.r tmm- fcr:r~ fu;m rrzrt I

ml1 mr-cn I:[Ci ~ Trfuq 'lffiT ~ Cf) 14ClI~ ~ Wi1 ~ 1996 c!;'C'f81 ~ ~ ~ I r.rufl'l ~ fun ~ 1996 if 1~ ~ tg ~ ~ <i;

~ (Specific) 3lRe1Uf em ~ ~ ~I ~ 1f\ ThJR~ ~ ~ FcPwr <i;

~ ~ 24.06.2008 Jtcr THE RAJASTIIJ\;\ CIVIL SERVICES(ABSORPTIO\i OF EX-

SERVICEMEN) RULES 1<)1(1;cj:; ~ ~ ~ %g 12.5 ~ ~ 3lRe1UT

(Horizontal Reservation) '\jCffi' 'lffif rme1l it ~ ~ eFToirt ~ ~ -~ 29.

09.2016 if ~ 3TTffi 40 ~ ~ \j~ mt('f ~ ~ ~ ('fq;' ~ -f<pmrrm ~I

THE RAJASTHAN CIVIL SERVICES(ABSORPTION OF EX-SERVICEMEN) RUI ':s19~R cj:; f.!n:r:r 1 cf> \3q f.'iwi 5 it ~ ~ f$ Where (I reserve vacancy remains unfilled

for non-availavbility of suitable ex-servicemen, such vacancy may be filled in from othersource in accordance with the rules regulating the recruitment and conditions of servicelor persons appointed to such post as if the vacancy was not reserved:

Provided that the reserved Vacancy so reserved shall be carried forward to the nextrecruitment year where after the vacancy in question shall be treated as unreserved.)

~ ~ &m "\j(ffl 'lffif rman ci; x:rmr B ~ &m ~ ~ \3~j ufjQi 40

~ <Fr t1.m fui7rc;r m ~ ~ 16638/2016 if ~ t;?r 1R ~ \fiX!

;:um~ ~ ~ ~ 1fu &m 'll~c.rC'f (Upheld) 'RilT rrzrr t. f$ "';:)jQ ~Tcflill

~ ~ B lfTTT ~ ~ t. c;) <) ~ ~fq;' RtfR'ur q;T ~ ~ t ~ ~I"

~~

~qm'J~TR l1IrAm ,,-eer -;:~:rmm<:lSRTmftrq:;rq;-ctf3lT q5'r \T<1TI mfuCfiI i'j wi, ~T\3<ffi. Trtterr q m GRT f.mtfuf ~f \T~ 40 ~ mt \3ftrTI tt >fAT rrzn t, 1

~ ~ iX1ll1lC'lll Gffi ~ ~.\;c1.l\T ~ 6433/2017 ~ ~ 'iA'Jll

~ ~~ .31W--RQ:ft:;ef ji~lC'lfUCfl ~ ~ ciri it 3rq-q ~ ~ 1707.2017 Ti~ ~ * ~ ~ frr~ 40 mmm wm <tT qrumr * ~ qft TfZ ~em ~ ~ ftm 'T<n t, 1

\3Cffi ~ Trtten it mT<r 3~~ ;:@ ~ <T 1:l"?"m tg TR 31j~1£!d ar~ ci>~.m . ~.tr C'Tm ~ 3l1ft11 ~'f <f>i ~t:1Tf.1q; mc:rtrAT m m:<1 m.n 3lj~IfiWiR it ~. ~{i.m..~.a 3l~ mt ~{>.IT1 3lj~1£!(1i:r?! .31~~ "C[cili'~

q rrgcl -<>1Wr mr ('~mf~ 3Fll mr ~) ~ 2014 cf> m;<l ~cm 31R1ffUl tg ~\3\110Iiq; it 'i9C w.B em TIt 'g I ~f m: n \NT J310Tt * ~ 31RlffUT ~ 'in \NT tWn~ ~ ~('fq) l{C m \JI'fill -g 1 \3Cffi tRten it ~ #f.1CflT em ~ tT ~ ~ -3R1 ~ m *3~ mt aW1vT 3iR1ffUT (Horizontal Reservation) ~ ~ \3(1"IOfiCfl it 3R'f1T f.i'~ cf> ~ ~ 1RR ;:@ ctr <Tt f, 1 ~ ~ ~ * ~u -# fcRTI %R

<fiT ~ ~ ~ m ~ Tf-{ '&1<lft affcWf 31Rfa:rc; WTiT * tRT q;'r m f,g aW1vT .~ \3~ofjCfl ~ ~ -f;

~2lCfl' f.i' tRT<l -;:;mf t, ill \ffi' ~~ if \jff WTiT cj; 3PlT ~ ~ IDT:{fm crrR3fRlcll ~ f.i' crftic1 ~ -;:;niriT vfT m fufm:MC1t:;ef ;::LwMild ;ffi'f Nrrr C'T2IT ~ ~ c:#r~ qfilc:fTl<Oll (legal Complications) ~ ~ 'it ~ t, I \3QgCfdlj+m <lfc:' ~~ * eifc1vl W q;'r '+R"i i:g l{C 1RR .<tt \JlTCfr t ffi 3R1 ~ 31Re:fUT * ~.:31A crr-R epf ~. ~. QR,ll<ffi~ (fm ~:t1'lbiQ~\1 (Sports Person) ..,~ ~ ~ Al{C <tt -.wr 'CfltiT ~ ffiu it ~ ~ it ~ mcrcrR ~ t I q)C'l,<:q~q \3CInTrtten <PT f.1ll"lj~11"! ~ fuR:rr rrm ~ q-~e-TTqftun-Jl f.r l:r~ iTrrr C'T2IT ~ TR5m if~ ~cll 'iI1Ff -n ~ i.r vnitir vIT ~ t:;ef rlj 11Ol1fild -::rm t, 1

~ Wffif C1~ em ~ ~~ ~ m &RT f.:ruh:r ~ 'Tm fcp 1JTT1 f.rcrcpt:;ef ~ ~ t:;ef '(91'iIClI~i 3rcfie1cl> ~ rr ~ mm ~ qfren-2016 * 3lCfrhr ~Wrco l0i ~ ~ cRT cf; ~ ~ 04.07.2017 em- ~ <rtt~1qftuw, ~~ cf> 3iR1ffUT ffitfi ~ f.1<:R1 / ~ ~ -c;ci ~ ~ cfi ~tt ~ -n ~ ~ * ~ ~ 31R1ffUT i:g tRT em- w -gg ~ \3-nlollq) -q ~R<:rr VfAT ~ ;:rf,j. g .31C1: mi &m ~ ~ wi it titi eFT 80cff ~ ~03.07.2017 i't ~ ~ f.1um ct>T r/2lTCTC1 WIT VITdT t, I